The Bazaar of War (@bazaarofwar) header
The Bazaar of War (@bazaarofwar) profile picture

Warfare, past and present. Read 'Saladin the Strategist': https://teapawt.org/t.co/KT9cGzHRIj More writing: https://teapawt.org/t.co/47yApgaler

Joined October 2020
The next James Bond film should be a period piece set in Flanders in 1386
5
31
1
636
19,019
The Bazaar of War retweeted
The idea of “maneuver” as a distinct style of warfare owes much to the Comte de Guibert, the French military theorist and reform advocate of the later 18th century. It was he who helped establish its meaning of “movement to a position of advantage”. 🧵
The paradigm of “maneuver vs. attrition” as two opposing styles of warfare is almost entirely the creation of William Lind, who beginning in the 1970s waged a one-man campaign to reform the US defense establishment. But its antecedents lie—surprisingly—Winston Churchill. 🧵
2
26
1
212
12,162
The Bazaar of War retweeted
The paradigm of “maneuver vs. attrition” as two opposing styles of warfare is almost entirely the creation of William Lind, who beginning in the 1970s waged a one-man campaign to reform the US defense establishment. But its antecedents lie—surprisingly—Winston Churchill. 🧵
2
15
5
96
17,483
The Bazaar of War retweeted
There is some obvious overlap between position & attrition; but even when 18th-c. operational dynamics resembled the Western Front—long, continuously-fortified fronts—its logic was not attritional, but focused on breaking into the enemy’s undefended rear. teapawt.org/bazaarofwar/status/175…
The Northern Front: Trench Warfare in the 18th Century The War of the Spanish Succession saw fighting along fortified lines over 100 km long, with striking tactical and operational similarities to WW1's Western Front. dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/t…
1
3
23
1,612
The Bazaar of War retweeted
The older paradigm was maneuver vs. position, which is how military writers from at least the 18th century described things: attacking fortresses or the enemy army in a strong field position vs. moving around them to gain some advantage.
1
1
24
1,480
The Bazaar of War retweeted
Just in time for the Marine Corps' 251st - new Dispatch on the intellectual roots of modern maneuver doctrine. "Churchill, Maneuver, and the Stickiness of Language" dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/c…
2
7
2
25
7,153
The Bazaar of War retweeted
Replying to @bazaarofwar
The mention of Liddell Hart reminded me how sticky ideas can be. I recently read a short, popular article by him from the 60s and realised more or less everything I'd been told about WWI at school was more or less taken verbatim from him: the central importance of the machine gun in creating the deadlock, a difficulty only overcome by the tank (which was yet only reluctantly recognised by backward and conservative generals). Despite some obvious shortcomings of this schema, it utterly dominated popular views of the world wars for decades.
2
2
11
1,229
📜Austerlitz Campaign, 4 November 1805 A boat carrying just six men helps open the way across the Enns. At Steyr, the bridges over the Enns have been burned and Austrian troops hold the opposite bank. French swimmers bring back a small boat under fire. According to Davout's subsequent report, it can carry only six men. Repeated trips put about thirty soldiers across the river, enough to attack the defenders in the suburb and establish a foothold.
2
9
72
2,244
The Bazaar of War retweeted
The Chickamauga Campaign was probably the most complex of the American Civil War and certainly among the most interesting, yet is overshadowed by the culminating battle of the same name. A shame—it’s a prime example of large-scale operational maneuver in very difficult terrain.🧵
It took a while, but the wait should be worth it: Part 2 on the Chickamauga Campaign is out. Having brilliantly maneuvered across the Tennessee River undetected, the Union Army of the Cumberland faced an even greater challenge around Chattanooga itself. dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/b…
2
10
2
91
7,610
The only way to war game this is with classic double blind kriegsspiel. Winning a classic game of kriegsspiel with blind maneuver remains one my proudest achievements. Although my job was made easier by being on the strategic defensive. It was close run thing.
The Chickamauga Campaign was probably the most complex of the American Civil War and certainly among the most interesting, yet is overshadowed by the culminating battle of the same name. A shame—it’s a prime example of large-scale operational maneuver in very difficult terrain.🧵
4
3
25
1,060
The Bazaar of War retweeted
Next part of the excellent case study of a highly complex campaign at the operational level.
It took a while, but the wait should be worth it: Part 2 on the Chickamauga Campaign is out. Having brilliantly maneuvered across the Tennessee River undetected, the Union Army of the Cumberland faced an even greater challenge around Chattanooga itself. dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/b…
2
5
595
The Bazaar of War retweeted
The Arab-Byzantine wars lasted over 3 centuries because it was extremely difficult for either side to defeat the other outright—even incremental territorial gains were difficult. Instead, strategy on both sides came to resemble Native American warfare of the Eastern Woodlands. 🧵
For >300 years, Arabs & Byzantines fought a series of frontier wars. These mostly resembled other large interstate conflicts, but their open-endedness also took on very different dynamics. Strategy in an Endless War: The Arab-Byzantine Frontier, Part 1 dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/s…
4
74
3
637
82,227
The Bazaar of War retweeted
It took a while, but the wait should be worth it: Part 2 on the Chickamauga Campaign is out. Having brilliantly maneuvered across the Tennessee River undetected, the Union Army of the Cumberland faced an even greater challenge around Chattanooga itself. dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/b…
4
2
22
7,595
The Bazaar of War retweeted
Who Was the Headless Horseman? Most modern retellings of the Legend Sleepy Hollow, especially by the tourist industry around Sleepy Hollow, indicate that the headless horseman was a Hessian decapitated at Battle of White Plains. But is that right? 🧵 1/14
10
35
6
182
12,044
The Bazaar of War retweeted
🚨 YOU HAVE ONE WEEK Feigned Flight Magazine's first print edition PORTALS has launched on Kickstarter and you have one week to preorder your copy! - 13 creative essays by 11 authors - No AI was used in the writing or production - Limited-edition print run Link below👇
16
44
17
129
38,799
The Bazaar of War retweeted
...and it breaks through! Washington's right routs under the combined pressure of the Hessians and Scots, and soon the entire American line collapses.
2
1
32
1,525
The Bazaar of War retweeted
Cannae is wrongly said to be one of those battles that perfectly embodies a specific tactic—in its case a double envelopment. In fact, Hannibal’s tactics were singularly unlike anything before or after. With one notable exception: the Battle of Agincourt.
Hannibal’s famous victory at Cannae in 216 BC is one of the most misunderstood battles of all time. It is often cited as a tremendous victory won by a perfectly-executed double envelopment. The truth is very different—and far more interesting. Thread
10
89
7
644
155,526
The Bazaar of War retweeted
Trafalgar is not the only significant milhist anniversary today: OTD in 1600 was Sekigahara, the largest battle on mainland Japan that inaugurated the long peace of the Edo Period.
1
8
45
2,352