Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman) header
Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman) profile picture

RW Morrison Professor of Political Science at Baylor University; editor of The Constitutionalist; author of The Discretionary President; life-long Celtics fan

Waco, TX
Joined March 2009
Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)Photo by Benjamin Kleinerman (@bkleinerman)
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
After DOGE, Elon came to a conclusion most people missed. He tried to reform the state from the inside. He failed. And he said it plainly: the government can't fix its own deficit. Nobody in power actually wants to cut. The machine protects itself. So he drew the only logical conclusion. If the state can't be reformed, there are only two ways this ends. Either global bankruptcy. Debt keeps compounding, interest payments eat the budget, and the system collapses under its own weight. Or robots. AI and robotics grow the economy so fast that the debt becomes manageable, and abundance makes the old fights over scarcity irrelevant. Here's the part almost nobody sees. For two centuries, capitalism has had a marketing problem. Its gains are real but slow and invisible. 2% growth a year doesn't feel like anything. Your life gets better over 30 years and you never connect it to the system that did it. Meanwhile, the left's promises feel immediate and concrete: a check, a subsidy, a benefit. That's why the left wins on promises even when it can't deliver them. Capitalism produces the wealth, socialism takes the credit. Robots break that asymmetry. When productivity doubles in a few years instead of a few decades, people will see it. Things get cheaper, services get better, opportunities appear, in real time. For the first time in history, people will connect capitalism and their rising standard of living directly, almost instantly. The causal chain becomes visible. And that changes everything politically. So there are two scenarios. Scenario one: we stay in the current inertia. No breakthrough, or a breakthrough we regulate to death. The debt wins. Living standards stagnate, then fall. A frustrated electorate turns to whoever promises the most, and that pushes toward a hard collectivist left. But collectivism fails, as it always does. And when it fails, the most organized, most disciplined collectivist force left standing isn't the old left. It's radical Islamism. Bankruptcy, then communism, then something worse. Scenario two: robots win. Abundance arrives, and it arrives visibly. The link between free enterprise and prosperity becomes obvious to everyone. And this is the key point: it becomes obvious to everyone, including the minorities the left was counting on. Because their long-term incentive is the same as everyone else's. A kid in the suburbs gains infinitely more from a booming, abundant West than from a bankrupt state handing out promises it can't keep. Abundance is the most powerful integration machine ever built. That's the Western renaissance. The West doesn't need to win the culture war by arguing. It needs to win it by delivering. And for the first time, it has the technology to deliver fast enough for people to notice. The race isn't left vs right anymore. It's robots vs bankruptcy.
3,407
8,291
922
48,487
8,987,660
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Hola, soy palestino. 🇵🇸 Y como la honestidad es poco común en mi política, permítanme confesar algunas cosas. 1947. La ONU me ofreció un estado. Junto a Israel. Fronteras, independencia, reconocimiento. Dije que no. Mis líderes prometieron que la guerra "arrojaría a los judíos al mar". En cambio, lo perdí todo y lo llamaron catástrofe. No porque no me ofrecieran un estado, sino porque lo rechacé. 1948–2025. Los estados árabes podrían haberme integrado, dado derechos, pasaportes, dignidad. En cambio, me encerraron en campos de refugiados durante generaciones, para que siguiera siendo un arma contra Israel. Construyeron palacios para ellos y cárceles para mí. Me usaron como propaganda, no como personas. 1967. Tras otra guerra perdida, podría haber construido un estado en Cisjordania y Gaza. En cambio, insistí en "ni paz, ni reconocimiento, ni negociaciones". Tres noes. Cincuenta años después, sigo sin Estado. Resulta que el rechazo no paga el alquiler. Oslo, década de 1990. Israel dijo: «Intentémoslo». Me dio autonomía. Armas para la policía. Miles de millones en ayuda. ¿Qué hicieron mis líderes? Robaron el dinero, armaron milicias y lanzaron una intifada. Atentados suicidas en lugar de escuelas. Cohetes en lugar de fábricas. Gaza, 2005. Israel se fue por completo. Sin colonos, sin soldados. Tuve la oportunidad de convertir Gaza en un Singapur mediterráneo. Voté por Hamás. La convirtieron en Mogadiscio junto al mar. ¿Miles de millones en ayuda? Túneles, cohetes y palacios para sus líderes, mientras mi gente come comida enlatada en la oscuridad. ¿Democracia? No he tenido elecciones en casi 20 años. Hamás mata a los disidentes en Gaza. Fatah los encarcela en Cisjordania. Mis líderes cancelan elecciones porque están demasiado ocupados luchando por el poder. Religión. En lugar de construir un futuro, pongo a clérigos en televisión enseñando a los niños a odiar a los judíos. Glorifico a los "mártires" que hacen estallar autobuses. Crío a mis hijos con canciones de sangre y fuego en lugar de libros y ciencia. Cambio la esperanza por la guerra santa. Mundo árabe. Los regímenes árabes me llaman "hermano". Pero pregúntenles cuántos palestinos pueden vivir libremente en Líbano, Siria, Egipto o Kuwait. Me excluyen, pero celebran mi muerte, porque mi muerte es su excusa. Absurdo. Sigo diciendo que quiero "construir un estado". E irónicamente, justo al lado está Israel: el vecino que construyó una democracia próspera, una potencia tecnológica, granjas en el desierto, ciudades de polvo. Sin petróleo, sin riqueza infinita, solo coraje. Podría haber aprendido, copiado, colaborado. En cambio, elegí la envidia y la rabia. Obsesión antijudía. Podría haber aceptado a los judíos como vecinos. Podría haber dicho: "Dos naciones, dos estados". En cambio, repito: "Del río al mar". En lugar de exhibir el honor, la hospitalidad y la rica cultura árabe, mostré solo la cultura de la espada: la ira, el extremismo y la sangre. En lugar de gritar salaam (paz) a los israelíes, grité muerte a los judíos. Y luego finjo sorprenderme cuando los israelíes no confían en mí, cuando están enojados, decepcionados y convencidos de que no quiero coexistencia en absoluto. Responsabilidad. Culpo a Israel de todo. Siempre. ¿Mis líderes roban miles de millones? Culpa de Israel. ¿Hamás dispara cohetes desde hospitales? Culpa de Israel. ¿Glorifico la muerte más que la vida? Culpa de Israel. La responsabilidad no es mi fuerte. Soy palestino. Podría haber construido una nación, muchas veces. Elegí el rechazo, la corrupción y la guerra sin fin. Podría haber vivido en paz con Israel, pero elegí vivir a la sombra de su destrucción. Así que sí, soy una víctima. Pero con demasiada frecuencia, soy víctima de mis propios líderes, de mis propias decisiones y de mi propia negativa a abandonar el odio. Y esa, querido lector, es la tragedia que nadie quiere admitir.
220
15,627
1,463
49,121
1,708,925
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Bingo.
303
2,639
39
22,760
215,539
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Mayor Mamdani, you said war criminals who set foot in New York should be arrested. Good news. One is in New York city this week. The president of the Islamic Republic is coming to the United Nations, right here in New York. He heads the regime that massacre innocent protesters. They gunned down unarmed protesters in the streets, hanged our children, and sent its agents to Brooklyn to kidnap and kill a New Yorker. That New Yorker is me. The FBI files and federal indictments are public. Look them up. If you have the courage to talk about arresting those responsible for crimes against humanity, start with the man sleeping five miles from your office. Are you willing to act, Mayor? Or do Iranian lives not count?
1,018
8,441
310
30,420
537,112
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Kyle Kuzma, forward for the NBA's Milwaukee Bucks, says Palestinians deserve "freedom from Hamas" and "Iranian-backed terror." This is what actual integrity looks like.
272
1,253
53
15,796
225,488
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
While many surviving Jews fled Europe to Israel after the Holocaust, much of the rest of the world had either… ~ Perpetrated it — Germany, Romania, Croatia, Hungary, Slovakia, Bulgaria, Fascist Italy ~ Collaborated with it — Vichy France, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, the Netherlands, Belgium, Norway, Greece, parts of Yugoslavia, Ukraine, and Poland ~ Stood aside — Switzerland, Spain, Portugal, Sweden, Turkey ~ Fought Germany, but did not prioritize rescuing Jews — United States, United Kingdom, Soviet Union ~ Restricted or refused Jewish refugees — United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Switzerland, France, and most Évian Conference states ~ Restricted Jewish escape to Palestine — United Kingdom ~ Opposed or fought the creation of a Jewish state — Egypt, Transjordan, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Yemen And if your country somehow escapes that list but sits in the New World, there is a good chance your own society was built through conquest and settlement of somebody else’s homeland. Jews, meanwhile, are a people whose history, religion, language, archaeology, and ancestry all originate in Judea. So spare us the lectures about the supposed moral stain of Jews establishing a state there 80 years ago. Much of the world had just murdered them, helped murder them, abandoned them, shut its doors to them, or fought to prevent them from having a country of their own. And many of the people now shouting “colonizer” live on continents colonized far more recently by their own societies. Seriously: STFU.
144
403
37
1,522
54,179
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Great Israel ad
252
985
120
5,805
453,767
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
I know Bill Maher is not a lot of people's favorites. But here he is making sense once again. Israel is not going anywhere.
240
2,047
66
10,509
126,071
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Secretary of State Marco Rubio gives an excellent explanation on why the U.S. needed to strike Iran It's less than 2 minutes and is worth the watch
1,215
5,607
348
28,623
3,401,731
Oxford University researchers have discovered the densest element yet known to science... The new element, Governmentium (symbol=Gv), has one neutron, 25 assistant neutrons, 88 deputy neutrons and 198 assistant deputy neutrons, giving it an atomic mass of 312. These 312 particles are held together by forces called morons, which are surrounded by vast quantities of lepton-like particles called pillocks. Since Governmentium has no electrons, it is inert. However, it can be detected because it impedes every reaction with which it comes into contact. A tiny amount of Governmentium can cause a reaction that would normally take less than a second, to take from 4 days to 4 years to complete. Governmentium has a normal half-life of 2 to 6 years. It does not decay, but instead undergoes a reorganisation in which a portion of the assistant neutrons and deputy neutrons exchange places. In fact, Governmentium's mass will actually increase over time, since each reorganisation will cause more morons to become neutrons, forming isodopes. This characteristic of moron promotion leads some scientists to believe that Governmentium is formed whenever morons reach a critical concentration. This hypothetical quantity is referred to as a critical morass. When catalysed with money, Governmentium becomes Administratium (symbol=Ad), an element that radiates just as much energy as Governmentium, since it has half as many pillocks but twice as many morons.
948
4,235
800
13,280
478,661
🚨 Students Supporting Israel at Catholic University wanted to hold an event on ending antisemitism. The administration said fine. Only if you also include the other side. The other side. Of ending antisemitism. SSI proposed: “Ending Antisemitism in America.” Submitted: January 19 Denied: February 25 The university’s Center for Student Engagement said the event required another speaker for a “balanced presentation” representing “both sides of this issue.” Both sides? Of whether Jew-hatred should be confronted? Other student groups get to hold one-sided events without a problem. But when pro-Israel students want to confront antisemitism, suddenly Jew-hatred becomes a viewpoint that needs representation. Disgusting.
393
1,100
96
3,462
94,452
This is why antisemitism is a disease. Great explanation.
425
1,632
168
5,053
286,913
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
The Muslim world is divided about Iran: Muslim countries in favor of removing the regime: Jordan 🇯🇴 Kuwait 🇰🇼 UAE 🇦🇪 Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 Oman 🇴🇲 Qatar 🇶🇦 Bahrain 🇧🇭 Muslim countries against the removal of the regime: Great Britain 🇬🇧 France 🇫🇷 Spain 🇪🇸
5,755
54,099
3,041
253,455
5,993,074
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
TRUMP CALLS OUT BAD BUNNY!
2,798
11,334
1,706
58,078
8,377,847
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
“Why has Congress given the president this massive military force without constraints, why does it continue to acquiesce in the POTUS's uses of force, why isn’t congress exercising its [] prerogatives and responsibilities to check these things?"execfunctions.org/p/law-and-…
8
14
3
70
10,133
Replying to @johnmcdonnellMP
Treat hunger strikers like the petulant children they are. Offer them food; when they’re hungry enough, they’ll eat. Until then, ignore them — they have the power to end the problem themselves. It’s not our fault they choose not to.
1
1
4
159
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
I was the quiet one who one day decided silence was no longer an option. It started small: just one short post on a tiny page, with one simple question: “Why is asking questions forbidden?” I didn’t know that question would be the beginning of the end of my old life. Now every morning when I open my eyes, the first thing I do is stare at the front door, wondering if someone is waiting behind it. My phone is full of anonymous messages: “Repent or we’ll finish you,” “We know where you are,” “We know your family too.” My mother no longer answers my greetings. She says, “If they kill you, you asked for it.” Sometimes on the street I feel footsteps following me. But I still write. Every night, when the city is asleep, I sit down and write for the people who haven’t found the courage yet. About the girl beaten for showing a strand of hair. About the boy who has to flee because he fell in love. About the children who are taught stoning before they’re taught play. I write so that maybe, just maybe, one person will say to themselves: “I have the right to think too.” I know this road has no return. I know one day they might knock on my door and I won’t come back. I know they might not even give my body to my family. But every time someone writes in my DMs, “Because of you I finally took off my hijab,” or “Because of you I allowed myself to say I don’t what I have been taught,” all the fear suddenly feels small. I am not a hero. I’m just an ordinary person who can no longer close her eyes to so much pain. If I disappear tomorrow, know that I kept writing until my very last breath. Until my last breath I kept saying that being human means being free to think, free to love, free to say “no.” Be human even if the price is your life. Until that day comes, I am still here. Still writing. Still breathing. And as long as I breathe, I will shout one thing: Free your mind. Free your heart. Free your life. Even if that freedom lasts only one day it is still worth it.
136
385
22
1,473
37,367
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Scholars Now Believe Number Of The Beast Is Actually 67 buff.ly/Q4jqyhi
152
163
32
2,653
245,557
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
Must listen. 🔥 Melanie Phillips on Western Hypocrisy You’ll rarely hear it said this clearly: Western liberalism has morphed into a fantasy-driven progressivism - one so detached from reality that it cheers for Hamas propaganda while condemning the only democracy in the Middle East for defending itself. Phillips lays it out: Progressivism once fought for truth and justice. Now it’s addicted to virtue-signaling, blind to facts, and easily weaponized by regimes that hate the freedoms it claims to protect. Israel is held to impossible moral standards while its enemies butcher civilians without a whisper of outrage. This is moral collapse. Phillips knows because she lived it: a self-described liberal mugged by reality. She’s seen how “progressive” spaces have turned a blind eye to antisemitism when it hides behind the word “anti-Zionism.” In an age where lies go viral faster than facts, her message is simple: If you can’t tell the difference between defending democracy and excusing terror, you’re not progressive - you’re regressive. Watch her. Share her. Let’s bring reality back into the conversation. @MelanieLatest
3
361
40
1,072
30,186
Benjamin Kleinerman retweeted
If you really want to understand how New York City Jews are feeling right now, listen to this amazing clip of Andrew Schultz from after October 7th. He explains it perfectly. Watch:
The strongest feeling I have right now is betrayal. Not outrage or even shock. Just that dull, sinking sense that the people you thought shared your basic sense of decency don’t actually see you at all. After watching Zohran Mamdani win, it’s hard to put that feeling into words. It’s not the extremists who bother me. Their hatred is loud, crude, and easy to recognize. What’s harder to accept is the quiet betrayal from the people around us. The people on the subway, in the office, at the grocery store. The people who smile politely, talk about tolerance, post about kindness, and still walked into a voting booth and chose someone who excuses violence against Jews. That kind of betrayal cuts differently. Because it tells you something uncomfortable about where you live. It tells you that antisemitism doesn’t always look like what we were taught to expect. It doesn’t always come with torches. Sometimes it wears a progressive label and speaks in the language of empathy. Sometimes it cloaks itself in “justice” and “freedom.” And sometimes it votes for a man who refuses to condemn a terrorist group that slaughtered Jewish families in their homes. That’s the part people don’t understand. The betrayal isn’t some abstract thing. It’s personal. It’s looking around at your city, at the people you’ve worked alongside, volunteered with, trusted, and realizing that when it came down to something as basic as condemning terrorism, they couldn’t bring themselves to care. And maybe that’s what hurts most. Not that they hate us, but that we simply don’t register. Jews have always been the easiest group to overlook. We don’t fit neatly into their moral frameworks. We are both too safe and too threatened, too privileged and too persecuted, too familiar and too foreign. So people convince themselves that antisemitism is someone else’s problem, somewhere else. And when confronted with it in their own backyard, they look away. They rationalize it. They call it “complex.” That’s what betrayal looks like in the modern age. Over a million people voted for Mamdani. Over a million people heard him refuse to call on Hamas to disarm and decided it didn’t matter. Over a million people looked past his rhetoric, his alliances, and his record and said he represents us. They should be ashamed to look their Jewish neighbors, friends, and coworkers in the eye. Because they voted to normalize a worldview that treats Jewish safety as negotiable. It would be easy to blame all of this on ideology alone, but there’s something deeper going on. America is struggling. People are drowning in rent, debt, and uncertainty. They are desperate for someone to tell them they’ve been wronged and that someone else is to blame. In that desperation, people stop thinking clearly. They mistake emotion for morality. They reach for simple answers, for villains to hate, for movements that promise fairness without effort. That’s what Mamdani offers, not solutions but moral anesthesia. He tells people that their frustration is righteous, that their anger is justice, and that their failures are someone else’s fault. It’s intoxicating. It makes people feel noble without requiring them to take responsibility. But when anger becomes identity, empathy dies. And when empathy dies, betrayal begins. That’s what this election revealed. A political shift, but also a moral one. A city that once prided itself on toughness and decency now seems willing to excuse hate as long as it’s packaged in the right words. The betrayal is of the city’s own conscience. Continued below 👇 /1
338
577
27
4,233
621,989