J.Dewey_contractCode (@contractCoding) header
J.Dewey_contractCode (@contractCoding) profile picture

Finance & Blockchain Partner, Holland & Knight. Hangs out at the corner of law and economics; deals computational law and code in the shadows. “What you need?”

Fort Lauderdale, FL
Joined October 2015
J.Dewey_contractCode retweeted
The regime-approved conservative intellectuals here remind me so much of the regime-approved dissidents in my native Iran.
78
1,092
64
5,306
Spot on. Many overthink this issue. Can gift IBM shares, but IBM shares are still securities. Give away free play before completing an arcade, that’s not likely a security. It might be a security, though, if sold as an investment (i.e., you can flip free play for profits). teapawt.org/msantoriesq/status/100…
1
1
That’s so 2017. You gotta be using zero knowledge proofs now. teapawt.org/stephendpalley/status/…
1
5
I agree with your observation. I bought ETH back then because I wanted to tinker with smart contracts. I don’t think I was alone in that regard. It may still have been a technical violation, but the circumstances surrounding that sale were nothing like most of the ICOs today. teapawt.org/stephendpalley/status/…
2
Replying to @prestonjbyrne
I agree. Only mentioning because some other folks mistakingly state gun shows are exempt from requirement.
2
Replying to @prestonjbyrne
And to be clear, in Florida, there is no “gun show” loophole. If you are a dealer, then you need a license and must run background checks at gun shows or anywhere else. A private citizen may sell a firearm without doing background check, whether at a gun show or anywhere else.
2
How would the SEC answer this question: Can a token that starts life not a security become a security?
1
In context of investing v. speculating, he equates speculating on inputs to investing. Most speculate on ETH, not invest. Regardless, making people, incl. devs, buy ETH from a broker-dealer is silly. What if a bway producer pre-sells tix to investors to fund play? Can TKTS sell? teapawt.org/prestonjbyrne/status/9…
1
It must be under certain circumstances. To hold that sales of tokens, which no longer meet the Howey test, are nevertheless a security because their origin arises from one would be contrary to decades of precedent applying substance over form to determine if an invest K exists. teapawt.org/propelforward/status/9…
That they have novel attributes merits examination. Is the token divisible from the contractual relationship created when the token is sold?
1
1
Replying to @propelforward
What’s interesting is that the mngt agreement was often not with the developer, but rather a third-party operator. So, while its existence and promise of pooling helped meet commonality under Howey, it was the purchase contract with the developer that was subject to attack.
1
During 2000's in Miami, pre-construction contracts for condo-hotels, like all MIA dirt, were highly liquid . SEC guidance stated (i) promoting profits, and (ii) pooling overnight stay revenue was likely a security. It was the contract, however, not the unit that was a security.
1
1
5
The tokens issued pursuant to the SAFT should stand or fall based on their nature. The same goes for any created as part of a hard fork. Designating tokens, which do not otherwise meet test, as securities solely because a SAFT was previously used, serves no public policy. teapawt.org/prestonjbyrne/status/9…
1/2 I think you'd have to make a couple assumptions. First, that the promoters benefitted from issuing the new tokens. Maybe in the general sense in that it was good for the network, but not from raising money. The promoters had the money. teapawt.org/prestonjbyrne/status/9…
2/2+ Also, SEC never even hints at ETH being security in DAO report, describing it only as "a virtual currency used on the Ethereum Blockchain." That would have been a good time to tell us all there was a problem. Finally, they know Vitalik won't last a week in the joint.
3
2/2 Plus, the nature of speculation around it looks and feels like a commodity. I don't believe the SEC could show with credible evidence that people buy and sell ether today based predominantly on the efforts of the foundation or anyone else.
4
1/2 Correct. I think the argument is stronger since holders kept the original coin and there was no expectation at the time of purchase that new ones would be issued. Although, one could make arguments to the contrary. Plus, even if that line of reasoning failed...
1
3