
ER MD, Medical multitasker, mythbuster and storyteller, former @StLouisBlues MD, One Health @Bayer4Crops, Medical Tox, Boy Mom. Tweets are my own.
St Louis, MO
Joined February 2017
- Tweets39.1K
- Following6.6K
- Followers10.4K
- Likes43.8K
Pinned Tweet
“The road to hell is paved with good intentions.”
The Sri Lanka disaster started with an ill-advised ban on agricultural chemicals in a bid to go “all organic” last year.
The conventional wisdom was that this was better for human and planetary health. 1/
Sri Lanka’s sudden economic collapse has broken its healthcare system. Sonia Sarkar reports on how the country might claw back years of progress, lost in months: bmj.com/content/377/bmj.o154… @sonia_26
Liza Lockwood retweeted
Missouri judge approves Bayer's $7.25 billion Roundup settlement
reuters.com/legal/government…
Liza Lockwood retweeted
Vitamin people will take 12 different supplements before breakfast and call doctors idiots for not recommending more of them.
But the vitamin k shot that is universally recommended and stops babies from bleeding into their brains is treated as a poison.
Liza Lockwood retweeted
"Healthcare providers have an additional source of misinformation: medical societies."
Informative article by @ArielleSelya , worth a read acsh.org/news/2026/11/17/vap…
Liza Lockwood retweeted
I’m a cardiologist who started practicing in the years right before the ACA passed. At the time, I assumed the health policy professionals knew what they were doing and would design a system that improved things for patients and physicians.
I was wrong.
Watching the revisionism from the health policy class about what actually happened after passage has been something to behold.
Anyone who still claims the Affordable Care Act lowered the federal deficit or made health care more affordable cannot be taken seriously on this topic. They may believe it in good faith, but a credential plus that belief does not entitle them to more say on future health policy than a random person on the street.
The strongest positive claim one can make is narrow: a small group of previously uninsurable patients (roughly 3% of the population) gained access to insurance. Policymakers took a real problem affecting a small minority and used it to fundamentally redesign the entire health care system. The result made things worse for the other 97%.
That is not a hypothetical.
In practice, the law created a mechanism to funnel large sums of taxpayer money to insurance companies and Medicaid managed-care middlemen—on the order of $800 billion in subsidies for ACA plans and another $800 billion in federal dollars to states for Medicaid expansion. The CBO scored this as paid for primarily through higher taxes and reduced Medicare payments to hospitals.
Because the ACA mandated essential health benefits and community rating, and because insurers knew government subsidies would kick in, premiums rose sharply even as deductibles on these plans reached thousands of dollars. Individuals were then required to buy one of these products or pay a penalty.
For physicians, the law built the first major penalty-based quality-reporting apparatus. This added overhead and cost for a set of largely clinically meaningless metrics, which contributed to many doctors retiring early or selling their practices to hospitals.
On the fiscal side, the tax increases and Medicare payment cuts covered a portion of the new spending on paper. What the CBO did not adequately account for was the fraud and waste incentives created by a 90/10 federal match on expansion populations. When the state and managed-care organizations receive 90 cents on the dollar for every enrollee, the incentive to rigorously verify eligibility is weak. When federal dollars are flowing into home care, learning centers, and similar services that boost the local economy, states have little reason to aggressively pursue fictional or inflated claims.
Medicaid spending is now roughly 20% higher than earlier projections. Any serious attempt to slow that growth is met with academic preprints and media coverage warning that large numbers of people will die.
Helping a small number of previously uninsurable patients did not require redesigning the entire health care system around subsidies, mandates, community rating, and penalty-based reporting. That redesign raised costs, accelerated consolidation, and created spending dynamics that are now treated as untouchable. The results are visible. The revisionism is not.
An extremely narrow field of view from Fiedler on Obamacare :
1. Actual Medicaid spending has far outstripped early projections. CMS reports tens of billions in improper payments annually. Independent analyses put millions of expansion enrollees as likely ineligible—ghosts and fraud CBO never fully scored.
2. Medicare payment cuts didn’t magically create free savings. Hospitals consistently report Medicare/Medicaid underpayments. The gap was just shifted onto commercial insurers and the uninsured. It isn’t an accident that hospital Private rates run 200-250% of Medicare. Those “savings” Fiedler is pumped about just became higher premiums for everyone else.
3. Essential health benefits + community rating (and a healthy dose of consolidation driven by the ACA) produced major premium increases for people buying coverage on their own. Benchmark premiums rose ~75% from 2014–2024 (and more for older enrollees)—roughly double the growth in employer plans. That’s a large, unaccounted-for tax on families
Bottom line: If the goal was deficit reduction, raise taxes. Don’t pair the tax increases with a massive new spending entitlement and a regulated individual market that has driven large premium inflation.
Liza Lockwood retweeted
Similar to administrative takeover in healthcare
The Boston Symphony used to run on 100 musicians and 6 administrators. According to Heather Mac Donald, it now has about 100 of each.
She says that's the real story behind the fight over what an orchestra is for.
Mac Donald: "Feeding and keeping occupied all of these human resources consultants and whatnot costs a fortune, which results in ticket prices going up."
Her fix is the part I keep coming back to.
Mac Donald: "If you want a diverse audience, how about you lower your ticket prices? How about even making it free to schoolchildren?"
Instead, she says, the staff needed something to do, so they started shaping the programming. This summer, one of Tanglewood's closing humanities programs was about mass incarceration and systemic racism.
Mac Donald: "Classical music is seen simply as a jumping-off point to get to what really matters."
On the other side is conductor Andris Nelsons, who wanted the orchestra's plan to name the core repertoire and the orchestra's own sound as its mission.
That's the irony. The cheapest way to bring new people to Tchaikovsky is to let them hear Tchaikovsky. A free ticket for a 12-year-old does more for the audience of the future than another panel discussion.
When the people running the music outnumber the people playing it, the music stops being the point.
Coming up shortly!
What if overeating isn’t the cause of obesity—but a consequence?
Join @JonEntine, @camjenglish, and @DrLizaMD, with author and science journalist @garytaubes, who challenges the conventional “calories in, calories out” explanation for obesity. teapawt.org/i/spaces/1NgQlRAYbQjzE…
Liza Lockwood retweeted
Want to know what modern science has done for humanity?
Turn off your electricity
Stop using treated water
Empty your refrigerator
Give up modern medicine
Now imagine that’s not an experiment. That’s everyday life.
Progress isn’t the enemy. It’s the reason you have a choice.
Liza Lockwood retweeted
Declaring healthcare is a “right” is classic politician virtue signaling. It is lazy and intentionally ignores actual real life resource and system limitations.
The reason why healthcare is so expensive now in America is because of the massive consolidation the “Affordable” Care Act created by giving government unprecedented control over healthcare, eliminating free market conditions. The ACA picked winners: health insurance companies and big corporate health systems who profited handsomely since 2010. It picked the losers: patients and physicians.
Medicare for All will be the nail on the coffin and we will be doomed to a two tiered, massively inefficient healthcare system like Canada or the NHS.
Come join us tomorrow for a fascinating discussion on obesity!
What if overeating isn’t the cause of obesity—but a consequence?
Join @JonEntine, @camjenglish, and @DrLizaMD, with author and science journalist @garytaubes, who challenges the conventional “calories in, calories out” explanation for obesity. teapawt.org/i/spaces/1NgQlRAYbQjzE…
Wowzers 👇🏽
Atlas Shrugged, Ayn Rand - Dr. Hendricks in Galt’s Gulch (Part III, Chapter I).
“I quit when medicine was placed under State control some years ago,” said Dr. Hendricks. “Do you know what it takes to perform a brain operation? Do you know the kind of skill it demands, and the years of passionate, merciless, excruciating devotion that go to acquire that skill? That was what I could not place at the disposal of men whose sole qualification to rule me was their capacity to spout the fraudulent generalities that got them elected to the privilege of enforcing their wishes at the point of a gun. I would not let them dictate the purpose for which my years of study had been spent, or the conditions of my work, or my choice of patients, or the amount of my reward. I observed that in all the discussions that preceded the enslavement of medicine, men discussed everything — except the desires of the doctors. Men considered only the ‘welfare’ of the patients, with no thought for those who were to provide it. That a doctor should have any right, desire or choice in the matter, was regarded as irrelevant selfishness; his is not to choose, they said, but ‘to serve.’ That a man’s willing to work under compulsion is too dangerous a brute to entrust with a job in the stockyards — never occurred to those who proposed to help the sick by making life impossible for the healthy. I have often wondered at the smugness at which people assert their right to enslave me, to control my work, to force my will, to violate my conscience, to stifle my mind — yet what is it they expect to depend on, when they lie on an operating table under my hands? Their moral code has taught them to believe that it is safe to rely on the virtue of their victims. Well, that is the virtue I have withdrawn. Let them discover the kind of doctors that their system will now produce. Let them discover, in their operating rooms and hospital wards, that it is not safe to place their lives in the hands of a man whose life they have throttled. It is not safe, if he is the sort of man who resents it — and still less safe, if he is the sort who doesn’t.”
Liza Lockwood retweeted
Who is actually in charge of healthcare? Because right now, it doesn't feel like it's the physicians and it certainly doesn't feel like it's the patients.
I showed up to work today with two surgeries scheduled. Two women who had prepared for these procedures, arranged their lives around them, and trusted us to provide their care. Yet somehow, both cases ended up outside of my control.
This is what I find so frustrating about the healthcare system we're working in.
As physicians, we spend years training to make decisions in the best interest of our patients. We have medical licenses, professional obligations, and a responsibility to the people who trust us with their lives.
But increasingly, decisions about patient care are being made by people who aren't in the operating room, aren't treating the patient, and aren't necessarily accountable for the outcome.
Insurance companies determine where patients can receive care. Hospitals make decisions about staffing, resources, and where patients go after surgery.
And the physician is still expected to be responsible for the outcome.
I understand that healthcare is complicated. Hospitals have operational challenges. Insurance companies have financial considerations. But at what point did we become so focused on managing the system that we lost sight of the people it's supposed to serve?
These aren't just scheduling problems or administrative inconveniences.
These are real people. Women who are already navigating incredibly difficult circumstances. Women who have emotionally prepared and taken time away from their families, their jobs, and their lives to have surgery.
They deserve better than this.
And the healthcare professionals who show up every day wanting to do right by their patients deserve a system that allows them to do that.
I don't want to work in a system where providing appropriate care requires constantly fighting obstacles that shouldn't exist in the first place.
We have to do better.
To my fellow physicians and healthcare professionals, are you experiencing this too?
Coming up tomorrow!👇🏽
What if overeating isn’t the cause of obesity—but a consequence?
Join @JonEntine, @camjenglish, and @DrLizaMD, with author and science journalist @garytaubes, who challenges the conventional “calories in, calories out” explanation for obesity. teapawt.org/i/spaces/1NgQlRAYbQjzE…
Liza Lockwood retweeted
We had to pass it to find out what was in it
And we had to lie to pass it
Remember this when they talk about how great M4A will be
Liza Lockwood retweeted
From a recent @BostonGlobe story about a 33-year-old medical resident and mother of two who’s making $85,000 and is over $400,000 in debt:
How often does the AMA come out against rising tuition, or make any moves to meaningfully lower it? I agree, of all the graduate student loans, medical student loans are most justified, and will have a positive ROI for essentially every graduate by the time they turn 40, but above $200,000 for four years of tuition is still insane—especially when you factor in undergraduate loans (plus interest) and the fact that doctors spend at least four years in residency (often more + fellowship) before they are making serious money, and by that point they're in their early 30s. That's not even factoring in the opportunity cost of spending your twenties and early thirties in school or training; and beyond that, even debt you can pay back is still debt, and will still hamper you from doing anything riskier or less lucrative; it can also mean the difference between spending time with your children when they’re young and working reduced hours and not being able to have even the option of that flexibility.
A lot of the criticism of this graduate loan cap is that “only rich people can afford to become doctors” but I basically never see the same people consider the simple question of: if you’re not rich, should you be saddling yourself with upwards of $200,000 in student loans, even if there is a positive ROI, or are you better off doing something else? And listen, maybe the answer is yes! But make that argument full-throatedly, not sitting around blaming conservatives for making a different, and IMO more compelling, argument.
Liza Lockwood retweeted
The year is 2006.
A young researcher in Minnesota publishes a paper in Nature. He says he has found a special form of amyloid, the sticky protein that builds plaques in Alzheimer’s brains. He calls it Aβ*56. Inject it into young rats and their memory collapses. It looks like proof. The sticky stuff is not just sitting there. It is the cause.
The paper gets cited thousands of times. Money pours into amyloid drugs. The field lines up behind it.
Other labs try to find the same thing. They can’t. The protein is hard to see. The results refuse to repeat. Nobody says much. Careers are built on papers like this one.
In 2022 a doctor starts looking at the pictures. Western blots. Those dark bands that are supposed to prove a protein is there. Some of the bands are copies. Same noise, same edges, stuck into different places. Pieces cut from one experiment and pasted into another. An eraser tool used to clean up what did not fit. Experts call it shockingly blatant.
In 2024 the journal retracts the paper. Most of the authors agree the images were manipulated and the data cannot be trusted. The first author does not. In 2025 he leaves his job after more of his work is flagged for the same problem.
For nearly twenty years a set of doctored pictures helped steer research, funding, and drug trials. The amyloid idea was already old. This paper gave it fresh fuel and a clean story. The clean story was built from cut-and-paste.
The plaques were always real. The proof that one particular form of them caused the memory loss was not. Patients waited. The pictures did not.
Excellent post 👇🏽
The FDA Commissioner role is open again. Dr. Heidi Overton’s nomination was pulled the night before her Senate committee vote. Whatever the internal reasons, this creates a rare opening to get the leadership right for American patients and for the innovation that actually reaches them.
Here’s what the next Commissioner needs to be. Not a wish list. A baseline:
You cannot regulate what you have never lived. The person in this seat should have spent real time on the other side of the table—building a product in biotech, pharma, or devices—and felt the weight of regulatory decisions as the recipient (sometimes the victim). That experience is not optional. Career government officials and pure academics can be talented, but they have never had a program delayed, a trial redesigned, or a company nearly killed by a decision whose full consequences they never had to carry. The ethics rules make it extremely difficult for anyone with industry experience to take this job because of the divestiture requirements. The result is that the role often defaults to people who have never created anything. That may be administratively easier. There is a price.
This person must be a licensed physician—ideally a physician-scientist—who has done both basic and clinical research and who has actually taken care of patients. An active license is ideal. They need to understand, firsthand, what patients face, including patients with rare diseases. For many of those conditions it is mathematically nearly impossible to hit a p-value of 0.05, the arbitrary threshold we treat as the definition of statistical significance. That reality has to be lived, not just read about.
The role is sacred. It involves life-and-death decisions for millions of people. It is therefore not a platform for partisan ideology. Americans are sick of extreme partisanship. The next Commissioner should be objective, serve all Americans, and recognize that this job is not subject to partisan manipulation. They should be blindly loyal to exactly one large and powerful special-interest group: THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. Full stop.
They should be well-spoken and confident in public settings, yet humble enough to welcome feedback and constructive criticism.
They should not arrive with their mind made up on specific drugs or classes of drugs before they have seen the data. The FDA’s job is not to decide whether a particular patient should receive a particular drug. That decision belongs to the physician and the patient once the science is sound and the information is clear. Every regulatory choice carries 2 risks: the risk of approving something that later proves harmful, and the risk of not approving something that could have helped. Both are real. For patients with serious or rare conditions and few options, the second risk is often larger.
This is also a national-security position. It requires a counterintelligence background check (don’t ask how I know 😉) for a reason: the wrong decision or the wrong public (or private) statement can do real harm. The person who holds it should treat that responsibility with the seriousness it deserves—focused on the work, not on being a constant public figure, & never hinting at confidential information.
They may hold strong personal, cultural, or religious beliefs. Those beliefs stay at the door. The job is to follow the law and to do what is medically, scientifically, and ethically right for American patients.
Bring back open, FAIR advisory committee meetings so the public can see how decisions are made. Keep asking not only “Is it safe enough to approve?” but “What happens if we do not?” Protect the public from products that offer real risk with no benefit, while trusting informed patients and physicians when credible evidence exists that a treatment can help
This is a moment to choose leadership that is responsive to the needs of all Americans—objective, compassionate, and thoughtful. American patients & American innovation are counting on it.
We like this statement from FDA regarding nicotine.
Oddly, you won't see this one quoted by public health groups very often.
Via @ArielleSelya at @ACSHorg, an excellent illustration of how @LungAssociation deliberately manipulates language to mislead the public. If only there was a one-word way of describing such a practice. 🤔 acsh.org/news/2026/11/17/vap…
Liza Lockwood retweeted
How big a scam is health insurance?
I did the math and it’s eye-opening.
Over the past 20 years, I’ve paid a total of about $360k in insurance premiums for our family of four. (This doesn’t include lots of additional money we’ve spent out-of-pocket due to deductibles and things that aren’t covered by insurance.)
Had I invested those insurance premiums in the S&P 500, it would have grown to nearly $1.5 million.
One. Point. Five. Million. Dollars.
Over that entire period, I bet we’ve filed less than $100,000 in insurance claims.
That means we could have paid cash for healthcare and pocketed the remaining $1.4 million. 🤪
But of course, like everyone else, we kept insurance in case the worst happened—a catastrophic illness or injury.
But for a healthy family, is insurance the best way to cover that?
The answer is no.
That’s why we switched to @crowdhealth.
We pay around $500/month and we’re covered by the Crowd. No deductibles, just a $500 one-time fee per health event. And best of all, we’ll never have to deal with insurance companies again.
Had CrowdHealth existed 20 years ago, we’d have added over a million dollars to our net worth.
IT’S THE SAME FOR YOUR FAMILY!
If you’re interested in learning more about CrowdHealth, join our webinar tomorrow. Our CEO, @andyjschoonover, will explain how it works and answer your questions live.
Register here:
joincrowdhealth.com/webinar
P.S. If you join CrowdHealth, use my code CAMP4 and get your first 3 months for $99/mo.
Liza Lockwood retweeted
He thinks comparing government healthcare to public school is a selling point. 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Medicare for All means healthcare for everyone, like public school is free for every kid.
Private insurance can still exist on top of it, just like private school still exists.
“Medicare for All who want it” is pablum. It’s telling parents they have to pay for public school.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Medicare for All bills allow only supplemental private insurance that does not duplicate public benefits, unlike private schools which provide full education alternatives. Like public schools, M4A would be taxpayer funded rather than free.
congress.gov/bill/119th-con…
usafacts.org/answers/how-ar…

































