
Author, Journalist, Columnist. With interest in Democracy, Secularism, Human Rights, Law. Author of The Fearless Judge. Link in pinned post. @KingsCollegeLon
Joined May 2015
- Tweets463
- Following147
- Followers485
- Likes128
Pinned Tweet
Not many ppl know that when my grandfather passed away last year, he was in the process of writing a book - his atma katha as he lovingly called it. Sadly, his time on earth ran out before he could finish.
Today, it is here.
Available on pre-order now. amzn.in/d/7lfYI4w
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
#Opinion | India needs to rethink its legal education system
A realignment can ensure that our law graduates wear the gown not merely as a credential, but as a commitment to constitutional stewardship
Ashish Bharadwaj & @insiyahv ✍🏻
Read more about it: hindustantimes.com/opinion/i…
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
We are delighted to announce the acquisition of Broken Scales by @insiyahv, a riveting account of the Indian Supreme Court’s most testing moments in history, from the Emergency and Ayodhya to Kashmir.
Coming April 2028.
Read more: penguin.co.in/newsroom/pengu…
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
4. Yesterday’s student leaders must not curb dissent today
@insiyahv and Ashish Bhardwaj on student politics
hindustantimes.com/opinion/y…
It is curious how the right to protest looks different from opposite sides of a barricade.
Arun Jaitley, former president of the Delhi University Students’ Union, once escaped an early-morning attempt to arrest him during the Emergency. He returned to campus, burned an effigy of Indira Gandhi and courted arrest. Jaitley was in good company. The veteran Gandhian Jayaprakash Narayan’s call for Sampoorna Kranti, which started as a student movement and quickly became the symbol of anti-Emergency resistance, was practically a political finishing school for India’s students and future leaders. Lalu Prasad Yadav was leading the Patna University Students’ Union. Student leader Nitish Kumar was swept into politics through the JP movement. Sitaram Yechury cut his political teeth in JNU’s politics, marching to Indira Gandhi’s residence and demanding her resignation as chancellor of the university. Sharad Yadav, president of Jabalpur University students’ union, was backed by JP to contest a 1974 byelection — which he won. Fighting on the other side, Mamata Banerjee, then a young Congress activist, blocked JP’s convoy in Kolkata. She climbed onto his car and shouted slogans.
PM Narendra Modi, then an RSS pracharak, he joined Gujarat’s Navnirman Andolan of 1973, which began with student protests over rising canteen prices and grew into a statewide agitation. The movement brought Gujarat to a standstill. Within weeks, Chief Minister Chimanbhai Patel was forced to resign, the state assembly was dissolved, and Gujarat was placed under President’s Rule. Modi’s own website recalls Navnirman as his introduction to mass protest, a crusade against corruption that shaped his understanding of student concerns.
Home minister Amit Shah, too, came up through student politics. He was appointed joint secretary of the Gujarat ABVP and moved into the BJP’s youth wing. He and Modi met in the RSS network in Ahmedabad.
Jaitley did not ask the State for permission before his daredevilry. The Navnirman protesters did not wait for an invitation from the Gujarat police. Yechury did not seek an appointment before marching to the PM’s residence. They simply exercised their democratic right to dissent and protest.
Imagine the inconvenience of having to explain this to a student at Jantar Mantar today. Reports and visuals of protesters being beaten, dragged and subjected to sexual assault by police have surfaced. Protest sites have been denotified, trains cancelled, metro stations shut, and up to 7,000 citizens detained. And what are we to make of reports that people were intercepted en route to Delhi on suspicion of intention to join the protests? Evidently, the best protest is the one that never happens.
From strikes to road blockades, earlier protests were often disruptive by design to compel political action. Gujarat’s Navnirman, especially, was marred by arson, attacks on police, strikes, and destruction of public property. Ahmedabad had descended into near-anarchy before the army was called in.
Today, those demanding accountability from the Election Commission and Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar have faced disproportionate force by the police and state machinery; yet they display remarkable restraint and continue to insist on peaceful means. Demonstrators have invoked Gandhi, Ambedkar and the Constitution, making visible their commitment to peace and civic restraint. They know that the mechanisms of protest through which today’s leaders came of age may today be framed as disruptions to public order.
Yesterday’s rebels have become today’s leaders, and those who once knew the value of a street full of dissenting students now seem far less persuaded by it. They should remember that the students outside the barricades are asking for the same democracy they once demanded for themselves. It should not be so difficult to remember.
Hindustan Times, 22 October, '26.
hindustantimes.com/opinion/y…
The Uniform Civil Code is being presented as a historic project of equality: one nation, one law. It is an attractive slogan, provided one does not examine too closely what the proposed uniformity includes, whom it excludes and why it has been assigned an election-linked deadline.
Article 44 of the Constitution says that “the State shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India.” But we must ask: Is that truly what the state endeavors? Closer inspection may reveal a difficult answer — that the endeavor is for neither uniformity nor equality.
The BJP’s political case for a UCC has been built over decades on a familiar catalogue of assumed deficiencies in Muslim personal law: polygamy, divorce, inheritance and the alleged oppression of Muslim women. The message is clear. Personal law is the problem, and Muslim personal law is the problem within the problem.
And yet, the argument collapses when tested against its own logic. Discriminatory laws can be individually challenged, amended and struck down without a wholesale replacement by a single code. India has done this before, with both Muslim and Hindu personal laws. The 21st Law Commission’s 2018 Consultation Paper on Reform of Family Law made this very point, observing that “mere existence of religious differences does not imply discrimination” and concluding that a Uniform Civil Code was “neither necessary nor desirable at this stage.”
If the objective is to eliminate religious privilege from civil law, why does the system stubbornly retain institutions with specifically Hindu origins? The Hindu Undivided Family, or HUF, continues to enjoy significant tax and property advantages that are denied to families of other religions. It can hold property and income, allowing Hindu families to reduce their tax burden. Muslims, Christians and Parsis are not offered an equivalent benefit.
The clearest indication of what this project has become lies less in its constitutional promise and more in its deadline of 2029.
Union Home Minister Amit Shah has now announced that the UCC will be implemented in all 21 BJP-NDA-governed states before 2029. With the next Lok Sabha election due in 2029, it is not difficult to guess why this timeline has been chosen. At a time when equal access to education, employment, health care, social security and justice remain unfinished tasks, the state has chosen regulation of marriage, divorce and live-in relationships as the next political priority.
From the government’s standpoint, the attraction is evident. UCC provides for concrete legislation, yet is not required to demonstrate job creation, productivity or improvement in public services.
When the economic scoreboard becomes inconvenient, perhaps it is tempting to change the subject.
merotribune.com/2026/10/12/i…
53
There is a peculiar burden that a court acquires when it narrows its own precedents. It must then keep returning to clean up the consequences of that decision. The Supreme Court may now have such a problem with the SIR.
There is an uncanny symmetry to what is unfolding. In 1995, under Chief Justice AM Ahmadi, the Court answered two questions that have now returned. Can the State dislodge an existing voter, and can the Chief Election Commissioner unilaterally exercise the ECI’s powers? The Court answered with firm guardrails. In Lal Babu Hussein v. ERO, dealing with mass deletions from electoral rolls, the Court held that once a voter’s name is on the rolls, there is a presumption of validity. Removal must be justified by the State. In TN Seshan v. UoI it rejected the idea that the CEC stood above the other Election Commissioners, warning that they could not be reduced to “non-functional or ornamental” positions.
31 years later, one of those guardrails has already loosened. The Court now says that inclusion in an earlier electoral roll is not a “perpetual guarantee” and asking voters to produce material to find their way back onto rolls is permissible. In doing so, it de-fanged one of the Court’s strongest voter protections.
Then came the Indian Express expose, setting the cat among the pigeons. It found that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had objected 14 times to decisions on voter registration, deletion and restoration. In Form 6, they described the change as “unauthorised and illegal”.
This is where the Court may find a monkey on its own back. It had upheld the SIR exercise. If it is established that the Commission did not function legally, the Court will have to reconcile that finding with its earlier judgment.
And it will bring it back to another precedent, from the same year and the same CJI. Will Seshan survive this test as a meaningful limit on the CEC, like Lal Babu, be preserved in name while being emptied of consequence?
And then comes the elephant in the room. If SIR decisions are ultimately found to have been taken without lawful authority, what is the legal status of every election that followed from it?
Hindustan Times, 8 Oct. hindustantimes.com/opinion/a…
2
107
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
#Opinion | While the Indian Patent Office granted 100,000 patents in FY24, our contribution to global technologies is below 0.1%.
Ashish Bharadwaj & @insiyahv ✍🏻
Read more about it: hindustantimes.com/opinion/i…
Whether the heart is stopped by a drop or a drug, the act remains a rejection of reformative justice in favour of a State-sanctioned spectacle.
Years in solitary confinement and an uncertain mercy process may themselves violate the fundamental right to life long before execution. But what happens when the noose’s finality falls on a system prone to wrongful conviction and delay like ours?
India’s continued reliance on hanging is a step backward because it is the ultimate decolonisation paradox: We have replaced the names of our laws but kept the scaffold of our colonisers. While the world moves toward abolition, our framework remains tethered to 1860. The SC will do well to stop debating the method of the kill and start questioning the validity of the death penalty itself.
The apex court noted that death by hanging serves no restorative purpose. The reluctance to acknowledge that a painless death is an essential component of the Right to Life creates a vacuum where the State’s power to punish overrides the individual’s right to dignity. In a modern, democratic India, shouldn’t justice be measured by our capacity for reform, not by the efficiency of our gallows?
Hindustan Times, 27.08.26
#Opinion | Whether the heart is stopped by a drop or a drug, the act remains a rejection of reformative justice in favour of a State-sanctioned spectacle
Ashish Bharadwaj & @insiyahv ✍🏻
Read more about it: hindustantimes.com/opinion/d…
3
151
NEARLY EIGHTY YEARS AGO, a nation dared to dream of what freedom might mean. Gandhi imagined a secular India. Ambedkar insisted on liberty, equality and fraternity.
In the years since 2014, those ideas have given way to another. We have watched a politics built on identities that divide us: Hindu v. Muslim, Majority v. Minority, Nationalist v. Anti-National.
Against this politics stands one of the Constitution’s most fascinating ideas. Fraternity. It is perhaps the most neglected word in the Indian Constitution. We remember liberty, equality, and secularism. We argue about socialism. But fraternity? Fraternity sounds almost embarrassingly gentle in this age of political aggression. And yet it may be the most radical constitutional idea of them all. Fraternity cannot be built while teaching people to fear one another. A common brotherhood is impossible when citizens are constantly reminded that their neighbour belongs to another community, another tribe, maybe even another India. The loss of fraternity, therefore, was not accidental but a consequence of this politics.
But then, suddenly, the ‘cockroaches’ crawled out. What began as a joke sparked by a careless remark from the Chief Justice of India, soon spilled out of the internet and onto the streets. They came protesting examination leaks and the wider failures of India’s competitive-exam system. They came wearing T-shirts and jeans, kurtas and topis, turbans, swords and the unmistakable blue of the Nihang tradition. They came young and old. They came from different religions, castes and regions. They arrived angry, but they also arrived carrying food and water.
After all, the cockroach is wonderfully egalitarian. Everybody can be one. This too is politics. It is fraternity.
There is something almost cinematic about this. The Republic in miniature. No longer in monochrome, but in vivid colour. In a political culture that has spent years asking Indians to fear the person next to them, strangers were, inexplicably, feeding one another. After all, the cockroach is wonderfully egalitarian. Everybody can be one. This too is politics. It is fraternity.
It is what happens when the young Hindu preparing for NEET realises that the young Muslim preparing for NEET is simply a fellow victim. Or when the unemployed graduate from Bihar meets the unemployed graduate from Uttar Pradesh and discovers that neither of them needs to know the other’s religion to understand their frustration. Or when the Brahmin student and the Dalit student can disagree about almost everything but agree that an examination should not be compromised.
For a brief moment, the political imagination of thousands of young Indians escaped the old binaries and glimpsed into an alternate possibility. An India in which a Hindu and a Muslim see more in common with each other as citizens than they see reasons to fear each other. Where a Sikh turban can stand casually beside a student’s rock ‘n’ roll t-shirt without either worrying about their Indian-ness. Fraternity.
And perhaps, in today’s India, there is no act more patriotic than refusing to hate the person standing next to you.
I ✍️ for The Leaflet. 15 Aug 2026
theleaflet.in/leaflet-specia…
@insiyahv on fraternity as protest
theleaflet.in/leaflet-specia…
207
There are moments when clinical legalism can obscure human suffering. In March 2025, a ruling by the Allahabad High Court in a POCSO case served as a chilling reminder. The case involved a 14-year-old girl subjected to a harrowing sexual assault after being lured onto a motorcycle. The accused broke the string of the girl’s pyjama to “bring down” the garment and groped her. Yet, the High Court characterized these acts as “mere preparation” rather than an “attempted rape.”
The Supreme Court swiftly intervened, setting aside the order and describing the reasoning as reflective of a “totally insensitive and inhuman approach.”
Recognising that earlier attempts at sensitising the judiciary had not produced the expected results, the Court asked the National Judicial Academy to constitute an expert committee to examine what had worked, what had failed, and on-ground experiences. Its task was to improve courtroom terminology and help move them beyond procedural compliance towards an approach that places human dignity at the heart of judicial reasoning.
The resulting 2026 handbook titled Judgments and Gender: Sensitivity and Compassion in Writing Judgments recognises that words are not neutral. Terms such as “helpless female”, “lost her chastity” and “outraging modesty” are patriarchal and may reintroduce trauma. The guidelines ask judges to leave that language behind. Its recommendation to move away from the archaic term “prosecutrix” and use terms such as “survivor” or “complainant” finally aligns court vocabulary with constitutional promises.
The need for such a recalibration is long overdue. But it is only the beginning. The Handbook itself identifies a persistent “Language-Justice Gap.” A softer vocabulary cannot, by itself, undo stereotypes of the “ideal victim”— distrusting a survivor for delayed reporting, a lack of visible injuries, or behaving calmly after trauma. The deeper shift, therefore, must be in how the law understands sexual violence. It must move away from treating it as an injury to a woman’s “chastity” or honour and recognise it as a violation of her bodily autonomy. The law must not allow patriarchal assumptions about women to determine legal reasoning.
The focus on expression and language, though well-intentioned, only addresses part of the problem. Conventional jurisprudence has historically failed vulnerable litigants through gender-insensitive logic, clinical detachment, and moral judgement of survivors. Perhaps the most tangible contribution of the 2026 handbook is the “witness as guest” mechanism. It recognises that survivors can experience a second form of victimisation within the courtroom itself, particularly when their needs and dignity are treated as secondary to that of the accused.
This shift is a necessary response to a scarred history of gender jurisprudence.
It is a painful line that connects the 1992 brutalisation of Bhanwari Devi to the Vishakha Guidelines of 1997, from horrifying tragedies in Delhi, Unnao, Kathua, Hathras, and Kolkata to the legislative responses that followed. Each episode has demanded reform. Each reform has promised that the system will do better next time. The difficulty is that there is always a “next time.”
For too long, the judiciary has been a site where public morality and judgements about women were allowed to outweigh constitutional rights. We must arrive at a system where women do not have to bleed before the law takes notice. Protecting the rights of survivors is not an act of paternal sympathy for helpless victims; it is a rigorous, evidentiary method that takes trauma seriously while protecting the dignity of the survivor as a non-negotiable constitutional right.
The handbook may change how the courts speak; but we will have to wait to see if it changes how they listen.
#Opinion | For too long, the judiciary has been a site where public morality and judgements about women were allowed to outweigh constitutional rights.
@ashishbharadwaj & @insiyahv ✍🏻
Read more about it: hindustantimes.com/opinion/a…
185
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
#Opinion | There is a peculiar ritual in India whenever citizens protest. Before we scrutinise State action, the protester must first prove the legitimacy of his grievance, justify his methods, and validate his right to protest.
@insiyahv ✍🏻
Read: hindustantimes.com/opinion/t…
There is a peculiar ritual in India whenever citizens protest. Before we scrutinise State action, the protester must first prove the legitimacy of his grievance, justify his methods, and validate his right to protest. The State responds with a familiar script: barricades, batons, and tear gas.
But constitutionally, that is the wrong question. A democracy allows citizens to dissent and protest. It is the State that must justify restricting it.
Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(b) of the Constitution permit citizens to speak, dissent and assemble. Article 14 protects equality before law, and Article 21, life and liberty. Read together, they recognise that citizens in a democracy are entitled to hold opinions and express them collectively, publicly, and peacefully.
Again and again, it has fallen upon the Supreme Court to remind the State that its power is not unlimited.
In Himat Lal K. Shah v. Commissioner of Police (1973), the Court held that the State may regulate, but not extinguish, the right to assemble publicly. In Anita Thakur (2016), compensation was awarded in recognition of police excesses. In the 2012 Ramlila Maidan protests, the Court categorised the police crackdown as an “abuse of power” and ordered criminal action against officers responsible.
Above all stands DK Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997), the Court’s landmark judgment that addresses custodial abuse.
The images from Delhi last week have shown us the dangerous impunity with which these limits were defied. Bloodied heads, broken limbs, lathi charges, pellet gun wounds. A split head is a medical injury. It becomes a constitutional injury when inflicted by the State outside the guarantees of Article 14 and 21. That is why every lathi-charge, every detention, and every use of force by the State carries a constitutional burden.
The citizen cannot answer a lathi with a lathi, or an unlawful arrest with force of his own. His only shield is the Constitution. For decades, judgment by judgment, the Court has guarded this shield. Now is the time to raise it.
Hindustan Times, 30.07.2026
hindustantimes.com/opinion/t…
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
Student-led movements have historically wreaked havoc across the world. BJP knows this well, from experience and as a beneficiary.
Listen to them — they are your own.
Insiyah Vahanvaty retweeted
Very powerful piece in @merotribune by @insiyahv
From Tiananmen to Gaza, and the Limits of a Rules-Based Order
Insiyah Vahanvaty examines what the contrast reveals about power, international law and the credibility of the rules-based order.
Read: merotribune.com/2026/07/09/f…
Hindustan Times, 02.07.26.
#supremecourt #collegiumsystem
#HTOpinion | "Historically, the collegium system itself is a judicial creation rather than a constitutional mandate. It emerged out of institutional anxiety over executive interference in judicial appointments in the years after the Emergency."
@insiyahv ✍️
#SupremeCourt #India #CollegiumSystem
Know more 🔗 hindustantimes.com/opinion/t…
136
The inexplicable logic of proof of citizenship.
I have a VOTER ID card, but NO, it is not proof of citizenship.
I have a AADHAR card but NO, it is not proof of citizenship
I have a PAN Card, but NO, it is not proof of citizenship.
I have a PASSPORT but NO, it is not proof of citizenship.
So who will give me a CITIZENSHIP CERTIFICATE? A govt bureaucrat?
My question is simple: is the problem with the citizen, or with the Mai Baap State itself?😡
289
‘We have seen our morphed pics too,’ said former Chief Justice of India BR Gavai last year. It was a humorous yet striking admission: Even judges are no longer insulated from the distortions of the digital age.
With Artificial Intelligence already embedded in legal systems across the world, AI in courts is no longer a speculative question. The question now is how deeply AI will enter the judicial system.
AI can organise documents swiftly and save time on administrative tasks. But it remains a predictive technology, built on identifying patterns in data. Judicial work, however, often requires courts to break with patterns — to protect minorities against majorities, individuals against the State, and rights against convention. AI can efficiently handle the drudgery of administration but not judicial deliberation.
The real danger is not that robots will suddenly replace judges. It is in the algorithmic shaping of a profoundly human endeavour: judicial reasoning.
A good judgment does more than state a conclusion; it constructs a chain of reasoning that situates legal doctrine within social reality. Citizens accept difficult judgments not only for the court’s authority, but also for their coherence. Judgments are valued for the intellectual labour of balancing principles, interpreting precedents, and articulating moral responsibility.
There is also the problem of hallucination. AI systems fabricate legal citations with alarming confidence. Ironically, a technology expected to reduce judicial workload has increased it by introducing the burden of verification.
Today, Indian courts occupy an unusual, paradoxical position. They are being asked to regulate AI, adjudicate on deepfakes, misinformation and data rights, while simultaneously integrating AI into their own institutional functioning. The judiciary is thus both regulator and consumer of the same technology.
The promise is that AI will eventually surpass human intelligence not only in speed and memory, but also in empathy, ethics, and creativity. Perhaps that day will come. But at present, AI does not experience human consequences. Justice, however, is built upon consequence, through judgments that alter citizens’ lives.
Judicial legitimacy rests not only on correctness, but on accountability. A judge can explain reasoning, justify interpretation, and be publicly criticised. Judgments can be overturned when reasoning no longer holds. The authority of the Court is inseparable from this responsibility.
None of this means AI should be rejected by the judiciary. Its integration is inevitable and, in many respects, desirable. But it must remain strictly assistive. The burden of moral and constitutional responsibility must remain firmly human.
This article was written by humans. AI may have written it faster, but speed is not the highest virtue of justice.
Hindustan Times, 21 May 2026.
lnkd.in/g7GbSyRg
2
95
What began as a dispute over women’s entry into the Sabarimala temple has expanded into a wider inquiry into essentiality, equality, and the limits of judicial intervention that are not confined to one faith. This means the Court is no longer resolving a localised dispute but laying down a meta-framework for how religious practices will be tested across faiths, one that could reshape the architecture of religious freedom jurisprudence.
All eyes are now turned to the Court.
hindustantimes.com/opinion/t…
#sabarimala #SupremeCourt #essentialreligiouspractice #religionandlaw #ReligiousFreedom
1
63
























