Pinned Tweet
Eqbal Ahmad died today on 11 May 1999. It’s regrettable that most young intellectuals in Pakistan consume the whole repository of Western theory on colonialism and anti-imperialism before they find out about Eqbal : an organic intellectual par excellence, a son of the soil.
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Here are my two cents on the ongoing hoopla over new provinces in Pakistan.
First, this is not a legitimate government. This is not a democracy, or even a hybrid one. The present regime rests on the most rigged elections in Pakistan’s history and, therefore, lacks the mandate to make such drastic changes to Pakistan’s federal structure. The demands for new provinces are legitimate, of course, but that is a separate discussion.
Second, reorganizing provinces has long been part of the military establishment’s agenda, especially in ways that erase the historical foundations of those units. In other words, it is a continuation of the deadly triumvirate of Urdu, Islam, and Muslim identity overriding every other marker of identity or sense of belonging. The invocation of administrative efficiency or good governance as the main justification is hogwash.
In that sense, the push for new provinces or smaller units continues the same oft-trumpeted argument about greater efficiency that was once used to justify creating a larger entity - One Unit. Imagine: there was once an argument for making all of West Pakistan a single province in the name of efficiency!
The reason is that, whether it is One Unit or ten units, such arrangements can suppress the political expression of historically constituted identities without fundamentally altering power structures. They help mask the dominance of Punjabi political, bureaucratic, military, and economic elites while safeguarding their interests. So, if anyone thinks dividing Punjab weakens the hold of the Punjabi establishment, they are mistaken. It only helps render that dominance invisible.
Punjab’s national question is different from that of any other region. Punjabi interests do not necessarily depend on articulating a distinct Punjabi national identity. Punjabi identity - or at least its iterations among the urban and professional classes - is subsumed within a larger Muslim identity, with Urdu as the medium of its expression - the ideal Pakistani Muslim citizen, in other words.
Thus, Punjabi interests can dominate even when there is no single Punjab - or, in fact, no Punjab at all.
It is remarkable how Mumtaz Daultana, a former chief minister of Punjab, offered an argument for One Unit that can be turned on its head to make precisely the opposite point. To assuage smaller provinces' fears of Punjabi domination, he argued that Punjab was merely a term of convenience, a geographical expression, and that Punjabis would cease to exist the moment Punjab was dissolved as a provincial unit. That would not be the case, he said, for Pathans, Baluch, and Sindhis, who would continue to exist even without the NWFP, Baluchistan, or Sindh.
“On the other hand, if you take away the boundaries of the Punjab, the concept of the Punjab will disappear,” said Daultana.
Well, Punjab disappeared as a provincial unit between 1955 and 1970, but neither Punjabi identity nor Punjabi elite dominance disappeared with it. Nor did the other national identities that One Unit sought to suppress. And we know where that experiment led.
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Would trade much in life to be this clear in a classroom.
Adil Zahoor retweeted
It breaks my heart to post this graph, but running away from truth never helps
Pakistan's cricket is at its lowest in 50 years, and no one has been able to arrests its fall since the 1990's
/1
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Urooj Mumtaz’s analysis and articulation is so, so good
Urooj Mumtaz talks about Pakistan's ongoing pace bowling issue teapawt.org/pctstorage_/status/209…
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Ian Botham was famously asked "who writes your scripts" ... the same could be said of Ben Stokes ... the ball after news of his retirement was broken to the ground
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Saba Mahmood was arguably Pakistan’s finest scholar with a lasting global imprint in academia. So heartening to see her legacy preserved through a fellowship in her name by her family for MPhil students studying humanities & social sciences @LifeAtLUMS. A fitting tribute to a towering intellect.
Announcing the Professor Saba Mahmood Scholarships for the MPhil in Comparative Humanities and MPhil in Society, Culture and Politics, generously established by Mr. Khalid Mahmood & family.
Apply by April 14: admission.lums.edu.pk
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Respect for Stuart Hall, born today in 1932… His texts shaped my perception of the world from my college years onward. Although I had started to use the concept “articulation” in my Turkish essays by then, it was after Hall’s informal conversation with a group of ++
Adil Zahoor retweeted
“Let me insist that “the academic” and “the intellectual” are not interchangeable terms: they are not the same thing: they may even be at the opposite ends of the scale.”
Stuart Hall on Walter Rodney.
bostonreview.net/articles/wh…
Adil Zahoor retweeted
“ The lonely hour—and truly it would be a lonely one—when we finally become ourselves never arrives.”
One of the most lucid, moving essays of the last few years
thepointmag.com/politics/pol…
Adil Zahoor retweeted
David Graeber, a companion in life. Between the tears of losing you, I share a few words about you on this strange outer-space 'twitter' that in fact you introduced me to. I hope they may help all those who are feeling your loss too.
David Graeber: Releasing the genius in us...
Adil Zahoor retweeted
IMAGINE BEING ABLE TO SAY YOU BUMPED KUSH & CORINTHIANS IN THE WHIP WITH KENDRICK LAMAR
Adil Zahoor retweeted
Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji'un
Haniya Aslam passes away. What a talented musician and kind soul. May she Rest in Peace. Truly saddening.
Adil Zahoor retweeted
A historic performance, against near-impossible odds and with the most meager of resources imaginable. The kind that inspires generations for years to come. Thanks for bringing some joy and self belief to a society deeply starved of both, #ArshadNadeem.


































