Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1) header
Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1) profile picture

Criminology. Sociology. Teesside University. Views are my own.

Teesside University
Joined September 2013
Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)Photo by Anthony Lloyd (@lloyd_a1)
Great to see the final part of our Covid-19 research in print with my copy of The New Futures of Exclusion arriving today. Not sure what to get your loved ones for Christmas? Problem solved… link.springer.com/book/10.10… @DrAnthonyEllis1 @palgravecrim
5
17
2,059
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Replying to @MrEwanMorrison
I'm grossly over-simplifying here, but very basically all organisms try to minimise individual sacrifices and maximise flourishing and reproduction when either static or moving between environments. As emotional sophistication and predictive intelligence developed, it became possible to pre-emptively sense and identify an order of sacrifice and, eventually, to imagine the self as a victim. Empathy became essential to the avoidance and minimisation of sacrifices in both the 'planning' and active stages, especially when moving towards and testing out new spatial environments. It went all wrong when the more advanced primates and humans began to construct symbolic group identities, large 'extended families' that could restrict empathy as they imagined and symbolised themselves as potential collective victims of 'rival' internal classes and external groups that might elevate themselves to more secure places in the order of sacrifice - thus the elite fear of both workers and hostile enemies. This of course was exacerbated during the agricultural revolution when primitive agricultural techniques, expanding populations and a growing sense of scarcity made land acquisition necessary. Then it gets very complex psychologically, politically and culturally, but in a nutshell history became a long-running zero-sum game. The fundamental obstacle to the extension of empathy, cooperation and solidarity beyond the 'elite' internally and the 'tribe' externally is the continuation of a heightened sense of scarcity and potential collective victimhood. Neoclassical economics and its associated politics/culture do most damage by constantly positing both resources and money as scarce, which is how they understand value and justify accumulation, hoarding and usury. Put that in the dustbin and we might start getting somewhere.
5
14
2
46
2,731
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Chickens coming home to roost. For over 20 years, @URealists criminologists argued that from local drug distribution to the global corruption of the corporations and the Epstein class, crime/harm were not in overall decline but mutating into more sophisticated forms. We were happy to accept that some traditional crimes were declining, yet we were still denounced by the UK's number-crunching neoliberal apparatchiks as 'crime decline deniers'. We warned that the expanded surveillance and incarceration behind much of the actual decline were not long-term fixes. We also warned that the police and criminal justice system, recruited into paramilitary political repression and identity politics posturing, would be unable to cope with the accelerating mutation. We were unerringly right, but our research and theoretical framework barely figured in the major textbooks. Rowley's 'reforms' will just be more sticking-plasters. Forget politics and structural socioeconomic change - as long as we remain liberal, tolerant and anti-authoritarian, everything will work out fine. Let's not assume that economics is the only social science discipline suffocated by neoliberalism's Panglossian end-of-history thought control. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgl…
9
58
2
117
3,093
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Speaking of criminology producing revealing insights into the global economy, here's the excellent @Thomas_Raymen with a forensic analysis of the EU and 'systemic greenwashing'. Corporations capture 27 states at once - nice move, neoliberals! Open access. journals.sagepub.com/doi/epu…
2
22
55
1,611
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
My fab daughter Alex has just won a Leverhulme Prize. Her forensic analyses of illicit markets, freeports and special economic zones are on the cutting edge of a criminology coming of age to produce the most revealing insights into the global economy. northumbria.ac.uk/about-us/n…
104
276
11
1,058
19,215
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
This is where I am politically right now. Despite Melenchon's rousing speeches and appeals to appropriate post-Keynesian economic policies, the current European riots have sunk into their usual headless, directionless shape. The polls have hardly shifted - le Pen was already well ahead. Any 'revolutionary' situation will be captured by the far right. The awkward corollary of what I've written below is that if we seek to construct a serious, committed opposition, first we must elicit an equal and opposite fear grounded in reality. We must replace the manufactured fears of immigrants, public 'debt', bond markets and so on with an overriding objective fear. What will really happen to the West if we carry on like this? It's an unfortunate fact that fear is the primary fuel for the hope, rational discussions of political economy and positive protest and action - aimed at what we're FOR rather than against - that come later. Dupuy's 'enlightened catastrophism' - @winlow_s has written about this cambridge.org/core/books/abs… and there's a useful summary here. cyrilhedoin.substack.com/p/e…
Replying to @geeceevee
The constant flow of 'assured nonsense' you hear from the likes of Friedman - temporary winners, aspirers and their mouthpieces - is what aroused my interest in neuropsychology years ago. Ideological positions driven at root by primary affective demands - fear of loss and sacrifice being the strongest - create what Adrian Johnston calls 'deaptation'. The very thought of true democracy and the prioritisation of collective needs - the 'public interest' - triggers that fear. The more serial market failures and their negative real effects refute their position, the more fearful they become, which strengthens their beliefs, even though, cognitively, the relatively brighter ones might understand their absurdity. The evasive ethical/cognitive justification invoked is the sort of Churchillian 'least-worst' thinking you hear all the time - "ok, this is absurd and quite awful but it's better than socialism and we'll get through this rocky patch". The worse things get - and they will - the more they will double down on their beliefs. There will be no limits to their corruption and violence. No point in reasoning with them - we must construct a serious opposition amongst the unaffected and unconvinced.
18
67
3
219
10,686
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
It's not your 'success' were complaining about. That's defensive framing to make us look 'envious'. 1. Shit wages 2. Exploitative work conditions 3. Market sector monopolisation 4. High street decline 5. Tax avoidance 6. Political interference 7. Talking bullshit on the media
BEZOS: Success is not villainy. You can be a billionaire if you started a hamburger stand.
65
506
18
1,510
16,422
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
I'm reposting this below because it's a very clear condensation of the three major claims the holders of big capital - banks, hedge funds, sovereign wealth funds, corporations, insurance funds, private pension funds, very rich individuals etc. - require us to keep believing. Suggest a programme of public spending and investment to reboot an ailing economy, and you'll have these warnings immediately fired back at you. Should we worry? Yes and no. It's very complex, so it's a long read and I'm forced to omit a lot of stuff, but bear with me, I'll try to boil it down. The claims: 1. Taxes and government borrowing from international bond markets fund public spending. 2. These international bond markets will discipline any government that runs an unfunded deficit, principally by jacking up yields to make borrowing more expensive. 4. Capital will flee the country and invest elsewhere. OK, spoiler for those short of time. Are any of these claims true? Yes, but only because Western nations continue to believe them and keep electing politicians who, along with central bankers, operate their fiat money systems in accordance with the global system these claims represent. Politically and ideologically yes, technically no. We're conditioned to think that this belief system is 'reality'. This is how belief systems have always worked - metaphysical claims on reality are what the philosophers call 'ontology', often selected and justified by naturalised ethics - this is real, it's just the way things are and it's good (or evil). The basis of this particular and very recently established (300 years or so) belief system is that capitalist markets are good (fair, efficient etc.) and national states representing organised workers are bad (tyrannical, inefficient etc.). So let markets work their magic and allow the state to intervene minimally only when they hit problems (crashes, recessions, unemployment etc.) that can always be overcome - calm down, no sweat, just keep it going. Politics is reduced to the degree of intervention we should tolerate, nothing more, but, whenever possible, less. So, the bankers, economists, politicians and hacks you see on the telly all the time looking knowledgeable, clever and rational - steady hand on the tiller! - are either 1) subjects of an ontological-ethical belief system they want you to be subjects of too, or 2) liars who know it's just a belief system but want people to keep believing it's real and letting it run as a globally locked-in system because it enriches them and their pals. A little more detail - what are these bond markets and why can capital just up and run off somewhere else when it wants? Bonds first appeared in C12 Venice as forced loans to fund a war. It all went pear-shaped, the Doge was executed by a mob of angry rich people and hired thugs, and loans were consolidated into a fund called the Monte Vecchio. It paid 5% interest - hey guys, free money to make us richer! - so the richies enjoyed it and didn't press for the repayment of the principal because that would reduce the interest, which later became known as the 'yield' as secondary markets developed in which more interest could be extracted. So, don't ask for it all back, just keep it rolling, forever if you can. Free money forever, and even more when freely trading on secondary markets with discounts. Usurer's Heaven on Earth! In those days central banks and paper money didn't exist. So governments relied on metallic coins accumulated by the richies extracting labour and produce and doing dodgy deals on coin markets like the Rialto. After that a lot of stuff happened regarding coins and metal, but if we fast forward to the C16 coin values were set by decree (face value) rather than metallic value. Between C17 and C19 paper currencies were issued backed by silver and gold reserves. Government bonds were centralised first in C17 Netherlands. Of course the VOC (Dutch East India Company) loved this as a fairly reliable stash for its boatloads of spare dosh paying yields. Bonds were more reliable than the unstable private banking system because government land and tax were the endless assets of last resort - they even had VAT! The UK set up its central bank in 1694 under invited Dutch influence and immediately started selling gilts. The richies with spare dosh immediately fell in love with it. Things started moving faster in C18 as UK bondholders struck up friendly relations with politicians to establish dependency on secondary bond markets. Beginning with the famous 'coffee-house trade' - legend has it they liked coffee because it kept them alert while doing dodgy deals - secondary markets developed as a powerful force. The principle is simple - if bond buyers can get higher yields and lower prices in the secondary private trading market, governments are pressured to match them. But only if the politicians and central bankers are friendly. They have to be friendly. And it helps if they're believers in the magic of markets and the ethical notion that savers and investors are glorifying God by making themselves rich and trickling bits of it down to the Godly but less deserving poor. Of course, now that we had central banks, paper money and government accounting ledgers, fiat currency was used in emergencies, such as the Napoleonic Wars and WWI, but that was kept quiet. The very idea that governments can create money endogenously (from within) by fiat - Franklin and Lincoln also did it in the USA - rather than relying on interest-bearing loans from private moneylenders calling themselves 'bondholders' must be seen as evil. Abandon hope all ye who do this, by Jove! J.M. Keynes worked in the Treasury during WWI, and legend has it that he saw officials fabricating bond sales in order to keep politicians and the public alike believing that private loans are essential. Bond markets were rolled out across Europe in C19. Yes, the Rothschilds were heavily involved but let's not start blaming the Jooz because that's not the case. It was the richies combined doing it. In C20 a lot of stuff happened as the UK left the gold standard in 1931, then after 1944 Bretton Woods set up a gold exchange standard based on dollar convertibility and imposed capital controls to ensure at least some profits were reinvested in domestic economies. The richies didn't like any of this, and started circumventing these controls via the Eurodollar market. Between 1971 and 1978 Western nations abandoned Bretton Woods and the gold exchange standard. Free-floating fiat money was adopted. The richies understood the necessity and potential advantages (for them) of this but also saw it as dodgy because people might get the idea that democratic (one day!) governments can issue currency to spend and invest, thereby crowding out mega-rich private lenders and cutting back on their free money. What better mechanism to impose fiscal discipline on governments than the secondary bond markets and their vicious cousin the FX (foreign exchange) markets? All they need are friendly politicians, bankers, economists and hacks. Easy gig - plenty of them, either true believers or practiced liars. So, after 1979, the plan was to set big capital free to circulate around the world, like it did in the (for them) good old days of Empire, funnelling it through global bond markets and FX markets, enriching themselves and simultaneously imposing strict fiscal discipline on governments. By the way, lately, rapidly developing nations such as China have used massive dollops of public investment and capital controls to boost their economies. So the richies and their little helpers try to convince us to hate them as tyrants and watch as their economy eventually collapses into a vortex of unpayable debt - which it hasn't, of course, but we're supposed to live in hope. In 1979 the first thing the Thatcherites did was abandon capital controls. Other Western nations got the idea and stock (the productive end is more risky, so careful!), bond and FX markets (less risky and lucrative!) - the 'money markets' - were rolled out globally after 1980 by a powerful politician/banker/investor/media alliance whose adherents firmly believe (or want us to) that money markets should discipline and control governments. Of course they also gift them safe savings and endless oodles of free money in the form of yields, but you know, that's just a little sweetener for the valiant 'risk takers'..... even though these markets aren't very risky. Technical disempowerment would be quite simple - firm policies in the primary sales, central bank intervention, fixed-rate, non-tradable bonds and capital controls to throttle the secondary market and FX markets - but this would require coordinated policies initially across the G10.... or G8 first, because the Brits and Yanks wouldn't have it, would they? Some nation must be brave and set the ball rolling. We simply lack the politicians willing and able to do this. And we continue believing. Machiavelli said the best way to instill belief is fear - divine punishment. This is how it works. The markets are the divine supplier of fairness, efficiency, consumer democracy and prosperity to Godly (optional these days) sovereign individuals. Disobey them and we will be punished. Escaping this will be as big a leap for freedom as escaping from the Mediaeval Catholic Church.
Replying to @RichardJMurphy
If "taxpayers' money" is a myth and governments can just endlessly finance themselves by creating ledger entries, why do sovereign bond markets exist? As we just saw discussed this morning, the moment a government tries to actually operate on this MMT fantasy and run massive unfunded deficits, international bond markets price their debt at junk status and capital flees. You are advertising an economic fairy tale Richard.
25
168
13
357
21,986
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Accelerated decline down through comic-book fantasies to the strange Dystopia of atomised individuals serviced by online porn, crypto gambling, Amazon deliveries and the local drug-dealer.
In brightest day, in blackest night, no evil shall escape my sight. Let those who worship evil's might beware my power... Green Lantern's light!
10
50
1
183
4,677
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
I order a lot of secondhand and vintage books online. This year the prices jumped and I chalked it up to inflation. I was wrong. The reason behind the spike in prices is what AI companies euphemistically dub "destructive scanning." That is when they buy millions of second-hand books in bulk and send them to enormous warehouses across America. There, automated assembly lines cut the pages from the spines and then feed the pages into huge industrial scanners. Those books are being harvested for their text to expand the database for the LLM models. The physical pages? Later discarded. Some of these are the last remaining editions of historical and collectible works — once they're cut and scanned, they're gone. Booksellers across the UK, Germany, New Zealand, Australia and the U.S. are reporting the same thing: bulk, random, non-fiction orders. Orders have ranged from 1,000 books to as many as a million in a single purchase. Just one vendor contract called for scanning 500,000 to 2 million books. Anthropic ran this under an internal name, Project Panama, and tried to keep it quiet. Some booksellers noticed something was odd. A Devon bookseller, for instance, got an odd order this summer for books on subjects as disparate as Cornish pioneers in South Africa, cheeses of the world, and Hong Kong jewelry — from a "shipping company" near Heathrow. Her suspicions grew fast. It turned out to an AI run office. I should have seen this coming. I'm one of the author-plaintiffs in the Bartz et al. v. Anthropic class action — a different kind of theft. Anthropic had trained Claude on more than seven million digitized books, sourced from pirate websites, without paying a penny to authors or publishers. Mine included, seven of my thirteen. There are 120,000 individual authors and rightsholders (representing 447,576 eligible works out of 482,460 total listed books). A federal judge approved the $1.5 billion settlement this summer. It was the court documents from that litigation that exposed Project Panama. I missed it until the story recently hit the Washington Post and Daily Mail and other outlets. Having learned an expensive lesson from its class action payout, Anthropic is now going after physical books a different way — and legally, this time. Under the first-sale doctrine, established by the Supreme Court in 1908, once someone buys a physical book, they can do whatever they want with it, including destroying it. So Anthropic attorneys have determined that buying and scanning a physical copy sidesteps the piracy problem. And once that book is shredded, any future Claude user can draw on its contents for free — the original gone forever. Some call this a modern-day book burning. The Nazis destroyed books to erase what was in them — these companies destroy books to steal the information and then essentially sell it back to you. I am still angry this is somehow legal.
105
778
108
1,606
117,966
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
After 47 years of Thatcherism from all parties, chickens are coming home to roost. We face sporadic eruptions like this in the deindustrialised zones for the foreseeable future. But, as long as we keep the 'bond markets' happy, that's all that matters. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c2e0…
22
122
5
384
9,277
Terrible for everyone involved and their families. I’ve worked with Cleveland Police for four years, including its Roads Policing Unit. They’re good people doing an incredibly difficult job. This is devastating news.
1
2
497
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
The creditor class is asset-stripping right through to the heart of our public institutions. Galileo Global Education is backed by private equity specialist Montagu, the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB), Téthys Invest (the Bettencourt-Meyers family), and Bpifrance. Don't forget, some of these parasites and their 'asset managers' are leveraged up to their necks - borrowing cheap money to invest and get their free money from indebted students underwritten by the British state. What an incredible scam.
Private equity backed European education group eyes takeovers of UK universities. Govts created crisis. Froze fees, limits on foreign students. 40% of unis in financial distress, What will private equity cut? Takeover will be funded by student loans. archive.ph/lPWC1
10
129
5
241
6,328
RT @ProfHall1955: Arday/Cambridge is but one case. Sociology has been collapsing for a good while now. Can it be saved? Quite possibly, but…
4
1
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
This is a tremendous piece.
The Ruffian has LANDED. This week: the Jason Arday scandal. What the hell happened, and what does it all mean?
14
29
1
323
103,525
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Yes, we ignore economists who understand structures and system dynamics to flock around those who are limited to band-aid palliatives. Which is what the establishment want. Like all private, debt-based usury systems since 1500BC, this one is dying at the roots. Debt overwhelms the productive system's ability to repay, therefore such systems are inherently time-limited. The beginning of the end is always characterised by constantly broken political promises and the subsequent rise of incoherent populist anger. The 'successful' rentier-monopolists don't care - they let economies crash, welcome the so-called 'dark age' interregnum, grab assets on the cheap, with a bit of fascistic violence where necessary, and start over. Because they're uncivilised money-grubbing hucksters incapable of foresight or understanding higher purposes, they find all this quite exciting. 3500 years of circular non-history. Until we put a stop to it, issue credit as a public good and kick-start real history.
16
56
3
112
4,811
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Absurd. We've now stepped through the Looking Glass. The world's footballers should walk out and the USA under Trump or anyone like him should never again host a major football competition. bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art…
4
19
54
816
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Right on the money as usual from @winlow_s, the UK's finest ethnographer and social theorist. The decomposition of the traditional British working class. Open access. journals.uwyo.edu/index.php/…
6
36
96
5,322
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
New from me. Free to read here: ‘Living in the Ruins: Melancholic Nostalgia and the Decomposition of the Traditional Working Class’ journals.uwyo.edu/index.php/…
1
9
15
680
Excellent new research from @winlow_s on melancholic nostalgia and the decomposition of the traditional working class in England. It’s hugely important that we understand and make sense of how we got here. journals.uwyo.edu/index.php/…
1
1
3
174
Anthony Lloyd retweeted
Yes indeed - rentier profiteering. Reduce the service, reduce the employees, siphon out the returns and compound interest, increase the share value. The bedrock of the global financial capitalist system is corruption, exploitation and extraction. A criminal enterprise.
and I received this yesterday - “to deliver a better all-round service”. This corporate scrounging needs to stop
7
90
1
152
3,127