Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley) header
Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley) profile picture

Netholabs — NYC | SF | DC

New York, USA
Joined July 2009
Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)Photo by Margot Hanley PhD (@margothanley)
+1 on medium term questions
Two things I’ve been thinking about regarding AI: • People often highlight the risks involved in AI, which are surely very real. I’m struck, however, by how hard it is to understand the contours of the positive scenario. There are easy-to-perceive and frequently invoked elements of a positive vision — more diseases cured, more material abundance, etc. — which sound great, but these are by themselves just ingredients. I’m curious what the larger equilibrium is supposed to look like. Do people work? If so, why? What is their marginal contribution? If not, how are resources allocated? What is scarce? What is the ratio between humans and AIs? Are humans in control, whatever that means? One sometimes hears the Culture novels invoked as one scenario, but I’m not sure they depict a desirable outcome. (AI runs everything and humans compete in games? Iain Banks himself said that the humans in the Culture are “somewhere between passengers, pets and parasites.”) There is Richard Brautigan’s famous poem, but do we want to be “returned to our mammal brothers and sisters”? (Isn’t that rewinding Genesis?) We could say that it was hard to imagine the world of 1900 from the vantage point of 1700, and that’s assuredly true. But nobody in 1700 was trying to recast humanity itself within a couple of years — things necessarily unfolded slowly and by increments, and therefore with the possibility for error correction. Given how rapid the rate of progress in AI may be, it feels strange for the upside case to be so opaque. • There is increasing discussion of whether AIs are conscious or how we would know whether they are, with conclusions there often assumed to be relevant to matters of moral worth. At first blush, this seems a rather arcane, benign, or even absurd issue. (Remember the response to Blake Lemoine’s fears.) Setting aside the terms of the debate itself, or the relevant demarcation criteria, it seems to me a quite high-stakes question, for an affirmative answer — that is, granting moral worth to AIs — would presumably mean that the aggregate worth of AIs would soon outweigh that of humans in any utilitarian calculus. The AIs will be exceptionally wise and intelligent, and vastly more numerous (especially once one considers the imminent future and the AIs not yet born). As such, even epsilon of moral worth will multiply to a lot once one considers the quadrillions that could soon exist. (This is effectively a distributed version of the Nozick’s utility monster.) If this conclusion is unpalatable, I think one of three propositions needs to be rejected: the premise AIs can have moral worth; utilitarianism itself; or the belief that there is even a possibility that they will be far more numerous than humans. With both of these matters (contours of future society; AI moral worth), there is the possibility of dramatic change. Today, people argue about datacenters. I’m curious how popular support for AI will evolve as more people come to understand these medium-term questions and the relevant stakes. What is the vision for AI that most people would be excited about?
42
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
Two things I’ve been thinking about regarding AI: • People often highlight the risks involved in AI, which are surely very real. I’m struck, however, by how hard it is to understand the contours of the positive scenario. There are easy-to-perceive and frequently invoked elements of a positive vision — more diseases cured, more material abundance, etc. — which sound great, but these are by themselves just ingredients. I’m curious what the larger equilibrium is supposed to look like. Do people work? If so, why? What is their marginal contribution? If not, how are resources allocated? What is scarce? What is the ratio between humans and AIs? Are humans in control, whatever that means? One sometimes hears the Culture novels invoked as one scenario, but I’m not sure they depict a desirable outcome. (AI runs everything and humans compete in games? Iain Banks himself said that the humans in the Culture are “somewhere between passengers, pets and parasites.”) There is Richard Brautigan’s famous poem, but do we want to be “returned to our mammal brothers and sisters”? (Isn’t that rewinding Genesis?) We could say that it was hard to imagine the world of 1900 from the vantage point of 1700, and that’s assuredly true. But nobody in 1700 was trying to recast humanity itself within a couple of years — things necessarily unfolded slowly and by increments, and therefore with the possibility for error correction. Given how rapid the rate of progress in AI may be, it feels strange for the upside case to be so opaque. • There is increasing discussion of whether AIs are conscious or how we would know whether they are, with conclusions there often assumed to be relevant to matters of moral worth. At first blush, this seems a rather arcane, benign, or even absurd issue. (Remember the response to Blake Lemoine’s fears.) Setting aside the terms of the debate itself, or the relevant demarcation criteria, it seems to me a quite high-stakes question, for an affirmative answer — that is, granting moral worth to AIs — would presumably mean that the aggregate worth of AIs would soon outweigh that of humans in any utilitarian calculus. The AIs will be exceptionally wise and intelligent, and vastly more numerous (especially once one considers the imminent future and the AIs not yet born). As such, even epsilon of moral worth will multiply to a lot once one considers the quadrillions that could soon exist. (This is effectively a distributed version of the Nozick’s utility monster.) If this conclusion is unpalatable, I think one of three propositions needs to be rejected: the premise AIs can have moral worth; utilitarianism itself; or the belief that there is even a possibility that they will be far more numerous than humans. With both of these matters (contours of future society; AI moral worth), there is the possibility of dramatic change. Today, people argue about datacenters. I’m curious how popular support for AI will evolve as more people come to understand these medium-term questions and the relevant stakes. What is the vision for AI that most people would be excited about?
525
469
201
5,497
935,497
Soaking up as much beauty as possible before I return west Location tag: Sailor
2
44
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
.@nathanfielder, you should moderate a US president debate ; h/t @margothanley
2
1
4
1,120
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
Neurotech is Humanity’s Next Frontier! I’ve been investing in neurotech since 2021 and working with teams building BCIs, NeuroAI, and connectomics. It now feels like AI did in ~2019. We are entering an extraordinary era: neurotech already restores functions, it can enhance our capabilities, and will evolve what it means to be human. PLC Neurotech is the fund backing the extraordinary founders and defining companies of this booming industry.
69
131
52
941
551,356
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
New pub! @MargotHanley and I coauthored this article on anthropomorphized artificial intelligence in @BigDataSoc. We show how engineers make technology that conveys what we call "shifting personhood" by selectively designing anthropomorphic qualities. journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.…
1
6
317
NRF Chair @yusterafa alongside co-chair @JaredGenser and director of industry affairs @margothanley visit the White House Advocating for neurorights @WhiteHouse
3
21
3
40
2,531
Philosophers @FAccTConference! @sethlazar and I are organizing dinner/drinks tomorrow evening (Wed, June 5). Let me know here if you're interested in joining and I'll send you a link to our Signal group! #FAccT24
3
4
15
3,264
🌟We are proud to announce the unanimous approval of the Colorado neural data protection bill by the Senate. This bill represents a historic bipartisan step in declaring Colorado the first place in world to legally define and protect neural data as sensitive.🌟 We send immense gratitude to @SeanPauzauskie , @Cathy_Kipp , Reps. Kipp and Soper, and Senators Baisley and Priola for making this possible.
18
89
14
133
7,642
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
Colorado neural data protection bill approved unanimously by Senate 34-0! In a bipartisan effort, Colorado becomes first place in world to legally define and protect neural data as sensitive. Thanks @SeanPauzauskie @Cathy_Kipp Reps. Kipp and Soper and Senators Baisley and Priola
3
24
6
49
5,236
The historic Neurodata protection bill HB24-1058 passes the Colorado House on a vote of 61-1!!
15
50
14
112
13,258
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
Judicial Committee of Colorado House of Representatives unanimously approves neurodata protection bill! Thanks to Reps. Kipp and Soper and the Colorado Medical Society for sponsoring it. Honored to testify in favor of this historic bill!
Today, NCMS President Dr. Pauzauskie testified in support of HB 1058: Protect Privacy of Biological Data. This first-in-the-nation legislation sponsored by @Cathy_Kipp and @SoperMatthew will protect the privacy of individuals' personal biological data. #coloradophysicians
1
11
2
23
3,335
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
Two places in the world today with legal protection of brain activity: the Republic of Chile and the State of Rio Grande in Brazil !!
The Brazilian state of Rio Grande do Sul has incorporated neurorights into its constitution 🇧🇷 Thank you to all who helped make this possible!!!
6
24
39
5,652
Margot Hanley PhD retweeted
universities around the world are in fierce competition to create a website with the most crowded, fucked-up navigation header
7
3
103
Can you imagine the reaction if I had said that?
274
480
159
8,181