
Born early 60s, retiree living in Melbourne, Australia (ex Sydney). Interested in justice, progress, environment, @NRL_Bulldogs, @GWSGIANTS, $QNT, $XRP.
Melbourne, Victoria
Joined March 2009
- Tweets45.5K
- Following2.1K
- Followers1.5K
- Likes49.7K
Pinned Tweet
Started on Twitter in 2009. My main reason was to vent about Aussie politics (an enduring frustration of mine). Also to comment on the @NRL_Bulldogs (another frustration). I've expanded my scope to include global politics (the US yet another frustration) and financial technology.
2
4
2,662
Of course Pat has the full support of CA. He's doing exactly what they've told him to do.
#BREAKING: Pat Cummins will remain the captain of the Australian cricket team after receiving a "unanimous" vote of support from the Cricket Australia board. ab.co/4C7BEuq
18
It's a bugger of a job at #COP31 alright. How do you put together a statement which sounds like you're making progress when nobody actually wants to commit to progress?
36
Mark Dixon retweeted
Jesus and I will be playing GTA VI straight through Sunday. If you need anything pray to Zeus.
Mark Dixon retweeted
Over the last few days I've had so many people come and tell me they are voting Green for the very first time.
Pascoe Vale has been held by Labor for over 40 years. We can turn it Green 💚
A better future is possible, vote #1 Greens!
vote.greens.org.au/
Mark Dixon retweeted
People don't fake a depression. They fake being okay... Remember that. Be kind.
— Robin Williams
Hey Victoria. Don't want to vote Labor but aren't impressed with the Liberals, Nationals or One Nation? There is an alternative which makes sense...
What you get with the Greens:
🏡 Affordable housing
🚃 Permanently free public transport
🦷 Free dental clinics
🍏 Cheaper groceries
Leadership that works for you - not big corporations 💚
Vote #1 Greens
vote.greens.org.au
14
Mark Dixon retweeted
I assume someone, somewhere is writing a doctoral thesis on how Labor went in one generation from the party of Keating, Wran, Carr and Bracks to that of Albanese, Marles, Andrews and Minns.
Something like "From giants to pissants: the incredible shrinking Labor party 1985-2025."
Mark Dixon retweeted
Governments who crack down on protests are usually dictatorships and authoritarian governments.
Vote #1 Greens 💚
victoriangreens.org/join-for…
Mark Dixon retweeted
We need to stop regarding political opinions as sitting on a one-dimensional “left/right” continuum. You may despise Donald Trump (as I do) while agreeing with him on one issue (as I do). Each one of us is better seen as a point in MULTI-dimensional space. The number of dimensions is open to discussion, as is their interaction with each other, and the feasibility of reducing their number because of correlations. Moreover, we need to form our opinions on each issue separately, in its own right, instead of identifying with a “tribe”, especially a tribe with its own social-media “echo chamber.”
#abc730 Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive!
1
101
Mark Dixon retweeted
We said we were here to replace Labor and we meant it!
The Greens have a positive plan to make life affordable and put people before corporate profit.
It’s time for real change 💚
It's really not apples v apples here. You can pay high taxes and get a lot back from government, ie value for money. You can pay high taxes and get very little back from government. That's a rip-off.
60
Replying to @JEChalmers
@JEChalmers @AlboMP I would suggest giving strong consideration to Allegra Spender's CGT proposals. It would show that you're listening to feedback and willing to take advice from respected non Labor sources. Her reform suggestion makes sense to me.
1
28
GOOD STICKY TAPE?? OR NOT??
Allegra Spender suggests changing the new CGT arrangements outside of property - going back to the discount approach, but at 40% rather than 50%
That wouldn't be the best outcome, but it is probably better than what we're otherwise getting
Let me step back for a moment
Remember that it absolutely makes sense to tax capital income differently to how we tax wages
1). Partly that's because we tax wages immediately, but we only tax capital gains after they're realised. So, unless we adjust for it, part of the gain we're otherwise taxing is simply inflation
2). Partly it's because we tax a capital gain as if it has been earned all at once - even though it's usually been earned over some years. As we have a progressive tax system, that lumpiness can unfairly push people into a higher tax bracket
3). And partly it is because we need to save before we can earn a return on those savings, so taxing those returns therefore means we tax savers more than we tax spenders
That backdrop means that ideally we should:
1). adjust for inflation,
2). average out capital gains, and
3). provide a discount relative to the tax on wages
But that's not what the government has done
Yes, it has allowed indexation for inflation. But it didn't allow averaging to smooth out the lumpiness of returns. (Instead, it put in a minimum tax rate). And it didn't allow for any ongoing discount
And, although it has allowed for inflation indexation, that's only on gains - not on losses. That doesn't matter much for property. But it does for shares - effectively boosting the tax rate on portfolios
That backdrop means three things
First, that Australia has gone from taxing capital gains too little to taxing them too much, with both the old and new systems being less than ideal
Second, the Allegra option therefore needs to be compared with the government's legislation - not with perfection. And on that front the Allegra option is, in my view, the better bet
Third, it looks to me as if the government's estimates of the revenue it'll raise through its approach are too low. It has tried so hard to plug potential loopholes that it has overegged its rules and underegged its estimated tax take. In turn, that says to me that the Allegra option won't hurt the bottom line versus the costings in the budget
The bottom line?
The Allegra option isn't perfect
But perfect isn't on the menu
So count me in
12
























