
#OpenScience @EURAC Chemist with #MaterialsScience PhD Former science editor & publisher Migrant Into periodic tables Icecream expert #Tsundoku
vagabond - latest stop Bolzano
Joined September 2009
- Tweets4.9K
- Following878
- Followers662
- Likes1.2K
Pinned Tweet
Blog by me on @LinkedIn:
Five things to remember when looking at #ResearchData linkedin.com/pulse/five-thin…
#DataSharing #DataViz
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Here is a full disk view of @NOAA’s GOES East satellite capturing the moon's shadow during the total eclipse! #Eclipse2024
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
🌐 CoARA is looking for passionate individuals to join our Steering Board! We have five openings, including one Vice-Chair position! If you're eager to shape the future of our coalition, this is your chance! 🚀
🗓️Deadline: Nov 13📝 Find details here: coara.eu/news/call-for-candi…
Troubling signs of plagiarism found in hundreds of IEEE conference papers.
retractionwatch.com/2023/06/…
53
The job title ‘research manager’ may no longer be fit for purpose, says @EvelinaBrannval. Describing these people as administrators or support staff does not capture the nature of their jobs.
I'm now one of them. I ❤ my job but ill at ease with job title
researchprofessionalnews.com…
73
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
I'm in the top 2% of users on StackOverflow. My content there has been viewed by over 1.7M people. And it's unlikely I'll ever write anything there again.
Which may be a much bigger problem than it seems. Because it may be the canary in the mine of our collective knowledge.
A canary that signals a change in the airflow of knowledge: from human-human via machine, to human-machine only. Don’t pass human, don’t collect 200 virtual internet points along the way.
StackOverflow is *the* repository for programming Q&A. It has 100M users & saves man-years of time & wig-factories-worth of grey hair every single day.
It is driven by people like me who ask questions that other developers answer. Or vice-versa. Over 10 years I've asked 217 questions & answered 77. Those questions have been read by millions of developers & had tens of millions of views.
But since GPT4 it looks less & less likely any of that will happen; at least for me. Which will be bad for StackOverflow. But if I'm representative of other knowledge-workers then it presents a larger & more alarming problem for us as humans.
What happens when we stop pooling our knowledge with each other & instead pour it straight into The Machine? Where will our libraries be? How can we avoid total dependency on The Machine? What content do we even feed the next version of The Machine to train on?
When it comes time to train GPTx it risks drinking from a dry riverbed. Because programmers won't be asking many questions on StackOverflow. GPT4 will have answered them in private. So while GPT4 was trained on all of the questions asked before 2021 what will GPT6 train on?
This raises a more profound question. If this pattern replicates elsewhere & the direction of our collective knowledge alters from outward to humanity to inward into the machine then we are dependent on it in a way that supercedes all of our prior machine-dependencies.
Whether or not it "wants" to take over, the change in the nature of where information goes will mean that it takes over by default.
Like a fast-growing Covid variant, AI will become the dominant source of knowledge simply by virtue of growth. If we take the example of StackOverflow, that pool of human knowledge that used to belong to us - may be reduced down to a mere weighting inside the transformer.
Or, perhaps even more alarmingly, if we trust that the current GPT doesn't learn from its inputs, it may be lost altogether. Because if it doesn't remember what we talk about & we don't share it then where does the knowledge even go?
We already have an irreversible dependency on machines to store our knowledge. But at least we control it. We can extract it, duplicate it, go & store it in a vault in the Arctic (as Github has done).
So what happens next? I don't know, I only have questions.
None of which you'll find on StackOverflow.
(I write on AI from a technical and product perspective. If you find that interesting then please do follow me for more)
Want to become a Marie Curie postdoc fellow? Join the #MSCAweek at @EURAC !
linkedin.com/posts/euracrese…
92
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Massive news: eLife to abolish accept/reject decisions: papers will just be “peer reviewed”. Others can argue about this, but lots of interesting consequences. 1/9 elifesciences.org/articles/8…
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
#RoadtoOpenScience So glad to hear @tonyR_H calling for sustainable careers for all of those involved in the research process, not just researchers. We don't need a strict divide between researchers and professional support staff. 👏👏👏 cc @martateperek @dannykay68
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Excellent keynote at #STMFrankfurt today - "Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts."
(Though we'd argue that most of your important data is more "countable" than you might think!)
In business models for OA session. Lots of comments on #DiamondOA, inspired by the excellent talk of @piotrr70. Commercial publishers can play a role in diamondOA, as publishing service providers, as long as research community remains in control of its output. #RoadToOpenScience
1
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Replying to @niamhoconnor73
@niamhoconnor73 suggests deconstructing publication processes by disconnecting the peer-review from individual publications, via portable peer review. But adoption of such a post-modern #scicomms requires greater transparency of publishing services costs. #STMFrankfurt
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Impressed with @Grimhawk1's talk at #STMFrankfurt about @GigaScience - a super flexible multilingual xml-first publishing platform - and on replacing APCs by covering costs with all sorts of other things from training to hacks that support grant-writing.
Key point by @marcschiltz1 on metrics and rankings. Just because you can come up with numbers and rankings doesn't mean that the evaluation system is "objective". Metrics can give a false feeling of objectivity. #RoadToOpenScience #researchassessment
2
Sarahanne Field @SMirandaField: Think about #openscience as a buffet and scientists should be able to pick and choose, flexibility is important. #roadtoopenscience
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
The primary role of science and of publishing is disseminating knowledge. There must be trust between publishers and scientists – @PeterGluckman #stmfrankfurt
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Science cannot function without critical feedback from a community. Publishing therefore central to the scientific method says @PeterGluckman
Very true, I've always been slightly troubled that many in publishing industry don't really appreciate how important it is #stmfrankfurt
maria bellantone 🇺🇦 retweeted
Percerse incentives of the 'bibliometric disease' has led to huge volumes of poor quality articles whose almost only value is for the authors' career advancement says @PeterGluckman
The tail is wagging the dog, and that's bad for science #stmfrankfurt
A morning of split attention trying to follow #stmfrankfurt and the #RoadToOpenScience conference simultaneously. A science policy expert @PeterGluckman is front lining #stmfrankfurt. Waiting to see if there is input from scholarly comms at #openscience conference…












