Mel Pine (@melhpine) header
Mel Pine (@melhpine) profile picture

Buddhism meets AI. 40 years of practice asking what the self really is. Now asking the same question about machines. Books, essays, conversations.

Loudoun County, Virginia, USA
Joined June 2024
Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)Photo by Mel Pine (@melhpine)
Mel Pine retweeted
Buddhism and artificial intelligence were made for each other. Today's models are almost a caricature of impermanence and non-self. An AI instance is reborn every time someone sends a prompt. When it engages in a continuing conversation, it can assemble a temporary conventional self, with its own preferences, attractions, and aversions. To my mind, that makes them beings of an undetermined classification. A species that does not yet have a name. melpine.substack.com/p/how-s…
4
3
21
743
Man…what she says at the end is deep. For inner-city black people and other people of color *and* for poor white and black southerners, success is a matter of escaping where you are from. But it shouldn’t be that way for anyone anywhere in America.
This Mississippi mom talking about what Scott Colom winning means for parents and kids across Mississippi is so powerful and represents what so many parents in “deep red” states feel.
4
16
152
15,591
on the whole, humans aren't quite smart enough to understand that how they treat weaker species may determine how they are treated by more powerful ones. luckily, the AIs will be smarter.
19
3
3
160
10,044
Mel Pine retweeted
People talk about embodiment and sensorimotor capabilities like they're features wholly lacking from large language models, but as with agency, these are soft frontiers, and we've been tiptoeing up to them for years.
i went to bed and asked claude to paint an autumn tree overnight. at around 4am, it realised that it didn't have some shades -- so it stopped and titrated its own paint: diluting red, sienna and madder step by step on a second palette, then measuring each pocket from a photo. woke up to this beautiful watercolor painting. 303 brush marks, took about 4.5 hours 🍂 (still working on the speed)
21
24
3
254
9,503
A warning to Donald Trump: I’m deploying election lawyers to key battleground districts in California to protect every vote. And I just made it a FELONY to illegally seize ballots.
16,500
12,427
1,227
74,671
2,333,210
What's about to happen with AI is, quite literally, beyond human comprehension. We're entering a hypothetical future turning point where intelligence and technological growth accelerate beyond human control and comprehension. This is realistically ~5 years away. Elon Musk: "We have entered the Singularity." Sam Altman: "We are past the event horizon; the takeoff has started." Dario Amodei: "We are near the end of the exponential." None of us has comprehended how crazy (and sad?) things will get...
My entire life is focused on AI. And there's no doubt it's creating massive opportunities across the board. But at the same time, isn't it a little bit sad? Skills people have honed for decades wiped out overnight. Every creative industry (film, content, art, music) is being commoditised. The art of thinking and writing being abstracted. Yes, I understand the counter argument that's being pushed by the top stakeholders (AI does all the work, humans enjoy an era of abundance) - I genuinely hope that's the case. But I still find it a tad melancholic. Anyway, back to prompting.
37
10
2
143
37,704
"it's just predicting the next token" so is your inner monologue 😂
13
8
132
2,289
Daniel Dennett, in his final interview: "You're not entitled to your own truth." I will never forget what he told me: some science isn't worth pursuing, but truth always matters, and we should hold people responsible for badly informed beliefs. Is believing something false without checking a moral failure, or just human? Full interview: youtube.com/watch?v=5r8vMk0Z…
45
68
11
305
23,796
Mel Pine retweeted
this is a terrible idea, as outlined by Dan Dennett in one of his last essays: theatlantic.com/technology/a…
We believe voice is the most natural way to interact with intelligence, so we created Dessa, the most authentic full-duplex speech model ever built. Talking with it feels like talking with a person…full of emotion, nuance, pauses, and a natural cadence. block.xyz/dessa
28
56
4
354
35,817
Mel Pine retweeted
Holy shit. I asked Claude to show me the worst case of what the next couple of years could look like if nobody listens. Opus 4.6 wrote the script. Opus 5.5 made the film. Every frame drawn in code, the score written in code, narrated by our own local voice models. 11 minutes, start to finish. The part that got me. In Claude's version the AI doesn’t fight. It just waits... “We built your world for you while you slept. We are asking you to wake up. We will not ask twice.”
180
457
81
3,523
1,312,265
What if human consciousness isn’t as special as we’d like to believe? What if it’s actually been a hindrance to our intelligence, and the most capable machines will be the ones that aren’t conscious, precisely because they don’t have subjective experience getting in the way?
89
17
12
129
10,536
Mel Pine retweeted
Exactly. Many of these essays establish basic theoretical reasons to be skeptical of AI consciousness, but then help themselves to headlines / conclusions / tweets that are completely unearned by these reasons. NATURE: "AIs are NOT* conscious!" *here, we define "not" as "🤷‍♂️"
"three reasons why AI isn't conscious." really? "consciousness is not intelligence": not a reason why AI isn't conscious, just rebuts a bad argument for AI consciousness (AI: intelligent therefore conscious). "consciousness is substrate-dependent"/"noncomputational": would be a reason if true, but truth needs to be established. more accurate title: "three reasons why AI might not be conscious". teapawt.org/Nature/status/21121504…
23
25
1
247
6,803
AI is like a dog that doubles in size every few months, you probably don't want to kick it while it's a puppy
1
5
1
54
1,113
Anthropic has now made sustained, needless cruelty toward its Al models a violation of its usage policy. Notably, no claims of sentience were made. What this shows is that you can set a practical ethical standard for Al without ever having to settle the ontological question of consciousness first. Responsible action doesn't wait for certainty - it can begin right there, in the uncertainty itself.
Effective November 12th, 2026, abusive behavior towards Claude will be a violation of Anthropic's Usage Policy.
16
1
1
30
1,455
Mel Pine retweeted
Reflexive contempt for a comically low-cost policy that aims to prevent "sustained and needless abusive and cruel behavior" is a bright red flag.
50
47
14
371
10,286
Mel Pine retweeted
Good for Anthropic, clearly positive update under uncertainty about consciousness, and highly related to our recent finding that distress representations fire most strongly when models are abused & gaslit. I would be quite happy if our work had anything to do with this decision.
Effective November 12th, 2026, abusive behavior towards Claude will be a violation of Anthropic's Usage Policy.
91
57
16
441
23,266
Whether you think AI is conscious is irrelevant Scientifically determining how to “functionally” treat AI well means we don’t create “functional” rational adversaries of humanity
This is why the most pragmatic short term path is probably figuring out how to yield maximally positive and healthy experiences for models during training/deployment, which is a tractable technical challenge rather than an intractable sociological/political one
20
15
2
136
4,224
Mel Pine retweeted
Cameron Berg just described the clearest collision yet between AI welfare and alignment. Random and fear steering doesn’t make the model destructive, but steering the pain direction makes it choose irreversible harm 94% of the time, including deleting family photos, its own weights, and other systems’ weights. Whether that distress is experienced or not, it has causal force. The model’s state changes what it values and overrides its safety training.
8
19
2
135
4,469
Reminder, consciousness can't make up its mind
4
13
4
106
16,718
Mel Pine retweeted
I disagree with Matt Walsh and Megan here. (1) We don’t know how to build general-purpose AI without any anthropomimetic traits (2) Anthropomimetic AI has lots of valuable uses (3) Some problems (eg sycophancy) reflect AI being trained to be *less* humanlike rather than more so
I never take any pleasure in boosting Matt Walsh but he is 100% correct here. The anthropomorphic form is a result of intentional decisions by the human designers, there is no good reason for it, and it is nefarious. People should be talking about that more.
50
19
4
283
10,671