MODBAN retweeted
This is why we argue that Muslim scholarship is often characterized by desperate polemics.
This particular fella claims that the established text isn't actually written down and that the overwhelming consensus of scholarship over the past 1,400 years has been incorrect.
He argues that his understanding of Allah involved instructing the People of the Book to follow a recitation through memorization.
Additionally, he interprets the Quran's statement that the text is "between their hands" to mean it is not actually present.
@ModernDayDebate ask him if he wants to debate @SCApologia or @JaiNDoC_RL. He is a prolific poster all day on X; certainly, he has time to debate.
Nice straw man. The Qur’anic term gospel refers only to the words and teachings of Jesus. Some of those words and teachings of Jesus are extant in the four gospels and by close analysis can be distilled and distinguished from later generations’ accretions and interpretations of his words that are in the New Testament writings. But the four gospels, the New Testament and the gospel taught by Jesus are by no means co extensive. Quran 5:48 and surrounding verses are referring to the legal teachings of Jesus, nothing more. Your argument rests on intentional equivocation on your part between gospel narratives, New Testament canon and the teachings of Jesus.
If Muhammad's authority depends on the Quran, and the Quran's authority depends on Muhammad, where is the independent verification?
Muslims please use your brain and stop allowing satan to draw you into a false religion
Muslims, are you for real?
"We love the Ka'aba because Allah commanded us to love it. And we will defend that love with our lives, our wealth, and our voices, till the last day."
Is it possible that 2billion Muslims are unexplainable morons ?
This quoted post is unavailable.
1
5
459
🚨HEADLINE: Muhammad & Allah committed shirk
MUSLIMS claim Islam is pure Tawhid. But the Quran, Hadith, and earliest Sira show both Allah & Muhammad fail
Rule: Muhammad said "Whoever swears by other than Allah has committed shirk" (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi).
Shirk is worst & unforgivable Quran 4:48
1. Allah commits shirk. He swears by created things:
· Sun & moon (91:1–2)
· Night & daybreak (92:1; 89:1)
· Fig & olive (95:1)
· Muhammad’s life (15:72)
· "What you see and do not see" (69:38–39)
By his own rule, Allah makes all creation partners.
2. Muhammad commits shirk & fabricates revelation.
The earliest biographical text of Islam, al-Ṭabarī's Tārīkh, records the "Satanic Verses" incident (al-Gharānīq).
While reciting Surah Al-Najm (53:19-20), Satan cast words onto Muhammad's tongue praising the Meccan goddesses:
"Those are the exalted Gharānīq, and indeed their intercession is to be hoped for."
This is explicit shirk, attributing intercessory power to created beings. The Quraysh rejoiced, believing Muhammad had endorsed their gods.
But the text doesn't stop there. When Gabriel later confronted him, Muhammad made a stunning admission:
"I have fabricated against God, and I have said on God's behalf that which He did not say!" (iftaraytu ʿalā Allāh)
If the earliest Sīra records the Prophet of Islam admitting to fabricating revelation and uttering shirk, how can the Quran be trusted as the perfect, eternal word of God?
A perfect, holy God cannot violate his own nature or commands. And a true prophet cannot fabricate revelation.
Contrast this with the God of the Bible. In Hebrews 6:13-16, when God made a promise, "since he had no one greater by whom to swear, he swore by himself." The biblical God does not need to invoke creation. He is completely self sufficient, perfectly consistent, and utterly sovereign.
‼️Islam's books leaves Muslims with a terrifying dilemma, a God who breaks his own rules, and a prophet who admits to fabricating revelation.‼️
Christianity offers the only consistent hope. We don't worship a God who is a mushrik (polytheist), nor do we follow a prophet who admits to saying what God did not say. We worship a God who is perfectly holy, perfectly just, and perfectly loving. A God who stepped into His own creation to save us from our sins.
Jesus didn't just point to the truth, He is the truth. He lived the perfect life we couldn't live, died the death we deserved, and rose again so that we could be forgiven.
Lies don't last forever. The logic of Islam collapses under its own weight. But the cross of Christ stands firm.
JESUS SAVES. ✝️
#Christianity #Apologetics #Islam #Tawhid #Shirk #SatanicVerses #JesusSaves #ExMuslim #DavidWood #Acts17
🚨BREAKING NEWS:Whose Voice Is This? The Quran’s Fatal Identity Crisis‼️
Q 81:19 & Q 69:40 — same Arabic phrase:
إِنَّهُ لَقَوْلُ رَسُولٍ كَرِيمٍ
the speech of a noble messenger
But Islam can’t agree who that messenger is:
❌ Gabriel in one
❌ Muhammad in the other
So which is it?
❌ If Gabriel — the Quran is an angel’s word, not God’s.
❌ If Muhammad — the Quran is a man’s word, not God’s.
❌ And by the text’s own wording, it is not said to be Allah’s direct speech but only the speech of a noble messenger (qawl rasūlin karīm) which can be an entity (possibly demonic) or a man.
A revelation that cannot identify its own source has no right to claim it is from God.
‼️‼️The One Man Switchboard: Allah, Gabriel, and Muhammad — All the Same Voice
❌The entire chain is a closed loop with one living speaker.
1Muhammad said.
2Muhammad said Gabriel said.
3Muhammad said Gabriel said
Allah said
That’s not independent revelation.
❌That’s a single man reporting what a single man claims an unseen being claimed an unseen God claimed. Then you are told it is blasphemy to notice the only verifiable human in the chain is Muhammad.
❌If this is the uncreated speech of God, why did the same God never send a prior prophet from Ishmael’s line to announce the coming of this specific man the way earlier scriptures announce other figures?
❌Islam later retrofits Ishmael into the story, but the earlier texts do not prepare the ground the way they do for other claimed fulfillments. The silence is convenient.
❌If Gabriel is a real messenger who delivers scripture, why does he go permanently mute the moment Muhammad dies? No later confirmation, no later correction, no later warning. The angel’s entire career apparently ends when the last person who could contradict him is gone.
❌If Allah speaks, why does He also fall silent after 632? No later prophet, no later public recitation that can be checked against living witnesses outside the movement, no later intervention when the community immediately splits over succession, text, and law. The revelation stops exactly when the only earthly recipient stops.
❌A system that places God, the angel, and the prophet behind one man’s report, then declares the line closed forever, is asking you to treat an un-auditable monopoly as the highest possible authority. That is the claim.
The audacity is treating skepticism of that monopoly as the scandal.
It keeps getting worse and worse.
Why will Allah sacrifice Jews and Christians to eternal hell as replacement for Muslims?
The plan of Satan is to deceive Muslims and make them to sin continually with a get out oh hell card hence why Muslims have no sincere remorse towards evil
And they wonder why we say Allah is a false god and Muhammad a false prophet
If the Quran was the speech of Allah, it would not need a committee, a bonfire of rival copies, and 10 official recitations to keep the story straight. What you have is a human book by Muhammad compiled after Muhammad, edited into one official skeleton, then sold as divine dictation
❌ Ten approved ways of reciting the same book means the wording was never one fixed text
❌ Uthman wrote an undotted, unvowelled skeleton; later reciters had to decide how to pronounce and complete it
❌ Muhammad never authorized Uthman to decide the official Quran
❌ Reports of forgotten or missing surahs and verses
❌ The goat/sheep hadith about a written portion being eaten
❌ Early pages were scraped and rewritten; the Sana’a palimpsest still shows a different text underneath
❌ Companion readings that did not match the Uthmanic text
❌ Companions said whole sections vanished, so what remains is a reduced official edition
❌ Internal incoherence and abrupt, unclear passages
❌ Internal contradictions between Quranic verses
❌ Contradictions with history: Jesus’ crucifixion denied, Haman placed with Pharaoh, Mary treated like Aaron’s sister
❌ Contradictions with science and facts: the sun setting in a muddy spring, semen created from backbone and ribs, mountains pegged down to stop the earth shaking
❌ Contradictions with the Bible: Jesus not crucified, Mary folded into a Trinity scene, and shared stories rewritten with different details
❌ “Preserved for 1400+ years” is a slogan, not a manuscript conclusion
Islam is dying
Internet is killing Islam
Muhammad had an epileptic fit and coined it as revelation
Muslims, I pity you
Hi @grok good evening.
I want to ask, Mohamed's "revelations" involved heaviness in the body, bell sounds, buzzing, lip movements, sweating, a change in facial color, and a feeling of choking. Which disorder is usually associated with these symptoms?
Damn, this is Muhammad the best of mankind
What a sick false prophet 🤢
Hi @grok Has there been an accusation that Muhammad had sex with a dead woman?
This was a powerful discussion with a Muslim seeking truth.
I NEVER knew such honest , open minded and truth seeking Muslims exist
Muslims, this is what truth seeking looks like without the brainwashing
Replying to @_Maverick143_
@_Maverick143_ educates Muslim on how Islam Allah is no different from a human
Allah and man share same few attributes 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Islam is really confused
youtube.com/live/Qgg_muBrXYA… via @YouTube


















