Enjoy the map of the market of Onchain Organizations
more to come...
paragraph.xyz/@ooa/mapping-tโฆ
New voting mechanism in the works that brings the best of direct democracy and also delegation with multiple fallbacks
Get in touch if you're interested in learning more or helping out
An update from the Governance Team at @onchain_org, discussing ranked choice delegation (RCD):
(1) we're soliciting feedback (esp from DAO delegates, architects, and operators)
(2) we're looking for onchain organizations interested in piloting this program
City DAOs are onchain organizations. Many have:
-onchain assets
-onchain membership
-onchain elections
-onchain funding/donations
-onchain expenses
Help us identify which onchain tools City DAOs should be using
Thanks to everyone who joined at Stanford Blockchain Conference DAO workshop!!
The #SBC24 DAO Workshop (aka DAO NYC) had rich discussions, lots of room for conversations and short lightning talks: This is how an event should look like!
Thanks to @TheDRC_, @metagov_project, @tallyxyz for organising and a big shoutout to @dao_officer!
๐งตThe talks:
4
197
Ranked Choice Delegation
We have a group discussion tomorrow at 12pm ET. Please message if you'd like to provide commentary or join the discussion
8
165
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
๐ขGovernance Review #24 by @l2beat is out!
Highlights:
๐ด @Optimism Security Council nominations
๐ต @arbitrum ArbOS 31 upgrade
๐ฆ @Uniswap Attackathon sponsorship request
๐ @HopProtocol multisig signers renewal
๐ช @0xPolygon MATIC to POL change
โช๏ธ @EverclearOrg Security Council proposal update
๐ณ๏ธ @wormhole first governance proposal
Find the link to the full review in the following tweet ๐
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
This is a good point Monica brings up and Tarun is correct, there are a lot of @solana DAO experiments going unnoticed by the Ethereum DAO crowd and its a shame because so much DAO mindshare lives there. I regularly read mostly about Ethereum DAOs, but im learning through experimentation much faster on Solana
The Solana DAO experiments that stand out and are worth a look:
@MetaDAOProject - Decisions based on Predictions Markets. Every proposal creates a market where anyone can trade to signal which decision they believe will ultimately lead to more value to the metaDAO. Already 3 others DAOs ( @deanslistDAO @DriftProtocol @Future_Protocol) are using the platform and the feature set keeps growing. The biggest challenge today is the user learning curve; trading instead of voting for your preference
@GreedAcademy - Dual token voting connected to validator staking built on @Realms_DAOs. This DAO has shattered previous proposal records with multiple new proposals going up everyday. DAO members have to regularly communicate to get each other to participate in their individual proposals. The highest number of unique proposers across all of crypto
@bonk_dao - Also Dual token voting built on Realms with bonk holders and locked bonk both counting to voting participation. The rewards schema and the revamped dedicated voter UI increased voter participation by 10x . This is one to watch as the upcoming @LiveBonk launchpad will start using governance to decide on new token launches
@PollDAO - relatively obscure, but the only DAO that I know of using a sybil-resistant quadratic voting schema (powered by @civickey ). This is a good example of how a DAO could fix the common "whale voter" problem that was recently brought up again with the @compoundfinance governance attack
@jup_dao - The highest participation across all DAOs on all chains. Their innovative voter participation rewards schema and the votes for launchpad favorites is a great experiment in how to achieve the highest possible voter engagement. They are also using 30 day minimum staking to qualify voters
@deanslistDAO - A service guild using 2 different DAO platforms. On @MetaDAOProject, proposals with quantifiable results are posted to decide how initiatives should be selected for their impact on market cap. On @Realms_DAOs, stake weighted voting using a Voter Stake Registry plug-in lets the DAO vote on constitutional changes and role allocations. This is an interesting experiment because the DAO is navigating the process between deciding between the platforms and they complex choices DAO members need to make with their tokens
@MarinadeFinance - A liquid staking protocol that requires staking to participate in voting and rewards DAO members with the power to delegate stake across their validator set based on their voting weight. With their new stake auction marketplace, I expect that the voter participation will start to increase alot.
These are the ones that are live today that people can join. There are plenty of more configurations to explore and more features coming soon.
If any of these features exist on other chains, post them in the replies. If there is a feature you wish existed, do the same. If im missing a DAO that is doing unique things on Solana, I want to know!
"There are a lot of examples of people trying to do more wilder governance mechanisms (...) @Solana experiments are far more interesting (...) People in @ethereum land don't spend enough time looking at Solana stuff." - @tarunchitra @gauntlet_xyz
Do We Need Better DAO Governance? - The Chopping Block youtu.be/xm-HVLSLR5w?si=Jwfwโฆ
@deanmachine @Realms_DAOs @MetaDAOProject #futarchy #DAOs
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
The Compound Governance Support Working Group has posted an important update on the status of Compound Governance, highlighting a recent surge in delegation to a handful of delegates. We also share more details on the upcoming Delegate Race, aimed at further securing @compgovernance in light of recent events.
Stay tuned for more updates.
h/t @AranaVentures @PGovTeam
comp.xyz/t/compound-delegateโฆ
Professional delegates and advisors are shaping the decisions of major DAOs. A great example of one team's approach at @EntropyAdvisors
We have a research piece on this industry segment coming soon!
I co-founded a company focused on DAO Operations. @EntropyAdvisors is the first of its kind in this regard.
So, it probably begs the question to many, WTF is DAO Ops? At Entropy, we focus on 4 key areas.
1๏ธโฃ ๐๐ผ๐ผ๐ฟ๐ฑ๐ถ๐ป๐ฎ๐๐ถ๐ผ๐ป
DAO's are made of up of a large number of global and diverse delegates and contributors. Most of the time, a DAO's key stakeholders will have different motivations, incentives, and visions for the protocol.
We are talking anons, lawyers, public goods supporters, VCs, liberals, conservatives, dev teams, service providers, airdrop farmers, protocols, et al. This isn't your traditional Ops Consulting.
Step 1 to an effective DAO is building a "workplace" that facilitates camaraderie and rapport (maybe even a little tribalism lol.)
2๏ธโฃ ๐๐ผ๐บ๐บ๐๐ป๐ถ๐ฐ๐ฎ๐๐ถ๐ผ๐ป
With such a large number of people working and no enforced organizational structure, we need to ensure that redundant work is mitigated.
Delegates need visibility into what people/orgs are working on and be able to give input along the way.
Step 2 is creating an organized systematic approach to work and a communication mesh layer.
3๏ธโฃ ๐๐น๐ถ๐ด๐ป๐บ๐ฒ๐ป๐
Next, we must get the DAO to align on a vision, mission, and strategic goals for the DAO and protocol.
Step 3 is walking the thin line between leadership and stepping on toes in order to make sure everyone is a little happy, and a little pissed with the solution. Alignment follows the sentiment "A good compromise is when both parties are dissatisfied," although this case, more like 10s/100s of parties.
4๏ธโฃ ๐๐ฟ๐ถ๐๐ถ๐ป๐ด ๐ฆ๐๐ฟ๐ฎ๐๐ฒ๐ด๐ถ๐ฐ ๐๐ต๐ฎ๐ป๐ด๐ฒ
Once we have created a DAO with delegate rapport, a communication mesh layer, and an as much alignment as possible.. We can finally focus on what matters most, driving changes that further the protocol towards its strategic goals.
We can bring in tactical partners, change protocol parameters, introduce RFPs, set up new "Sub DAOs," support ecosystem projects, drive new tech, move toward operational sustainability, and so much more.
At Entropy, we consider this the fun part, where we get to make quantifiable impact on one of the most important protocols in the space: @arbitrum.
3
142
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
1/ Events took a surprising turn in Compound DAO after what initially resembled a โgovernance attackโ to many has now been resolved.
Briefly, we discuss this incident and a give a high-level overview of defence mechanisms for safeguarding DAOs from governance vulnerabilities
Great meta-analysis of hundreds of DAOs over many years
Amazing work @arndxt_xo
Over 581 DAO projects, analyzed 16,246 proposals over 5 years.
The DAO paper covered all the projects using the DAO/governance platform called Snapshot, covering over 95% of in-the-wild DAO projects (over 11,000 spaces).
I've found 4 key findings in this "The DAO Dilemma" ๐
โข The Centralization Paradox
The data paints a picture of impressive growth - 581 DAOs, over 16,000 proposals, spanning 5 years. The member distribution follows the Pareto principle.
A small minority holds most of the power.
I'm left wondering: Are we just recreating traditional power structures in a blockchain wrapper? The Gini coefficient of token distribution within DAOs would be a telling metric here.
โข The Technical Ticking Time Bomb
The lack of IPFS upgrades sends shivers down my spine. It's a classic case of technical debt that could implode as DAOs scale. We're talking potential data loss, skyrocketing storage costs, and crippled efficiency.
Here's a thought experiment: What happens when a critical proposal's data becomes irretrievable due to outdated IPFS links? The consequences could be dire.
โข The Democracy-Efficiency Tug-of-War
The study shows a wide range of voting contexts - from budgets to hiring decisions. It's democracy in action, right? Not so fast. I'm seeing two massive red flags:
a) Voter apathy: Low turnout plagues many decisions.
b) Token-weighted voting: A few whales can sway entire ecosystems.
This creates a governance paradox. On one hand, we have the ideal of decentralized decision-making. On the other, we're facing the harsh reality of consolidated power and disengaged communities.
โข The Token Dilemma
Here's where it gets really interesting. The majority of DAOs are using self-issued tokens rather than established cryptocurrencies like USDT or ETH. This raises serious questions about incentive structures and long-term viability.
Are we witnessing the birth of robust governance systems, or just sophisticated token pumping schemes? The cynic in me leans towards the latter, but I'm open to being proven wrong.
โข The Path Forward
Despite these challenges, I remain cautiously optimistic about DAOs.
Here's what I believe needs to happen:
โข Implement quadratic voting or other mechanisms to balance influence.
โข Prioritize technical infrastructure upgrades, especially around data storage.
โข Develop stronger incentives for consistent participation in governance.
โข Encourage the use of more stable value tokens for governance.
This study has reinforced my belief that DAOs are at a critical juncture. The promise of decentralized governance is immense, but so are the hurdles.
What's your take?
Are DAOs the future of organization, or are we witnessing a grand experiment that's doomed to recreate the systems it aimed to replace?
2
105
Professional Delegate Organizations are a new class of onchain organizations that have started formalizing in the last few years
they're largely support organizations that study the governance and processes within DAOs. They're delegates, advocates, and researchers
THE RISE OF THE PROFESSIONAL DELEGATE ORGANIZATION
A handful of firms like @StableLab, @labsGFX and @PGovTeam have set up teams whose primary purpose is to represent token holders' interests in governance matters. They're concerned with gov structure, intervention, and resolution
PDOs are one type of an Onchain Organization that are generally centralized, legally incorporated, regulated, permissioned, and run by a small team of full-time professionals. Various token holders delegate their token votes to these parties. Sometimes there is direct compensation, other times, they receive payment from the protocols themselves for their active participation
Other companies have added a kind of "Professional Delegate" service in addition to an existing service, product, or business: @karpatkey, @gauntlet_xyz , @llama, and @hi_Reverie
There are also quite a few University blockchain clubs that act as professional delegates (many of which have received delegated tokens from A16Z, who stays out of governance matters)
DAOs have demonstrated extremely low voter participation (apathy, inability to track dozens of holdings, etc) and this has led to numerous governance exploits... Hopefully Professional Delegate Organizations are a part of the solution
One thing is certain: onchain representation, voting, and delegation must make substantial improvements from the current state
1
2
150
we specifically talk about this cluser of onchain organizations in this piece here:
paragraph.xyz/@ooa/mapping-tโฆ
50
Network states should be designed as onchain organizations
- clear and transparent governance
- unambiguous powers
- globally scalable
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
2
199
next piece of research is coming soon on tools & products. we're making a directory of resources for new (and current!) onchain organizations
tag your favorites
4
5
275
this is probably one of the biggest categories with a huge number of small orgs who do GREAT work, but fly under the radar. tag your favorites
Replying to @gnovak_
PRODUCTS AND SERVICES
Although many of the sub-categories are likely self-explanatory, these are rough definitions for many of the operational onchain organizations:
Products - usually teams of software developers building products. Examples include teams building tools forย fundraising (@juiceboxETH ), governance (@fractalappxyz , @RaidGuild ), and others
R&D - teams who haveย aggregated capital and choose which experimental project to fund. Examples include @vita_dao (longevity science) and @OfficialMoonDAO (software and space exploration)
Service Guild - those who complete work for other teams, usually for cash, token, or equity compensation. Examples include @dOrg_tech , @bd3xyz , and Growth DAO.
Talent Collective - An aggregation of people who may be well suited to help with a particular type of work. For example, LexDAO (@lex_DAO ) aggregates lawyers, Vector DAO specializes in graphics, UI and interfaces.
Media - similar to traditional media companies, these are teams who publish writing, content, videos, or other media, and potentially share in the revenues. @coinage_media , for example, has owners via NFTs and is structured to issue dividends to members of the media organization. Others like @banklessDAO have a ERC-20 token
Professional Delegates - this is an emerging category of governance analysts who comment and submit governance proposals for large organizations, the largest DAOs often compensate these groups. This includes @StableLabs @llama @hi_Reverie @EntropyAdvisors
Mixed - some organizations touch many of the categories above. For example, @gauntlet_xyz has an advisory service, but also participates in governance and they build products. @myosin_xyz builds products and also advises
3
243
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
Follow @onchain_org for much more research on content on these topics.
It's a brand new industry group representing the hard work and interests of Onchain Organizations and supportive software & service providers who make it feasible to build onchain
teapawt.org/onchain_org/status/181โฆ
Enjoy the map of the market of Onchain Organizations
more to come...
paragraph.xyz/@ooa/mapping-tโฆ
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
Thanks to a lot of folks on twitter, farcaster, and the Onchain Organization Alliance @onchain_org we've pulled together an incredible research piece covering the massive spectrum of onchain organizations, spanning DAOs, network states, guilds, grant councils, and more. Summary ๐
Onchain Organization Alliance retweeted
I like the rephrasing to onchain organization's from DAOs, which imply that decentralized & autonomous is the right way for your org to be onchain
Autonomous = community managing a product
Operational - bring human capital together
Societies - bring communities together
Enjoy the map of the market of Onchain Organizations
more to come...
paragraph.xyz/@ooa/mapping-tโฆ




























