Patrick Rafferty retweeted
I think lots of people are confused about this Alpha business. When you see someone who has advocated for a specific set of ideas for a long time go on to join or lead an organisation that seems completely antithetical to those ideas, then it's reasonable to be confused.
Yesterday, I briefly discussed this with @PepsMccrea, and I argued that Alpha represents educational progressivism with a veneer of "learning science" (or what we have normally called "cognitive science" in England). Here, I'd like to expand a bit on that. I'm not going to cite every claim, because this has been part of common discourse here for at least a year (as long as Carl [and I think Peps]) have been working for Alpha.
First, instrumentalism. In England, educational traditionalists (like Carl and Peps) argued that education and the education system is not designed merely to prepare students for the world of work. Instead, it is there to pass on cultural heritage, and knowledge for its own sake. Progressives on the other hand argued that it was more about "21st century skills" and railed against a system that "failed to prepare students for jobs that hadn't been invented yet."
It's clear that Alpha is built in this vein. It runs courses on entrepreneurialism, media training, startup founding etc etc. NONE of their marketing that I have seen is about the joy of learning or being inculcated into a cultural or intellectual tradition.
Second, long term learning. Proponents on this site have boasted about how students finish courses in a matter of days. One of the very first things I learnt from the traditionalist school was that learning is a process that occurs over the long term, and that short term performance means little.
Third, "time back". Alpha uses an app called Timeback, which broadly - in my understanding - means that if students do well on their 2 hours of AI-enabled academics, they get more time to do other stuff. This again emphasises that academic education is something to be "got through" so we can get to the fun stuff: Navy SEAL training, social media, horse riding and...entrepreneurship.
Fourth, in a similar vein, extrinsic motivation. Alpha has heavily pursued gamification and an extrinsic reward system. Again, English traditionalists used Self Determination Theory as a key plank of their arguments about schools and education, and extrinsic motivation as an educational lever has been widely derided based on simple findings from the SDT literature.
Fifth, personalisation. Every so often someone here said we should teach shakespeare through rap or dance or whatever. Traditionalists thought this was awful. The content is the content, and it is our job to take students beyond their horizons, not pander to their narrow set of cultural experiences. And yet this is exactly what Alpha does. Writing lessons are based on students' particular interests, so Harry Potter and minecraft. Alpha students have spoken about how Romeo and Juliet etc is outdated and boring. Again, very much at odds with what proponents have said in the past.
Sixth, trashing the traditional model. We suffered our way through Shift Happens and Schools on Trial (or whatever it was called) which went on and on about factory models and Gradgrind and sage on the stage etc. And yet Alpha promotional materials do the same.
Seventh, children on social media. This was the most surprising thing this year, where students at Alpha schools were tasked with setting up an X account and getting a certain number of followers. This is obviously a safeguarding concern, and if an English school leader did this it is likely they would be out of a job pretty quickly. Again, opposing social media and teens on phones has been an important part of the traditionalist movement.
Eighth, it's an experiment. This is a kind of trial - "we are trying to figure out if we can do this." There's a couple of problems here. First, children aren't guinea pigs (even if their parents are rich). Second, trialling it in the best possible circumstances (i.e. a rich private school) seems like a good idea because the risk is low, but it's also why it won't scale. Anyone who has tried to roll out educational change knows that there is an "adoption curve" and a chasm between your early adopters and everyone else. What works for one categorically doesn't work for the other. This is basically as close to an iron clad law of business and scaling tech as you can get. But also, if you really wanted to make change and improve the lives of children globally, you'd focus on the things we know work because we've seen them work! Everyone on that team knows about Michaela, Mercia, Ark King Solomon, West London Free School, Mossbourne, TTA and more. Schools that do incredible things for underprivileged students with a fraction of the budget. High academic expectations. Expert teachers. Brilliant behaviour. Knowledge-rich curriculums. If we really care about scaling educational solutions, let's start there.
While we're at it, the focus of the traditional movement was always on disadvantaged students. What can we do for them? How can we help them? How do we serve those who need it the most? Alpha is so obviously not that. It's a hyper-expensive school for the children of elites. Of course, those students need educating too, but dedicating so much time and energy and intellectual capital to them seems at odds with everything that has come before.
Ninth, and it's going to be hard to say this without being catty, but respect for academia and qualifications. I want to be super clear that I massively respect the intellectual acumen of people like Carl, Peps, Becky and others. But, they are not "learning scientists." To the best of my knowledge, nobody on the team has produced original research in that particular field. Again, that doesn't mean they are not worth listening to or whatever - but part of the traditional revolution in England was discovering these researchers who had made incredible findings about learning and the brain, within the confines of the peer-review and scientific inquiry method. I know that arguments from authority aren't empirical, but being able to rely on people like Kirschner, Willingham, Dunlosky and others was critical to the success of the traditional movement.
Tenth, transferable skills. One of the founding principles of educational traditionalism is that you cannot teach generic or transferable skills like "Leadership" or "resilience", but the Alpha website and promotional materials are full of this stuff.
Eleventh, track record. Alpha people have been talking about how fantastic their content is for at least a year, but we are now told that it is just "ok." Obviously most of it is proprietary, but someone posted some physics stuff last week and I thought it was pretty poor. Michael Pershan has blogged similarly, and Dan Meyer (!) has pointed to the objective data from a school that adopted Alpha and ended up doing worse.
Twelfth, similar - ratification. Part of why England has succeeded is that we have objective metrics like standardised assessments and progress 8 that allow us to test the claims of schools and educationalists. Alpha has no such metrics, and instead we need to take their word for it that they are causing "2x learning." It's a surprise to see people who have been part of the positivist and outcomes-led policy movement wanting to be involved in this kind of non-verifiable model.
Thirteenth, real books, but as a totem standing for traditionalism. A number of people have asked if Alpha students read real books. On paper. Great books. There hasn't been much of an answer, beyond a picture of a library. Ok, books are important, but they aren't really my point here. My point is that there is a romanticism around traditional education. Something that goes beyond the petty mechanics of pedagogy, and taps into something social and cultural about learning. That we are one link in a long chain of transmission, a chain which cherishes books not because of a fascination with bleached wood pulp, but because of what they represent: our ability to transcend the narrow confines of our lives and swim in the streams of collective human intellectual endeavour. Nothing I've seen at Alpha tells me there's anything like that idealism. Instead, it strikes me as a desiccated and hollowed-out vision of education, where students learn not from another human, but from an AI-generated screen.
It doesn't surprise me that some people are interested in Alpha. It seems exciting and innovative as a business model. But it does surprise me that THESE people are interested in it. I harbour no ill will towards them, and as I've said I respect their work. I hope this comes across as respectful and measured. But it's no surprise that people are surprised.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
This is a completely outrageous effort to intimidate a priest *in his own church*. It is an obvious thing to say, and not the kind of argument I make very often, but Restore are *miles* away from what most people would consider English values.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
This is obviously sweet but the reveal of the duck is Arrested Development-esque
A golden retriever suffering from seizures seemingly lost her spunk — until one day her owners brought home a miracle cure — a duck named Louie. @SteveHartmanCBS is On the Road.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
Here's my tuppence worth on curriculum and "what school is for".
I've always said of Gove that I agreed with his diagnosis but not his prescription. Did Foundation Tier GCSE English look a bit pitiful in 2010? Yes. Did the over reliance on Of Mice And Men shut out swathes of 1/
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
This a deeply disappointing, borderline irresponsible interview of Morgan McSweeney from @bbcnickrobinson. It looks like impunity in action. Has the media not learnt any lessons from Mandelson and of the need to properly scrutinise political actors?
It is the BBC's job to hold political actors to account, to pose them real questions, and to get them to put a proper version of events on the record.
That is all the more important for a figure like McSweeney, who has wielded extraordinary power and has led or participated in attacks on legitimate, factual journalism, but who has never spoken about his role in these scandals on the record.
The interview doesn't touch, once, on the rock-solid evidence of McSweeney's serious unlawful misconduct or the Labour Together/APCO scandal. This stuff is widely available and easy to verify.
Here is a reminder of what we know about McSweeney, about which he wasn't asked a single thing:
1. McSweeney was Company Secretary of Labour Together from July 2017 to April 2020. During this period he failed to report over £700,000 in donations to the Electoral Commission. This was plainly unlawful. LT was found guilty and fined for this offence, but said in public it was an 'administrative oversight.'
2. McSweeney failed to report donations after he had unsuccessfully attempted to convince the Electoral Commission he didn't need to report them in late 2017.
3. McSweeney failed to report donations after the Electoral Commission told him, explicitly, that Labour Together had a legal duty to report donations.
4. McSweeney engaged in a two-month correspondence with the Electoral Commission in early 2018, in which it was clear he knew he had to report donations. Yet he failed to do so for over two years thereafter.
5. McSweeney failed to report donations even though he was telling MPs he was reporting donations, and even though Labour Together's website also stated that it was declaring donations to the Electoral Commission.
6. McSweeney failed to report donations even after Shabana Mahmood, on Labour Together's behalf, wrote an article for LabourList in February 2020 stating that Labour Together was reporting its donations. At the very time Mahmood wrote the donations, LT was taking in donations it was failing to declare.
7. McSweeney used this undeclared money, to fight an undeclared, covert war on the Labour Party leadership between 2017 and 2020. He also used it to pay for polling which was then fed into Starmer's leadership bid. Materials produced by McSweeney during his time at LT was fed, word-for-word, into Starmer's campaigning material. According to Rachel Wearmouth, McSweeney spent 'every spare moment' during the last six weeks of 2019 to prepare Starmer's leadership bid, during which time McSweeney was drawing a salary from LT.
8. When Labour Together was put under investigation by the Electoral Commission for McSweeney's failure to report donations, McSweeney was consulted by LT's lawyer Gerald Shamash. The email recording this consultation and its contents were published by the Tory Chairman Kevin Hollinrake and have been available in public for a year. The email raises serious questions about whether LT was candid in its responses to the Electoral Commission and, in particular, McSweeney's correspondence with the Commission in 2017/2018 that shows he was aware of the need to report donations. Early correspondence between LT and the Electoral Commission shows that, despite being asked to provide all information of relevance to the Commission's inquiries, LT failed to even mention McSweeney's name, let alone the phone call.
9. In early 2019 McSweeney launched an astroturf campaign called Stop Funding Fake News (SFFN) , with his friend and factional ally Imran Ahmed. It was supported by @SteveReedMP and operated out of the same office as Labour Together. SFFN purposefully set out to 'eviscerate' the economic viability of @TheCanaryUK and to destroy the livelihoods of its journalists, many of whom were long-time members of the National Union of Journalists.
At no stage in its first year operation did SFFN declare its controlling minds. Instead it presented itself as a 'grassroots' campaign of well-meaning activists.
McSweeney and Ahmed tried to take out proper journalism because they saw it as a threat to their political objectives. "Destroy the Canary or the Canary destroys us," is what McSweeney told Labour Together insiders according to Anushka Asthana.
SFFN made promiscuous allegations of antisemitism against The Canary - the antisemitism that McSweeney claims is what drove his factional war on the left - which were found to have no substance when reviewed by a panel of media lawyers and practitioners at media regulator Impress. SFFN repeatedly inferred that The Canary was antisemitic because it run articles quoting left-wing and anti-Zionist Jews disturbed by aspects of the "antisemitism crisis."
10. SFFN also targeted well-known US media sites, which led to McSweeney being directly called out by the US State Department. His colleague, Imran Ahmed, is now sanctioned by the US because the US accuses the company he and McSweeney set up, CCDH, of being part of a global censorship complex.
11. When I started reporting on McSweeney's undeclared money and his secret campaigns, including by taking damning primary documents to the Sunday Times, Labour Together appointed APCO Worldwide to produce a 'package' that would 'proactively undermine' my factually accurate, public interest reporting.
To be clear: APCO were hired to 'proactively undermine' my reporting on McSweeney and his role in Starmer's rise. The intention, as shown in internal docs, was to protect both Starmer and McSweeney's reputations ahead of an imminent general election, while I was trying to warn people about the true nature of this project and it's unlawful origins.
12. APCO produced an insane, ludicrous, highly defamatory report that accused me, my family and my colleagues of being part of a pro-Kremlin network of journalists and speculating that I received hacked documents from Russia. APCO also investigated @Gabriel_Pogrund, with whom I'd collaborated with on the Sunday Times story, making a series of offensive comments about him and his ethnicity. APCO identified a range of other journalists in the UK and US as "persons of interest" to be investigated.
This highly invasive, despicable investigation targeted my work colleagues and my family, including by finding my home address and mapping my personal relationships. Labour Together and its Managing Director, Josh Simons, reported me to the National Cyber Security Centre on the basis of this mad, insane report.
13. Less than a month ago, it was revealed that McSweeney and his buddy Paul Ovenden (later Chief of Strategy at Number 10, who would resign following revelations from my book) were copied into emails about the investigation. McSweeney plainly knew about APCO's investigation. Simons, in one mail, wrote to set up a meeting with McSweeney, Ovenden and APCO's Tom Harper in 'HQ' to discuss the 'Paul Holden report.'
Three days after this meeting I was reported to the NCSC, along with my colleagues and family members. Emails show Simons was coached in how to make a 'crime report' about me to the NCSC.
14. The APCO/Labour Together scandal was so ugly and so damning that Labour Together has been forced to change its name. It also led to the resignation of Josh Simons as a Junior Minister. The Speaker of the House has supported calls for a Parliamentary inquiry into Labour Together.
15. Josh Simons thereafter stepped aside as the MP for Makerfield in order to make way for Andy Burnham, the incoming PM who has displaced McSweeney's man, Starmer. There is a straight and clear line between attempts to protect McSweeney from scrutiny in 2024 and Starmer's resignation in 2026.
So, to make this clear: there was a massive scandal because plans were put in motion to stop questions being asked about McSweeney's unlawful failure to declare money... and now the public broadcaster is failing to ask McSweeney questions about the money. Has the media learnt nothing from the Mandelson scandal about what happens when you don't properly scrutinise political actors?
And here's some things McSweeney and Robinson did talk about, but which doesn't bear scrutiny:
1. Starmer didn't just take some suits and glasses as 'freebies' during the election campaign. He took over £100k in freebies between 2021 and 2024, more than every Labour leader since Tony Blair combined. In addition to free clothes, Starmer took football tickets, tickets to watch the horse racing, and free holiday accommodation for his family from a billionaire. One of his football freebies was donated by a company that had only just been forced to pay a £11m settlement because the installed faulty and potentially flammable cladding on tower blocks in Gosport. Taking these donations means that Starmer had conflicted himself on key areas of policy even before he was elected.
2. Both McSweeney and Robinson quickly collude in claiming that Sir Keir Starmer didn't say that Israel 'has that right' to shut off water, fuel, food and electricity to Gaza. But we've all seen the video, where what Starmer has said is utterly plain. Multiple Ministers went on air to defend the statement thereafter. Does the BBC really think that huge numbers of Muslim councillors immediately left the Party by mistake, because they can't understand plain English?
3. McSweeney has said that Labour Together was 'neutral' during the 2020 leadership election. But Labour Together, and its key associates, have said repeatedly since 2022/2023 that LT backed Starmer's leadership bid. You can find these comments on the Wayback Machine in about two minutes.
4. McSweeney says he never intended to rid the Party of Corbynism. There are now multiple accounts, including from the country's leading political editors and journalists, about how McSweeney crafted and distributed strategy documents, including a plan called 'Operation Red Shield' and a 2017 SWOT analysis, that set out plans to undermine Corbyn's leadership and install a new leader who would 'renew' the Party.
5. This is not the first time that McSweeney has spoken to the media. Instead, it is the first time he has let his comments be attributed to him in public. Multiple journalists have spoken about how he was the source of stories damaging to his opponents. While he was Chief of Staff at Number 10, he was meeting with the editors of the major UK newspapers more regularly than Number 10's own head of comms. We know this because transparency regulations means that these meetings are recorded and can easily found on the gov website. This man has shaped our media discourse, and our political epistemology, in profound and disturbing ways. It is utterly disingenuous to claim that this is the first time he's spoken to the media.
Morgan McSweeney - the “most powerful unelected official in the country” & “a latter-day Thomas Cromwell” - has never given an interview. He has now.
Coming up on Political Thinking on @bbcsounds the man credited with securing Labour’s landslide & blamed for the failures of Starmer’s government.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
Bloodsport (1988) having a low critic score never matched the movie’s actual legacy. Van Damme doing full splits, the Kumite fights, Bolo Yeung stealing scenes every five minutes. That movie absolutely knew what people came to see.
This is by far the most interesting post-mortem of the local elections. 1. The panellists don't find time to discuss the Green Party's showing. 2. Finkelstein play suggests that Labour and the Conservatives should give up trying to win outright in FPTP ...
podbean.com/media/share/dir-…
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
"You'd all be speaking German if it wasn't for me."- German teacher with low self esteem.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
Final chance to write to the consultation to try and stop the government taking school exams online. This is the address to write to.
[email protected]
And here’s what I wrote.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
Hannah Spencer's acceptance speech climaxes with a line I wrote. Lesson for labour there maybe.
theguardian.com/politics/liv…
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
Aesthetically like a cross between Threads and a video art exhibition at the ICA. Laughed out loud at the red squirrel and the Bond clip. Absolutely mental.
This quoted post is unavailable.
Patrick Rafferty retweeted
To be injured by flying skull fragments by your side, well, the pleasure, the privilege is mine
Montreal mobster Pierre Sciara is killed in a shotgun attack outside a cinema where he has taken his wife to see The Godfather for Valentine’s Day.
Sciara is killed instantly and his wife is injured by flying skull fragments.
The hit was believed to be ordered by Nicolo Rizzuto, who is nicknamed “The Canadian Godfather.”




































