People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith) header
People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith) profile picture

Nie mój cyrk, nie moje małpy

Scotland
Joined December 2010
Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)Photo by People’s Republic of Leith (@pr_leith)
1
145
Post like this make me wonder whether the 2026 mid-terms will be seen, in retrospect, as the beginning of the end of the 'southern strategy' (∼1966-2026?).
When I first saw the video of Scott Colom pulling up to a Trump rally to greet, listen to, and earn the votes of Mississippians waiting in line, I couldn’t help but think of the clips of Mamdani in Nov 2024, passing the mic to Trump voters in Bronx & Queens neighborhoods that shifted away from Dems most. Patrick's reflection is worth sitting with.
8
Young conservative disaffection with the US-Israel 'special relationship' was alleged in the online commentary. But didn't seem evident in the way Republicans campaigned this cycle.
The shit I’m hearing from Republican pollsters about Israel rn after these midterm results…..if a DSA member said what they’re saying, they’d be called an antisemite holy shit
1
201
There's an even stronger hypothesis that Israel has become a strategic liability for Israel (in American politics).
There is a strong argument for the hypothesis that AIPAC has become a strategic liability for Israel
54
If anyone deserves a victory lap, it's @justinamash who was spot on about the eventual result back in the summer -- when Rogers appeared to be ahead.
Never has so much money been spent to bolster a candidate, Mike Rogers, who had zero chance of winning—something that was always clear to anyone who studies and understands Michigan politics.
43
If one is on the receiving end of privilege, it may be quite rational to fight back ..
Replying to @samhaselby
He’s wrong. Antisemitisms sole purpose is to push Jews out of public spaces. There is no other benefit to it. So it operates like a conspiracy theory that seeks to strip Jews of their privilege and property.
1
30
They didn't so much 'choose a name' as they adapted the transliteration of his name for an English-speaking / Roman-alphabet linguistic environment. It's a sort of classic 'first-generation American' vignette ..
2018. While running for Governor, Abdul El-Sayed says that his parents chose the name Abdul because Paula Abdul was popular at the time.
11
The various clips circulating online suggest that AES is preternaturally gifted pol ... .. and that's a complement ..
In Michigan, AES gives daily master classes on how to stand your ground & be combative while remaining pleasant, natural--without alienating voters. Troy Jackson here is the opposite. Not a natural, though rough edges & grouchiness play better in ME than in MI
1
2
203
If true, No 2 is basically immobilisme and a recipe for ungovernability.
Seven widespread misunderstandings about politics. 1. The Democratic Party’s elected officials, staffers, and donors are on average very progressive compared not only to the median voter but to most of the rank and file people who vote for Democrats. 2. The public’s persistently angry mood is not a demand for large policy changes, almost all changes generate backlash and the biggest electoral overperformers are wrong-party governors like Andy Beshear and Phil Scott who don’t do very much. 3. Third parties are most likely to succeed when the differences between the two big parties are small (1992) or at least wrongly perceived to be small (2000) not when they’re both seen as too extreme. 4. Donald Trump’s behavior is very extreme but the main way that his policy platform differs from Mitt Romney’s 2012 platform is that he’s more moderate on social security, Medicare, gay rights, and abortion. 5. How much progress you make on Issue X is more a function of how much you’re willing to drop or compromise on issues A, B, and C than of how aggressively you emote about X. 6. The qualities that are good for winning primaries and raising money are unrelated to (and in some ways antithetical to) the qualities that are good for winning general elections. 7. Increasing political polarization reflects deliberate choices made by highly engaged elite actors and is not an emergent property of the mass public.
15
This analysis seems exactly correct, and is more generally applicable to a variety of LDC cases. MENA states are, indeed, shockingly resilient as objects of aspiration, defining the bounds of the political imagination. 'Statism without the state'.
Replying to @TurkeySurveys
So in general, the Sykes-Picot states essentially proved themselves shockingly durable as concepts, even as the conditions supposedly artificially keeping them together (centralization regimes, state repression et cetera) repeatedly collapsed or disintegrated.
1
9
Cooperation/coordination with civil society groups, interest orgs et al is, indeed, a well-recognised aspect of democratic governance and infrastructural power. Another genuine issue obscured by, in JB's case, DSA bashing ..
silly take from a silly goose. every elected official co-governs. centrists co-govern too, they just do it with lobbyists 🤷🏽‍♀️
2
18
Muad Dib has entered the chat room ... "At least the British imperialists understood anthropology. They learned [..] that agnatic descent groups, once they have been organized into a fighting resistance, simply cannot be subdued. They gave up entirely on trying to subdue them."
Danny is sharp as always. Even if he remains an incorrigible imperialist, I appreciate his clear-eyed analysis. 'One of the fundamental challenges in dealing with the Houthis is that whenever military pressure against them increases, they respond by escalating further rather than backing down.' At least the British imperialists understood anthropology. They learned over time that agnatic descent groups, once they have been organized into a fighting resistance, simply cannot be subdued. They gave up entirely on trying to subdue them. Instead, they recruited them and bribed them to leave the Empire in peace. See my policytensor.substack.com/p/… The Saudis, in their defense, did not see the diffusion of precision-strike any more than the Americans. Now they are learning a bitter lesson. The world of one-sided imperial violence is over. This is now the cost of imposing your will on Yemen. Deal with it. If you do not like how this is going, you are not going to like what is coming. Houthi capabilities will increase over time. They are in a period of high intensity learning. As they get more skilled and sophisticated, they will become more resilient and their strike capabilities will become more survivable. Sue for peace. Or be prepared to pay the new price. teapawt.org/citrinowicz/status/210…
17
The patron can never do enough for the client. Dependency, and thus resentment, are hard-wired into the relationship.
This quoted post is unavailable.
29
"weakening the previously indissoluble connection between one's work and one's social identity" Presumably why we don't really talk about 'peasants' any more, at least outwith an LDC context ..
weakening the previously indissoluble connection between one's work and one's social identity was one of the great liberatory achievements of capitalist modernity; its failure to do the same with the analogous bond between work and personal meaning (which it may even have
25
Ironically, @mattyglesias does sort of have a point here. It's not entirely clear how 'corporatism' is being used in the thread (to say nothing of all the follow-on comments).
Replying to @AsteadWH
What is "corporatist politics"?
12
Hence Zohran, AOC et al may get at least as much aggro from their own side as from their opponents ..
Replying to @dontsippy
“Why don’t you picket Donald Trump?” Because Trump does not gaf about the opinions of the pro-Palestine crowd, while Zohran and the left/center-left are generally more amenable to pressure. I thought this simple political fact was obvious but apparently it’s not.
1
59
The Israeli way of genocide ..
Replying to @howserob
2/n What was clear is that there was a strong message from the political leaders, from the top, destroy everything, to obliterate Gaza. But to get these young people, who started out in many cases as decent human beings, to do this required a gross perversion of law.
1
12
Herbert was indeed a brilliant writer. But I sort of think Dune captured his authorial voice. Much of his subsequent oeuvre was, both stylistically and substantively, a bit of a rehash.
People compare Frank Herbert with Martin and I think they're almost exact opposites. Herbert was an actual genius. A lot of the interesting scholarship on Islam since 2010 has looked at the influence of Buddhism and Herbert was able to kind of intuit that as a weirdo crank weirdo homophobe paleocon autodidact. The thing that actually gets me, though, is the Harkonnens - Herbert looked at the USSR in 1965 and foresaw it's transformation into a dynastic, fascist, decedent society based on oil money. He saw Putin and Aliyev during the literal peak of the USSR. Genuine prescience shit. By contrast Martin mostly just inverts fantasy tropes and people mistake that as deep, he's better at internal character motivations and plotting than Herbert but he's just not a deep thinker about the kind of societies he's writing about. ASOIF is best understood as the fantasy version of Hillary Mantel's Cromwell trilogy (shift from feudal to early moden society in Western Europe) and once it leaves that area it becomes a C- satire of the Iraq War.
12
TBF, the public authorities in a number of British cities did much the same thing of their own volition.
What the Big Three car companies did was actually far worse than just lobbying — General Motors bought up the electric transit-car systems of 46 major cities, literally destroyed them, and replaced them with GM buses. One of the casualties of GM’s sabotage was the Los Angeles interurban electric railway system—then the largest in the world.
24