
She/her. Therapist. Founder @GuftaguTherapy. Interests - mental health, social justice, art, reading, podcasts, music, movies, shows. And cats!
Bombay, India.
Joined January 2011
- Tweets57.9K
- Following1.2K
- Followers3.7K
- Likes3.8K
Pinned Tweet
Hello folks! @GuftaguTherapy is the Twitter handle for my mental health venture! Finally I got to starting my own in 2021. Do follow for interesting takes and perspectives on mental health themes. We have an Instagram by the same name :)
Loved putting this together with @TraciRubleMFT ! We have been having conversations on how identity is manifesting - for months now. This is a small snippet of our co-thinking. Much more to come!
reallyalive.substack.com/p/t…
3
133
Sadaf retweeted
The Election Commission of India is under fire like never before.
The SIR has struck 13 crore names off draft rolls, putting the EC at the centre of intense public debate over its role in deciding who gets to vote — and who doesn’t.
HOWEVER, what nobody knew: through that same period, some of the sharpest questions were being asked from inside.
Out today, after months of work. Our #ExpressInvestigation 🧵
(1/10)
HRT is not a bad word it was made out to be a decade ago. If you or your loved one is in peri menopause, discuss the pros and cons of HRT with your gynecologist (a well informed one) and endocrinologist.
Use of estrogen-only hormone therapy by menopausal women may significantly lower their odds of developing Alzheimer’s-related brain changes or being diagnosed with dementia, according to a study published Sept. 8, 2026, in Neurology. #HarvardHealth
buff.ly/En2iy1q
Sadaf retweeted
How exactly is a "broken mother" supposed to "sound"?
And why assume she is "broken"?
It's unfortunate that we have not only lost all empathy but are also happy to flaunt it publicly.
#CasteBias
Sadaf retweeted
“Society punishes those who improve it... The awards go to those who maintain the status quo, not to those who change it. Freud never won a Nobel prize; they gave it to the fellow who introduced frontal lobotomy.”
“I hadn't realized that my efforts wouldn't combine smoothly with those of others to push our field forward, but rather that my work would be like flowing water, dispersed by large boulders of resistance, into small rivulets that turn sideways and end weakly in infertile soil.”
—Nassir Ghaemi
Sadaf retweeted
Maybe that’s why we’re so desperate for a simple answer.
Kaun pagal hai?
And who gets to decide?
Sadaf retweeted
The Clancy case sits directly on that line.
What makes it so unsettling is the possibility that madness may not always announce itself and that someone can appear completely intact while something underneath is coming apart.
Sadaf retweeted
For centuries, we’ve tried to draw a clean line between the sick and the sane, the mad and the bad.
Sadaf retweeted
She is not a criminal. She isn't carrying a weapon. She is just an Adivasi woman fighting for Jal-Jangal-Jameen and her constitutional rights.
This is how she is being treated. There are countless others facing the same. Why is nobody talking about them??
#KenBetwa #Bundelkhand
What does earliest mean? It's been 26 hours now. It's bad that it's gone for so long and you can't even give a timeline? Absolutely zero preparation for monsoon @CMOMaharashtra
Replying to @sabareeshpillay
Dear consumer, we sincerely regret the inconvenience caused. Due to an emergency outage, electricity supply has been discontinued and will be resumed at the earliest.
FREE EVENT ALERT! A dilemma perhaps as old as the profession! And yet, can it be skillfully resolved? what rules of thumb or clinical parameters can we use to distinguish when to use what?
Join us this saturday, 11th July, at 5.30 PM IST for a brief workshop on this-free of cost!
1
154
lnkd.in/dkjxbk_n Faciltated by Sadaf Arafati and Aryan Somaiya, co-founders of Guftagu Counselling and Psychotherapy Services. They practice with a relational psychoanalytic lens which grounds the self of the therapist, the relationship with the client, ambivalence, love
1
120
Sadaf retweeted
This is excellent teaching
Replying to @JonathanShedler
My thoughts, as promised:
Words of condolence can be a mistake. Suppose the patient had expressed rage and bitterness toward the parent and told the therapist they wished for their death. Suppose they felt extremely guilty about those feelings.
Saying “I’m so sorry for your loss” makes it difficult for the patient to explore complex and contradictory feelings in therapy. If they are feeling guilty about their feelings, they will go underground. That’s the opposite of what we want.
Saying “I’m so sorry for your loss” may be well-intentioned, but the message the patient hears may be, “your feelings are not acceptable here either.” The patient has heard that message their entire life.
👉To be most helpful as a therapist, we have to view the situation through a *therapy* lens, not a conventional social lens.
The relevant question is: will our response open space in therapy for the patient to experience and express the full range of their emotional experience, or could it constrain it?
Emotional life is complex, layered, and frequently contradictory. A helpful therapist response creates maximum space for the patient to explore *their own* emotions without presuming to know them in advance.
One alternative is simply to acknowledge the difficult circumstance, respond to the scheduling issue, and not make assumptions about the patient’s state of mind:
“I fully understand. Unless I hear from you otherwise, I will plan to see you at our regular time next week.”
When we make assumptions, or substitute social conventions for therapeutic curiosity, the space for emotional exploration shrinks. This may seem counterintuitive, but in-depth psychotherapy requires more than intuition. As Otto Kernberg reminds us, “Psychotherapy starts where common sense ends.”
Can a therapist communicate their human concern and emotional availability without making assumptions, closing space for emotional exploration, or retreating to a social rather than a therapeutic mode of responding?
Social media therapy influencers often traffic in performative displays of virtue and empathy. They may be quick to dismiss the suggested therapist response as cold or uncaring and position themselves as “human” and “authentic.”
Performing empathy is easy, but real psychotherapy cannot be performative. It is attunement to our actual patient, building an increasingly authentic connection, and opening space for the patient to explore *their own* experience—whatever it may be.
There are no fixed rules about the “right” or “wrong” way for a therapist to respond—but there is one very clear *principle*:
A response that preserves maximum space for the patient to explore and communicate their ongoing experience is helpful. A response that contracts that space is unhelpful.
Skilled psychotherapy builds on that principle. The specific application of the principle is a matter of tact, timing, empathy, and attunement.
__________
✍️ Related reading
“Much of What Is Called Therapy Is Not Psychotherapy” open.substack.com/pub/jonath…
Sadaf retweeted
When the girl is the perpetrator and not victim, the Indian media will become stalkers themselves and incribe their chests with the girl's name in blood and make a wall of their every move.
When girls are the victims, the name of the guy is barely even mentioned, let alone breathlessly.
Siya Married Lover Chetan 4 Months Ago, After Engagement With Ketan: Sources
ndtv.com/india-news/siya-goy…
Sadaf retweeted
when we attend to feelings about what was missed, yearned for, covered in shame, or associated with hurt and rejection we are providing recognition of not “replacement for missed infantile experience”
— Jessica Benjamin
Tilting Back Toward Development
This Bill risks jeopardising access to much-needed healthcare services and excludes those it must protect: TNM
Stop the arbitrary classification and invasive control of transgender persons
#RejectTransBill2026



































