manavs.eth (@sethimanav) header
manavs.eth (@sethimanav) profile picture
19.111195,72.84396
Joined April 2009
Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)Photo by manavs.eth (@sethimanav)
manavs.eth retweeted
The greatest mystery in Indian economics: You spend 15 years studying, land a job and watch 30% TDS disappear before your salary even hits your bank account. Meanwhile, the local ward corporator, who has no traceable business on paper: Cruises in a convoy of 2 white fortuners, builds a multi crore mansion in your locality, and spends your entire annual CTC just putting up birthday hoardings across the junction. In India, an honest corporate career buys you a 20 year EMI. Local politics buys you generational real estate. We aren't paying taxes for public infrastructure. We’re crowdfunding VIP lifestyles.
128
872
40
3,066
52,355
manavs.eth retweeted
Jean Dreze took Amartya Sen developmental economics forward. Gave us Right to Food, Education, MGNREGA. Should have got the Nobel Prize with Abhijeet Banerjee. Meanwhile, Sanyal was so bad at his job that he was kicked out as Economic Advisor by Modi post Demonetisation, MSME Collapse, Covid mismanagement in 2022. Sanyal fudged Economic Survey Data for which the entire Economists and Statistics Community ostracised him. Today, Sanyal writes fictional novels for Sanghi Ecosystem and roams around in Fictional History Seminar Circuits. Sanyal is a toilet paper Fiction Writer at best. He is not even fit to polish the shoes of Jean Dreze. Dont compare Apple to Cow dung! P.S. Always a Jean Dreze fan since I learnt how he brought in Technology to plug in leakages in Public Distribution System.
Sanyal, Dreze is worth 100 of you. A far far far better economist than you, with your supplicant mediocrity, would ever be. And an infinitely better human being who’s done more for India than you or ideological forefathers have ever done.
34
111
16
630
18,322
This story will sound like a joke but it is not. -A teacher in MP was disappointed by bad condition of village school. -He used his own money to paint it, put some furniture in dining space, cleaned it. -brought a smart board. Gave some stationary to students. -brought 2 retired people to teach students for free. -also brought 2 other teachers & paid them from his pocket. -school enrolment increased, kids left private schools to study here. -kids from nearby villages also came. -Education Department transferred the teacher. -angry villagers protested on highway against his transfer. -he had to leave. Kids cried, everyone sad. -retired teachers were also removed. -kids started leaving school. -villagers protested again at collectorate to bring back that teacher. -Edu Dept gave show cause notice to the teacher asking him if he really used his own money? Who gave him permission. -Also asked him how he hired other teachers w/o permission. -asked if he has given stationary to kids, where did he get the funds? -warned him to reply to the notice to avoid the disciplinary action.
237
2,214
152
7,988
201,438
manavs.eth retweeted
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi, the judges that made sure the illegal SIR process goes through without any trouble in Bengal and Bihar, must quietly sit this one out. Even if they choose to do something, they can continue doing it. No one cares. The Supreme Court has been complicit in ensuring that Gen Z’s voting rights are stolen and state elections too. By ensuring that important petitions are not heard and decided in time, like the Maharashtra government toppling, parties being broken up, Delhi constitutional crisis case, the BJP had the last laugh. It’s a big blot on our judiciary. And so, this Supreme Court Bench may do whatever they want to but it will hold absolutely ZERO CREDIBILITY in people’s eyes. The accountability will be decided by the people of India, the young generation. The Court can do whatever it wants to do tomorrow or whenever. @Cockroachisback
1,181
2,696
246
8,929
369,191
An open letter to all my countrymen. Do you want India to remain a democracy? Then you must understand what Gyanesh Kumar, the CEC, and his bosses are doing in the so-called SIR. They are violating the law. - As per Section 21 of the law, a special revision is to be undertaken only in special cases, for reasons to be recorded in writing in each case; and that also only in any constituency or part of a constituency. An order for intensive revision for the whole country was illegal. An exception allowed for special cases cannot become the rule. The Supreme Court order upholding the general SIR was wrong. Another question is - who took the decision for SIR in the whole country? Was it the full commission; or only Gyanesh Kumar. - Section 21 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, provides that where the revision of an electoral roll is taken up, the electoral roll in force at the time of the issue of the notification of revision shall continue in effect till the completion of the revision. The revised electoral rolls become complete only after all the appeals filed against inclusion or deletion are disposed off. Where the appeals were still pending, the original Electoral roll which was valid on the date of notification was to be used. Contrary to this the new roll with deletions was used during the elections even though appeals against deletions were still pending. This was illegal. - Section 22 of the RP Act provides that the Electoral Registration Officer, and not anyone else, can remove a voter's name from the roll and that also only on the grounds listed in Section 22(a), (b), and (c); and only after a specific enquiry, after giving the concerned person a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and only after appeals against his order are disposed off. Gyanesh Kumar removed the names of all the voters who had been listed by the ERO's after 2003, without any basis, without any enquiry, and without any show cause to the registered voters. This was blatantly illegal. The persons whose names were removed summarily had to apply as fresh voters in Form 6 and give evidence that they were eligible to be registered. This is a clear violation of the Supreme Court judgement in Lal Babu Hussain and Others v. Electoral Registration Officer and Others, [(1995) 3 SCC 100], which held that the enquiry authority or the objector and not the voter - must bring forth material evidence to back any claim that an enrolled voter be disqualified. And in such cases the voter must be asked to show cause why his name should not be removed on the basis of the grounds adduced by the enquiry officer. All this did not happen. The established jurisprudence is that the onus to prove that there are sufficient grounds for subjecting any person to a disability or punishment is on the person or institution which is seeking to inflict the punishment. Here, Gyanesh Kumar has inverted the burden of proof. This is also against the law. Up to now, the efforts of the Government and the Election Commission have always been to enroll all eligible voters. It was a mission to deepen democracy and empower all citizens. This is the first time in history of the country that the mission is to disenfranchise people. Gyanesh Kumar added a new appendix to Form 6. He was not authorised to do so, as Form 6 is mandated by statutory rules. And he added this himself – against the views of the two election commissioners. The decisions of the commission are to be taken either unanimously – or by a majority. The majority was against the addition of the new appendix to the form. So the addition of the new appendix was against the decisions of the Commission itself. So why was it added? On whose orders? This was illegal. This appendix asks the applicant to state the serial number in the 2003 voter list on which their parents' names were listed. Where can an ordinary person – a young man of 18; access the 2003 roll in 2026? This stopped the registration of all young voters. BJP knows that young voters will not vote for it. Objections to inclusion of voters names in form 7 were filed in bulk. Who filed them? How were the forms accepted and acted upon when the persons who signed it did not appear? Names of 16 lac voters found valid by the ERO were not registered in Bengal because, it seems, the EC filed appeals against them. Why? On which grounds? Who authorised the Commission to file appeals? Two Election Commissioners say they did not do so. So the Commission did not authorise anyone to file appeals. Who did it? Gyanesh Kumar? These people were prevented from voting in the election. So the Election Commission and some people from a political party were acting in cahoots to get bogus Form 7 objections filed in bulk and delete names? How were elections allowed to be held when the appeals of lakhs of voters were pending? The ECI and the Supreme Court have to answer. The appeals which have been decided show that 90% of the voters who were left out were valid. A ridiculous thing was brought up called "logical discrepancy". Gyanesh Kumar does not have any idea of how the poor live in India. Their children are not born in hospitals. They do not have birth certificates. They do not have calendars in their homes. When the BLO approached them to enroll them in the voter list they gave their estimated year of birth. Similarly, when their fathers' names were enrolled in the electoral roll, they gave their estimated year of birth. The dumb people in the Election Commission, under Gyanesh Kumar, said that any difference of less than 15 years between father and children would be a logical discrepancy justifying excluding their names. The “Logical Discrepancy” names were excluded without enquiry, contrary to sec 21 of the act. The largest number of exclusions have been the poor and the underprivileged, those without a voice. They were and are mostly away from their homes, earning their daily bread. Lakhs are working in faraway places/states. They could not and cannot afford to go back to their homes for a month to get their names registered. They will go hungry if they do not earn. They cannot fill the complicated forms. They do not have birth certificates and the papers. Why should they sacrifice their daily wages for a vote? The illegal immigrants are not affected. The first thing they do on entering India is to get their documentation made—Aadhaar card, ration card, etc. The earlier immigrants are their support systems. It is the poor Indian citizens who have been disenfranchised. The dumb people in the Election Commission and their bosses did not understand this. Or they wanted it this way. Gyanesh Kumar has made a digital electoral roll and empowered it to refuse addition of names because of “Logical discrepancy”. In the name of "Logical discrepancy", the names of millions of voters have not been included. This is against the law. The only authority designated by law to add or delete names and publish the electoral rolls is the Electoral Registration Officer. Contrary to this, the electoral roll was centralised and the revision happened centrally. This was illegal. Two Election Commissioners pointed out that the only people authorized to add or delete names – the ERO, the DEO and the CEO were not being allowed to access the voter list. In Goa, 97 electors were found by the ERO to be valid and fit for inclusion in the roll. They have not been able to add their names to the roll as yet. The centralisation of the voter list amendment is dangerous. It can be used to cut voters from booths which vote against NDA. Is this what happened? Deleting voters names before verification is a heinous offence, and Gyanesh Kumar is guilty thereof. 13 crores names have been deleted by SIR so far. This is 13% of the voters, and SIR is not over. The difference between NDA and INDIA in the 2024 elections was only 3%. So the deletion have had and will have a material impact on the elections. The press note issued after the Commission meeting on 26th September confirms the illegalities mentioned above. Did Gyanesh Kumar commit all these illegalities himself or was he directed to do so by his bosses? The Opposition says that they will impeach Gyanesh Kumar. That is an exercise in futility. They just do not have the numbers. If they really want a remedy, they should file criminal cases against Gyanesh Kumar. The next step to be taken is that all opposition parties should unite and say that they will not participate in any election till the CEC and Election Commissioners' resign and the selection of their successors is as per the previous selection system, with the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition, and a sitting Supreme Court judge. Elections held in states while the appeals of lakhs of voters were pending must be set aside and fresh elections held. And the poll must be held by ballot not by EVMs because no electronic system has yet been invented which cannot be hacked. That is why none of the economically and digitally advanced countries use EVMs. If we want to preserve our democracy the whole country will need to be made aware and united. The reputation of the Supreme Court has been besmirched by the judgement on SIR. It is at par in infamy with the judgement upholding the emergency. Hon’ble Judges may please note. The procrastination on the challenge to the law on selection of Election Commissioners is also sending a bad message about the Supreme Court – as it is an open and shut case that the Election Commissioners should not be selected by the party in power; but by a neutral selection committee to ensure their neutrality. Let us unite to save our democracy. RK Singh (IAS Retd. Ex Union Home Secretary) @abhijeet_dipke @Cockroachisback @RahulGandhi @kharge @ArvindKejriwal @MamataOfficial @yadavakhilesh @mkstalin @yadavtejashwi @Pawankhera
930
4,981
358
12,488
939,744
Celebrating 5 years of #PolicyBazaar IPO thread. Issue price ~ 1000 listing price- 1200 Your return after 5 years <5% 67% of ownership has been sold to retail & Mutual Funds at perfect prices. Owners have the money today. You carry all the risk. I told you so in 2021.
#PolicybazaarIPO Long thread: There is monetary printing by RBI, there is lending by banks & finally there is the Indian IPO. “Foreign owned” company with ~1 Bn investment is selling “Indian” unicorn to “savvy” Indians for $ 6.2 Bn. Want to know how this printing works? Let’s go-
41
62
11
493
85,511
10,000 रुपए के UPI पेमेंट पर 40 रुपए का MDR लगेगा. फ‍िर 40 रुपए पर 18% GST भी लगेगा. मतलब 10 हजार पर MDR और GST जोड़कर कुल - 47.20 रुपए वसूले जाएंगे. मेरा सुझाव है - मोदी सरकार 47.20 रुपए पर Education Cess और Clean Environment Cess भी ठोक दे. अलग लेवल का मास्‍टरस्‍ट्रोक होगा
138
1,779
12
6,836
116,667
You got to book this car driver under “hit and run” case @gurgaonpolice. Bring them to justice. Car No: HR 30Y 4949 📹: IG/rebelwheels_sia_
870
8,136
309
27,546
3,142,648
manavs.eth retweeted
Mr Anurag Kumar @CPDelhi @DelhiPolice , Informing an individual's family during interrogation or detention is a legal mandate, not an optional courtesy. ​Yesterday, I was taken for interrogation after my morning walk under the assurance that it would take very little time. However, as the hours stretched on, my repeated requests to inform my wife of my whereabouts ,the concerned Police Officials/Officer simply stated they were "following instructions." ​I was only permitted to make a call at 6:38 PM, leaving my family & friends in total panic the entire day. I request that you issue clear instructions to all units directing officers to strictly uphold the legal duty of immediately informing the family of any person taken for interrogation , so that no citizen’s family has to endure the distress that mine suffered.
363
2,910
173
8,899
352,271
Aap chronology samajh lijiye. July 29: "Show us the order proving Shah ordered firing" —Rijiju "Shah couldn't have ordered firing; only a magistrate can" —Jitendra Singh "There was no firing" —Piyush Goyal August 7: "You can't dictate that Shah must appear" —Rijiju "The day the discussion begins here, and when Amit Shah responds, you won't be able to sit through it" —Rijiju August 8: "Shah is in Parliament every day" —Rijiju August 12: "Fine. Let's have a discussion. Start at 3 pm. I will personally sit there and answer everything for 24 hours" —Amit Shah August 13: Amit Shah in the front row, next to Modi. This was the first time Shah entered the Lok Sabha during this entire 18-day session! Speaker Om Birla entered the House. Instead of taking up the promised discussion, the House first proceeded with the national song, Vande Mataram. All six stanzas were rendered. Members, including Modi and Shah, stood. And immediately after it ended, Birla announced that the House was adjourned sine die. As they say, patriotism is the last refuge...
28
1,077
19
4,948
134,103
manavs.eth retweeted
On the fifteenth of June 2020, a young reporter in Uttar Pradesh wrote to the state authorities to say he was being threatened. He named ten people. Four days later, two men on the road shot him six times. His name was Shubham Mani Tripathi. He was twenty five, a local correspondent for a Hindi daily called Kampu Mail. Not a national newspaper, not a television face. A small paper in a small district, covering illegal sand mining and land grabbing in Unnao. His reporting had worked. On the fourteenth of June he wrote on his own Facebook page that an illegal construction put up by what he called the famous land mafia had been demolished because of a report he had filed. In the same post he wrote that they were enraged, and had filed a fake complaint against him with the district magistrate. He had also told people around him, plainly, that he thought he was going to be killed. The next day he wrote to the authorities and named the men he was afraid of. On the nineteenth of June, riding home on a motorcycle with a friend, he was shot near the milk market in Unnao. Six bullets, three of them to the head. He died shortly after. Police later said the killing was arranged in retaliation for his reporting, and that four hundred thousand rupees had been paid to two shooters. Arrests followed. Reporters Without Borders describes Uttar Pradesh as one of the most dangerous places in the world to be a journalist, and says the ones most at risk are those who try to cover the sand mafia. The United Nations cultural body condemned his killing by name. Sand is not a glamorous subject. It is dug illegally out of riverbeds at night, it is worth an enormous amount of money, and the people who control it in parts of India are effectively untouchable. A twenty five year old at a small Hindi paper decided to write about it anyway. He told the state exactly who was coming for him, and the state did nothing, and they came.
49
579
30
1,016
100,046
How dare women be crass? How dare women be angry? How dare women occupy public spaces without first proving they are dignified enough to deserve that space? That is the burden we women  have carried for generations..the burden of respectability. And it is precisely that burden these young women refused to carry. We, as millennial women, were raised on those expectations. We were taught that a woman must be graceful, calm, composed, demure; that she must make her point politely and with dignity. We lived through those  standards...  -  Every step outside those boundaries invited judgment. Every act of defiance came with a price. Ms Ranaut - we are millennials , we cared. We measured every word. We watched every step. We carried the burden of respectability everywhere. They don't... and dare we pass that burden on to them ..they deserve better because we know we deserved better -
476
626
196
2,287
421,785
Preeti Chaudhary has delivered one of the most graceful, fearless and devastating rebuttals to Kangana Ranaut’s deeply misogynistic remarks targeting an entire generation of young women. Without trading insults or descending into theatrics, Preeti simply held up a mirror to Kangana. She made it unequivocally clear that an entire generation of young women cannot be dismissed through prejudice, stereotypes or sweeping labels. They deserve to be heard, not ridiculed for asking uncomfortable questions or refusing to conform. Her closing observation was the knockout punch: If Kangana still has any doubts about Gen Z, she doesn’t need another monologue, she just needs to scroll through the comments under her own post. Preeti’s message was crystal clear, fearless and impossible to miss. Whether Kangana has the maturity to reflect on that mirror (or she is actually too dumb) is something only she can answer. #MirrorToKangana
134
1,247
77
4,880
181,951
कल जंतर-मंतर पर चल रहे आंदोलन का सुखद अंत हुआ. इस आंदोलन का एक चेहरा जो मुझे हमेशा याद रहेगा वो इरफ़ान का होगा. पहली बार 6 जून को उससे मिला था. उसी दिन जंतर-मंतर पर आंदोलन की शुरुआत हुई थी. उसके बाद मैं इरफान के घर गया. परिवार से मिला. गरीबी झेलते हुए भी इरफान हमेशा मुस्कुराता रहता है. अपनी नहीं अपने लोगों की बात करता है. अपने समाज की. समाज की कुरीतियों को तोड़ता है. इरफान का नंबर मांगने और उसकी मदद करने के लिए अब तमाम लोग संपर्क कर रहे. उन सभी का बहुत शुक्रिया. उम्मीद है इरफान को अपने सपनों का आसमान मिले. मेरे संस्थान @TheLallantop का बहुत शुक्रिया जो हमे इन कहानियों को कहने की हिम्मत देता है. #irfan #lallantop
292
1,690
84
8,456
291,770
ये मोहम्मद इरफ़ान हैं, इन्हें औपचारिक शिक्षा नहीं मिली। दिल्ली की एक झुग्गी बस्ती में रहते हैं, ये भी जंतर-मंतर पर हुए आंदोलन का हिस्सा थे लेकिन लोगों तक इनकी आवाज़ शायद पहुंच नहीं सकी, लोकतंत्र पर इनकी बात एक बार ज़रूर सुनिए।
181
1,743
199
5,958
793,661
manavs.eth retweeted
This order is illegal and unlawful and there’s no law as far as I know that allows the Government of India to do this. They’re acting as a law unto themselves. Let me explain: 1. Bitchat itself has not violated any law. It’s a piece of software that people use to communicate without the Internet. If a threat was created using Microsoft Word OFFLINE, would you hold Microsoft responsible for it. If that is the principled rationale here, then every software in the world is susceptible to the vagaries of actions from the Indian government. 2. Such an act of disproportionate blocking needs to be backed up with proof: merely being able to communicate without surveillance, is not a violation of any law. Neither the platform nor the government of India can track what is being done with it. On what basis is this order being issued? 4. Decentralised technologies are critical to the functioning of the web: they allow users to take control over their own Internet usage, without dependence on a single platform. Maybe that’s exactly it: the Indian government controls our speech and our communications THROUGH concentrated large platforms like x, Instagram, Facebook, and the idea of decentralisation, where they can’t order a single player to take something down, seems unmanageable to them. 4. An act of blocking has to be proportionate: there is legitimate speech potentially on the platform itself. We don’t know what is the actual speech which it thinks (doesn’t know) is illegal. By taking down these platforms you censor/prevent people from having the opportunity to communicate privately, and legitimately. 5. Directing Github to remove this app is also deeply problematic: not only is Bitchat not illegal, a platform that allows you to download an app or code for your own personal usage, for legal purposes, is also not illegal. Github is at risk because it’s a centralised platform btw. 6. No law in India mandates an app to have mandatory user registration, phone number verification or centralised logging of communications. There is no ban on anonymous coordination. Surveillance isn’t mandatory. In face, many existing communications apps do not do this. THIS as a basis for issuing a blocking order is itself illegal - no law supports this action. 7. The order says that the platform is capable of being used for unlawful activities: I’m afraid that’s no reason for blocking something. A messaging app can be used for illegal activities, it can be used for legal activities. A knife can be used to till or cut fruit. You don’t ban knifes. Again, this order is illegal and unlawful and there’s no law as far as I know that allows the government of India to do this. They’re acting as a law unto themselves.
the government of india does not like technologies like bitchat and wants it taken down
55
324
8
869
119,062
Is your police trained to hit people on the head? Especially women?? What orders did you give them @DelhiPolice ? Since you have been quick to clarify- do tell us!
प्राचीन समय में युद्ध के नियम होते थे बच्चों और महिलाओ पर वार ना करना और हथियार ना उठाना। #genz
5
2,197
36
8,629
130,392
I just received a call from @DelhiPolice and they have said not to go tomorrow to the residence of Hon'ble Transport & Highway minster shri @nitin_gadkari ji! But Nitin sir, you gave us a challenge to to get people affected whose vehicles are affected by E20Fuel! Sir you please give us an appointment!! Secondly sir: yesterday you said your son's Ethanol business is just 0.07%, this sir is roughly about ₹50-₹100 crores a year! How many INDIANS earn that kind of money? Sir with humility, this is BETA BADHAO YOJANA & a conflict of interest. Sir we await your revert! Tehseen Poonawalla Team Bharat
727
5,665
133
24,687
1,163,530
manavs.eth retweeted
*STATEMENT* As per reports, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court today has issued notice to me in a plea seeking initiation of criminal contempt proceedings over one of my reports concerning the appearance of conflict of interest and reasonable apprehension of bias in Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma hearing the CBI appeal in the Delhi Excise Policy case. The petitioner alleges that my report contains “serious, unfounded and scandalous allegations” against Justice Sharma. I stand firmly by my reporting. The report was based entirely on documentary material: RTI data furnished by the Ministry of Law & Justice, the judge’s own judicial orders in Criminal Revision Petitions, publicly available records, and statements made by a sitting Hon’ble Judge of the Supreme Court himself. Not a single fact reported by me has been rebutted either by the judge concerned or by the CBI in any of the proceedings, including the suo-motu contempt proceedings. In that backdrop, an unattached third party has now come into the picture. That said, since the matter now directly concerns me and is sub-judice, it will not be appropriate to comment further on the merits at this stage. I shall place my response before the Court after consulting distinguished members of the Bar, eminent legal luminaries, and respected members of the fraternity. The constitutional guarantee of free speech includes the right, not just of journalists, but of every citizen, to fairly scrutinise and critique judicial functioning and administrative decisions that have a bearing on public confidence in the institution. The faith in the institution can never be strengthened through opacity or the chilling of public scrutiny. Journalism that seeks to uncover these uncomfortable facts in the largest of public interests is part of the constitutional duty of the fourth pillar. Questions cannot be contempt.✊🏻 #JournalismIsNotACrime
255
1,629
76
4,653
238,407