a violet so ultra retweeted
Heidi, We have never interacted before, so before I begin I would like to say I am deeply sorry for what the horrors your family has suffered at the hands of the terror group Hamas. I oppose Hamas and antisemitism unequivocally, and whatever else we may disagree about, I will stand with you on that no matter what.
However, your posts about my 2010 talk seriously misrepresent what I said, my work on 9/11 and appear to be aimed at deliberately damaging my professional reputation.
My published work in books, essays and talks holds al-Qaeda responsible for the 9/11 terrorist attacks. It investigates how Western governments’ relationships with states supporting Islamist militants - Saudi Arabia and Pakistan above all - compromised intelligence and accountability. Investigating those relationships does not mean claiming that the US government perpetrated the attacks.
My 9/11 work has received substantial recognition. My first book on the subject, The War on Freedom, was among 99 books made available to each 9/11 Commissioner. In 2005, I gave evidence at a Congressional briefing (this is how I first met Cynthia McKinney who at that time was not a conspiracy theorist but a Democrat Congressional representative who had twice won the state of Georgia); an extract appears in the Congressional Record.
The Independent described my second 9/11 book, The War on Truth, as “disturbing and clearly evidenced”.
The bin Laden line you quote comes from my closing remarks. In those same remarks, I called for moving beyond the division between conspiracy theorists and their opponents to focus on facts:
“… we need to come out of this constructed divide and focus … fundamentally on what we know, and ask really hard questions about those issues. Because it’s clear that we cannot establish a paper trail on either side.”
You make out as if questioning the government's evidential case amounts to denying al-Qaeda's involvement. That is not the case. Legal scholars routinely distinguish between intelligence consensus and admissible courtroom proof. Although intelligence agencies documented al-Qaeda’s responsibility for 9/11, the US and UK governments bypassed and compromised standard criminal procedures, leaving the wider official narrative heavily reliant on unverified detainee interrogations rather than open-court convictions.
While I questioned the government’s evidential case, I also criticised conspiracy theorists and said "there was no paper trail establishing that a particular individual had ordered or allowed the attacks." I concluded:
“… we’re much stronger if we focus less on those particular interpretations and focus on the contradictions [and] anomalies.”
You cannot fairly present that passage as endorsing an alternative theory while omitting its explicit warning that the alternative had not been established either. This is especially clear given my repeated published criticism of inside-job reasoning. You omit to acknowledge that I described “inside job” as a “meaningless bullshit euphemism” for claiming government responsibility without proof, and “a vague, amorphous cop-out typical of the conspiracy industry in general”.
I also recorded challenging David Shayler at my 2006 House of Lords book launch when he declared that 9/11 and 7/7 were inside jobs. I described his pronouncements as “a disgraceful affront to the 9/11 and 7/7 families”.
These are my own words, publicly available from over a decade ago: nafeezahmed.net/thecuttinged…
You also wrote that I “cast doubt on the hijackers being Islamists because a few went to Las Vegas”. Yet in the same talk I described the men at the centre of the plot as “very, very close to Osama bin Laden, part of this very strict Salafist Wahhabi puritanical trend”.
Their Islamism was the starting point of that discussion. I noted that Las Vegas visits were documented by US investigators and examined former CIA officer Robert Baer’s account of ignored warnings. The Commission itself noted the anomaly, saying it had “seen no credible evidence explaining why” the hijackers visited Las Vegas. Reducing that passage to “a few went to Las Vegas” strips out its substance.
Such questions are more live than ever because of the mounting evidence of the ties between the hijackers and Saudi military intelligence - which anomalies such as above may be consistent with. In August 2025, a US federal judge rejected Saudi Arabia’s attempt to dismiss the 9/11 families’ claims on sovereign-immunity grounds. The judge concluded that the evidence was sufficient to support an inference that two Saudi men had assisted the hijackers through their employment by the Saudi government. This demonstrates why investigating possible state support for al-Qaeda is a serious evidential question.
On the meeting itself: it took place in Parliament in 2010, not 2011. As I recall, the room was booked by the late Michael Meacher, then a Labour MP and former environment minister. Recordings were subsequently posted online by others, including a 9/11 truth website, independently of me.
You also linked me to Cynthia McKinney, who spoke at that meeting. I first met her in 2005, when she convened the Congressional briefing. The 2010 meeting was the last time I met or had any contact with her.
Her subsequent claim that “Zionists” carried out 9/11, made in 2021, is undoubtedly an antisemitic conspiracy theory. The suggestion that I am presciently responsible for views she expressed more than a decade after our last contact is indefensible.
Your posts grotesquely disregard and misrepresent my own published position, which is clear for anyone to check and see. And your selective omissions change the meaning of what I said.
You are of course entitled to challenge my research, and my actual views. Identify a factual error and substantiate it. You are not entitled to attribute positions to me that I have explicitly criticised and then use them to attack my professional credibility.
I regard your posts as defamatory and reserve my legal rights.
a violet so ultra retweeted
Replying to @TinaRSH
You might enjoy the book “Finite and Infinite Games” by James P Carse. The purpose of a finite game is to bring it to an end (achieve a terminal outcome). The purpose of an infinite game is to keep playing. Pics from my annotated copy. See also “The Inner Game of Tennis.”
a violet so ultra retweeted
Replying to @matthewstoller
It is exceedingly difficult to define fascist movements, particularly in real time. That said, your argument uses a characteristic as a necessary outcome w/o explaining why. Sharing Robert Paxton’s 1998 5 Stages of Fascism to make the case this is fascism. election.princeton.edu/wp-co…
a violet so ultra retweeted
The people closest to the pain should be the closest to the power, driving and informing the policymaking.
a violet so ultra retweeted
.@BedoyaUSA on @ttsgpod breaks down how allyship between working people and small businesses is key to the populist movement: "Great things happen when small business owners ally with working people. The big moment this happened was in the 19th century when sharecroppers in the South, the Farmers Alliance decided, 'hey, no, screw you, fat cats of Wall Street'... I actually have more in common with the Knights of Labor... I'm going to break bread with them. I'm going to ally with them. That is what created the populist movement in this country."
a violet so ultra retweeted
Tolstoy, gençliğinde bir gece kumar masasında bütün servetini kaybettiğinde, sabaha karşı kendini Moskova Nehri'nin kıyısında bulmuş. Cebinde tek kuruş yokmuş, borçları dağ gibiymiş. Nehrin buzlu sularına bakarken içinden şöyle geçirmiş: "Eğer bu beladan kurtulursam, bir daha
++
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Tolstoy'un gençliğinde Moskova Nehri'nde kumar kaybı sonrası yemin edip kısa sürede bozduğuna dair anlatı biyografilerde veya 'İtiraflar'ında yok; bilinen kayıplar farklı (örneğin doğduğu evi satmak zorunda kalması) ve atfedilen alıntı uydurma.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_Tolst…
en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Compl…
gw2ru.com/arts/241495-ho…
a violet so ultra retweeted
Heard there’s no more photo limit on twitter so here are all my rave fliers as a treat
a violet so ultra retweeted
Democrats, the people gave us a mandate for bold, transformative change.
And our majority must meet their cries with action.
a violet so ultra retweeted
How we beat back the corporate takeover of America:
1. Break up corporate monopolies
2. Continue building union power
3. End Citizens United and get big money out of politics
Let’s keep working to unrig the system.
a violet so ultra retweeted
My colleague and friend Dr. Rizk Abu Shaaira was killed yesterday at work when Israel, backed by the US as always, bombed the surgical recovery room at Nasser Medical Complex. Two of his colleagues were badly injured, and many patients were hurt and killed. Dr. Rizk is featured on the original poster for the documentary American Doctor, standing to my right as we did a redo laparotomy on a disaster abdomen.
Dr. Rizk was one of those surgeons we describe as "super enthusiastic". On rounds he would jump at the opportunity to change a dressing, clean a wound, or pull a drain. He always had an answer to any question anyone asked. He embodied the surgical wisdom that "a chance to cut is a chance to cure."
Dr. Rizk's shocking murder is yet another reminder of why we must get control of our country. Our government has no right to force us to subsidize the mass murder of doctors and children, not in Palestine and not anywhere.
a violet so ultra retweeted
We gotta stop throwing America’s sons and daughters into the damn meat grinder of war just so Raytheon and the military industrial complex can make a shiny penny.
a violet so ultra retweeted
There was a lot of misinformation on X today about credit card interest caps. The bottom line is this -- the conventional wisdom, that interest caps necessarily always lead to denied credit, doesn't apply to credit cards. I've done a lot of research on this topic.
cdn.vanderbilt.edu/vu-URL/wp…
a violet so ultra retweeted
Y’all need to stop trying to turn this Hakeem Jeffries situation into a race issue. For many of us, it’s about his unwavering support for Israel while our tax dollars fund what we believe is genocide. And you conveniently leave out that we don’t want Chuck Schumer either. Schumer isn’t Black. The opposition is for the same reason. It’s about policy, not race.
a violet so ultra retweeted
Why should Congressional Democrats investigate corporate America if their mandate is to deliver real economic change? Because investigations are a key catalyst for securing reform and legislation. For much of the last century, Congress used to be the main institutional player working to secure an economy that serves working people. A key tool was oversight. Lawmakers routinely investigated complex markets and major corporations, identifying problems and exposing wrongdoing. A major goal of these investigations was to learn what was driving certain problems and figure out how to fix them.
After Democrats took back the House during the first Trump administration in 2019, I joined the House Judiciary Committee as a staffer on the Antitrust Subcommittee. Under the terrific leadership of @RepJerryNadler and then-Rep @davidcicilline, we pursued an 18-month investigation into Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google, securing key evidence of how their business practices were undermining competition and harming people, setting the basis for both lawsuits and proposed legislation.
A few lessons from that experience:
1. The quality of legislative oversight depends on the staff and the support of top members to confront power. Committee and Subcommittee Chairs that are focused on getting answers and unafraid to take on powerful corporate interests will make the difference between oversight that doesn’t surrender to their evasion tactics and oversight that aims low or flames out.
Even a relatively small number of dogged, talented lawyers ready to dive in can make a big impact. In the 1930s a single congressional lawyer, Ferdinand Pecora, helped reshape our entire banking system by subpoenaing records and interrogating top financiers, including J.P Morgan. The investigation exposed self-dealing, market manipulation, and tax avoidance, and laid the groundwork for foundational New Deal legislation, including the Glass-Steagall Act and the Securities Exchange Act.
2. Eliminating bottlenecks to moving investigations forward is key. For example, the House should make sure that Subcommittee Chairs can issue subpoenas rather than needing the sign-off of the full Committee or its Chair. A credible threat of sending subpoenas is critical for credible oversight.
3. Ensuring that members can develop the muscle to effectively interrogate CEOs requires investing in real preparation. In the lead up to the hearing with Bezos, Pichai, Cook, and Zuckerberg, the Antitrust Subcommittee spent months reviewing millions of documents collected from the firms, interviewing affected parties, briefing members on key evidence, and conducting practice hearings. Members came into the hearing deeply informed and able to rebut and call out CEO dissembling. The result was some of the most effective member questioning of executives we’ve seen in decades. @TheProspect wrote up a great overview: prospect.org/2020/07/30/triu…
4. For decades, institutional capacity in Congress has been extremely weak. Much of this traces back to the Gingrich Revolution, which was effectively the 1995 DOGE-ing of Congress. Republican leadership fired over 600 professional staffers, eliminated the Office of Technology Assessment, and gutted research capacity. None of that capacity was ever meaningfully restored.
As a result, members have way fewer resources to develop serious expertise or go deep on a new topic. Members should start rebuilding that capacity so the institution can fully play its Article I role, where Congress can again do serious policy development and legislating and serve as a real check on the executive and judicial branches.
5. AI markets should be high on the list of investigations. The business decisions of the major AI firms have huge public ramifications, yet the public is at a severe informational disadvantage when it comes to how these markets work and the choices these firms are making. A congressional investigation will help ensure future legislative action is based on a more complete view of what is going on rather than selective and partial corporate disclosures.
a violet so ultra retweeted
Brazil's two-round system makes this easier, but the underlying strategy could be adapted to the U.S. The obstacle isn't electoral theory; it's that the organizations capable of mobilizing at that scale are often dependent on the very interests such a movement would challenge.
a violet so ultra retweeted
If you wake up this morning and see the surge of black voters across the Deep South and the bold response of Latinos who came out despite the threats, and the presidential level participation of young folks, and conclude that the scale of our victory was solely because “we had the discipline to stay on message about kitchen table issues” - you should not be given a dime of our ActBlue donations for your guaranteed future mediocre strategies.
That was a rights based surge. A democracy surge. Gas prices, irrational tariffs, and broad cost of living played a huge role. But we cannot ignore what animated the souls of our surge voters. And we absolutely cannot continue to ignore corruption as an issue even within our own Party “until the polls catch up”
a violet so ultra retweeted
Texas will rise. Mississippi and Alabama will rise. Louisiana and South Carolina will rise. Arkansas and Tennessee will rise. Folks really believe that. Invest in Southern voters. Every state. #GASen
















































