
Economic historian #RyC at @UNavarra: inequality, taxation & public policies. Also @LuEconHist, Co-editor @ihe_ehr
Pamplona, Spain
Joined August 2013
- Tweets3.8K
- Following927
- Followers1.5K
- Likes2.6K
Pinned Tweet
🧵 New working paper with Ramiro Coviello: “The Rise and Fall of the Personal Income Tax in Argentina (1932–73)” (Lund Papers in Econ. History, No. 276)
With historical tax returns, we estimate PIT’s progressivity and redistributive effects, compared with Sweden, UK and US 👇
"Writing is thinking"
I am sharing a new paper today with Dario Caldara: “Can Peer Review Survive AI-Generated Text?”
sas.upenn.edu/~jesusfv/Peer_…
Dario and I, as editors, are increasingly getting papers submitted to our journals that are 99 percent AI-generated. Even worse, we are also receiving many AI-generated referee reports, both as editors and, more frustratingly, as authors.
And we cannot emphasize this enough: the real problem is not that the papers and reports were AI-generated; it is that no one had done the thinking behind them, and you can so easily tell. The papers were eminently forgettable, and the referee reports were disappointingly uninsightful. We have seen too many reports of the form: “The paper is well-written and addresses an important problem. However, the authors should consider additional baselines.”
This deluge of AI-generated text puts peer review in jeopardy: journals will be flooded with low-quality submissions, economists will decline requests to referee papers or routinely use AI to referee them, and which papers get published will become less and less linked to their quality.
We do not want to defend the status quo entirely. Peer review is slow, many reports are poor, and editors (including us!) make bad calls all the time. Still, well-executed peer review remains the best system we have for assessing each other’s work and advancing the profession. AI could improve peer review if used deliberately for that purpose, for instance, to check proofs and code. That is not what we are seeing.
The difficulty is that readers, including editors and referees, cannot see how AI was used. As a result, in practice, the burden of verification shifts from the author to the reader.
Since we reject this shift, Dario and I did what economists always do when something bothers us: we wrote a paper.
So, what do we do in it? First, we check whether AI detectors such as Pangram get this right: is a referee report flagged as AI-generated indeed AI-generated? Or is Pangram just flagging proofreading and editing? No. We run an experiment with 25 referee reports from the pre-AI era. Proofreading and editing do not trigger AI-generated flags. Only when we ask the LLMs to substantially rewrite the referee report or to generate a new report do we get the AI-generated flags. Pretty compelling evidence, if I may say so.
Second, we build a theoretical model to explore who should bear the burden of verification: the author or the reader? (Yours truly always enjoyed the courses on the rules of evidence in law school; yes, as Billy Wilder would say, nobody is perfect.)
The answer is that it is much more efficient for the author to do it, because the author can verify at a much lower cost and only needs to do it once (rather than each reader repeatedly). Before AI, the authors more or less had to verify the results, even if only because they had to type them in. This was not perfect (and all papers ever published in economics probably have at least one mistake). But the problem is that, with AI, the author does not even need to read the text. Or can just skim it. Writing is thinking, and without writing there is usually not much thinking.
So, a paper flagged as AI-generated is prima facie evidence that the author has not verified it. Should this lead to an automatic rejection? No. But there should be a zero-tolerance policy for serious mistakes. The first serious mistake we find in the paper, and it is out! In comparison, for a non-flagged paper, a serious mistake is something that the editor might determine it can be fixed in a revision.
We are stricter with referee reports. There is absolutely no point in the referee generating a report using an LLM. As an editor, I can do that directly and save myself the trouble of asking you for it. Now, of course, you can use the LLM to help you with the report (if the journal allows it! Many journals do not allow you to upload the paper to an LLM, and you need to follow the rules). For example, you can use the LLM to search for existing results in the literature.
But peer review is not about finding one sentence that is not entirely precise or a slightly sloppy mathematical proof. Referees are asked: “Is this idea important despite its flaws?” And, relatedly: “Is the paper a good fit for the journal in terms of quality and focus?” That judgment is the task for which you are selected as a subject expert.
We also propose that journals require that, before a paper is submitted, the author submit it to an LLM using an approved prompt and include the LLM report and a discussion of what was and was not fixed. That way, the referee would not need to check (or at least not check so carefully) every technical detail, and they could focus on the big picture: Is this a good paper? Is this a good fit for this journal? What is fundamental for this paper to become publishable at this journal?
Anyway. The paper has many other arguments, and we try to be nuanced. So, before ferociously typing the first complaint that crosses your mind, would you consider reading it? Chances are that we have already discussed your objection. We have been thinking about this for a long time.
But by all means, leave good comments!
3
170
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
No me puedo creer que la respuesta al comentario de "me parece irresponsable que neguéis el cambio climático" es que "por las mañanas hace un clima, por las tardes otro". Dios mío no me puedo creer que haya gente que vaya a votar esto de verdad.
Even at its peak, redistribution was modest by international standards: after WWII, developed countries reached 4–6 Gini points (previous work with @oriol_sabate)
There, the PIT became a mass tax. In Argentina it remained a class tax, hollowed by evasion and inflationary crises
Our reading: elites shifted from cooperation to active evasion as a way to resist redistribution. Latin America’s weak income-tax redistribution has deep historical roots.
Comments very welcome! 📄 lup.lub.lu.se/search/files...
@UNavarra #econhist #taxation #inequality
29
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
Retirees own 60% of the wealth in Feance. Given high life expectancy, when they pass it on, wealth is not inherited by the young, but by the about to be old (those in their 50s). Read the entire thing, an excellent analysis of the pickle our societies find themselves in.
The ugly truth about France and some of the other European countries currently in turmoil - and which none of the politicians want to admit because it'd be political suicide - is that you can't solve the problem by going after immigrants (as the right asserts) or the rich (as the left asserts), but you could solve it by going after the old.
One extraordinary statistic for you: people over 60 in France, a quarter of the population, own 60% of France's wealth, non-financial and financial (ofce.fr/pdf/revue/2025/3-192…).
And here is another crazy statistic:
that same quarter of the population, those above 60, receive nearly two-thirds of all social spending by the French government (previssima.fr/actualite/prot…) - which is famously among the highest in the world (France's government spending is an insane 57.3% of GDP).
Last statistic: they make up about 40% of voters because they're a third of registered voters (insee.fr/fr/statistiques/266…), and they turn out far more than anyone else (franceinfo.fr/elections/sond…).
Put our 3 statistics together and there's almost a bit of an apartheid situation here: the old own most of the country's wealth, collect most of the social spending and have the political power to keep it that way.
Which makes them a de-facto rentier class, living off assets and transfers paid for by younger generations.
And, of course, at the risk of stating a truism, the future is built by the young. Yet France keeps effectively taking money away from them to give it to those whose working lives are already behind them - and need the money far less since they already own the country's wealth.
What about inheritance, I hear you ask? That's the funniest/saddest aspect: given that life expectancy has kept rising, the French now inherit a home at 54 on average. The most common case is someone in their 80s leaving it to heirs in their 50s, in effect the very old transferring wealth to the about-to-be old (insee.fr/fr/statistiques/fic…).
You can add this to our earlier apartheid statement: on top of all the rest, even when the old finally let go of their wealth, it stays within their own "camp".
That's my personal situation, incidentally: I'm 42, my father is 71 and he is starting to look at ways to pass things on to me and my siblings, when our professional lives are already well settled, so it'll arrive when it changes things the least, which is pretty much the French system in a nutshell.
Now, I get that there'd be some unfairness in going after them: they paid into the system their entire working lives, playing by the rules of a social contract that told them if they paid up they'd collect at the end. Changing the rules now means breaking that promise, which is admittedly unfair.
But there's no magic wealth tree in any society: you can only take it where it is. That's the way most major societal transformations end up happening. They're often triggered by a catastrophic event (the so-called "four horsemen": mass-mobilisation war, revolution, state collapse, plague) BUT what really drives change is a transfer: wealth gets pried from the privileged class who've been sitting on it and handed to those who'll build what comes next.
So, in theory and in an ideal world, you can do without the catastrophic event and directly proceed with the transfer...
The fact that in France, and elsewhere in Europe, it's the youth protesting is probably no coincidence - even though they don't frame it as a generational fight. And even though, cruel irony, the left politicians many of them march behind promise to bring the retirement age back to 60 (lcp.fr/actualites/legislativ…), which would make the situation even worse.
Let's say they understand intuitively that the system is stacked against them, even if they haven't yet figured out how. And politicians are obviously doing what politicians do, meaning pandering to the people who actually vote, while pointing the young towards easier - and politically convenient - scapegoats.
To be clear I'm not saying it's the only problem in France, VERY far from it. I'm also not saying that all old people in France live a lavish lifestyle at the expense of younger generations: there are also plenty of very poor retirees who, if anything, would deserve more.
What I am saying is that it's probably the biggest elephant in the room: everyone can see it, nobody dares mention it - no politician, from any side, wants to run on cutting grandma's pension - and it makes every other problem harder to fix.
New Working Paper!
J. Fink and I compare innovation projects that obtained public funding with those that were rejected. Approved projects were TWICE likely to result in significant innovations.
portal.research.lu.se/en/pub…
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
Now on Early View: 'Income taxes and redistribution in the early twentieth century'.
By Sara Torregrosa-Hetland & Oriol Sabaté .
@sthetland @oriol_sabate @UNavarra @LuEconHist @ubeconomics
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/…
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
A fascinating graph: Less than a quarter of the population paid taxes in the UK and US before WW2
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
⏳NOW HIRING! Call for expressions of interest for Assistant Professor positions:
📁Different fields of interest
🔴Deadline: November 20, 2024
🗓️Starting date: June 2025
🔗ub.edu/school-economics/call…
#EconTwitter #AcademicJobs #EconJobMarket
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
Coming May 2025 from @RoutledgeHist, this new and large edited volume co-edited with @jariaeloranta, Elina Kuorelahti and Price Fishback. Check out the table of contents here: routledge.com/The-Routledge-…
I wonder how many of those 24% do not have the right to vote 🤔
in spain, ~16% of total population is foreign-born. but among prime-age population (25-54), it's 24% – and in madrid or barcelona, it's almost 1 in 3
explore fully disaggregated data by country of origin, province and municipality in my updated app: pablogguz.shinyapps.io/datav…
3
357
Looking forward to our seminar tomorrow at @UNavarra with @LuisBauluz! He will talk to us about "The Wealth of Generations"
unavarra.es/sites/research-i…
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
📅🌲 Dos jornadas de voluntariado los días 16 y 23 de noviembre repondrán árboles en el Bosque Olímpico creado en la ladera que une Mendillorri y Lezkairu
↔️ @PamplonaEsVerde
🔎 +INFO: pamplona.es/actualidad/notic…
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
Recently some prominent people have argued that 19thcentury tariffs were beneficial for American manufacturing. In our new NBER working paper, Alex Klein (Sussex) and I argue: there is no evidence for this assertion. 1/N
nber.org/papers/w33100
La Generalitat Valenciana crea una cuenta solidaria para apoyar a los afectados por la DANA eldiario.es/sociedad/ultima-…
Todo mi apoyo hoy a la huelga por la #educaciónpública, que debe garantizar la igualdad de oportunidades y hacerlo en condiciones dignas! – at Pamplona, Spain
3
442
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
'Evitar una universidad clasista'. Editorial @el_pais @CienciaGob @CrueUniversidad @universidad_si @enriccanela @nmontlab @subirats9 @QuimBrugue @ricardgoma @psalaburu @Merce_G @eponsf @oescardibul @montserrat_tura
Sara Torregrosa retweeted
#mujeresyfinanzas
¡No se pierda la exposición sobre la #publicidad financiera en la España de los 60!
📊💼 Hasta fin de mes en la @ualmeria
Organizado por @MCarmenPrez y Vicerrectorado d Igualdad, Inclusión y Compromiso Social. #mujeresyfinanzas #igualdad #historia #finanzas





















