Grouchy Historian retweeted
🧵"Military Science and the Intellectual Foundations of War”
👤 John Spencer (@SpencerGuard)
“Military science is not guesswork. It is the accumulated study of war built by soldiers, historians, statesmen, and theorists over centuries of conflict.”
We explore Spencer's intellectual foundation of key military thinkers-- 14 of them-- in this thread.🪡
@WarInstitute
smallwarsjournal.com/2026/06…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
Today is publication day! @BasicBooks – at Highland Park, TX
Grouchy Historian retweeted
First of the Federalist Papers is published
On this day in history, October 27, 1787, the first of the Federalist Papers is published. The Federalist, as it was originally called, was a series of articles written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay, to explain and justify the need for the newly proposed United States Constitution.
The United States Constitution was written by the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in the summer of 1787 to replace the failing Articles of Confederation, America's first governing document. The Confederation Congress sent a copy of the new Constitution to each state at the end of September, 1787, for each state to debate and make its own vote for or against ratification. Within days of its arrival, the first criticisms of the document began to appear in newspapers.
In New York, one of the states whose ratification of the Constitution was deemed critical to its success because of its large population, a very strong anti-Constitution coalition arose. Articles published under pseudonyms such as Brutus, Cato and the Federal Farmer began to appear, by people such as George Clinton, Robert Yates and Melancton Smith. To counter these arguments, Alexander Hamilton masterminded a plan to write a series of articles to refute the arguments and provide solid reasons why the Constitution should be adopted.
The first of the articles, which was written by Hamilton, appeared on October 27, 1787. Hamilton recruited fellow Federalist John Jay to write more articles, but after writing only 4 articles, Jay became ill and James Madison was recruited to the effort. Hamilton and Madison wrote the remainder of the 85 articles with the exception of one more written by Jay. In all, Hamilton wrote 51 articles, Madison 26 and Jay 5, all of which were written using the pseudonym, Publius.
According to The Federalist No. 1, the purpose of the articles was to explain how the Constitution would benefit the individual American citizen; why the current Confederation was not working; and the benefits of each provision in the Constitution. For example, Federalist Nos. 6-9 explain the benefits of a federal union; Federalist Nos. 24-29 discuss the need for common defense; Federalist No. 45 discusses alleged dangers to the authority of the states from the federal government; and Federalist Nos. 52-56 discuss the proposed House of Representatives.
The articles were published from October, 1787, to August, 1788, in several New York papers. Some of the articles were printed elsewhere, but they were primarily read in New York. By March of 1788, the articles had become so popular that a bound edition of the first 36 articles was printed under the title of The Federalist. Eventually all the other articles were printed together as well.
Scholars debate how much the Federalist Papers actually influenced the New York ratification vote. The required 9 states for the Constitution to be established had already been achieved with New Hampshire's vote for ratification on June 21, 1788. Virginia was the tenth state to ratify on June 25. New York finally voted for ratification on July 26 in a 30-27 vote.
In later times, The Federalist Papers have come to be regarded as a unique window into the intentions of the Founders. They are studied by law students and Constitutional scholars and are often referred to in Supreme Court decisions, perhaps taking on an even greater role today than they held at the time they were written.
Thank you, revolutionary-war-and-beyond…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
On June 1, 1774, in response to the Boston Tea Party, the newly appointed governor, Lt.-Gen. Thomas Gage, shut down the towns’ harbor. All shipping and commerce came to standstill. allthingsliberty.com/2023/10…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
The latest book in our JAR series, Seized With the Temper of the Times: Identity and Rebellion in Pre-Revolutionary America by Abby Chandler has been released. We recently reached out to Abby to ask a few questions about her work. allthingsliberty.com/2023/10…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
Retiring Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Gen. Mark Milley is hitting the media circuit as he retires. How odd of him to warn about all the unconstitutional measures that Donald Trump threatened to enact that supposedly justified the illegal or unethical acts that his opponents in the military and intelligence community actually did.
Or to put it another way, Biden’s abject corruption, his chronic lying, his unapologetic racial condescension, his utter destruction of the border, and his dementia still would not justify Milley’s replacement to call his communist Chinese counterpart to warn him that Biden was cognitively inert and dangerous, or to order theater commanders to ignore Biden-routed orders and instead report directly to him.
Nor would Biden’s pathologies justify a dozen or so retired 4-stars to violate the Uniform Code of Military Justice by publicly blasting Biden a liar, a Mussolini, and to be gone the sooner the better.
Nor would Biden’s failed and dangerous presidency warrant a former Pentagon lawyer to publish a warning that he needed to be removed by a possible military coup.
Nor would Biden’s dangers to the republic justify 51 former “Intelligence authorities” to issue a lying affidavit to warp an upcoming presidential debate and election.
So Mark Milley ends as he begins—without a clue that he and others set precedents that if followed with future controversial presidents would soon destroy the republic.
Grouchy Historian retweeted
"Highly enlightening and at times disturbing" -- the New York Journal Of Books on Eagle Down nyjournalofbooks.com/book-re…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
Presenting LT Thomas Conway’s posthumous #navycross to Monsignor John Bevins during a Navy Award Ceremony at the Basilica of the Immaculate Conception in Waterbury, CT.
Grouchy Historian retweeted
On this day in 1963 we lost one of the greatest minds of the 20th century. CS Lewis
Grouchy Historian retweeted
I am deeply saddened to report that my mentor and inspiration, Sir Michael Howard, died this morning just after reaching his 97th birthday. Here Hew Strachan and I discuss Michael and his enormous contribution to the study of war. thebritishacademy.ac.uk/podc…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
Impeachment inquiry: Comparing the Donald Trump impeachment probe to Richard Nixon's - My piece for @CBSThisMorning cbsnews.com/news/donald-trum…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
Journalism possesses in itself the potentiality of becoming one of the most frightful monstrosities and delusions that have ever cursed mankind. This horrible transformation will occur at the exact instant at which journalists realize that they can become an aristocracy.
Grouchy Historian retweeted
There’s a shortage of perfect movies in this world. It would be a pity to damage this one.
Grouchy Historian retweeted
We're thrilled to be hosting a wargaming workshop today with @GirlSecurity_ to help empower young women in national security.
To learn more, check out this piece from Girl Security founder Lauren Bean Buitta: warontherocks.com/2019/06/em…
Grouchy Historian retweeted
The elder millennial compromise: Oxford comma BUT one space after a period.
Grouchy Historian retweeted
Video of the Day: In the cemetery of Colleville-sur-Mer, Normandy, where 9,387 fallen US fighters are buried, rows of white crosses are a strong reminder of the sacrifices made by 156,000 Allied soldiers who took part in the invasion & opened a Western front against the Nazis.
Grouchy Historian retweeted
We end the week with some awesome photos of SGT(R) Daniel Cowart receiving the Distinguished Service Cross during a retreat ceremony held on Wednesday. See the photo album here: flickr.com/photos/1st-cav-di… … #FirstTeam #LiveTheLegend @forthood @USArmy @FORSCOM

























