Replying to @DavidKButlerUoA
I can subitize groups of 5, then make groups of 5 with the leftovers… and there was one left.
1
165
Spoiler alert! Here’s the rest of my comment.
Paying attention to units (mph vs hr) also helps clarify things here. SMP 6, attention to precision, is especially important when decontextualizing and recontextualizing.
(Note: “she” refers to Jessica.)
1
9
Ready for the answer?
Spoiler alert!
…
It doesn’t really mean anything, because the variable J in this equation wasn’t precisely defined.
Here’s the first part of my comment to the person who posted this method: Upon further reflection…
1
8
Happy with my work, I submitted and refreshed the page. Some other teachers had posted their solutions. Some were variations of one of mine, but then I saw this (doing my best to maintain anonymity here):
1
11
Spoiler warning! Here was my idea…
Switching from Jessica’s speed to Janine’s speed wasn’t very interesting (it basically just shuffled some terms around). But then it occurred to me there was another unknown quantity here: time. Check out how that went:
1
13
Since it was in a middle school math group, I added some tie-ins to middle school math standards, too. Math builds!
1
14
A few other teachers had shared the answer, but you know I love problem-solving and connect everything back to teaching, so I explained my whole process, along with tie-ins to SMPs as they came up (see the pics if you’re curious - spoiler alert):
1
15
(12) After removing the pillars that the third charge would explode, and removing two more orange dots that were no longer needed (since the 3rd charge had blown up the last remaining pillars in its column), there were 2 charges and 4 orange dots remaining, and it was easy peasy!
1
46
(11) With those orange dots eliminated, there was now another orange spot that had to be included, as it was the only one left in its row. Charge number 3… ready to go! I used dashed lines to show how it would go through pillars already blown up by the first two charges.
1
41
Yes! The first charge took out not only the 2 pillars in its column, but also the only 2 pillars in its row. That eliminates the other orange dots in its row as possible places for the remaining charges. (The two X’d out orange dots in the pic, added just now for clarity.)
1
39
(8) Wait… This is the only orange dot in its column. The only place that will explode the pillars in that column. It has to be one of my five! Similarly, this other spot is the only orange dot in its row, so it has to be included to hit the two pillars in its row. Two down!
1
42
(7) How much more manageable? Can I just try all the combinations and see which work? 13 spaces choose 5 to place charges is… 1287 possibilities. Not fun to brute force. Scribble that idea out. There’s gotta be something to help me narrow it down. Look at the orange dots again.
1
52



















