
Reality-tested thoughts on healthy authority transfer dynamics. “Rule #1: you can only have one master.” Straight man. ⛓️ 49M
USA
Joined October 2013
- Tweets6.9K
- Following84
- Followers6.9K
- Likes23K
On knives and puzzle pieces.
I have a theory I call “knife theory”: that trust is built by trading ‘knives’ - a little personal information I share with you that you could hurt me with, and you don’t use it. Then you share a little personal information back that I could hurt you with, and I don’t grade who you are because of what you chose to hand me.
The more information we know about each other that we could hurt each other with and don’t - shared vulnerability - the more we trust each other with new vulnerabilities.
Over and over we trade these little bits of information that could ruin either of us, and the trade is only ever as safe as the last exchange. One lethal stab to either of us ends things, no matter how long we’ve been together.
Every knife is a risk for the person handing it over, and it’s also a job for the person receiving it: I have to notice you’re handing me a knife, handle it carefully, and show you I’m not going to use it. That takes my attention, and it should. That’s why knives build trust: something was actually at risk, and you got to watch me handle your knife with care and attention and keep it safe.
The thing is, knife theory has a major gap: not everything you share with me needs to be a knife I could hurt you with.
The other things we share with each other are puzzle pieces: tiny parts of the ‘big picture’ of who we are. A puzzle piece is something you share that isn’t meant to put anything at risk, and needs nothing back from me, because it’s just information: a piece of who you are.
Knives and puzzle pieces build different things. With knives, you find out whether I’m safe. With puzzle pieces, I find out who you are.
A dynamic needs both. You can’t submit consensually - fully informed - to someone you don’t know. And to keep my authority worth something, I have to know enough about your life to make good decisions for both of us. Puzzle pieces are how we get fully informed about who each other is, a little at a time, with nobody risking anything.
The problem is, sometimes we turn puzzle pieces into knives. How?
Think of the difference between knives and puzzle pieces in terms of energy.
Let’s say you see something cute, you think of me, and send me a picture of it. I’m under no obligation to reply to a random picture. I might say “cute” or I might say nothing or I might say something funny. My total energy cost to receive your energy and attention is nearly nothing. Maybe I even feel more energetic, because a girl I like sent me a cute thing.
Now, let’s say instead you send me that same cute picture and then apologize for wasting my time. Now I need to put my energy on your apology. I need to take my energy to correct you and reassure you and teach you how to send me things without apologizing for who you are, spending my energy on something I don’t really want to spend it on. Your cute picture now costs me energy.
Worse yet, “sorry if that wasted your time Master” asks me to decide whether it actually wasted my time. Now you’re at risk if I decide that yes it was a waste of my time, and because I have to make a decision about what receiving your thing meant to me, I now have a job. Your apology got added on to the puzzle piece, and turned it into a knife: one you didn’t mean to hand me, and one I didn’t ask for.
The same conversion of a puzzle piece to a knife happens if you add on an expectation of some kind of response from me. Receiving puzzle pieces from you is unlikely to be any kind of bother to me if you don’t expect any response from me, and you’re just sending me attention and energy and information about you. It’s only if you’re apprehensively, expectantly waiting for me to give you some kind of feedback, that it costs me, and turns receiving your energy into a job.
Not expecting a response isn’t the same as not getting one. When I answer a puzzle piece, it’s because I wanted to, not because you were waiting.
The same conversion of a puzzle piece to a knife also happens if you don’t expect any kind of response from me, and I add on a grade anyway. “Sending me this was a waste of my time, and you are someone who wastes my time” turns a piece of information transmission into a judgment of the act, and worse, a grade of who you are. All of that is me adding on something to your puzzle piece, turning it into a knife you didn’t think you were handing me.
Worst of all is if I let you send me a dozen puzzle pieces, a dozen bits of information, and THEN tell you how much I didn’t want any of them. Now your twelve cute things turn into my grade on who you are, cutting into you like twelve stabs all at once.
Here’s the key: what makes the information we share a knife or a puzzle piece isn’t just the information itself, the single act. It’s also the grade that one of us attaches to the information.
If the thing you’re sharing really is a knife, something that could hurt you if I use it against you, hand it to me as a knife. Tell me it matters to you, and that you’re nervous to show me. I’ll put my attention on the thing you’re sharing, and handle it with care, because that’s what a knife is for.
If it’s a puzzle piece, a piece of non-threatening information about you, don’t apologize for it, because that adds negative energy I didn’t ask for and don’t need. Just send the thing, without grading yourself, and don’t have any expectations of me.
My role in receiving puzzle pieces is the same: when you send me a puzzle piece, I don’t grade it, and I don’t grade you for sending it. And I certainly don’t save up a whole box full of grades to stab you with the twelfth time you send me a puzzle piece. If there’s something I’d rather not get from you, I say so the first time, as my preference, not as a grade on you.
For both of us, don’t expect puzzle pieces to do a knife’s job. A hundred cute pictures I receive well will tell you I don’t grade the small things, but they won’t tell you whether I’m safe with the big ones, because none of those big things were at risk.
Also, you can’t build trust by only one person sharing all their vulnerabilities. We both need to keep trading knives for trust to be formed.
Changing a puzzle piece into a knife risks hurting everyone.
Every dynamic needs both knives and puzzle pieces - shared vulnerability, and non-threatening information about each other - all sent and received properly.
2
179
“With great power comes great responsibility” - this expression is actually not accurate, and I’mma tell you why. (Sorry, Spider-Man fans.)
The expression “power exchange” is also not accurate, and I’ll explain that too. (Sorry, everyone else.)
First of all, what IS power? Power is capacity: what each of us can do. Our own power to do a thing, not power over a person.
Just because I can do a thing doesn’t mean it’s my responsibility. Taking on something I am capable of doing as my responsibility is separate from my capacity or ability to do the thing.
Control and authority are two different ways I can take on different kinds of responsibility over things I have the power to do.
What is control? Control is who is doing the deciding and putting in the work right now. Who is taking the action, and choosing how it’s done, in this moment. Who is giving the orders.
“With great control comes great responsibility” is true: if I have control over something, I am obligated to see it through, otherwise I lose control and it doesn’t get done.
What is authority? Authority is whose decision it is. Who is in charge. Whose decision breaks the tie, when you disagree. Who has been granted the right to command.
“With great authority comes great responsibility” is also true: it’s up to me to decide when it’s appropriate to use my authority, and to develop a vision for both of us, where I can use that authority to direct the greatest benefit. If I use my authority irresponsibly, I not only don’t get the thing done, I also risk harming you.
This is why “power exchange” is inaccurate. By these definitions, power is the one thing that isn’t ever exchanged: your power - your ability to do the thing - stays yours, and mine stays mine. What changes is who has control in a moment, and who has authority over that thing for as long as you grant that authority.
These words all matter because they impact what I want as a Master, and what you might get out of our dynamic.
If a submissive offered to let me pick out her outfit every day, for example, I’d turn it down. Picking her clothes doesn’t really do much for me. That’s more a service for her: giving my time and attention to her in return for a moment of control, which honestly isn’t a great trade for me as a Master. I have a lot of things that need my attention, a lot of my own interests, and all those little moments of control are moments I could be doing something else I want or need to do.
What I want - no, what I need, as a Master - is having the authority to decide things in parts of your life, while you keep doing the work. Control, I only want sometimes, when I feel like it.
Why do I want authority, not necessarily control? When you give me control over something, you’re asking me to do two things.
One, you’re asking me to do the deciding for you: what exactly you wear, what exactly you eat, what you do with your evening. That can feel like submission, because I’m the one choosing. But if you look at who that process is really benefitting, it’s actually more for you than for me. You get my attention, and I get a new job. I’m now working for you.
Two, when you give me control, you’re also adding on that I now carry an obligation, a responsibility, to get the thing done. If I’m picking your outfit every day, I have to know your plans, what’s in your closet, and the weather, and I have to be there every morning to do it whether I want to or not. Sometimes that’s exactly what a dominant wants. For me? That kind of control is just one more thing I have to manage, which is the last thing I need.
Authority works differently. If you grant me authority over part of your life, you’re still the one responsible for doing all the work. You still choose your clothes, do your exercises, make your food, manage your time, do your tasks. But the decision about anything I have authority over is mine whenever I want to use it. If I have authority over what you wear, I can tell you I prefer you in dresses instead of jeans when you go out, and from then on you wear dresses. If I have authority over your diet, I can give you nutritional guidelines you’re expected to follow, and you get it done. Once I’ve made a decision, that’s the final answer, and you follow through without me having to check on it, because - here’s the key - it’s YOUR responsibility to get the things done as I command, not mine.
I’m not required to use my authority. Most days I might not. My authority is mine either way, whether I choose to use that authority or not.
To keep my authority worth something, I have to know enough about that part of your life to make a good call, so you are also responsible for keeping me informed. And, just because you’re responsible for getting it done doesn’t mean I’m off the hook. If I choose to use my authority, it’s in our best interests for me to know you’re getting it done right. That’s why authority often comes with check-ins, where you report how you’ve successfully done the things. Those feedback reports don’t necessarily need my input. And when you stop reporting? That’s when I know I need to check in myself. With great authority comes great responsibility: when I use it, I am still responsible for knowing whether the things are actually getting done the way I want.
This is also how authority works when we’re apart. I can’t necessarily pick every bite you eat or what you wear every morning from my own house, but I can give you guidelines, and those hold whether I’m there or not. At that point, you can share your choice with me and get my approval if I feel like giving it, but the control remains yours. If I decide I don’t like something, I’ll overrule and make you change, and you’ll obey my authority because you granted it to me.
As a major bonus to you, if I have authority over a part of your life, then with time, as you get into the habit of submitting to my authority, you may start to feel and hear my presence with you even when I’m not physically there. You’ll be asking yourself what I would want, what I would command if I were there. You’re following my commands even without me giving them. You’ve got a Master around you all the time, even when I’m at work.
What do I get out of having authority over you? I retain my power to create the moments that matter to me, with or without you, and I also get to decide how you behave in those parts of your life that matter to me. Not control over every moment of your day, just control over the moments that matter to me. I can’t use my power for the moments that matter to me, while I’m obligated to micromanage someone else’s life. I’m busy living mine.
When I have authority, and taking control over you IS the moment that matters to me? My authority is what lets me make it happen.
When I have authority, and giving you a moment of control is the moment that matters to me? There are plenty of times I just want to lay back and give you control over something - even me. My authority stays intact, even when you’re in control - I can take back that control any time I want. Giving you control IS part of my authority.
What you get out of granting me authority is knowing there are parts of your life where you are fully known, and seen, and wanted, and most importantly - not alone. You also get to know that my decision is the answer, so you don’t have to carry the responsibility of deciding that area of your life anymore, for as long as I have that authority.
You also keep your own capacity, and get more use out of it. A lot of submissives are fully capable of doing a thing, and still don’t do it until someone tells them to. You have the skill, and you want to do it, and what’s missing is the decision to start. When I have authority over that part of your life, that decision can be mine. My authority doesn’t give you the capacity. You already had that. My authority is what gets your capacity used. In fact, I often use my authority to guide you to become more capable.
What I want as a Master is authority, ideally over as much of your life as you’re willing to grant me. Control? I use that when I want a moment with you.
What you might want as a submissive is to grant someone else authority over parts of your life that you no longer want to be responsible for alone. Sharing responsibility for your life means granting authority. You can still have control over your life, while not being the final authority over those parts.
What we get together? Transferring authority over parts of your life to me gives me more power, and gives you access to my power, so we can enjoy more moments that matter to both of us. No power is exchanged. Authority is transferred, and now we both have more of everything we both want, and less of what we each don’t want.
The more authority I have over you, the more our dynamic can grow, and we can grow together.
For many of you who crave giving up control, you might find that what you really wanted to let go of was never control, nor power, but actually authority.
Great news! There are a few men out there like me who love having authority, and also know how to use it responsibly, as we both work together to build our dynamic.
3
222
Master Greg retweeted
Replying to @thefourgregs
As a slave, feeling safe and accepted, I need to know my Master, the good and the bad. I need to know who he truly is, to understand him, so I can better serve him. But it goes deeper than that. I need this because I care for him, because I desire I know him as a person.
Jealousy is the fear of losing something you already have, to someone else.
If your anxiety about losing something you already have exists whether or not there’s anyone else to lose it to, then jealousy isn’t the real issue. Having someone else there doesn’t really change your anxiety, it just gives it a new target.
That doesn’t mean the jealousy you feel is fake. It means your anxiety was there first, and that pre-existing anxiety got assigned to a person instead of staying a generalized feeling.
Fear of losing something you already have is the real issue, which is great news - that means your anxiety is treated the same way regardless of who else is there: reassurance that you’re wanted.
Reassurance won’t cure anxiety, of course. Nothing a partner says permanently cures anxiety. Reassurance settles anxiety today, and then you might need the same reassurance again tomorrow.
And if you go quiet instead of asking for reassurance, someone has to notice you went quiet and reassure you anyway. That’s just something your person needs to know you need.
And importantly, that you need reassurance remains true no matter how many times you’ve been reassured, and that’s another thing the other person needs to know about you: just because you need the same reassurance again, doesn’t mean yesterday’s reassurance didn’t land. It did, and today’s anxiety needs reassurance again.
Needing the same thing repeated isn’t a flaw in how either of you is communicating, it’s just how anxiety works. It doesn’t mean you need bigger or better reassurance, or that the ‘treatment’ didn’t work. Daily doses of feeling wanted is a very normal human thing, in any relationship. Yours might come in the form of reassurance, and mine might come in the form of obedience, for instance.
Needing reassurance doesn’t take away your responsibility: bringing your thoughts to your partner instead of ignoring them, or silencing them.
Also, sometimes jealousy really is about someone else - especially if there is an act you can identify: an agreement that got broken, time you were supposed to get with someone that disappeared. Actually losing something you had is a real, different problem with a different fix than simply reassuring you everything is fine.
4
389
Master Greg retweeted
Mutual safety is such a gift.
There is something magical about allowing each other the space to change and grow while continuing to choose one another.
The container can change and both people get to participate in understanding what that change looks like.
Walking alongside one another.
🐾💫
There is a lot of talk about what subs need from Doms and Masters, and very little said about what we need from our subs.
We all know a sub needs to feel safe.
What I need as a Master is to feel safe with her too.
Safe to be who I am, and safe to want what I want.
Safe to tell her all of my interests, kinks, and fetishes, and even if she’s not into them, her rejection of my interests won’t come with a rejection of who I am.
Safe to give an instruction, and trust that even if she says no, her refusal to obey this time won’t be because she no longer respects me, and it won’t have any effect on my authority.
Safe to set down control when I want to, and know my authority is unchanged.
Safe to say I’m not into doing this thing with you right now, let’s do something else, and to trust that she’s not taking my changing desires as a rejection of who she is.
Safe to tell her I’m worried about her opinion of me. We all like to pretend other people’s opinions don’t matter, and, they do, even for those of us in charge.
I’ve talked many times before about how I crave frictionless dominance. Frictionless obedience, service, and pleasure from her. And one critical piece of that actually happening in a real dynamic, is for me to feel safe to be all of me, with her.
If I’m worried about sharing part of myself with her because I feel ashamed of it, or worried about how she might react, then I’m not operating frictionlessly myself. A frictionless dynamic means me telling her anyway, shame and fear included, and trusting that she will continue to like me and want me even if I tell her I want something she doesn’t.
None of that makes her responsible for my feelings. It just means she doesn’t think less of me for having them.
Feeling safe with her doesn’t mean she has to like or want everything I do, or that she can’t tell me when I’m wrong. It just means I am wholly accepted, and safe to say everything that is in my heart, because she genuinely wants to know all of me.
She wants to submit to me because she has chosen me. She feels safe with me as I change and grow and express different parts of myself, and I feel safe with her to be all of who I am.
There is a lot of talk about what subs need from Doms and Masters, and very little said about what we need from our subs.
We all know a sub needs to feel safe.
What I need as a Master is to feel safe with her too.
Safe to be who I am, and safe to want what I want.
Safe to tell her all of my interests, kinks, and fetishes, and even if she’s not into them, her rejection of my interests won’t come with a rejection of who I am.
Safe to give an instruction, and trust that even if she says no, her refusal to obey this time won’t be because she no longer respects me, and it won’t have any effect on my authority.
Safe to set down control when I want to, and know my authority is unchanged.
Safe to say I’m not into doing this thing with you right now, let’s do something else, and to trust that she’s not taking my changing desires as a rejection of who she is.
Safe to tell her I’m worried about her opinion of me. We all like to pretend other people’s opinions don’t matter, and, they do, even for those of us in charge.
I’ve talked many times before about how I crave frictionless dominance. Frictionless obedience, service, and pleasure from her. And one critical piece of that actually happening in a real dynamic, is for me to feel safe to be all of me, with her.
If I’m worried about sharing part of myself with her because I feel ashamed of it, or worried about how she might react, then I’m not operating frictionlessly myself. A frictionless dynamic means me telling her anyway, shame and fear included, and trusting that she will continue to like me and want me even if I tell her I want something she doesn’t.
None of that makes her responsible for my feelings. It just means she doesn’t think less of me for having them.
Feeling safe with her doesn’t mean she has to like or want everything I do, or that she can’t tell me when I’m wrong. It just means I am wholly accepted, and safe to say everything that is in my heart, because she genuinely wants to know all of me.
She wants to submit to me because she has chosen me. She feels safe with me as I change and grow and express different parts of myself, and I feel safe with her to be all of who I am.
As a slave, your role isn't to align with your Master's vision for you.
It's to decide for yourself if you choose his vision as your vision.
A dynamic only works when your visions are aligned.
Not by pressure, guilt, coersion, nor any force but your own free will choice.
Authority is granted, not given.
I enjoy authority, am good with authority, and responsible with authority when I have it.
Therefore I have the personal qualities of someone who uses authority, with or without you.
You can’t give me something I already have.
Your part then isn’t to ‘give’ me authority, it’s to recognize my existing traits. Not to take my word for it, but to watch what I do with the authority I already have.
You can, however, grant me authority over you, on top of everything else I already have authority over. And I in return can claim the authority you grant me.
The only authority that’s worth anything is authority you voluntarily grant me.
I could force someone to obey for a minute, but I can’t claim authority over them if they don’t want it.
Your boss can demand all he wants, but you choose to walk into work.
You can also choose not to walk into work, or leave a dynamic - that’s part of consent.
Volunteering authority over a specific part of yourself or your life, or all of it, is something YOU do, YOU grant.
Ideally you grant that authority before I ever ask for it. If anything, I can suggest you consider granting it, but I can never demand it.
You choosing to grant authority is how we both know it’s real, and that it’s what you want.
As a submissive or slave, you can’t imagine how someone would get off on having authority.
As a Master, I can’t imagine how anyone would get off on giving up authority.
Neither one of us really has to relate with how the other works, or wants, or why - we just have to like it.
Saying the hard things is hard, and, necessary.
I needed a word for trying to guess someone else’s interior, thoughts and feelings (their “interiority”), so I invented one for the book I’m (eventually) writing: interiorating.
None of us can accurately know anyone else’s inner world. This has been measured: when married couples guess each other’s thoughts and feelings, they score about a third on accuracy, at best.
In a dynamic, you can’t submit consensually - fully informed - to someone you don’t know. You’d just be submitting to the concept of them, not actual them.
And you can’t get fully informed by guessing what’s inside them.
Both of us play a role in fully informing each other about what’s going on inside us.
Your role is when you catch yourself guessing about what’s inside me, don’t guess, because you’ll mostly be wrong - ask.
My role is to say what’s inside me. When I keep quiet, all you have to go on is your inaccurate guess about me, and you can’t consent to an inaccurate guess. I NEED to tell you what I’m thinking and feeling, otherwise you’re not actually submitting to me.
There’s really no other path to genuine submission than for both of us to know each other, and then choose if we want to do this thing together.
Now, an important caveat. Humans suck at communicating when we don’t feel good.
I’ve found it’s really hard to stop myself inside a ‘weed-filled’ brain - upset, clogged with thoughts - and find the words to tell you I’m “still here” with you - especially during those moments when I’m uncertain if I’m still here - and then to ask you to wait until I can think clearly.
I’m getting better at recognizing when my brain isn’t thinking clearly, and stopping more words from coming out of my mouth until I get time to think - or ideally sleep - and clear the weeds. What I’d like to get better at is telling you when I’m stuck in the weeds - that I’m still here, with you, and will come back when I can think clearly.
Here’s the key: a dynamic is a commitment not just to BE with each other, but to KNOW each other.
A moment of uncertainty - even about us - is not an irreconcilable difference. And it’s not an excuse to stop communicating.
Apparently a lot of men just walk away during moments of uncertainty, or decide they don’t want the “added pressure” to continue building deeper connection by talking through the hard things.
Too bad. If you’re going to commit to a dynamic, you HAVE to talk through the hard things.
Taking a night to clear the weeds isn’t walking away. Ideally we all get better at communicating to our partners when we need time to think, and that time away doesn't mean we're leaving.
A moment of uncertainty - or a moment to think - is something to talk through, not something to abandon each other over.
1
7
493
You know you've got a good girl when she's happy, excited, and grateful you bought a new broom for her to clean your place with.
Shame creates cognitive dissonance, and we wear a ‘mask’ to try to resolve it. Here’s how that works:
Shame is a grade on you as a whole being: you are all-wrong (a term from the book I’m writing... eventually).
Your own history contains acts that you did that were right, so you can’t be all-wrong. If you feel like you’re all-wrong and know you’ve done right, that’s where the dissonance comes from.
(Guilt for a single wrong act doesn’t produce this contradiction, because the guilt is limited to that one act, not you as a whole person.)
I’ve learned we don’t heal shame by trying to contradict our self-grade of all-wrong with an equal measure of “I’m all-right” because that’s still a grade. And one grade can’t replace another.
There was a study done in 2009 on exactly this: people with low self-esteem who repeated “I’m a lovable person” to themselves felt worse afterward, and the ones who were told to think about ways it was true and ways it wasn’t felt better than the ones told to focus only on when it was true.
Because we KNOW we are partly ‘wrong’ and partly right, and that accurate self-knowledge is what actually makes us feel better about ourselves.
This is why what ‘works’ instead is grace. Not ‘grace’ as in ‘we are all flawed’ (also a grade), but a slightly different kind of grace: we merely exist, and are all part-right and part-wrong.
Now, for the mask. Since that all-wrong grade can’t be reconciled with your history of being right sometimes, it’s cheaper, instead of constantly handing other people our self-knowledge of part-right/part-wrong, to manage those other people by producing a ‘mask’ of someone who we think would be graded all-right that directly contradicts our internal grade of all-wrong.
The mask we ‘wear’ balances out the part of us who believes we are all-wrong, and that’s why identifying the mask can help you identify the shame.
If you understand what someone is trying to make you feel about them, what they want you to notice, that’s their ‘mask’ hiding whatever it is they feel ashamed of in themselves, that they don’t want you to know. We all do this somewhere.
Not everyone is safe enough to remove that mask around. Very few people are safe to reveal your shame to, and, they’re the ones we forge the strongest, longest lasting bonds with.
Because that mask we wear to hide our shame is representing an all-right grade, which also produces cognitive dissonance... and taking it off with someone we feel safe to be part-wrong and part-right with, is the only relief from all that extra mental processing, mask-making, and ego-defense.
A consequence or punishment is not the same as abuse, though from a vanilla perspective they can look the same because they're both... unpleasant, for the recipient.
What's the difference?
Abuse is NOT dependent on whether or not you agree you did the thing wrong, or whether you agree you earned the consequence. Taking the consequences you've agreed your dominant has authority over is part of the deal you make when you take on a dynamic and agree how it will be run. You can disagree with a specific consequence, and still get punished, and still be inside a healthy dynamic.
On the other side, a submissive can agree they've deserved every punishment and still be getting abused.
Abuse is using what he has over you to get something you didn't consent to, under conditions where you can't make it stop.
If he does something once that the two of you agreed he would not do, and you are still free to walk away from the dynamic, that's a mistake he made. You can choose to talk about it and fix it together, or walk away.
If he keeps doing things you never agreed to, and at the same time makes it harder and harder for you to walk away, that's abuse.
So, to know if something is abuse or consensual punishment, ask four questions:
a) Did you agree to the system of consequences itself, knowing that's what it was? Did you know what things you agreed to be punished for, what those punishments would look like, and whether or not your dominant has the authority to decide when you've earned one?
b) Is your dominant only operating within the lines you agreed to? Or is he inventing rules you supposedly broke after the fact to cover for his actions, or ignoring the hard limits you set?
c) Can you easily leave? Does leaving cost you more than just losing the relationship?
d) Are the punishments aimed at what you are? This is the one easiest to hide inside a dynamic: the question of your worth. "If you were a good submissive you'd do this" is a grade on who you are, based on how well you match your dominant's idea of that label. Withholding your worth until you do what he wants is abuse using a dynamic as an excuse.
If you're in a dynamic where punishment is a consequence, and you've agreed your dominant has the authority to decide when you get punished, you don't get to opt out of a punishment because you disagree that you earned it. Opting out isn't part of the deal. Leaving the deal - leaving the dynamic - is always part of the deal. Your ability to leave a dynamic is a basic requirement for it to be consensual.
A dynamic does not obligate you to agree to accept his behavior for anything he does outside the lines of what you've agreed to, nor are you agreeing to take his grades on who or what you are. Maintaining your boundaries doesn't make you a "bad submissive", it makes you a person with boundaries.
A dynamic that works focuses on your acts, today, and correcting them however you and your dominant agree they can be corrected - whether you like it or not.
Being seen and feeling seen are two different things.
My girl reminded me of that this morning, and she was right. Thousands of people can see you online. People all around you can see you in real life. Feeling seen happens with almost nobody.
Here’s how you tell the difference, because “feeling seen” isn’t actually just a feeling. It’s testable.
You feel seen when someone knows a part of you the same way you know it yourself. The test is whether they can reflect what they see back to you, and it sounds the same coming from them as it does coming from you.
Of course, it’s more than that, because that test - do they see me the way I see me - has two big loopholes.
The first loophole is that they could just parrot your words back at you and pass the test, and parroting isn’t knowing. The real version of “feeling seen” only happens when they say something about you that you never told them, in their own words, and you recognize it. Even better, they catch you being wrong about yourself and they’re right.
This is exactly why I LOVE IT when one of my girls tells me I’m wrong, especially about myself. It means she sees me, and knows me well enough to know when I’m wrong about myself. There’s (ironically) no better way to feel seen than to have someone correct you about you.
The second loophole is that if you want someone to know you badly enough, you might hear what you want to hear, not what they’re saying. Worse yet, you might even feed them the words you want to hear, instead of the words they actually said. Then you’re not running the test of whether or not you’re seen, you’re passing it for them. That’s why what they say can’t just be parroting you back, it has to be something you never handed them, or that conflicts with what you’re saying about yourself.
Where things get really interesting is moving from pursuing someone to knowing them. Psychology has studied this for forty years under a worse name, “self-verification”. What they found is that people who are dating want to be evaluated favorably, and people who are married want to be seen accurately, even when accurate is less flattering. Married people get more intimate with a spouse who sees them the way they see themselves. So if someone pursuing you makes you feel wanted but not seen, that’s why. Pursuit is evaluation. They’re showing you, and looking for, the most favorable version of both of you. Feeling seen comes later, when the evaluating stops.
There are two reasons feeling seen matters from my perspective, as a dominant. If a woman is ‘submitting’ to me - merely obeying - and I don’t feel seen, that’s evidence she’s not submitting to me, she’s ‘submitting’ to her own concept of submission. She might even be obedient all day, and I still feel like a stranger to her. Whether she knows me or not is only checkable from inside my head, and it’s only when I feel seen that I know it’s me she’s submitting to.
The second reason feeling seen accurately as a dominant matters is because if the only part of me she reflects back is the grade I give myself, she’s verifying a grade, not seeing me. If I present - either here online or in person - as oh-so-cool and she reflects back how oh-so-cool I am, she’s not really seeing me, and any ‘dominance’ I might feel isn’t real. It won’t feel real because it won’t feel like she knows me well enough to see past the self-grading I present, and see the real me. A woman who makes me feel seen knows what I do and what I want. (She doesn’t know what I am, because nobody does, including me. That’s one of many reasons it’s not useful to grade who we are.)
If she can’t call me on my bullshit, I’m not going to feel seen, and it’s not real.
When she knows what I do and what I want, AND she can correct me when I’m wrong about myself, AND she knows parts of me that I haven’t shared with her yet, then I feel seen.
When I feel seen, and she is also demonstrating behavior that shows she wants to do what I want, and she wants me to have what I want, and she calls me on my bullshit when I need it, then I know she’s submitting to actual me, the man, not just a concept.
On ego redirection (yes, I just made up that phrase):
Submission doesn’t quiet your mind by giving it a break. It focuses your mind because your attention redirects to him instead of to yourself, with your ego still fully intact.
You’ve surely seen a similar, but incorrect version of ‘submission’ all over the BDSM space: your brain is overloaded, you hand him control, and your brain finally gets to rest. That’s “ego depletion”, psychology’s name for the idea that self-control runs out like a battery. Yes, something like it does happen inside an intense S/m scene, where one small study found bottoms lose some executive function in subspace. But the rest of your waking week, “decision fatigue” isn’t really a thing. More importantly, the concept of your brain resting when you give someone else control relies on making the submissive (and their ego) smaller, which isn’t healthy or sustainable. Some women do want to be made smaller for an hour in a scene. Making you small all day every day by depleting your ego isn’t submission, it’s self-erasure.
Before I talk about what IS sustainable submission, think about what’s actually loud in your head. “Did I do enough? Did I mess that up? What’s wrong with me? This doesn’t fit what I’ve been taught about what women should want, so something must be wrong with me for wanting it. Every time I give up control to a man, it ends badly for me, so I must deserve it going badly. Why do I want him in control all the time, and not just in bed?” Every one of those is a grade on yourself. What’s grading? Here’s how you tell a grade from everything else: when the voice inside your head gives you a conclusion about what you are, that’s a grade. When it describes specifically what you did or what you want to do, that’s just information.
The problem is, if you just redirect your attention at a dominant to get away from that self-grading voice in your head, you haven’t actually stopped it. You’ve stopped listening to it. It’s still screaming obscenities at you from inside your own head, and the first time he corrects you on something you don’t like to hear, or the first time you catch yourself making a mistake and feel embarrassed, or the first time you let yourself want his control outside the bedroom, or the first time someone else asks you if you really want this life and why, that voice will be right there waiting with yet another grade on who you are.
Trying to get away from your self-grading by putting your ego in a dominant’s hands is how you end up spending years serving a man in a dynamic built around making you smaller, and never once feeling settled. Or it’s how you end up ‘submitting’ to men in bed, and still grading yourself for wanting more.
So the order of how you get to submission matters. First step, stop grading the part of you that wants this. Your ego doesn’t just grade you as being great, it also grades you as being awful. All that grading has to stop first, before you can submit yourself to him. You want to belong to him. Maybe you need it. Maybe you need it all day, not just in the bedroom where so many people want to limit submission to sexy play time. None of your wants and needs can be graded because they’re just your wants and needs, so there’s nothing to defend, and nothing to prove. Information about what you want and what you need, regardless of what anyone else - including that voice in your head - says. If this first step - to stop grading yourself - sounds like plain self-acceptance with nothing kinky about it, it is. You don’t need a dominant to stop grading yourself.
The second step, once you stop grading yourself, is what makes directing your attention at him - giving him what he wants - submission. Stopping that grading voice is not the result of submission. It’s what makes submission possible.
Now your attention is free to redirect from inside your own head - where you’ve been frustrated that you want this, and resisting it - to him, and your attention can stay on him from then on, because nothing is pulling it back trying to grade you. You’re just... doing what you want, and need, and putting your attention - and your effort, and your thinking - on him. Learning what he wants, and giving it to him, because that’s what you need to do, for you.
That’s ego redirection: it’s what your attention does all by itself, when your inner critic has nothing left to say about you, and you also want - need - to serve him. It’s not making you or your ego smaller, it’s accepting you for who and what you are, and directing your attention onto someone else, instead of yourself (or listening to all those other voices telling you what you want is wrong).
Coming to terms with who you are, and then giving your attention to your dominant, it isn’t a way to hide from the critic in your head. It’s also - and this is critical - not a way to give the job of your critic to him. A dominant who takes over the job of judging you is still grading you, just from the outside. Nothing goes quiet, your critical voice just goes to someone else. You traded a judge you carry around in your head for a judge in another person. Giving the job of grading you to someone else isn’t better.
A man who actually helps you quiet the critic in your head does a different job entirely: he specifically corrects only what you did, and he never says a word about what you are. A correction on an act ends, because you can change the act, and the correction is over. A grade on who you are never ends, regardless of whether it’s you grading yourself, or him grading you.
Dominance is correcting your acts, not grading who you are.
There’s also a real danger in giving someone else the power to tell you what’s right and wrong. You’ve handed him the same judgment you’d need to notice when something has gone wrong with him. Your inner critic and the alarm that goes off when he’s the one doing something wrong are not the same thing. Yes, he gets your obedience, but he doesn’t get to take over your perception of right and wrong. You still need to be able to decide for yourself when he’s gone too far, or isn’t healthy for you.
That’s his half: correct the act, leave your ego alone. Your half is the two steps: stop grading yourself, then put your attention on him. How much of your life that covers is a separate question.
Whether submitting to him belongs only in the bedroom for you, or is something you need all the time, that’s up to you.
Either way, your ego remains intact. You want what you want. You need his control. You still know right from wrong. You don’t let anyone, including yourself, tell you that wanting his control is wrong. And, your attention - your effort, your decisions - go to him, and onto what he wants.
Submission isn’t making your ego smaller. It’s stopping your own self-grading, then directing your attention to what he wants, because that’s what you need.
Master Greg retweeted
He didn't teach me to be submissive.
He recognized something in me that I'd barely begun to understand myself.
And with patience, confidence, and just the right amount of authority, He helped me discover a part of myself I'd been waiting to embrace.
A ‘rule’ is something he tells you to do, that he can see whether or not you did it.
For example, “answer when I phone you” could be a rule. If you don’t pick up, he obviously knows every time. Then you two can talk about why, right from the first time it doesn’t get done.
A ‘commitment’ is something only you know whether you did it, and he has no way to prove it.
A ritual you do when he’s not around - let’s say, kneeling by his bed before you make it in the morning - is a commitment. If you skip it, he only finds out if you tell him.
He can’t ‘make’ you follow either rules or commitments. You’re the only one who can make yourself do anything. The difference is who knows when you don’t do it, and what if any consequences you both agree to if it doesn’t get done.
Where a Dom gets this wrong is trying to make a rule out of something he can’t prove got done. If he has no way to know whether you did it, the most he can do is ask you to commit to it.
Keeping your word on a commitment is on you. You could theoretically just lie and say you did it, and he’d have no way of knowing. Just as bad, if you do confess and if he gets upset at you for confessing, he’s teaching you to stop telling him.
A missed commitment isn’t something he corrects, because he can’t prove whether you did it or not. Getting upset about it, or worse yet punishing it, doesn’t help you win next time. Far better to have a conversation about what got in the way, and whether you still want to commit to it, or make the task smaller.
If you feel guilty about missing a commitment and want it settled, you could ask for a way to make it right. That settles guilt too, and unlike a punishment, it helps you do better next time.
If it matters enough that he needs to know it’s done, he can turn a commitment into a rule by making it something he can see, like “send me a photo when it’s done.” That way you’re held accountable by more than your own word.
If it doesn’t matter enough to get proof every time it’s done, there’s no sense making a rule about it.
A Dom’s work is to let go of trying to control you in ways he can’t. Your work is to make sure you don’t promise things you can’t follow through on.
Your ‘reward’ as a submissive isn’t praise, even if you love it.
Praise is a little like apology. It’s a separate act that takes you away from the moment.
Your real reward is your dominant’s excitement, in the moment. That’s how you know you’re doing it right, and connecting.
The reason I don’t want to give up control is a little like when you go on vacation from work and then come back to a pile. I'd rather 'rest' by having total control.
The thing is, a sub who does want to give up control has the same problem. If you set down control, you need to catch up after, just like I would have to.
It’s part of my responsibility to contribute some of my other daily leadership skills to keeping my girls from falling behind in the rest of their lives.
This is where a lot of Doms get it wrong - they want you to put down all your work and then deal with being behind on your own.
You can’t just take someone’s control away and then expect them to rebuild it all on their own without some kind of support behind them.
Aftercare is for a scene. A dynamic needs more than that.
The more involved your dynamic is, the more you need to care for each other, and provide each other interdependent support.
Far better to have so much support around you that during those times you set down control, you don’t need a lot of ‘aftercare’, because you’re surrounded by care all the time.
4
396
I think Doms and subs encounter similar pressure throughout our week, and we each want a different escape from it, and that’s part of what both we get from doing D/s together.
A sub wants to give up control and stop fighting.
A Dom wants to have control, over both of them - with none of the bullshit of fighting - and win without trying.
There isn’t really a ‘loser’ since there isn't really a fight, and both people are getting what they want from the transfer of control.




