By the same logic, the Germans and other progressives pushing for women's ordination, gay marriage, etc. have "weaponized" the Novus Ordo. So that rite should be entirely suppressed by the same logic, right?
Right?
Replying to @RaymondArroyo @ChristineNiles1
Because yall weaponized the Holy Missal as an act of disobedience and defiance. Its a shame because I enjoyed the Tridentine Mass. I think, when folks can get it together, things might change
Pay attention to which "trad" Catholic podcasters and commentators tried to tell you Leo wouldn't be the Francis papacy redux and how they've spent the past year and a half trying to convince you days like today wouldn't happen.
Food for thought, especially when it comes to where you choose to spend your money.
I'm not the only one who's noticed we're no longer talking about "two forms of the Roman rite." We're now talking about the "rite of Vatican 2." That language shift tells you everything you need to know about where this is going.
Your liturgical patrimony should not be a plaything for Rome to hand out or take away based on your behavior, or whatever the current guy in charge thinks on a given day. But thanks to the top-down, pope-centric Church we've had since at least Vatican 1, this is how it is now.
And we wonder why the Orthodox are so reluctant to seek reconciliation with a Rome that acts like this.
I'm convinced at this point that Francis's only mistake was being so openly against the trappings of his office. Had he dressed traditionally and publicly prayed the Our Father in Latin every week, yet done the exact same things, he'd have met almost zero resistance from the "conservative" Catholic crowd who spent his pontificate skewering him.
Leo seems to have learned that lesson. The "conservative Catholics", sadly, appear to have not.
Meanwhile, trads on the ground, even those who are the "good trads" who "accept Vatican 2" and do everything else they're "supposed" to do (unlike those icky SSPX people) are suffering, and their father is telling them "Sorry. Not my problem. Maybe in 20 years a pope will be ready to deal with this, but I'm not, so them's the breaks."
If "muh this is the way the hierarchical Church is supposed to work", then what's the point?
This desperate "He said 'not right now', not 'never', so something may happen to restore the TLM in the future" wish casting needs to stop. We have enough evidence by now based on Leo's episcopal appointments and other actions to demonstrate he has zero intention of doing anything other than continuing the Francis project; he just happens to pray in Latin occasionally and dress more traditionally than his predecessor.
It does no good at all to string the faithful along otherwise offering them false hope. We need to be realists here and acknowledge what we're dealing with.
Catholics attached to the Traditional rites of the Latin Church will continue to be second-class citizens of the Church.
But notice a very important detail left out by the Vatican transcript: right at the start of answering if the document will be changed, the pope says, “No, not right now.” And then he continues with, “Traditionis Custodes is…” etc
The detail is explained in our post: rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/20…
Spare me your lectures on humility while parish after parish abuses the rubrics of the Novus Ordo with zero consequences. Just stop it.
Replying to @CatholicSat
Good. Most of the so called traditional groups must understand the importance of obedience and humility. If you think that attending a Latin Mass makes you a perfect Catholic and gives you a free pass to be arrogant and aggressive then the Latin Mass is harming your soul.
Oh, shut up.
Replying to @YourAuntAmerica @MLJHaynes
How do you determine that it is abusive and unjust?
If you don't trust the authority of a Pope, then you don't trust the successor of Peter and you will always be trying to find defects on him in order to justify attacks on him and his ministry and even put his faith in doubt.
1
11
443
Called it.
Everyone who criticized me for calling Leo "Francis 2.0", you can start your apology tour now.
BREAKING: Pope Leo comments on Latin Mass restrictions & Traditionis Custodes ––– “we will continue to follow it”
Questioned on the papal plane about changing TC, Leo replied:
“Traditionis Custodes was a decision by Pope Francis, and we will continue to follow it.
Traditionis Custodes includes the possibility of granting a dispensation or permitting the celebration of Mass according to the Vetus Ordo.
And so, once again, for the unity of the Church, the overwhelming majority of Catholics worldwide celebrate the Vatican II Rite, that of Paul VI, and we will continue to do so.
There is a path available for those who wish to request a dispensation.”
Adding variations to Koji Kondo's original score based on time of day and location (i.e., altered arrangements of the Hyrule Theme for places like Zora Fountain when in the OG it was the same vanilla version that played in Hyrule Field) a la the Xenoblade series is the icing on the cake of this fantastic remake.
Because the CGI in the "George Approved Versions (TM)" looks woefully dated and low res due to it being made in the mid 90s and thus capped, IIRC, at 2k resolution tops (if that), whereas the practical effects that were created in camera and actually exist on the film itself can be scanned in 8k and higher due to the inherent high resolution nature of film.
Additionally, every single time the GAVs have been released since 1997, there's been some sort of screw up in the mastering. The 2004 DVDs were notorious for this; the audio mix during the final battle in the original film completely dropped the score entirely as the X-wings descended toward the Death Star, Princess Leia's ship at the beginning of the OG had an obvious blue tint to it due to improper color timing, Darth Vader's lightsaber was pink in Empire, and so on and so forth. So just stop.
As a music teacher, it warms my heart to see the remake of this game *finally* have a proper five-line staff with treble clef for its music notation (the original used a four-line staff). The notes are written where they actually should be on the staff (e.g., the Y button, which sounds as the pitch B, is written where B should be on the staff). And Link's fingers move to the correct fingerings for each pitch he plays.
So much love and attention to detail went into this game. I just wish the internet would be happy with it rather than trying to tear it down for its perceived inadequacies.
Before we commence with the pearl clutching and fainting couches, by last net count I believe the SSPX has actually gained priests among its ranks since July. This hardly seems a "devastating indictment" to me.
The shocking departure of a former European SSPX district superior, just months after the Society’s schismatic episcopal consecrations, looks like a devastating indictment of the direction it has taken. But it is where he has chosen to go that makes this development truly extraordinary...and raises some profoundly uncomfortable questions for the SSPX leadership.
Fr Patrick Duverger, formerly the SSPX district superior for Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg, has left the Society and been welcomed into a traditional Latin Mass community served by the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter (FSSP), under the authority of the local diocesan bishop. His successor, Michel Poinsinet de Sivry, was among the four men consecrated bishops by the SSPX in July, without the authorisation of Pope Leo XIV.
Consider the historical irony. In 1988, Archbishop Lefebvre's illicit episcopal consecrations precipitated the departure of priests who founded the FSSP precisely because they believed that fidelity to the traditional liturgy could not justify separation from Rome. Thirty-eight years later, following another set of episcopal consecrations, a former SSPX district superior has found a home in the very Fraternity born of that original rupture. We do not yet know whether the July consecrations prompted Duverger's decision, and it would be premature to suggest an exodus. But his departure follows that of another former European district superior, Fr Firmin Udressy, who left in 2024 after more than twenty years of priestly service. Udressy's own explanation was revealing: he had come to desire a priesthood exercised in genuine communion with the Church's hierarchy and the universal Church.
Let's be clear, this is not a dispute between those who love tradition and those who despise it, these are priests formed by the SSPX, deeply attached to the Catholic inheritance, who have nevertheless chosen to exercise their priesthood within the Church's recognised structures. Surely therein lies the uncomfortable ecclesiological question the SSPX cannot indefinitely evade: at what point does an extraordinary response to a crisis become a permanent alternative to the Church's own authority?
Catholic tradition is not a possession to be defended against the Church, nor is communion with Peter some optional administrative arrangement that can be suspended until Rome becomes sufficiently agreeable. Apostolic tradition and apostolic communion belong together.
There are legitimate grievances about the treatment of traditional Catholics, and Rome must take them seriously. But the failures of ecclesiastical authority cannot become a justification for establishing a parallel ecclesial existence.
The tragedy would be for a movement founded to preserve Catholic tradition to lose sight of something essential to that tradition: the Church is not merely where the ancient liturgy is celebrated, but where the Catholic faith is professed cum Petro et sub Petro — with Peter and under Peter.
1
10
316
This is an *extremely* dishonest framing considering the vast majority of those who left the SSPX were the founding members of the FSSP in (wait for it) 1988.
Come on now.
This quoted post is unavailable.
16
370
No, we’re not playing this game any longer. We’re not doing the thing where you get to accuse people who criticize Israel as “Jew haters”, because you people have cried wolf on this for so long that the term is meaningless.
If Israel wants to go after Iran, they’re welcome to do so on their own without the U.S, thank you very much.
Replying to @FeserEdward
Well he is right because most of them (which a handful of misguilded exceptions) are Jew hating psycho...Massie and MTG...all Jew hating trash.....and conspiracy nutters.......they will burn down America just to hate Jews...This is known bro...

















