Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup) header
Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup) profile picture

Nonprofit lead for @BetterDotGiving. Edtech/AI enthusiast and Edtech/AI sceptic! Love cycling. Creator of https://teapawt.org/t.co/iPWoada2d4 Avid user of https://teapawt.org/t.co/FSIGq6gAgR

Bishop's Stortford
Joined March 2009
Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)Photo by Tim Stirrup (@timstirrup)
If you are serious about better mathematics education - be it in a traditional classroom or supported by tech, then ignoring the QAMA really means you are just happy with mediocrity. Sorry. Take a look and if you think they are not worth the time or effort - PLEASE say why. This is one of those times when silence means complicity with the poor substitute for thought that calculators have generally become.
Desirable Difficulties - as discussed by UCLA - Hear from the Bjorks on @mrbartonmaths podcast at 1:06 how the QAMA contributes to thinking. podcast.mrbartonmaths.com/ro… The result of their thinking? See more recommendations at qama.world
2
6
1,229
The QAMA is seen as useful by so many different people. Learning scientists even! The world’s first ‘ai-enabled’ calculator I wrote in 2018. Do you agree? medium.com/@timstirrup/the-w…
Desirable Difficulties - as discussed by UCLA - Hear from the Bjorks on @mrbartonmaths podcast at 1:06 how the QAMA contributes to thinking. podcast.mrbartonmaths.com/ro… The result of their thinking? See more recommendations at qama.world
93
Tim Stirrup retweeted
0.1 + 0.2 in Python gives 0.30000000000000004. Excel has the same habit. Microsoft's own help page shows 43.1 − 43.2 + 1 coming out as 0.8999… when you format it to 15 places. Chapter 2 of the video explains why. youtu.be/3rrT4OOihy8
2
2
33
Tim Stirrup retweeted
But where are we headed? This is my attempt to model the future (AI assisted of course)
🤖 Made with AI
1
2
2
34
Couture-d’Argenson, un village où la #solidarité est bien réelle 💛 Des jeunes réfugiés de 16-17 ans accueillis auprès de personnes âgées en maison de retraite : de super résultats. Et des bénévoles qui conduisent les habitants à leurs rendez-vous quand taxi et voiture sont impossibles. gmcouturois.fr/transport Couture-d’Argenson: a village where solidarity is real 💛 Young refugees aged 16-17 are placed alongside elderly residents in a care home, with great results. And local volunteers drive people to appointments when taxis and cars aren’t an option.
1
1
126
Tim Stirrup retweeted
Type this into your phone's calculator. 10^100 + 1 − 10^100 The answer is 1. Tim's iPhone says 0. Google's calculator says 1. Why do calculators get easy sums wrong? We made a 19-minute video about it. 🧵
1
2
2
121
Back in 2012, I started a free school application for a school enabled by tech - with a personalised curriculum delivered by tech and opportunities for other activities in the afternoon. So, the various tech enabled schools have always been of interest to me, and Alpha currently obviously so. I even applied to join them! But failed miserably, probably when I started arguing with the AI interviewer about why the need to have Learning science qualifications was negated by years of experience in using learning science concepts. C'mon, even my first teaching experience in the 1980s was built on distributed practice, spaced and personalised learning! But I have long been critical of edtech as well. My bios have always said edtech enthusiast and edtech sceptic. I thought I could help Alpha move forwards. Building on things I have experienced and written about for the last 20 years. That's why I wanted to join, and I hope that's why those on the video recently released by Alpha joined (ok, the salary probably did help as well!) So, It is good to see such as @PepsMccrea and @profbeckyallen onboard. @miss_mcinerney as well. I was VERY pleased to hear Becky railing against multiple choice. I find it incredible that when I have challenged such, based on 30 years of NOT supporting MCQ and on the importance of quick, appropriate feedback, I was blocked. I don't imagine she will be blocked. and that will be to the benefit of whatever Alpha produces. I do worry about the lack of subject specialists in the classroom and the apparent 'getting the academics out of the way, as children hate to learn' emphasis from some. Where do the students get input from people who have a real love of a subject for that subjects sake. I believe that maths for example, does not need to be dressed up in 'fun' as the maths itself is enjoyable, and that 'fun' can detract from that. And yes, success is an important art of that enjoyment, but so is struggle and overcoming it. Where is that "Aha, I got it" moment, or that amazement on some aspect of study, of reading a new book or author coming from? Where is the academic creativity? And where is the communication? Being able to communicate well about what you are doing, what you are learning. I hope also that, as the geographic context is different, that aspects of 'Liberating Learning' are not the hidden subplot that is not so apparent in the UK. I eagerly wait to see whether (like in Timbles, created 30 years ago on paper) the 'x' as a sign for multiplication disappears, or whether a calculator that does not create 'cognitive stunting' is used (QAMA would only support what is being done, but any approach I have made is met with, well, nothing! Take a look at who has written appreciatively about it), and while I absolutely agree that DI is easily transferred to tech, I wonder why Engelmann's appreciation and support for alternative approaches is apparently ignored in what is created. So, I look forward to seeing how Alpha works out and how it transfers to 'normal' contexts. And it's great to see people getting involved who can make a difference. If they railed against tech previously, it was probably because it was rubbish tech! I think I first wrote about 'Junk food, Junk e-learning' in 2006! (edited to add - watch the alpha school video they just produced, far less of the 'marketing' content that earlier videos suffered from. Even the old 'interviews')
2
1
2
3
660
As always on this subject - Donald right on the mark. My question about motivation is about enjoyment. Are ‘academics’ just something to just be ‘got out of the way’ before doing something more enjoyable? IMO subject teachers that are still able to motivate through an enjoyment of the subject they are teaching/guiding are important. That can motivate you to read some book not because you’ll get XP or be allowed to run around in the afternoon, but because the experience of reading it through is enjoyable.
AI Tutors: Do we still need teachers? A look at the research and models that are emerging, including predecessors, Alpha Schools @Alphaschool and costs. donaldclarkplanb.blogspot.co…
1
144
I’ve always been intrigued by the idea of schools enabled by technology. I wrote this in 2020 about something I did in 2012, which was actually start the ‘Free School’ application to put it into practice. One difference from current Greek letter of the year is that expert teachers were core to the process. medium.com/@timstirrup/a-sch…
144
The EES data really is messed up atm! Here's my 'actual' days used and available against what the EES service thinks! I mean, I am happy to have 90 days back, but much like having an incorrect £10k dropped into my bank account, it will probably be rectified soon and if I travel wrongly... there could be trouble! Lesson is to keep track. @SimonCalder
95
Was it only me who read ‘Liberating Learning’ 17 years ago and got worried? Is it only me who sees parallels today? Especially given the recent increase in school vouchers in the USA and how they’ll be used to support watered down versions of very expensive alternatives? medium.com/@timstirrup/liber…
98
This is an excellent summary and lots of good advice. I don't know if you are aware of Timble.com that takes multiplication further than the MTC - and useful for adults (even teachers, dare I say that...) let alone secondary practice! Give the free daily challenges a go... But crucially, for schools it also allows users to write or record their reflections and have feedback about how they communicate mathematically. It then supports teachers as well in providing a summary of their class personal reflections for class discussion. Computer supported education is so often a solitary affair, when talk and communication is so important. The MTC gets the speed aspect covered (for good or bad) and TTRS does that job admirably. Post y4, the maths itself can be the discussion and motivation.
tommanners.substack.com/p/th… Given the recent comments by an MP against the use of apps by children in education, I wanted to share the summary of research I'd done on how to teach timestables and division along with how to use apps such as TTRS effectively. Enjoy :)
73
Tim Stirrup retweeted
22 days in Schengen, and the EU border system said Paula Pugh had overstayed. The Telegraph reports EES missed one of her exits. Track90 Pro lets you keep an entry photo and an exit photo for each visit, plus a PDF of your trips. track90.co.uk #EES #Schengen
1
1
30
Re. Walliams claim that he hadn’t broken any laws. There were even people a year after Savile died saying “well he was never convicted in a court of law, they are only allegations”.
1
118
1/ New RCT from Google DeepMind & Eedi: 1,179 pupils, 10 UK secondary schools, 10 weeks. When pupils got a maths question wrong, they got standard hints and videos, an expert human tutor, or AI tutoring (Gemini) supervised by an expert.
5
4
311
My opinion, and it is only an opinion! AI services that rely on multiple choice, a format around 100 years old, will never be as good as tools built on more up-to-date methods. Refer back to my Tesla comparisons elsewhere!
1
1
27