Tristan retweeted
George Lucas, December 29, 1975, from a transcript of a private conversation with Alan Dean Foster:
“Then someday I want to do the backstory of Kenobi as a young man—a story of the Jedi and how the Emperor eventually takes over and turns the whole thing from a Republic into an Empire, and tricks all the Jedi and kills them.”
Tristan retweeted
It's wild how when people don't know something, instead of learning about it they'll just make up whatever they want the truth to be and then go around confidently telling people these ideas that they've just invented as though they're facts. People doing this is about 99% of the discussion about Star Wars on social media. Imagine how nice it would be if the people who don't know anything about a topic had the self awareness to just excuse themselves from the conversation
Tristan retweeted
The Ronto blocking the camera is GOOD
Greedo shooting first is GOOD
Jedi Rocks is GOOD
Vader screaming "Noooo" is GOOD
What else do I have to say?
Tristan retweeted
It's anti-art to respect artists' wishes now, apparently. Whenever I read people talking about SW online, I'm always thinking that maybe they're just saying the most ridiculous things possible to get engagement and I shouldn't respond and give them what they want, but usually if you look you'll find that, no, they're not faking it, they're actually that stupid
Tristan retweeted
Patrick Willems not only doesn't understand the visual language of Star Wars, he's not even able to accurately describe simple things you see onscreen like the types of camera moves Lucas does. In my video from seven years ago, it took me all of a minute to point out thing after thing that Willems says about SW that just aren't even true. What he did was figure out that if he threw in a few technical terms, people that weren't any more interested than he is in educating themselves would be impressed and just repeat what he said like he's some sort of authority on the subject
Patrick Willems covered "The Storytelling Language Of STAR WARS" for his channel a ways back, and pointed out that in the 1977 film, Lucas and Taylor rely heavily on traditional locked-down wide and medium shots with minimal camera movement. So when Lucas adds swooping camera shots for his Special Edition, it feels disjointed and out of place. It clashes with A NEW HOPE's already established visual language.
Tristan retweeted
Kevin Feige says he first approached Robert Downey Jr’s agent at the ‘Ant Man 3’ premiere about returning as Doctor Doom with a cryptic message:
“We have an idea. It’s time"
Had to repost this because it is good information on HDR (which all major modern productions are using) and SDR that most people are ignorant of
I'm pretty sure I figured out the issue with the Harry Potter scene's bad color. TLDR: the HDR to SDR tonemap is incorrect, so the gamma is wrong. Here is the scene with the correct gamma. (No grading changes were made at all. Just a technical transform).
Ok, now for the long description: When you make a show in HDR, you need to properly tonemap the final grade to SDR in order to watch on an SDR device, or to share clips on social media (because most social media sites don't handle HDR well, or at all).
Tonemapping is when you take a high dynamic range video source, and remap the color and luma values to fit within a standard dynamic range container. You're essentially "translating" a large format into a lesser format.
HDR in cinema/streaming typically has a gamut of Rec.2020 and a gamma (transfer function) of ST.2084. This needs needs to be converted down to Rec.709 Gamma 2.4.
The Rec.2020 gamut got converted to Rec.709 just fine, which is why the hues look correct in the original clip. But somebody forgot to do the other half of the conversion, which would be to take the ST.2084 transfer function and convert it down to Gamma 2.4. This explains why the contrast looks completely wrong in the original clip. Here's what it looks like when you tonemap the gamma.
NOTE: There are multiple ways to tonemap an image. Some ways handle high brightness and high saturation values better than others, and give you tools to dynamically adjust those values (this is what Dolby Vision is, in case you didn't know). The tonemap method I used for this demonstration is just a simple global one though, so the saturated values of the lamps would probably look better using a more robust/dynamic method.
1
1
119
Tristan retweeted
I'm pretty sure I figured out the issue with the Harry Potter scene's bad color. TLDR: the HDR to SDR tonemap is incorrect, so the gamma is wrong. Here is the scene with the correct gamma. (No grading changes were made at all. Just a technical transform).
Ok, now for the long description: When you make a show in HDR, you need to properly tonemap the final grade to SDR in order to watch on an SDR device, or to share clips on social media (because most social media sites don't handle HDR well, or at all).
Tonemapping is when you take a high dynamic range video source, and remap the color and luma values to fit within a standard dynamic range container. You're essentially "translating" a large format into a lesser format.
HDR in cinema/streaming typically has a gamut of Rec.2020 and a gamma (transfer function) of ST.2084. This needs needs to be converted down to Rec.709 Gamma 2.4.
The Rec.2020 gamut got converted to Rec.709 just fine, which is why the hues look correct in the original clip. But somebody forgot to do the other half of the conversion, which would be to take the ST.2084 transfer function and convert it down to Gamma 2.4. This explains why the contrast looks completely wrong in the original clip. Here's what it looks like when you tonemap the gamma.
NOTE: There are multiple ways to tonemap an image. Some ways handle high brightness and high saturation values better than others, and give you tools to dynamically adjust those values (this is what Dolby Vision is, in case you didn't know). The tonemap method I used for this demonstration is just a simple global one though, so the saturated values of the lamps would probably look better using a more robust/dynamic method.
Tristan retweeted
RUMOR: Jonathan Majors’ legal troubles derailed Marvel’s plan to cast Robert Downey Jr as Doctor Doom in Avengers Secret Wars 😳😳😳
I completely believe this simply because Kang already wasn’t working how they wanted him to (most people didn’t care about the character) and the Secret Wars they’re adapting is a Doom story anyway
Kevin Feige says the plan was using Kang as a decoy for Doctor Doom in ‘AVENGERS 5:’
"It probably would still have been called ‘The Kang Dynasty’, but it would have been a set-up for Doom, midway through that movie."
(Via: @empiremagazine)
1
3
92
Tristan retweeted
The Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time remake is the best selling physical game in the US for the whole of 2026 after its first week!
- First game to surpass 1M physical units at launch week in the US since The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom in 2023
via Mat Piscatella/ Circana
Tristan retweeted
People keep telling us to take the original Star Wars seriously as a film, instead of just viewing it as part of a consumer franchise, but I'm not sure I've ever seen them take their own advice.
For example:
George Lucas starts a shot with two droids having a petty squabble in the sand; then he cranes up to an expansive view of starships ascending into space from a city in the desert. This is obviously a more interesting and artistically deliberate way to introduce a location representing the threshold between the desert and outer space than the sequence of shots introducing Mos Eisley in the original cut.
The only thing people really have to say in favor of the version in the original cut, from an analytical or artistic standpoint, is that Mos Eisley is supposed to be "just a shithole." Well, that's not very interesting, and it's not even what Lucas was trying to communicate in the first place. Mos Eisley is a harsh place, but people live there. They're not all weird alien spacers living at the cantina. Mos Eisley is a spaceport. It has an economy. It has different sections, and those sections are different from each other. There are different kinds of both wild and domesticated animals there. This isn't just "lore."
"Just a shithole" isn't a real place. That version of Mos Eisley isn't real. This is basically non-debatable, and that's why the only retort is to fixate on the photorealism of the visual effects or to complain that Lucas's vision of Mos Eisley is not sufficiently historically situated within the behind-the-scenes technological realities of the 1970s.
Only the first is technically an artistic criticism, but it's pretty boring. The second completely misses the point of what a story is, and particularly what the story of Star Wars is. "A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away" means that Star Wars does not take place in the present, nor does it take place in the future, nor does it even literally take place in the past. The story of Star Wars is completely outside of time as we know it. It takes place at every time and at no time, inside eternity.
But these people are really only fans of the original Star Wars as a historical artifact—which is fine. I'm interested in that too! But I'll be honest, yeah, I am still substantially more interested in the story. Guilty as charged.
Tristan retweeted
Obviously people are going to throw a fit because of the combination of 90s CGI and slapstick comedy here, but firstly, this simply happens to be a very appropriate location for a crane shot like this, because we're following a fast-moving landspeeder on the ground as it enters a spaceport with ships taking off into the air.
Secondly, this is a very George Lucas shot because it doesn't just start when the landspeeder enters frame. The "camera operator" is originally engrossed in capturing the petty drama of the lives of these two random droids. Then he is suddenly compelled to abandon this drama as the heroes enter frame, and so he cranes up from a squabble between two droids to an expansive view of the Mos Eisley cityscape.
The heroes are transitioning from what has generally been a very ground-level world to a place that represents the threshold between that world and outer space. If you are going to have one shot in the movie like this, this should obviously be it. If there's no reason for a shot like this anywhere else...there doesn't need to be another one. Swooping POV shots aren't exactly stylistically typical of the film either, but it's appropriate for the plunge into the Death Star trench.
Replying to @mightydudbolt
It is so unfortunate that George Lucas couldn't have brought in someone who understands the visual grammar of Star Wars, like Patrick Willems
Tristan retweeted
Arguing with George Lucas haters is like arguing with a brick wall. Present irrefutable evidence their claims are wrong, & they ignore it. So from now on I'm responding with sarcasm. No point in putting serious effort into convincing emotional people who don't care about truth.
Tristan retweeted
Interestingly the changes to Cloud City in the special edition of Empire were actually done for Irvin Kershner who himself was quite unsatisfied with how it looked in the initial film.




































