Vik retweeted
This is Final Fantasy XIV’s fatal flaw.
A Realm Reborn does suck. It is one of the driest, most boring gaming experiences available on the market.
For what is ostensibly an MMORPG, Final Fantasy XIV’s introductory chapter has minimal gameplay, trite and unimaginative quest design, a total lack of engaging character progression, zero player interdependency, and a world that isn’t worth exploring.
What it has in spades are hundreds of thousands of words of unvoiced dialogue, which the game insists that the player read, since the narrative context is the only saving grace for an otherwise hollow gameplay experience.
This is why, in my opinion, Final Fantasy XIV is closer to a visual novel than an MMORPG, which is important for someone to know before spending their valuable time playing the game and waiting for the promise of “it gets better in Heavensward.”
It does, absolutely, but the game does not meaningfully change—from 2.0 to 7.56, it is a lot of walking, talking, and essentially no gameplay. Not to mention that your reward for 400 hours of investment is Dawntrail, for the love of God.
Obfuscating that fact is not our responsibility as veterans hoping to fool newcomers into playing the game that we love. It’s the responsibility of the developers to improve the experience of A Realm Reborn and for the players to pressure them into doing so.




























