Honest thoughts on @GuardianFutures
I've been with BG since the beginning, and for a long time they were one of my favourite firms. Clear rules, smooth payouts, good communication. I recommended them to people without hesitation.
That changed once they moved me to live.
My live cooldown just ended. I come back, trade well, and request one payout. Instead of an approval I get an email from Risk Management with two options:
1. Take the payout, have the account marked as breached, and sit out another 30 days
2. Skip the payout and roll it into a live account
So after a single payout I'm back where I just came from. Nobody even looked at the payout normally first. It feels less like a reward for consistent trading and more like a way to avoid paying consistent traders.
I get that firms need to manage risk. I get that profitable traders cost them money. But be upfront about it. Don't let people build accounts, pass evals and pay fees, and then send a "congratulations, you're too good" email the moment they ask to get paid.
I'm taking the payout and the 30-day pause. But being pushed straight back into the same cycle as soon as my cooldown ends is not how you treat traders who've been loyal from day one.
To be clear, this isn't me saying BG is a scam. I've been paid by them before. But the experience since going live has been nowhere near what it was at the start, and I think traders deserve to know how this works before they scale up with them.
Curious if others have had the same experience. 👇
@GuardianFutures @BlueGuardiancom
Yves retweeted
1/
@AtlasFunded found a new way not to pay me.
First they deducted my profit. After I went public, they restored it and apologised. (Which I appreciated @CianHansardAF )
Then I requested my payout again. And instead of paying me, they moved my account to "live". 🧵
2/
Let me be clear about my situation:
- 0 payouts ever received on this funded account
- No other accounts with Atlas
- Never asked to go live
- Never offered a cash-out option
I requested a payout. I got a new account instead.
3/
My signed agreement says nothing about being moved to live. Not one word.
§6.2 is simple: after 7 days and 4 qualifying days, I'm eligible for a payout.
I met that. The contract promises a payout, not a different account.
4/
And the "live" account comes with worse terms than the contract I signed:
- 5 winning days instead of 4 (§4.3)
- $2,000 max payout instead of $3,000 (§4.1/§6.3)
So I have to qualify all over again, under stricter rules, for less money.
5/
Look at the timeline:
- Profit deducted → payout denied
- Support claims nothing was deducted
- I go public → balance restored
- I request payout → moved to live
Every time I meet the requirements, the goalposts move.
6/
To me, this looks like one thing: another reason not to pay.
A payout I earned under their own agreement has been turned into a fresh account, with new rules and a lower cap, without my consent.
7/
What I'm asking for is simple:
Pay out what I earned under the agreement I signed. Or at the very least, give me the cash-out option.
Not another account. Not new rules. The payout.
8/
Traders: before you buy a funded account, read the contract and ask exactly what happens when you request your first payout.
If you trade futures with @atlasfunded and have a payout pending, read this before you click anything.
My $1,800 payout is now stuck in an account I can never withdraw it from.
Here's how "Atlas Live" works 🧵
———
Nov 6 → I request a $1,800 payout
Nov 10 → still pending, I get "selected" for Atlas Live
I sign. My mistake, I moved too fast.
Within an hour I ask to reverse it. Zero trades placed.
Still no reply from support.
———
📄 §3.4
Your pending payout becomes your "Starting Balance".
It is "never paid out" and "stays at risk".
Your own earned money becomes their drawdown buffer.
———
And the rest of your profit?
I had around $6K in profit on my funded account. Live doesn't carry it over. Your Starting Balance is only the converted payout.
Your options:
→ Take $1,800 + a 30-day cooldown
→ Or move to Live with $1,800 + $4000 drawdown you can never withdraw
Either way, the rest is gone.
———
What "Live" actually gives you:
❌ 5 qualifying days of $150 before a payout
❌ Max 50% of profit per payout
❌ $2,000 payout cap
The exact same rules as a normal sim funded account.
———
Is it even live?
📄 §9.1
"may be executed in a simulated environment that mirrors live market prices"
My account was ready within seconds, on the same data feed as my funded accounts.
———
The part every Atlas trader should read:
📄 §3.5
Atlas "may move your futures accounts to Atlas Live without offering a choice. Any futures payout you have requested then becomes a Converted Payout."
Any pending payout. No choice needed.
———
Now compare the Funded Trader Agreement:
📄 §6.7
Live review happens at your 5th payout. That payout is "processed as normal". You're referred to a broker partner.
Me: moved after 3 payouts. Converted, not paid.
———
To be fair: two weeks ago Atlas wrongly denied and cut two of my payouts. After I pushed back with my contract, they admitted it, paid both in full and apologized.
Respect for that.
But this experience undoes all of it.
———
I've asked Atlas to process my $1,800 as a normal payout. Waiting on their answer.
Get a Live offer with a payout pending?
→ Pick "Take the payout"
→ Read §3.4, §3.5 and §9.1 first
I'll update this thread.
@CianHansardAF @LAntonioAF @atlas_futures @atlasfunded
What up with the payout button on Blueguardian not working? @BlueGuardiancom
Yves retweeted
1/
Atlas Funded removed $661 from my funded account, reset my winning days to 0 and denied my $1,800 payout.
Then their support told me nothing was deducted.
Here's what actually happened, with their own contract and emails. 🧵
2/
Their reason: 4 trades held under 3 minutes.
Their own agreement (§4.7): "Occasional short trades that occur naturally are acceptable."
Only a "primary strategy" of sub-3-minute trades is prohibited. 4 trades over 3 days while I traded this account for more almost 2 weeks is not a strategy.
3/
The agreement also says each rule carries "the consequence stated in the rule itself."
§4.7 states no deduction for occasional short trades.
So they applied a penalty that isn't in their own contract.
4/
Worse: the profit from those trades was already gone. I lost it in later trading, then rebuilt the account with one trade of ~$3,300, held well over 3 minutes.
They deducted money that no longer existed, from new, fully compliant profit.
5/
My contract (§4.2): "This Account has no daily loss limit."
Yet on 6 Nov my account hit a daily loss limit after the $661 was taken off my balance.
A rule that isn't in my contract, introduced without the 7-day notice their own §17 requires.
6/
Then support.
Their Risk team, in writing: "A deduction has been applied."
A day later, support: "The trades were not deducted."
Both can't be true. Screenshots attached.
7/
When I asked about my payout in their Discord, my message was automatically blocked by the server's filter.
8/
I've sent detailed emails citing every clause. No answer on the substance.
All I ask: restore my balance and winning days, and pay out what I earned under the agreement I signed which both me and atlas have to honer.
Traders: read your contract before you buy. @CianHansardAF @LAntonioAF @atlas_futures @atlasfunded
Yves retweeted
Replying to @TaurusArena
@TaurusArena
Moving live after one payout 😅this isn’t expected but let’s see how this goes .
@salmanmunir96 big no for the firm
1/
I got permanently banned by @TaurusArena for asking to negotiate.Not for breaking a rule. Not for gambling. For asking questions about my own payout. Here’s exactly what happened, with all the emails. 🧵
2/
I passed my evals and was trading multiple Profit Accounts with Taurus. I had received exactly 1 payout. My 2nd payout request was pending. Then I got an email: “Congratulations, you’ve been selected for Live Trading.”
3/
Sounds great, right? Except:– My pending payout would be “allocated toward the transition”
– My sim accounts would be closed
– The live conditions would only be shared AFTER signing an NDA: sign first, see the terms later.
4/
I read the agreement I signed. It says the trader gets 85% of approved profits. It lists the only reasons they can terminate: rule violations, fraud, ignoring compliance, or breach. Nothing about withholding a payout for “live allocation”. No rule violation was ever mentioned.
5/
I simply asked: Pay out my pending payout
Move my remaining balance into the live account
Show me the terms before I sign anything
That’s it. A negotiation.
6/
Their response: all accounts permanently closed. Business relationship terminated. Banned from ever trading with them again.“This decision is final, irreversible, and not open to further discussion.”The remaining balance on my accounts is gone.
7/
I got my payout partially. But I lost 6k balance I built while following every rule. Lesson: if a firm pushes you to “live” early and makes you sign before showing terms, ask questions. And see how they react. Choose your prop firm carefully.
@TaurusArena, is this how you treat your customers?
Using “live trading” as a way to avoid paying profitable traders?
Unpopular truth: most prop firms aren’t trading companies. They’re eval-selling companies.
– Your “funded account” is sim. No real capital.
– Their main revenue is traders failing evals and buying resets.
– Profitable traders are a cost, not an asset.
So what happens when you actually win?
Payouts get “reviewed”. Rules get “interpreted”. Accounts get pushed to “live” early. Or you get banned.
Not every firm is like this. But the model rewards them when you lose.
Treat prop firms as a tool, not a career. Take payouts early, spread across firms, and never trust a balance until it’s in your bank.
Yves retweeted
Hi, traders! I want to share my experience with you so that you don't face the same problems I'm facing with @fundedfamily.
I bought one account Premier+ account, passed it, got a 2k payout, breached it. Then I bought 2 accounts, passed them, I had 4/5 $200 profitable days for a full 2k payout in each account and I was sent an email to be upgraded to a Pro account (live) without getting any payouts in these two accounts. I didn't reach the 3 payouts or 10k profit required to be moved as stated in their policy.
The Pro account: 5k Trailing Max Drawdown, 1k Daily Drawdown, 1 Contract, Profit share 80/20, 20 profitable days ($200) for 100% withdrawal else 50% and the Max Drawdown fits at 50,100.
Now in the live stage, they sent me an email: My live account was paused to confirm consistency in another account where I have to make a Profit of 10k, Profit Factor 1.5, 10 profitable days of $200 with a 2k Max Drawdown.
All this so that they resume my live account...
This is HIGH WAY ROBERY business. With the stress and how difficult Trading is in general.
I just ask you @fundedfamily to return my evaluation fee cause I don't want to continue losing my time, SCAMMERS.
















