
धर्मो रक्षति रक्षितः (Protect the justice and justice in turn shall protect you). Lawyer & Consultant. Legal Philosophy & Jurisprudence; [email protected]
Patiala
Joined September 2014
- Tweets11.1K
- Following128
- Followers2.4K
- Likes6.5K
My legal confusions are not "if the judgment was good or bad."
I see it in broader lens, consistent applicability and administration of law and justice, to get further confused on a question that is:
What the hell is law even?
It you are a lawyer, a judge or even a common human contesting similar case, let me know if you can assure your client or whoever you want to guide, that similar rule will apply in your case and the next judge won't have his own punchline to punch into the judgment.
11
351
Let us ignore it because a man did it
Or
Let us bash because a man did it
Let us not talk about justice. Let's tell everyone what's our version of justice is.
Judge sahib apna soch ke dar gye.
But God bless a bed ridden non earning husband should pay the maintenance to an able bodied wife.
41
Common people: Why do husband pay maintenance to wife? Especially without any corresponding duty? If I owe her a duty she must owe me a duty in return, because any agreement without consideration is void.
Court: Its because marriage is not a contract but a sacrament.
Religion: Well, in that case, she must come on "Doli" and leave on "Arthi" only. Because religiously she owes 7 promises in exchange of a man's 7 promises.
Court: That's patriarchal mindset.
Patriarchy: Now where did I come in this all? Can you keep it between you two?
Court:
Its a shame that they pick and choose the verses.
Manusmriti also says this
But .... that's patriarchal
Both Supreme Court and Manusmriti hold maintenance of wife to be pious obligation of husband: Allahabad High Court
Read here: barandbench.com/news/both-su…










