Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden) profile picture

I am a lazy urban ethnobotanist who likes high prairie winds and prefers information to opinion

Rome, Lazio
Joined May 2012
Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)Photo by Christopher Emsden (@CHCEmsden)
Christopher Emsden retweeted
Josh Turek in Iowa was one of several self-described "prairie populists," seeking better outcomes for rural America. Many of them won or pushed their opponents to the brink on Tuesday. prospect.org/2026/11/05/good…
1
13
31
2,335
Christopher Emsden retweeted
Great post from @adam_tooze on why African urbanization is one of the greatest policy imperatives of our time 🌆🌆 adamtooze.substack.com/p/cha…
3
30
101
3,404
“It’s probably the most iconic sound in nature, at least in the Northern Hemisphere,” Reed said of the wolf howl. “It basically means ‘Here I am. Where are you?’ atmos.earth/science-and-natu…
5
57
Christopher Emsden retweeted
The ancient world was a far more interconnected place than is commonly recognised. Nearly 2,000 years ago, a sailor named Diogenes travelled 25 days inland from the coast of Tanzania to reach the source of the Nile near the “Mountains of the Moon” africanhistoryextra.com/p/an…
3
19
1
60
5,452
if fertility is properly measured as "babies per woman", is the person in this image a contributor?
If we want people to have more babies, we need to combat the stigma against ... illegitimacy? So says Hollis Robbins @anecdotal @unherd. unherd.com/2026/09/fertility…
1
7
113
his second term ends in 2029
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
50
ranchers are like bankers!
These ranchers are welfare queens of the first rank: they graze public lands, not just their own lands, to death; they fence and ravage land that doesn’t belong to them. Then they demand the right to kill any native wildlife that they find inconvenient.
41
...incentivizing safe, tractable and easily evaluated outputs... nature.com/articles/s41562-0…
2
1
43
so... non-market policies are going to roar? so it seems.
FT: “China has scuppered a consensus at the G20 finance ministers’ summit by opposing language in the communiqué agreed by the US and the other countries about eliminating “non-market policies” to curb global trade imbalances.”
1
45
Christopher Emsden retweeted
The Blackfoot Confederacy is four related nations on the northwestern Plains: the Blackfeet in Montana, and the Kainai, Piikani, and Siksika in Alberta. They are one people. The line that now splits them is the United States–Canada border, drawn in the nineteenth century by Washington and London along the forty-ninth parallel. The Blackfoot did not negotiate that line, and it cut through country they already used as a single homeland. When writers say “the Front,” they do not mean a battle line or a weather map. They mean the Rocky Mountain Front: the eastern face of the Rockies, where the Great Plains come to an abrupt end and the mountains rise in a wall of foothills, limestone reefs, canyons, and high peaks. In northern Montana and southern Alberta that meeting of prairie and mountain is especially sharp. You can stand in open grassland and look west into a sudden range. The Blackfoot know those mountains as the Backbone of the World. Their older stories are set along that edge of grass and stone, not in the eastern woodlands. The argument was never about whether the Blackfoot exist. It was about where they came from, and how old that presence is. For a long time the standard account said they were late arrivals. Blackfoot is an Algonquian language. Most of that family is spoken around the Great Lakes and in the Northeast. Linguists and anthropologists treated the family tree as a trail. If the closest linguistic relatives lived in the woodlands, then the Blackfoot, the thinking went, must have migrated west onto the Plains only in recent centuries and become bison people after they got there. That version settled into textbooks as if it were settled fact. Behind that local story sat a larger one about the whole continent. For much of the twentieth century, archaeology taught Clovis First. Clovis is a culture named for distinctive fluted spear points first recognized near Clovis, New Mexico. The points, and the people who made them, date to a narrow window at the end of the Ice Age, a few centuries on either side of thirteen thousand years ago. The model said these hunters were the first people south of the Canadian ice sheets. They were supposed to have walked down from Beringia through an ice-free corridor that opened between the two great glaciers, then spread across the interior with remarkable speed. If Clovis was first, then a deep Blackfoot presence on the Front was hard to take seriously. Everyone, in that picture, was a latecomer. The Blackfoot never told the Great Lakes story, and they never needed Clovis to begin their history. Their oral traditions do not remember leaving the woodlands. What they remember is older weather and country: ice standing against the mountains, meltwater in the valleys, animals that no longer live on those plains. Archaeology along the Front has long suggested people were in that region earlier than a late woodland migration would allow. The language evidence was never as simple as the arrow on the map. Blackfoot is Algonquian, but it is a deep and unusual branch of the family, not a recent dialect. Languages can move without whole nations packing up and walking west. So two origin stories sat side by side. One came from a language map, and behind it from Clovis First. The other came from Blackfoot memory and pointed back into the Ice Age. For a long time, only the first was treated as the scholarly default. The nations finally put the question to genetics. Working with archaeologists and geneticists, they compared DNA from living Blackfoot people with DNA from ancestors buried in Blackfoot country after European contact. The study answered two different questions, and it helps to keep them separate. The first question was recent. Are today’s Blackfoot the same people who were already living along the Front when the written record begins? The DNA said yes. Living community members and those near ancestors belong to one lineage. That rules out a quiet swap of populations in the last few centuries. The Blackfoot on that plains-and-mountain edge now are descendants of the Blackfoot who were there at contact. The second question was much older. Where does that lineage sit among the other Indigenous peoples of the Americas? Here the genomes did something neither the Great Lakes story nor Clovis First predicted. The Blackfoot samples do not cluster with the other Native American branches already mapped from north to south. They look like their own early branch. To see why that matters, it helps to know what geneticists mean by Ancient Beringians. During the last Ice Age, Siberia and Alaska were joined by dry land. That whole region, land bridge included, is called Beringia. The ancestors of Native Americans formed there, or just behind it, from a mix of older East Asian and Ancient North Eurasian ancestry. They did not immediately pour south. Many researchers think they paused in Beringia long enough to become genetically distinct from the populations still in Asia. That pause is the Beringian standstill. Then that founding population itself began to split. The first known split produced two sister groups. One stayed in the far north. The other became the source of almost everyone later sampled in the rest of the Americas. The northern sister group is the Ancient Beringians. We know them from the genome of an infant buried at Upward Sun River in interior Alaska, given the name Xach’itee’aanenh T’eede Gaay by the local Healy Lake Village Council. She lived after the Ice Age had begun to wane, but her ancestry was already old. Her people had branched off from the ancestors of other Native Americans while ice still dominated the north. Ancient Beringians remained in Alaska and eastern Beringia. They are a basal Native American lineage: related to everyone farther south, but not the direct source of the later northern and southern branches. Their line is not the one that fills most of the continents. In Alaska it later fades from the record as other Native American groups move in. Everyone else in the usual maps comes from the other sister group, the one that did not stay behind as Ancient Beringians. That group later split again, most researchers think south of the ice, into Northern and Southern Native American lineages. Athabaskan and many Algonquian-related peoples are generally placed on the northern side of that later split. Most groups from farther south sit on the other side. The only Clovis-associated genome we have sits on that southern side. It belongs to a child buried with Clovis tools at the Anzick site in western Montana, not far, in continental terms, from Blackfoot country. Anzick lived around the time Clovis points were being made. His ancestry is Native American, and it aligns more closely with the southern branch than with the later northern one. Clovis, in other words, is not a unique founding people from whom all later nations descend in a simple line. It is a toolkit and a moment, carried by people who already belonged to a branch that had formed earlier. The Blackfoot genomes do not fall where the language map said they should, and they do not fall with Anzick either. They do not sit with other Algonquian speakers inside that later northern branch. They are not Ancient Beringians. In the family tree used by the study, the Blackfoot lineage splits after the Ancient Beringians have already gone their own way, but before the rest of the Native American tree divides into those northern and southern branches. That timing is the problem for both the old Blackfoot migration story and Clovis First. Clovis First needed a late door. People wait in Beringia until the Canadian ice sheets pull apart. A corridor opens between the glaciers. Hunters walk south and invent, or bring, the Clovis point. Then the continent fills. The trouble is the door. The ice-free corridor did not become a usable interior road until after the worst of the Ice Age had passed, and some studies put a living landscape in that gap even later than the first Clovis dates. Meanwhile archaeology has been turning up sites and technologies older than Clovis, from the Pacific Northwest to South America. Not every early claim has held. The pattern has. People appear to have been south of the ice before those fluted points become common. A Blackfoot lineage that is already separate before the northern-southern split does not look like a population that waited for that inland door, picked up Clovis along the way, and then drifted west from the Great Lakes in recent centuries. It looks like a people whose ancestors differentiated in glacial time, earlier than Clovis, earlier than the corridor story allows, and earlier than a late woodland migration requires. That is not the same thing as saying the Blackfoot predate every crossing out of Asia, or that we have Ice Age Blackfoot skeletons from the Front. Ancient Beringians and the ancestors of other Native Americans still share that older Beringian root. The historic bones in the study are only a few centuries old. The early date is a split on a family tree, not a dated hearth in the foothills. What the tree can say is narrower and still sharp. By the time Clovis points are being buried with a child in Montana, the Native American population is already old enough to have grown several deep branches. One of those branches, on present evidence, leads to the Blackfoot. Clovis is too late to be the beginning of that story. Put the two genetic results together and the controversy changes shape. The first result says there was no late replacement along the Front after contact. The second says the ancestors of those people were not late woodland migrants, and not simply the descendants of the first Clovis hunters through the corridor. Their beginnings belong to the same deep American radiation as the Ancient Beringians, but on a different early branch, older than the chapter in which Clovis was supposed to explain everybody. None of this means one community never moved from one creek. People travel, marry out, leave, and return. What it does mean is that the assumed origin was the weaker story. The evidence now points to an earlier people: descendants of an Ice Age lineage already distinct before the inland route from Beringia opened and before Clovis became the face of the first Americans. The old arrow on the map was drawn from language, and from a spear point. The deeper record was pointing somewhere older.
51
41
8
307
9,285
fully automated cattle ranching! gonna be fun to watch!
Replying to @SaysSimulation
I, in fact, do care about farmers, ranchers etc. even as a blue state right winger. I care that they stop hiring illegals, and fully automate their farming.
44
will the muzak change when people learn this ghent micropod is into mandatory crispr editing of human embryos to select for a wobbly group-based definition of "intelligence"?
This whole article is based on one single assumption: that Cofnas's work constitutes "research" that challenges "established taboos". Ergo he gets the Galileo treatment. It's obvious that you haven't read anything he wrote or your definition of scientific evidence covers everything. Your article is accurate but irrelevant because it doesn't apply to Cofnas. How can I make you guys understand? He does *not* produce knowledge. He does *not* do research. He *expresses* a view. However deplorable, he has every right to express these views *as an individual*. He can say, do or think whatever he wants as long as he doesn't incite people to violence. BUT VIEWS ARE NOT SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE. My objection is not to his views. It's to the way he presents them. And you're simply amplifying this.
57
Christopher Emsden retweeted
Since he's in the news I decided to reread Nathan Cofnas' paper on power in cultural evolution. The gist of the argument is that cultural evolutionary models, particularly by Boyd & Richerson, focus too much on learning biases influencing cultural evolution and not enough on how norms can be imposed by a group rather than preferentially adopted by individuals. This is an argument I'm broadly sympathetic to. About a year before his paper came out I talked about male cults in the ethnographic record and how they impose and enforce norms in many small-scale societies. I noted how cultural evolutionary methods often focus on the beneficial effects of the transmission of information but in my view not enough on its selective and strategic monopolization. I do think Cofnas overstates the contrast with Boyd & Richerson though. Learning biases are not necessarily at odds with power and coercion, since enforcement changes the payoffs and payoff-biased learning is part of many cultural evolutionary models. He selectively quotes B&R saying that for most of human history states did not exist and norms were not enforced by *external sanctions*, but I think it's pretty clear they're referring there to states/formal institutions, since in Not by Genes Alone they describe how "prosocial norms are enforced by systems of sanction and reward". I think Cofnas broader point that cultural evolution could focus more on power is right, as I've talked about with male cults and arranged marriage in particular. Callin O'Conner's book 'The Origins of Unfairness' is a good example of a book using game theoretic models to integrate cultural evolution and power dynamics. The biggest problem with the paper though, and the main point I want to bring up because it is of particular interest and importance to me, is Cofnas' discussion of hunter-gatherer societies. Cofnas, in a 20 page paper, cites Christopher Boehm *50 times* inside the text. Cofnas spends 5 pages purporting to give a full description of hunter-gatherer societies yet he did not read a single hunter-gatherer ethnography on his own, and his account consists exclusively of uncritically parroting claims made by Boehm, and in some cases going even farther than he did. Cofnas writes that, "All nomadic hunter-gatherers that have ever been described, without exception, live by an ideology of extreme egalitarianism (among men). No nomadic hunter-gatherer society tolerates adult males issuing direct orders to other adult males. Some groups have a titular leader, but his role never goes beyond leading by example and helping to organize group discussions aimed at reaching a consensus on group actions". That is quite obviously not true and absurd. We have thousands of ethnographic accounts of hundreds of hunter-gatherer societies and Cofnas gives no indication of having read any of them, so why he thinks he can categorically say there are no exceptions to such a sweeping generalization is beyond me. A.W. Howitt (the anthropologist who led the expedition to find Burke and Wills!) has a great chapter on this in 'The Native Tribes of South East Australia' describing the authority a Headman holds across different groups. Many Aboriginal Australian groups have coercive initiation systems with strong power differences between elder leaders and younger (but still adult) men, with a great deal of authority and direction provided. Overall I do think drawing attention to the neglected role of power and coercion in many cultural evolution models is useful, so I don't think this is a particularly bad paper. The discussion of hunter-gatherer societies in it is genuinely terrible, but it's terrible in a way that is typical of most writing on hunter-gatherer societies, where people simply repeat broad generalizations and at most cite one or two ethnographic accounts. His discussion of hunter-gatherer societies implies a single uniform hunter-gatherer socioecology with group imposed norms to contrast with Boyd & Richerson's models, but nomadic hunter-gatherer societies actually vary considerably in this (and other) domain(s). Power and coercion are still relevant and neglected but not in the way Cofnas describes it. I think it is a big problem how much popular discussion of hunter-gatherers and the 'Environment of Evolutionary Adaptedness' is reduced to lazy stereotyping and generalizations rather than being given the deep ethnographic investigation the topic deserves. And when people just repeat assessments from Boehm it really compounds the problem: Boehm specifically excluded inegalitarian and sedentary hunter-gatherers from his surveys! He assumed that sedentism and inequality aren't 'late Pleistocene appropriate' so he removed such foragers from his samples. So the generalizations get even more simplistic as his views get repeated, because people who don't look in detail at his method miss how circular the 'nomadic egalitarian' generalizations are.
10
31
7
229
32,465
Christopher Emsden retweeted
Quite amused to find that Alan Macfarlane, who I only know as the author of The Origins of English Individualism (which was an important early influence on me), has become a major social media figure on Xiaohongshu. Life can take very interesting turns. scmp.com/news/china/diplomac…
3
13
2
94
19,718