Catholic Primer retweeted
Long live Christ!
Long live the Virgin Mary!
Long live the Catholic Church!
Catholic Primer retweeted
BREAKING: Trent Horn has left Catholic Answers!
Please offer up your prayers and any help you can for Trent and his family
youtu.be/k7z6v-I8cxE
Catholic Primer retweeted
I was initially inclined to give the benefit of the doubt to @WesleyLHuff on the plagiarism allegations, bc it's easy to improperly cite a source innocently, and Wes was initially claiming that all of this was years ago when he was a young student, and in unpublished work. It now seems pretty clear that virtually none of that is true, and that the scope and duration of the plagiarism was a lot worse than he was letting on.
Unfortunately (but predictably), a lot of people quickly rallied behind their “side,” dismissing @maklelan and his arguments because he’s in the wrong tribe. But I wanted to highlight two people who seemingly didn’t: @BMcGrewvy and @MikeWingerii clearly put love of Truth over ideological tribe, at least in the comments that I've seen from them. And I’ve got to say, as much as I disagree with Mike Winger’s views on Catholicism, he seems to consistently be on the side of the angels when it comes to scandals in the Church and he takes a lot of flack from fellow Evangelicals for it. So my respect to him and McGrew and anyone who avoided the tribal impulse.
And please, pray for Wes and his family amidst this. Whatever his faults, he’s a man with tremendous talents and a heart for the Lord who seems to be going through a terrible crucible right now between this scandal and family medical issues. 🙏
Catholic Primer retweeted
Bc this isn’t a private disagreement between friends. Wes lying negatively affects Christians and his fans are perpetuating it. If we claim to worship God (who is Truth itself) we can’t treat public deception as something that should always be handled quietly behind closed doors.
Catholic Primer retweeted
The Council of Florence proves Catholicism! Read my article below:
papacy101.substack.com/p/the…
Catholic Primer retweeted
You can now read this!
papacy101.substack.com/p/the…
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @brycejofficial @Talonthepapist
This is a complete red herring. You're making a distinction between civil and religious authority that isn’t mentioned at all. The quote is about religious authority of Rome being instituted by Jesus, and you’re changing the subject.
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @brycejofficial @Talonthepapist
That interpretation is not tenable at all. He’s saying the authority is divinely established and canonically (humanly) confirmed. There is zero indication this quote is distinguishing between exercised authority vs influential authority.
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @basedFishTaco
The Mormon conception of an infinite God is asymptotic: continually progressing in glory, yet never possessing divine perfection.
The Christian God is eternal and immutable: All-Powerful, All-Knowing, All-Glorious, etc. He’s not becoming more God; He eternally IS God.
🤖 Made with AI
Catholic Primer retweeted
Who was the most recent Protestant?
Peter Heers, of course.
The Heeretic who acted for years as a schismatic, and who rejects all Episcopal authority, unless the Bishop lets him do whatever he wants.
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @WesleyLHuff
@WesleyLHuff has removed everything from his website.
This speaks volumes. He doesn't want people looking and checking, it seems...
Catholic Primer retweeted
Another follow-up on the Gospel of Thomas paper Wes Huff wrote as a PhD student at the University of Toronto. Huff criticizes scholar Stephen Patterson as if it’s his own analysis. But it isn’t his. It’s copied from a 2014 article by Mark Goodacre, which Huff never cites.
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @ShamelessPopery
Joe, dont you know that debating with Protestants that hold to Protestant theology as it actually exists in the minds of 99% of lay Protestants is an implicit strawman of the "nuanced" and "sophisticated" views of classical Protestants that hold to gross approximations of the Catholic position + subtle technical distinction???
Catholic Primer retweeted
This is very strange. I did a 2.5 hour debate with James White defending the proposition that the Mass is a propitiatory sacrifice, only to have an online Protestant apologist falsely claiming that I don't talk about the Eucharistic Sacrifice, and hold to views that "are actually out of step with even [the Council of Trent itself."
No evidence is given of this assertion, and when @ErickYbarra3 asks, "Do we have evidence that either
@Trent_Horn or @ShamelessPopery denies that a real and proper sacrifice takes place upon the altar?," he answers "I never claimed that they denied this."
Very strange behavior.
A lot of the popular-level Roman Catholic apologists today are actually quite dull on the subject of Eucharistic Sacrifice when compared with the vast majority of Roman theologians after the Council of Trent.
For example, they commonly just say that "the Mass is a re-presentation of the sacrifice of the Cross," or simply "applies the sacrifice of the Cross" while being unaware that most confessional Protestants also agreed to this without any difficulty.
The real issue was that Roman Catholic theology has always historically held to the idea that a real immolation of the sacrificial victim is necessary and essential to the nature of a proper and external sacrifice. Without it, you merely have an oblation---but not a sacrifice.
The views held by the Catholic Answers bros are actually out of step with even Trent itself, since they hold to something more like the view of Gabriel Vazquez or perhaps Maurice de la Taille, who were criticized on this very issue by other prominent authors, such as Emmanuel Doronzo.
If you want the best survey possible, check out L'Idée du sacrifice de la messe by Marius Lepin. It is a 900-page study of all the different theories, and ultimately comes to the conclusion that the majority of them are wrong and inconsistent in explaining how some immolation of Christ occurs in the Mass.
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @tgtengage @WesleyLHuff
I respectfully disagree. I can’t think of any prominent Catholic influencer who defended VOR’s behavior. Granted, their sins are way different. But I don’t think this is an example of tribalism. Of course forgiveness is possible, but it doesn’t mean avoiding accountability.
Catholic Primer retweeted
Replying to @sccarlson
Can't say I'm surprised ... didn't know about the papers, but some years ago he took one of our @ArmstrongIBA infographics, added some highlights, and put his stamp on it. Looks like he also deleted our comment to his FB post addressing this at the time. facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=…
Catholic Primer retweeted
Of all the fields to plagiarize in, NT studies might be the worst—we are obsessed with analyzing source dependence (e.g., the Synoptic problem).
@WesleyLHuff is attempting to distract you in his apology. His reply to @maklelan is bad. Here's my analysis.
youtu.be/eZaktN2Uusw?is=LkI8…
Catholic Primer retweeted
This is wildly ahistorical.
Not only were living people commonly depicted in icons (even in churches) there is a whole iconographic tradition specifically associated with it: the square halo of the living!
Replying to @MJSeverson24
In general, the history of the church & language of the 7th Councils is that we do not depict people until after death when they are seen as saints because anyone including Popes (read church history or even Dante) could shipwreck their faith by the end of their life.



































