Colm (@Colm1917) header
Colm (@Colm1917) profile picture
Dublin City, Ireland
Joined June 2009
Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)Photo by Colm (@Colm1917)
Colm retweeted
I've been sanctioned, but the real issue is bigger than me. The Euro-Reich is destroying the spaces where people can disagree. It's a death of a thousand cuts for liberty, Orwellian and dangerous, and they're sending a warning to anyone who refuses to toe the line.
The EU sanctioned me for being a "disinformation hub". No evidence, no hearing, nothing. Now I can't move around the EU, can't bank, and can't receive money. All because I challenged the Western narrative on Ukraine.
78
783
36
1,902
27,894
Chay Bowes is an idiot loudmouth who parrots Russian propaganda. But it's mad that far-right Israeli genocidal maniacs and propagandists face no EU sanctions, while he gets his assets frozen.
28
24
7
195
8,859
I don’t know Chay Bowers but I stand behind him today. Wtf is this nonsense about? Challenging the establishment and the thought police used to be something called…. Ehhhhh…. Journalism. rte.ie/news/europe/2026/1116…
48
69
330
5,072
EU sanctions against Irish journalist Chay Bowes are a blatant attack on the rule of law and democracy. The EU only has to claim "disinformation" and his basic rights are gone. The EU has frozen his bank accounts and put a travel ban on one of it own citizens without even a day in court or legal recourse.
The legal bases for this are Council Decision (CFSP) 2024/2643 and Council Regulation (EU) 2024/2642. They created the so-called "hybrid sanctions" regime - allowing the use of EU sanctions to punish "disinformation." Put plainly, that means extrajudicial punishment for disfavoured speech. No court is involved. There are no charges and no conviction. Evidence is secret. There is no hearing, and no right of defence. People who are sanctioned by the EU have their EU bank accounts frozen, along with any assets. It is illegal to give them money. If they live in the EU, this means that effectively, they cannot work or earn a living. A travel ban is also imposed. Traditionally, in democracies, governments cannot impose severe punishments on citizens without following criminal procedure. They have to find a crime to charge them with, and go before a court. This is what it means to have the rule of law and separation of powers. All of that has always been a pretty important part of being a democracy. But that's gone now and has been since 2024. And it has mostly passed without comment. Journalists reporting on it do not seem interested in the legal basis for which someone engaged in speech - which is also central to press freedom - could be subject to severe punishment by their own government without being charged with a crime. Is @tconnellyRTE going to inquire much further into this? Is the government going to have to explain how any of this is democratic? Probably not. Based on some of the cheerleading, many people are over the moon about all of this, because they don't like Chay Bowes and don't agree with what he says. Again, traditionally, in democracies, you don't have to like someone, or what they say, to agree that they should have rights. Public cheerleading while someone's rights are stripped away is a classic and ugly feature of repressive regimes everywhere. It is a cause for serious reflection that it's happening in Ireland and the EU in 2026.
157
1,425
69
4,035
42,020
People justifying the sanctioning of Chay Bowes by pointing out that political repression is "worse in Russia" are amazingly incompetent. Are we trying to counter Russia by emulating it? Is that what we're doing now? Because it very much looks like it.
22
29
2
173
2,825
Steve Sackur, respected former BBC Middle-East corr and voice of “cancelled” BBC show Hard Talk confirms what has long been crystal clear: the BBC’s chilling institutional pro-Israeli bias designed to cast doubt about the extent of the Gaza genocide.
Veteran BBC journalist Stephen Sackur has called out the corporation’s “impartiality” on Gaza as unsustainable and one-sided. He highlighted how the BBC was ordered from the top to attach a terrorism label every single time it reported Palestinian death tolls from the Hamas-run health ministry. Yet when Israel officially denied bombing apartment blocks full of women and children, or striking a food kitchen and killing aid workers, the BBC never mentioned that Netanyahu is wanted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes. “BBC’s notion of impartiality is a difficult thing to sustain… it’s difficult for me to justify the BBC talking so rigorously about impartiality and then reporting that way.” “The BBC manual doesn’t talk about morality.” This is what “both-sides” journalism looks like when one side is an occupying power with an ICC arrest warrant and the other is under bombardment.
24
464
6
1,055
16,800
300,000 followers. Its humbling. And its all thanks to you all.
280
1,175
30
7,040
54,470
By my own count, if one includes these latest sanctions, the EU has now sanctioned 8 European citizens for speech: - 3 German citizens: Alina Lipp, Thomas Röper and Hüseyin Doğru - 3 French citizens: Xavier Moreau, Adrien Bocquet and Sylvain Afoua (aka Egountchi Behanzin) - 1 Lithuanian citizen: Ernest Mackevičius - 1 Irish citizen: Chay Bowes The sanctions include freezing these people's assets and making it a crime for anyone in the EU to pay them, hire them or even lend them a single euro. They also include a travel ban, which leads to some absurd situations: Doğru - based in Germany - was invited by some members of the EU parliament to Brussels to plead his case but he couldn't go due to the travel ban. As one of the MEPs who invited him - and made 40 phone calls to try, unsuccessfully, to get him cleared to come - put it: "It really was like something out of a Kafka novel" (berliner-zeitung.de/article/…). And, probably worst of all, all of this was decided without any charge, trial or court ruling - simply as a unilateral decision of government ministers. Yesterday's sanctions, for instance, were decided at the Foreign Affairs Council meeting of EU Foreign Ministers and were simply signed by Kaja Kallas alone on behalf of the Council (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Put it all together, and this violates at least half a dozen of what the EU keeps saying are the fundamental values and principles it supposedly fights for: 1) Separation of powers: here we have government ministers - members of the executive branch of their countries - acting as prosecutor, judge and jury 2) Presumption of innocence (Article 48 of the EU’s own Charter of Fundamental Rights): they’re punished without guilt ever being established, and without being given a chance to plead their case before the decision 3) Right to a fair trial (Article 47): there was no trial at all, let alone a fair one 4) Freedom of expression and of the media (Article 11): they were sanctioned - explicitly so - for what they said and published. For instance, in these latest sanctions, Chay Bowes was sanctioned for, among other things, the speech crime of "participat[ing] in the spreading of anti-Western and anti-Ukraine disinformation at the UN Security Council" (eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-cont…). Sanctioned in part for a speech at the UN, a forum that exists precisely so that clashing views on international matters can be heard, quite the message to send from the EU... 5) Freedom of movement (Article 45): they're under a travel ban 6) Right to work and to property (Articles 15 and 17): their assets are frozen and nobody may employ or pay them You can think whatever you want about these 8 people. But ask yourself this: even if you are pro-Ukraine, pro-EU, anti-Russia and you view these people as malignant Russian operatives... what is the EU fighting for here, exactly? This is more profound than you may think: we're speaking about the very foundation of modern European civilization, built on the very idea that political power alone cannot decide what is true. I'm not exaggerating. What we’re witnessing is a return to the pre-Enlightenment playbook, when monarchic or religious authorities defined the truth, deviations from it were called heresy, and heretics were excommunicated - cut off from the community, so that no one could trade with them, employ them or help them. In Europe's darkest times, heretics were even famously burned at the stake - like Joan of Arc or Giordano Bruno. It took literal centuries of religious wars and debates, and the likes of Voltaire, Kant and Mill, to replace it with a basic idea: that no single power, however legitimate, gets to be the final judge of what is true, and that you answer for your words only before a court, under laws written via a process separate from the power that does the accusation. You can find countless works of European literature on this very matter. Take Spinoza, excommunicated in 1656 by the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam, with a decree ordering that "no one should communicate with him" nor "accord him any favor". He went on to write the Theological-Political Treatise, one of the founding texts of the Enlightenment, with an entire chapter arguing that "in a free state every man may think what he likes, and say what he thinks." Or Mill, two centuries later in On Liberty, Chapter 2: "All silencing of discussion is an assumption of infallibility." Or Kafka’s The Trial, the story of a man accused by an authority nobody can quite locate, of something nobody will explain. How is what Europe is presently doing anything other than going back to that very system, under new appellations? The authority: government ministers. The heresy: "disinformation". The excommunication: assets frozen, banned from travelling and nobody may pay them, hire them or lend them a single euro. It’s basically Spinoza’s excommunication decree on EU letterhead, with a bit of Kafka sprinkled in given that the man invited to the European Parliament to contest his punishment couldn’t attend because of the very punishment he wanted to contest. You don’t have to like these 8 people, or even care about them, to see the problem. Heck, this system was developed precisely for the people nobody likes: consensual ideas never needed protecting. No, the real question here is this: do you want Europe to be the heir of Spinoza - or of Voltaire, or of Galileo, or of any of the countless Europeans who suffered or even died for thinking differently - or of their persecutors?
Today the EU sanctioned 30 individuals, including journalists & EU citizens, without trial, for “misinformation” & other speech crimes. Their bank accounts have been frozen, travel restricted & more. The EU has yet to sanction Benjamin Netanyahu - for anything.
321
2,874
372
7,759
257,003
Bowes is a journalist by EU's own admission. You may not like what he has to say. But (legal caveats apply) he has a right to speak his mind, & to do so freely. If he has violated any specific law (e.g. incitement of violence), he should be given an opportunity to defend himself.
Today the authoritarian EU sanctioned me, no recourse to defend myself, no hearing, no evidence. They want to bully me into silence, they want to deny you your God-given right to hear dissenting opinions, they want to kill freedom of speech. Their allegations against me are utterly baseless, their insinuations are false, they are terrified of the Truth I will fight this assault on our right to dissent with every fibre of my being, I will not be silenced, I will not take the knee for the enemies of free thought, reason and Democracy
34
114
4
480
7,616
A sinister move seriously threatening free speech & press. EU sanctions journalist for not towing western line. RT is a mouthpiece for Russian state that never criticises Putin but we have lots of voices on western media who push NATO, EU, US, Israeli propaganda with no sanction.
BREAKING: Irish blogger @BowesChay Chay Bowes has been sanctioned by the EU as an alleged propagandist for the Russian government. The listing was announced today by EU foreign ministers meeting in Brussels.
125
89
16
517
23,961
Ages when their first Bond film came out: George Lazenby 30 Sean Connery 32 Daniel Craig 38 Timothy Dalton 41 Pierce Brosnan 42 Roger Moore 45 Robert Pattinson is 40 (41 in May) so near the latter end of the spectrum (or Spectre-m)
96
259
77
4,716
837,310
Irrespective of whether you agree with Chay or not, this is shocking, totally undemocratic and ought to be opposed. My position is always anti-war. I support the ordinary person on the street and NEVER the military industrial complex because as a famous veteran once said, war is a racket!
Today the authoritarian EU sanctioned me, no recourse to defend myself, no hearing, no evidence. They want to bully me into silence, they want to deny you your God-given right to hear dissenting opinions, they want to kill freedom of speech. Their allegations against me are utterly baseless, their insinuations are false, they are terrified of the Truth I will fight this assault on our right to dissent with every fibre of my being, I will not be silenced, I will not take the knee for the enemies of free thought, reason and Democracy
4
33
1
90
1,087
Colm retweeted
Whatever one thinks of Chay Bowes this is a terrifying development in EU “administrative justice” That you can be sanctioned for an opinion without a trial/charges, in secret and without any right of appeal, totally upends the rule of law It’s how fascism operates in practice
61
122
10
546
15,751
So he’s a pro-Russian propagandist. Anyone would have known that. That shouldn’t mean he’s sanctioned. Liberal values only mean anything if they also apply to those whose views you oppose.
BREAKING: Irish blogger @BowesChay Chay Bowes has been sanctioned by the EU as an alleged propagandist for the Russian government. The listing was announced today by EU foreign ministers meeting in Brussels.
113
29
11
307
15,647
It is absolutely wrong that people can be subjected to life crippling sanctions with no notice, no charges, no evidence, no hearing and no trial.
Today the authoritarian EU sanctioned me, no recourse to defend myself, no hearing, no evidence. They want to bully me into silence, they want to deny you your God-given right to hear dissenting opinions, they want to kill freedom of speech. Their allegations against me are utterly baseless, their insinuations are false, they are terrified of the Truth I will fight this assault on our right to dissent with every fibre of my being, I will not be silenced, I will not take the knee for the enemies of free thought, reason and Democracy
117
1,096
30
2,962
31,432
Terrifying - no evidence, no trial, no jury, no appeal, no defence. Remember the USA has done this to Francesca Albanese for standing against war crimes. This isn't democracy it's deep authoritarianism.
The legal bases for this are Council Decision (CFSP) 2024/2643 and Council Regulation (EU) 2024/2642. They created the so-called "hybrid sanctions" regime - allowing the use of EU sanctions to punish "disinformation." Put plainly, that means extrajudicial punishment for disfavoured speech. No court is involved. There are no charges and no conviction. Evidence is secret. There is no hearing, and no right of defence. People who are sanctioned by the EU have their EU bank accounts frozen, along with any assets. It is illegal to give them money. If they live in the EU, this means that effectively, they cannot work or earn a living. A travel ban is also imposed. Traditionally, in democracies, governments cannot impose severe punishments on citizens without following criminal procedure. They have to find a crime to charge them with, and go before a court. This is what it means to have the rule of law and separation of powers. All of that has always been a pretty important part of being a democracy. But that's gone now and has been since 2024. And it has mostly passed without comment. Journalists reporting on it do not seem interested in the legal basis for which someone engaged in speech - which is also central to press freedom - could be subject to severe punishment by their own government without being charged with a crime. Is @tconnellyRTE going to inquire much further into this? Is the government going to have to explain how any of this is democratic? Probably not. Based on some of the cheerleading, many people are over the moon about all of this, because they don't like Chay Bowes and don't agree with what he says. Again, traditionally, in democracies, you don't have to like someone, or what they say, to agree that they should have rights. Public cheerleading while someone's rights are stripped away is a classic and ugly feature of repressive regimes everywhere. It is a cause for serious reflection that it's happening in Ireland and the EU in 2026.
24
226
1
717
10,848
I've never met @BowesChay and had absolutely no contact with him. But he's an EU citizen and sanctioning him effectively renders him stateless as he cannot travel to Ireland, even if he wanted to. I'm aware of his work and am not endorsing anything he says, but this seems yet another blow for free speech in Europe. What will the Eurocrats do when they have to face up to the reality that the war in Ukraine cannot be won and that European citizen have been made poorer and far less safe? Before we reach that point, I predict even more repression.
162
339
17
1,307
25,675
Today the authoritarian EU sanctioned me, no recourse to defend myself, no hearing, no evidence. They want to bully me into silence, they want to deny you your God-given right to hear dissenting opinions, they want to kill freedom of speech. Their allegations against me are utterly baseless, their insinuations are false, they are terrified of the Truth I will fight this assault on our right to dissent with every fibre of my being, I will not be silenced, I will not take the knee for the enemies of free thought, reason and Democracy
1,549
5,601
535
16,272
637,015
Hi @nealerichmond, @Aontacht_Media here, can you kindly disclose how FFG voted in the EU Council meeting where it was decided to sanction this Irish citizen? Did FFG, supposedly representing Ireland, vote to strip an Irish citizen of his rights? Awaiting your answer.
49
53
3
222
8,969
This deserves a response because it raises an important point. EU sanctions are subject to judicial review. That is correct. Sanctioned persons can apply for judicial review from the Court of Justice in Luxembourg. It is technically wrong to call this a "defence." It's an application to annul an administrative measure. This can take as long as 24 months. It requires specialized legal representation, potentially running into hundreds of thousands of euros in legal costs. For all of that time, the sanctioned person is subject to a travel ban and an asset freeze, making it difficult to pay for legal representation. For all of that time, they are subject to an ongoing deprivation of rights. Traditionally, in democracies, if an action risks irreversible harm, threatens fundamental rights, or lacks a fair way to fix mistakes later, ex-post review is considered inadequate. We don't shoot first and ask questions later. We involve a court before the punishment happens, and we hold the prosecution to an extremely high standard of evidence. We are abandoning that standard now. And we are doing it for what is ultimately - however much we might disagree with it - speech. We are creating a very broad EU power to punish speech. Today, you may abhor the victim. Tomorrow it might be you. It is correct to note that restrictive measures are not criminal convictions. That is the core of the problem. These sanctions were designed as a foreign policy instrument to pressure other governments and the powerful foreign nationals around them. That is why there are fewer checks and balances on how they are used. They were not designed to be used on EU citizens as a form of punishment. They are now being used in that way. They don't have the safeguards for fundamental rights that are present in criminal procedure, and which EU citizens expect. They are wide open to abuse.
This quoted post is unavailable.
41
401
31
1,207
29,189