David Ditch (@DavidADitch) header
David Ditch (@DavidADitch) profile picture

Policy analyst for @CatoInstitute covering the federal fisc. Fan of struggling causes (limited government & Buffalo Bills).

United States
Joined August 2011
Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)Photo by David Ditch (@DavidADitch)
David Ditch retweeted
He’s right and it’s important that we not lose our soul while fighting for the soul of the nation.
1
3
328
David Ditch retweeted
A close look at CBO’s 2015 score of the ACA repeal makes an even stronger case that the ACA has significantly increased deficits. The ACA is much worse from a fiscal perspective than CBO projected in 2015. I didn’t fully appreciate this until now. CBO projected $208B in FY25 ACA coverage spending (exchange subsidies plus Medicaid and CHIP). Actual spending on the exchanges and Medicaid expansion alone was ~$300B. Back out $30–40B for the enhanced subsidies, and CBO still missed by ~$60B. This is largely because CBO significantly undershot the cost of the Medicaid expansion. CBO projected $106B for Medicaid and CHIP combined. Medicaid expansion alone cost ~$155B. The pay-fors underperformed too. CBO projected $22B from the employer mandate in FY25, and it raised ~$1B. The $28B in “other revenues” assumed big drops in employer coverage that never happened, and we agree CBO was too high there. CBO also estimated $26B from the individual mandate and Cadillac tax, both since repealed. That’s $0 in reality. On Medicare, there are reasons to take the under on the ACA’s savings. CBO projected CMMI would save money. It now says CMMI raised spending by $5.4B in its first decade and will add $1.3B more through 2030. Under its 2010 approach, CBO would have projected $77.5B in savings for 2021–2030. Bigger picture: the ACA as it has actually evolved has increased deficits, even before counting the student loan takeover, which has cost hundreds of billions of dollars. Some of that was predictable. The spinach pay-fors (the Cadillac tax and the individual mandate penalty) were repealed, and the Medicaid DSH cuts have been delayed for over a decade. I focused on the major items; several I left out are small and often work in opposite directions. cbo.gov/sites/default/files/…
The ACA paired goodies (new spending) with spinach (Medicare “cuts” and tax increases). Much of the spinach is gone. The Cadillac tax, the health insurance tax, the medical device tax, and IPAB were all repealed, and the Medicaid DSH cuts keep getting delayed. What’s left comes down to four big items. On the spending side: Medicaid expansion and exchange subsidies. On the savings side: Medicare “cuts” and the Medicare and investment income taxes. [The "cuts" were very sensible payment reductions in my view. The best part of the ACA. I never refer to them as "cuts" but am doing so here given how the OBBB's reforms of Medicaid are being inappropriately characterized.] Almost everything else is an asterisk. The employer mandate raises almost nothing. Some small employers stopped offering coverage because of the ACA, which shifts compensation into taxable wages, but the revenue effect has been small. [In my previous estimates, I think I was generous with the amount that is being raised by the Medicare and investment tax by the way.] Rather than relitigate CBO projections built on enormous uncertainty, the best measure of the law’s fiscal effect is to add up the main components. Medicaid expansion plus subsidies clearly exceeds the Medicare “cuts” plus the remaining taxes, probably by quite a bit (unless the Medicare “cuts” were truly massive). And that’s before counting the enhanced subsidies. I think it’s fair to count those too. Many congressional Democrats argue ACA plans are so expensive that subsidies need to be even higher. That’s the law working in practice. And the student loan pay-for has been a fiscal disaster, wherever you place the blame. And even CMMI has raised costs, rather than reduce them...another reason it is foolish to look at what CBO originally thought of with the ACA's fiscal effect! The biggest partisan Republican change, zeroing out the individual mandate penalty in 2017, actually reduced the law’s fiscal cost by lowering subsidy spending. I think CBO overestimated those savings, but it certainly got the direction right. Every other piece of spinach was rolled back in big bipartisan votes. I would love to see the actual math that leads people to think the ACA reduced deficits, even ignoring the student loan debacle.
4
10
31
4,706
David Ditch retweeted
Reminder that our last Democratic president referred to Medicaid provider taxes as "scams" and advocated eliminating them. And the provision in the OBBB to limit them was put forward by @BarackObama in his 2012 & 2013 budgets and by his deficit reduction commission.
Big Dem agenda update: House and Senate leaders plotting out how to reverse Medicaid work requirements and future cuts to provider tax in new Congress. Rank-and-file Dems say Republicans are talking to them about a potential deal, but Dems will go to reconciliation to put them on Trump's desk if Senate Rs block their Medicaid bills - Booker advising single-issue bills to make it harder for Rs to block them: "When you pack in these big bills, it makes it easier to give a pass to Republicans" - Kaine -- future Budget chair -- says there's an "open door" to Republicans: “There’s disquiet on the Republican side about implementing these at all" - Hawley is open to do a deal on provider tax -- he wants to send rural hospitals a dedicated funding stream -- but opposes delaying work requirements @davidalim @nicholaswu12 semafor.com/article/11/18/20…
2
11
2
28
2,151
David Ditch retweeted
I'm in @LawLiberty discussing how fixing Social Security must involve fixing the generational contract lawliberty.org/the-moral-cri…
3
8
214
David Ditch retweeted
NEW: Why should taxpayers subsidize Warren Buffett’s Medicare? Ryan Teetsel argues Medicare is an intergenerational wealth transfer that’s far more lopsided than Social Security. He advocates means-testing Parts B & D. boydinstitute.org/p/medicare…
3
2
164
Borrowing costs respond to policy choices. Washington wants lower interest rates but keeps running large deficits and trade wars that tax everyone and slow growth. Lower rates require reversing course, says Cato’s @norbertjmichel.
3
8
1
21
2,711
David Ditch retweeted
Republicans like Lawler insisted on this provision in the OBBB, and together with Dems like Schumer, they got it. Dems used this provision to brand OBBB as a tax-cut for the rich, and used that to defeat Lawler. Dems will keep this tax cut for the rich, though.
It's all driven by extra SALT for 200k-500k taxpayers who switched from std deduction to itemizing between 2024 and 2025
11
52
163
15,074
David Ditch retweeted
The ACA’s health and tax provisions have significantly added to federal deficits. I forgot yesterday to include the student loan takeover in the ACA’s reconciliation bill. CBO scored it as saving $61 billion over FY2010–2019, based on projected profits from loans made in that window. It didn’t work out that way. @BudgetHawks estimates that loans made from 2015 to 2024, a different and partly overlapping ten years, will now lose more than $200 billion over their lifetimes. Ten years earlier, those same loans were projected to earn $135 billion. That’s a $340 billion swing. Conclusion: The ACA has added hundreds of billions to deficits over the past decade overall, probably exceeding half a trillion dollars once you count the student loan takeover.
Interesting analysis, but this conclusion is almost certainly wrong. The ACA has almost certainly & significantly raised federal deficits. It’s more reliable to answer this question with recent data than with CBO estimates from more than a decade ago. The ACA has four main fiscal effects. Here’s how they roughly stack up in FY2025: Medicaid expansion: ~$155B Exchange subsidies: ~$145B, including the temporary enhanced credits (roughly $30–40B) The investment and Medicare taxes: ~$70B Medicare “cuts”: unknown, and very hard to measure. CBO’s 2015 estimate projected about $153B in savings for 2025. Everything else in the law has had marginal effects, and as Matt notes, several major pay-fors (the Cadillac tax, IPAB, most of the industry fees) have been repealed. For the ACA to have reduced the deficit in 2025, the Medicare “cuts” would need to exceed roughly $230B, well above the $153B CBO projected. (Or $190–200B without counting the enhanced subsidies.) Put differently: even crediting the ACA with CBO’s full $153B in Medicare savings, it increased the deficit by roughly $40–75B in 2025. Caveats: these are rough, back-of-the-envelope figures. CBO’s accounting includes indirect effects, mainly extra tax revenue when fewer people have tax-free employer coverage, which this tally doesn’t capture. But employer coverage has eroded less than anyone projected, so the budget is relatively small.
3
16
2
51
9,108
This was in my feed, quietly mixed in with all the other tweets about how we should massively increase federal entitlements.
37
279
5
1,439
38,773
David Ditch retweeted
Insistence on “buying American” is one of FAA’s biggest problems. They turn to defense contractors and demand poorly defined custom systems, which are inevitably over-engineered, rather than buying off the shelf from leading vendors, many of whom are based in allied countries.
You asked if we’re actually going to spend smart, buy American, and build fast, the answer is 100% YES.
3
14
61
1,958
David Ditch retweeted
Did the OBBB Cut Medicaid? Not if You Apply @KFF's 2012 Logic. The proof: the ACA was projected to reduce Medicare spending by >$700B, and KFF explicitly said this was not a "cut" since spending was projected to increase significantly. 🧵1/3 paragoninstitute.org/paragon…
6
15
2
38
8,002
Rising health insurance premiums are crowding out wages. In the past year, spending on employee health insurance has grown at twice the rate of wages: 6.4% vs. 3.1%. After inflation, wages shrank 0.6%. Workers need relief. cato.org/blog/introducing-un… @CatoInstitute @CatoHealth
30
17
15
67
10,976
The administration has turned executive discretion into a monetizable asset, extracting revenue shares, equity stakes, and fees without clear congressional authorization. The remedy: fewer powers. Cato’s @adamnmichel and @SantiagoForster explain. #CatoRFE ow.ly/E9vG51072jr
3
9
1,682
Cleveland Clinic isn't a rural hospital. But a rural designation is how it qualifies for 340B, and it made an estimated $2.4B in 340B revenue in 2025. It's not alone. “Rural” hospitals in urban areas went from 3 in 2017 to 425 by 2023. That's not what 340B was built for. READ MORE from @Paragon_Inst @rclong1997 ⬇️ realclearhealth.com/articles…
6
21
3
66
4,003
David Ditch retweeted
Congress passed $12.5 billion for air traffic control last year, and now Sean Duffy wants $50 billion more. The optimal amount of taxpayer funding for operating and modernizing air traffic control is $0. @PostOpinions washingtonpost.com/opinions/…
6
17
2
60
6,794
David Ditch retweeted
New from me @PostOpinions: "Economists like me spend much of our time explaining how wealth taxes hurt employers, drive out investment and raise little revenue. But the absurd things people do to avoid them can be even more revealing." washingtonpost.com/opinions/…
2
4
6
401
David Ditch retweeted
Some construction times for comparison: -Chesapeake Bay Bridge: 3 years, 6 months -George Washington Bridge: 4 years, 1 month -Golden Gate Bridge: 4 years, 4 months -Verrazzano Narrows Bridge: 5 years, 3 months -This footbridge: 7+ years
This seems like a good idea but why does it take seven years to plan and construct a footbridge?
3
9
52
2,211
David Ditch retweeted
"(Also, not for nothing: Unlike Trump and other supporters, most tax experts don’t believe that a federal film credit makes much policy sense.)" Not to mention it's $33-$49 billion cost... politi.co/4t4fiFZ via @politico @berniebecker3
1
5
1
5
952
David Ditch retweeted
This is the 30th anniversary of Canada's privatized air traffic control system, which is a global leader in new technologies. Meanwhile, America's system is still trapped inside the dysfunctional federal bureaucracy. cato.org/commentary/air-traf…
44
154
22
598
62,547
David Ditch retweeted
Classic government: Our failure means we need more of your money. Congress passed $12 billion for ATC last year. That's on top of the $36 billion in spending on the NextGen program that mostly failed. But the next billions will do it, for sure.
Transportation Secretary Duffy tells CNN he blames prior administrations for airspace meltdown and calls for more funding to modernize systems. Follow live updates. cnn.com/2026/11/15/politics/…
4
21
4
105
6,987