David Day retweeted
Replying to @MichaelPageFB
"Both leagues are in the sports entertainment business" -- this is a good spot to begin the conversation.
The problem with open systems is that open systems always come with open payrolls. When owners invest significant money into acquiring teams, they (usually) want to spend to protect their investment from the massive devaluation that comes from relegation. That's smart business, right?
The end result of that is what we see in Europe -- which is that most leagues have become defacto "Pay To Win." The biggest clubs spend the most money and sit at the top, trading the title around, while everyone else fights for the right to just stay up and be part of the conversation. Meanwhile, every fan of the "other" clubs silently prays for some billionaire, petrolstate, oligarch, public investment fund, etc. to buy their club and take them.
In America, we organize all of our successful sports around the concept of parity and the idea that every team has an equal chance on an equal field before any season starts. The last two holdouts from this concept are baseball and college football -- and large groups are actively fighting to bring them both to heel via a labor stoppage or congressional action to level the playing field. Parity is basically table stakes for being successful in American sports as an entertainment product.
This is where MLS has the advantage. Is it perfect? Absolutely not. There are definitely things that can and should change about the league to make it better / less complex / more entertaining. But the idea that every team competes on an equal salary playing field and that no one team can buy a title? Brilliant. Should be exported to every single league on the planet.
And that concept only works because the owners all agree that if every team has an equal shot to win, teams shouldn't be punished for having an equal shot at losing. Thus, a closed system.
That's entertaining for American sports fans. What isn't entertaining, and what wouldn't be tolerated, is being a team like Hull or Stoke -- a team where you have no shot to win a title ever, where the best you can hope for is being competitive and not falling out of the league. In America, no one is going to put their money behind a team like that. They'll go and support one of the other teams in town that plays in a league where they can be competitive.
You see this in other sports -- the Steelers and Penguins sell out because their sports allow them to compete. The Pirates need to give a bobblehead away for someone to care about them.
If you can make Parity + Pro/Rel work together then maybe we can have a convo. But, to date, it's never worked anywhere else in the world. And for me, I'd much (by a factor of 10,000) have parity in MLS.


