Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite) header
Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite) profile picture

post-protestant christian | ancient near east explorer | chivalric ethics | farmer | contrarian

Christian Middle Earth
Joined October 2023
Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)Photo by Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 (@Heiserite)
A (probably not yet fully baked) thread on Yahwist Canaanites.
5
8
3
48
6,893
Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 retweeted
Replying to @DPGBehler
Of course the prodigal son was worth being accepted by the Father and back into the family. Only some thing as despicable as Reformed theology even makes this question necessary to ask.
1
2
52
Little tip, if you are a manager at some firm and your department is chronically understaffed, and the company won't hire more people to help you, quit. Something will inevitably go wrong and you'll get the blame. Possible dismissal without severance.
1
9
87
AI slop
Plagiarism, Scholarship, and Moral Inflation The Tendency to Moralize Academic Failures The purpose of this article is not to defend Wesley Huff. If plagiarism occurred, then plagiarism occurred. The question is not whether academic plagiarism is real. The question is whether we have expanded the moral significance of plagiarism beyond what reason, Scripture, and common sense can support. In modern discourse, plagiarism is often treated as a kind of intellectual adultery. Once the accusation is made, many people skip immediately to the conclusion that the accused is dishonest, untrustworthy, intellectually bankrupt, and unfit to be heard. The accusation itself becomes a substitute for argument. This is a mistake. Plagiarism can be unethical. It can be dishonest. It can reflect poor academic habits. But not every academic failure is a profound moral failure, and not every professional violation is evidence that a person's knowledge or expertise should be discarded. The issue requires more careful distinctions than are often made, so I want to analyze this by looking at something completely different. The Disciples in the Grainfield: A Biblical Perspective When Jesus' disciples walked through a grainfield and plucked heads of grain to eat, the Pharisees accused them of violating the Sabbath. Notice what they did not accuse them of? Theft. The reason is simple; the Mosaic Law explicitly permitted travelers to pluck grain by hand for immediate consumption. One could not harvest the field with a sickle, but one could take enough to eat. This creates an interesting principle. The owner of the field objectively lost grain. A material loss occurred. Yet God did not regard it as theft. This matters because many modern discussions assume that any use of another person's resources must be theft. Scripture itself does not operate that way. The Bible distinguishes between unlawful appropriation and lawful use. That distinction becomes important when we move from grain to information. Information Is Not Grain If I steal your grain, you no longer possess that grain. If I steal your sheep, you no longer possess that sheep. If I steal your money, you no longer possess that money. Biblical theft consistently involves deprivation. Someone loses possession of something tangible, but Information behaves differently. If I learn an idea from you, you still possess the idea. If I copy a sentence you wrote, you still possess the sentence. If I adopt an argument from your book, your argument has not disappeared. Information is not rivalrous in the way grain, livestock, or money are rivalrous. This is why simply asserting that plagiarism is theft often feels philosophically unsatisfying. The categories are not obviously the same. The Problem with "Stealing Credit" People often respond that plagiarism is not theft of information but theft of credit, but what is credit exactly? Credit is not an object. It is not a piece of property. It is not a thing that can be physically possessed. Suppose I falsely claim to have written a chapter that someone else wrote. The original author remains the author. The historical fact has not changed. What I have done is not literally take authorship from him. Rather, I have lied about the authorship. The injury comes from the false statement. This is why plagiarism appears much closer to false witness than theft. The fundamental offense is not: "I took your idea." The fundamental offense is: "I falsely represented my relationship to that idea." That is a truthfulness problem. The Myth of Original Ideas There is another difficulty. No ideas are truly original. Every scholar stands on previous scholars same with theologians and writers. Augustine influenced the medieval theologians. The medieval theologians influenced the Reformers. The Reformers influenced modern Protestants. Modern scholars inherit concepts from all of them. Consider Dickens: "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times." Dickens did not invent contrasts. He did not invent language. He did not invent rhetoric. What he produced was a memorable arrangement of preexisting concepts. That line I just stole for this article. That is how nearly all intellectual work functions. Knowledge advances through combination, refinement, adaptation, and transmission. If all use of prior ideas is theft, then civilization itself becomes theft. Human learning looks much more like gleaning than stealing. We walk through the intellectual fields planted by previous generations and gather what they have left behind. This is becoming even more ambiguous today, I used AI to write this article, AI uses all of the accumulation of human knowledge in its training data, is any of this actually my idea? Ethics and Morality Are Not the Same Thing One of the biggest confusions in this discussion is the collapse of ethics into morality. Ethics are duties and responsibilities attached to roles not dictates of right and wrong. An ethical obligation is not automatically a moral absolute. Consider attorney-client privilege: A client admits to a horrifying crime committed years ago. The lawyer may be ethically obligated to maintain confidentiality, that is morally troubling. The point is not that ethics are irrelevant, but that ethical duties arise from particular roles, while moral duties arise from broader principles. As a scholar you have duty to give credit where credit is due, but that is an ethical duty not a moral one. Plagiarism Does Not Refute Knowledge This brings us to the issue that sparked this discussion. Suppose a biblical scholar commits plagiarism. What does that mean? Does he lack the knowledge he has put forth in his interviews? Does he misunderstand the sources he has used in his presentations? Are his arguments false? It does not follow that his expertise disappears. A bad student is not necessarily a bad scholar. A person may have poor academic habits while still possessing substantial knowledge. If someone correctly explains manuscript traditions, textual variants, or church history, those explanations remain true or false regardless of who first formulated them. Academic integrity and intellectual competence are corelated but distinct categories. The first concerns conduct. The second concerns knowledge. Conflating the two serves neither scholarship nor truth. Against Moral Inflation One of the persistent problems of modern discourse is moral inflation. Every mistake becomes a scandal. Every scandal becomes a character indictment. Every character indictment becomes a demand for complete disqualification. This tendency is especially common online. But moral categories should be used carefully. If plagiarism involves lying, call it lying. If plagiarism involves vanity, call it vanity. If plagiarism involves deception, call it deception. But we should resist the temptation to treat every failure of academic attribution as though it were equivalent to theft, fraud, corruption, or some comprehensive collapse of character. Precision matters. Especially when discussing morality. Conclusion Plagiarism is a real academic offense. It may involve dishonesty. It may reveal pride, carelessness, or poor scholarly discipline. But it is often treated as a moral category far larger than it actually is. Information is not property in the same way grain or money are property. Ideas are inherited, transmitted, adapted, and recombined across generations. Human learning resembles gleaning from a field more than stealing from a treasury. For that reason, accusations of plagiarism should be evaluated carefully and proportionally. A person can be a poor academic and still be a knowledgeable scholar. A person can violate professional standards without being guilty of the particular moral failings critics frequently assume. The goal is not to excuse plagiarism it is to place it in its proper place. Academic failure is serious enough on its own, it does not need to be inflated into something else.
3
9
450
Poor choice of proof texts. In Matthew Jesus is talking about receiving little ones i.e. this is a work and about character and the treatment of children not about heresy. In Galatians this is slightly better for you but still pertains to a practical matter where Paul is ...
1) Don't Care about Wes Huff. 2) Heresy is worse than Bad Character, like leaps and bounds worse, that is not me that is Jesus and Paul and Peter: Matthew 18:6 Galatians 1:9 2 Peter 2:1 Titus 1:11 Luke 17:2 Romans 16:18 Deuteronomy 13:1-3 Better to have a millstone fastened around his neck... Tell me it would be better for Wes Huff to have a millstone around his neck. The real problem with Christianity is no one actually believes it anymore, ETERNAL DAMNATION? nbd. He is dishonest at work? CRUSIFY HIM!
3
5
182
...actually saying that Gentiles can be righteous God fearers and take part in the new eschatalogical community without adhering to the doctrine of circumcision!
3
40
This is a problem with much of Christianity. Saying that heresy is worse than bad character. One guy has an independent thought that differs from the consensus and is reviled, another is being dishonest about his work and is defended.
Replying to @ProvisionistP
Hmmm....Leading people away from Christ or not giving some people a citation in papers virtually no one will read...its really sad. I get you are making a joke but you are equating something like jay-walking to actual heresy. I am afraid of what this says about you...
2
3
2
13
288
Michael Heiser was accused of pelagianism but never plagiarism.
5
2
45
3,854
Ideology is powerful. Positive when it aligns with reality, destructive when it contradicts it.
3
93
Remember, a lot of misbehaviour by small children is because their brain is still developing.
11
296
I'm tweeting from your future. Tomorrow will be OK.
3
14
235
Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 retweeted
Replying to @ImprecatoryOne
We don’t have to live like this
1
6
56
Heiserite ✝️ 🇦🇺 retweeted
Idk who needs to hear this but Plagiarism is not a mistake.
14
4
1
52
2,508
In more traditional societies, men sit on one side of the church, women on the other. Husband and wife sitting together is a modernist, egalitarian, petty bourgeois.
The Gospel Coalition is evil.
7
142
Once you see how human the Bible and Christianity is, it's not quite the same after that. I can see how people resist looking into things too deeply. And in a way perhaps remaining "blue pilled" is a happier existence and I wouldn't take that away from anybody.
4
1
16
527
...information they will find gaping holes in the world view they were raised in. Upon this happening the intelligent will often give up, while the unthinking remain, having a disgenic effect over time. So while "blue pilled" Christians may be fairly happy and often are...
1
1
12
120
... salt of the earth kind of people, it is still death to a sect if no one within it tries to wrestle with the discoveries of the historical-critical method in scholarship, in our information age.
14
77