Henric (@HenricCont) profile picture

“Il faut cultiver notre jardin”

Joined April 2018
Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)Photo by Henric (@HenricCont)
No matter what MMT tries to claim the real tax is paid when gov spends, by transfer of goods and service from private to public. The rest is just funding. If gov issue money and the money gets its value from taxation then its the tax payer. If the issue more, then devaluation.
27
11
6
59
25,341
@grok explain the biggest errors this MMT post makes.
1
1
3
97
Modern Monetary Theory is wrong and does not grasp the difference between fiscal policy and monetary policy. In consequence it misleads those who follow MMT. The Central Bank’s MONETARY POLICY manages the quantity of money in the economy through Open Market Operations. This is buying debt which adds new money and selling back debt which withdraws money from the economy. QE and QT are transparent versions of this process. This quantity of money can be managed irrespective of whether the government spends more, less or even nothing at all. The government’s FISCAL POLICY is how it finances its spending and whether it budgets for a deficit, surplus or balances its budget has no effect on the quantity of money in the economy except under one special case. If the government overspends its budget and cannot sell all of its debt then some is left unsold at the Central Bank. The money is spent and claims are settled by the Central Bank printing new money to the value of that debt. The main pillar of Modern Monetary Theory is that government spending creates new money and taxation destroys it. This is totally wrong as this process just redistributes money that is already in circulation. Please pass this on to MMT and all its followers.
13
8
17
855
Another MMT junkie who thinks I don’t understand MMT because I say that according to it a (fiat issuing) government’s money creation capacity isn’t itself resource constrained.
Sonny, if you don't READ the books or the hundreds of posts that point this out, you have no standing to criticize. From Keynes to Kelton, real resources are identified as the limitation on money creation. Stop Lying.
4
4
1
37
2,005
Replying to @RedMMT
It's not a waste of time at all. Hopefully your readers are seeing that MMTers don't know nearly as much about all of this stuff as they think! :-)
2
3
1
13
461
“Saying ‘inflation is the limit’ is like saying you can keep jumping from higher cliffs until you break your legs. The injury tells you you’ve exceeded the "limit." 🤦‍♂️ MMT ers make MAGAs look smart.
1
1
20
Replying to @RedMMT
MMT people are the ones "tangled up" on these concepts with your "vertical" and "horizontal" money and all. It's all nonsense. Bank deposits are every bit as good as money as cash or reserves are. They're not derivatives or subordinate forms of money. But MMT has to present them as such because if banks create an equal form of money then MMT's entire "state theory monopoly" becomes obviously wrong.
7
2
13
566
I like Lyn's work but it's wrong to say bank deposit creation is "IOU" creation and not money creation. That treats state money as the only real money. It's an excessively government-centric view of how money gets created, a mistake MMT ironically makes too. Reserves sit above deposits in the settlement hierarchy, but that doesn't make deposits any less money. It's fine to say deposits are an IOU, but deposits are absolutely money. They're the money households and businesses actually hold and spend, and they're accepted virtually everywhere. Banks make loans, which create deposits, and find the reserves after the fact. Reserve balances don't constrain lending for well-capitalized banks. And it's not the bank's IOUs that "fail at scale." A loan creates two IOUs: the borrower's loan, which is the bank's asset, and the deposit, which is the bank's liability. It's the assets that fail, not the deposits. Asset losses are a capital problem and the Fed can't print capital. Deposit runs are a liquidity problem, and the Fed lends reserves against collateral. SVB had discount window access and still failed because unrealized securities losses had already wiped out most of its capital on a market value basis. Capital, not reserves, is the constraint for banks. Banks don't lever reserves. They lever their capital. This matters for understanding the plumbing of the money system because deposits get created two main ways: when banks lend or buy securities, and when the Fed buys assets from nonbanks. Both are money creation, with different economic impacts. Treating bank lending as IOU stacking on top of state money diminishes how banks are major money creators in their own right and why the Fed interacts with them the way it does.
Banks don't lend reserves. They lever reserves and make IOUs on top of them, rather than "creating money." But then whenever those IOUs start to fail at scale, the central bank creates more reserves for them. Over the past 50 years, if the US central bank held reserves flat and banks kept making money, there'd be a 160-to-1 ratio between deposits and reserves, which would be untenable. However, whenever it comes even slightly untenable, the central bank creates more reserves and swaps them for assets from banks, boosting the ratio and giving banks more lending/leveraging ability to keep it growing. The US bank deposit-to-reserve ratio is under 4-to-1 because the central bank accommodates bank lending by creating new reserves.
30
29
10
218
25,887
The only thing worse than an MMT groupie is an MMT groupie who doesn’t even get the soundbites right. It’s notorious that according to MMT money is the one thing governments need never run short of owing to real resource constraints.
If you, or someone you know, has problems with reading or comprehension. Call for help. Dial 1-800 MMT-WINS
6
5
2
57
4,309
The concept of Modern Monetary Theory is so comically flawed that it’s not even worth a debate. Here are just two reasons it fails dramatically. One pillar is that the only constraint to rapid money creation is inflation. When the lever pullers see inflation they quickly raise taxes to pull money out of the system. Here’s the problem. The government has been awful at identifying persistent inflation (see 2021). The government would never raise taxes in periods before an election for fear of losing their jobs. This then morphs into stage two. In stage 2 government can only “do their job” if they don’t have to worry about reelection. So in five minutes MMT just morphed into a dictatorship…
49
24
137
6,223
Replying to @ProfessorWerner
MMTers are just enablers for socialist debt binges: pseudo-science for a cushy institute job. MMT has zero empirical basis. The only MMT 'experiment' is the nuclear-backed petrodollar—and Japan was just the bank for Wall Street carry trades.
1
1
5
269
MMT has been deceiving you. Government deficits don't create money. That's what Steve Keen is finally coming round to agreeing with me. See sciencedirect.com/science/ar… Or my book New Paradigm in Macroeconomics. Or my book Princes of the Yen, new only at www quantumpublishers.com
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create. When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system. Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals. The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled. This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today. Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector. The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban. #Economics #GovernmentDebt #MonetaryPolicy #Eurozone #SteveKeen
64
73
16
357
34,133
Henric retweeted
2 against 1, and it's still unfair for the 2! @saifedean destroys MMTers 🔥 “you haven't given me one reason why I would in any way sympathize with the existence of central banks, except for the fact that you just cannot fathom the idea that they don't exist. And because of the fact that you continue to assume that all of their actual track record of the last 112 years — raping, pillaging, and destroying the planet, and funding war and funding mass theft and genocide, and creating a global enslavement system where the entire planet is being impoverished to enrich a few small group of people — you want to treat all of that as just something that we could just ignore.” “You are under an extremely delusional belief that somehow if we just vote for the right kind of thieves, we can fix this institution that has caused more evil than anything in human history, and replace it with pink unicorns and flowers, and fixing the weather and climate change, and fixing homelessness, and all of that stuff. No, you can't.” Full episode: youtu.be/vgsSZ4mAHfQ open.spotify.com/episode/5Ky…
12
129
21
578
35,708
Watching these commie marxists spewing their delusions is painful, @saifedean spoke truth, and these MMT'ers are actually appalled at simple truths- this is actually painful
17
43
4
373
12,899
Fascinating debate Issues discussed: the nature of money, inflation, capitalism, central banking, the optimal monetary regime, Bitcoin, etc. @saifedean completely annihilates the statist and confused arguments of @ptcherneva & @jasonhickel youtube.com/watch?v=vgsSZ4mA…
6
11
103
2,733
"MMT is the culmination of the spending illusion and, as such, the unwanted stepchild of the neoclassical quantity theory." Chapter 2: The Spending Illusion: From Classical Monetary Theory to Modern Monetary Theory by @jtsale mises.org/library/book/anti-…
LOL, Fed, don’t you have anything better to spend your research resources on? Why do you keep jerking off to the quantity theory of money? MV=PY is an identity in which V=PY/M is determined residually. The velocity of money is not an independent parameter; that is, it changes endogenously with lending, portfolio preferences, incomes, and expenditures of economic agents. Without an independent model determining V and identification of causal relationships, your conclusions risk being nothing more than circular reasoning.
1
4
18
1,890
I taught these basics for 30 years precisely to keep students from succumbing to the crude fallacy that bank lending requires no input save “thin air.” So it pisses me off to see MMT and other heterodox hucksters fobbing off the “thin air” fallacy repackaged as profundity.
1/ George and I were consistent the whole time. I'll start with the 'market forces' that constrain money creation and individual bank lending behaviour, since that will teach you why i) deposits FUND loans, ii) why banks cannot lend limitlessly even to limitless solvent borrowers
6
10
1
76
3,817
Henric retweeted
Setting Marxism aside, probably the closest thing to a flat-Earth theory in economics is MMT. Its proponents are people so confused by accounting identities that they are unable to grasp the distinction between nominal and real variables.
Saying that saving creates investment is the flat-Earth theory of economics
10
34
320
5,311
Replying to @foscaecon
@foscaecon doesn't seem to understand the chartalist/MMT theory that @WilliamJLuther's article challenges, so let me to remind him: according to that theory, the value of fiat money depends on the public's need for it to pay taxes to the issuing gov't. "Ghost" gov'ts don't tax.
I always find it amusing when people treat social and economic theories as if they were laws of physics carved into stone tablets. Guys, social regularities are historically contingent. When structural and institutional conditions change, so do the regularities themselves. But that's not even the funniest part of the Somalia story. Somalis continued using a currency originally created by the state even after the central government had effectively collapsed. In other words, the state had ceased to function, but its institutional ghost lived on in people's monetary relations and collective expectations.
4
3
1
33
1,886
Just remember, people spouting MMT static accounting tautologies reveal their total incomprehension of the matters on which they never cease to pontificate.
Just remember: 1. Spending creates income. 2. Loans create deposits. 3. Taxes do not fund spending. 4. Government deficits create non-government financial surpluses. 5. Real resources, not money, constrain sovereign government spending.
1
3
178