rta_askjames retweeted
If you have 7 hours of free time today, here’s my comprehensive philosophical case for God’s existence!
youtu.be/erpKBoPQxN0
rta_askjames retweeted
I get a lot of questions and responses from non-believers that show a stubborn strain of positivism is still alive and kicking—waving its “trust-the-science” flag like it’s the final word on everything.
Positivism, as a philosophical approach, insists that genuine knowledge comes only from observable, empirical facts gained through our senses and the scientific method. In short: if science can’t verify it, it isn’t knowable. Its founder was the French philosopher Auguste Comte (1798–1857). Shaken by the bloody chaos of the French Revolution, Comte dreamed of rebuilding society on a purely “rational” and “empirical” foundation—one that banished theology, metaphysics, intuition, and speculation. I can’t blame the guy for wanting stability after that nightmare. But it’s almost comically naive to think humans could (or would) sustain a society whose core principles rested solely on science.
Here’s a perfect example of positivism’s blind spots. In Comte’s era, the best scientific knowledge and human senses available led him to declare that we would never know what stars are made of. It seemed eminently rational at the time—how on earth could we travel to distant stars to sample them? His boxed-in view of science, the universe, and human ingenuity left no room for creative breakthroughs.
Shortly after his death, Comte was spectacularly proven wrong. In 1859–1860, German physicist Gustav Kirchhoff and chemist Robert Bunsen (of Bunsen burner fame) unlocked the secrets of stellar composition through spectral analysis. They showed that by spreading light from a distant star into a spectrum, you could identify its elements from unique sets of spectral lines. Comparing lab spectra of known elements to the Sun’s absorption lines, they identified sodium, iron, calcium, and more in the Sun’s atmosphere. Astronomers like William Huggins soon extended this to other stars, proving they contain the same elements found on Earth. And in 1868, Pierre Janssen and Norman Lockyer discovered helium in the Sun’s spectrum during a solar eclipse—before it was ever found on our planet.
If none of this had happened, I wouldn’t be an astrophysicist today. Like most people in my field, my entire research career rests on spectral analysis of light from distant objects. I’m endlessly amazed by it—not just for the meaningful work it gives me, but for the practical wonders and knowledge it’s unlocked for humanity. I love science. But I’m not blinded by that love into believing we could build a stable society on science alone. ...
Want to read the rest of this? Hit the link below to go to my website where I offer this article and more than 100 others for free. You can also sign up to have my articles delivered straight to your inbox. (I know it's annoying to click out of here to read something, but X's article feature provides zero reach.)
Critics: Read the article first.
rta_askjames retweeted
“Paul was never approved by the disciples”
False.
Replying to @naicenamebaye
Paul was never approved by the disciples, but I do agree he met them, even acted like he was among them.
A wolf in sheeps clothing
rta_askjames retweeted
Christian doctrine is always received, contested, and interpreted through Scripture, tradition, worship, ecclesial authority, social location, and historical context. The Bible is often selectively used to authorize negotiated outcomes, but not merely so.
If there's a view that I have had to change over time its this one. From purely creationist point of view to EC. I need to read these books if you have a way I can find them, that'd be amazing @doofgeek4011
My view is evolutionary creation (EC). It's a Christian position on origins and an explanatory system that seeks to incorporate the best scholarship from science and theology.
biologos.org/common-question…
1
33
rta_askjames retweeted
The Big Bang theory says the observable universe has expanded and cooled from an early hot, dense phase, possibly after an inflationary and reheating phase, with support from galactic recession, light-element abundances, and the cosmic microwave background.
💯
Yes, though not because I think God is an object inside the universe, a teapot-like posit, or a conclusion that can be proven so that every rational person must believe it.
academia.edu/122349947/The_E…
I believe in God because, after a comprehensive weighing up of theistic and...
23
rta_askjames retweeted
The pseudepigraphal literature, including 1st Enoch (typically what we refer to as “the Book of Enoch” — there are 3 but the 1st on is the famous one), operated within a fundamentally different literary framework than modern historical narrative. 1st Enoch is a pseudepigraphal, apocalyptic collection of narratives and visions ascribed to Enoch. This was a genre that deliberately attributed writings to ancient figures to claim authority rather than to deceive readers about authorship.
Understanding the genre’s intention requires recognizing its theological purpose. As a collection, 1 Enoch offers a glimpse of what was likely a common worldview during the later 2nd Temple period (1st Enoch almost certainly doesn’t predate this time), which identified the world as an evil and unjust place in which the Jewish people awaited the redemption of God in their eschatological world.
The primary message was the soon-coming divine retribution of enemies and the judgment and eradication of evil that permeated the cosmos, with the author’s truth and authority relying on his heavenly journeys during which God gave him divine revelation of the coming redemption of the righteous.
Rather than presenting factual history, pseudepigraphal works employed symbolic and visionary language to convey theological truths about divine judgment and redemption. Topics like angels, demons, the spiritual realm, and the coming Messiah are all being fleshed out by this type of work.
1st Enoch offers an embellished textual tradition of Gen.6, and the pseudepigraphal accounts parallel the Septuagintal tradition, reflecting the interpretative biases of the period. This interpretative expansion, albeit not literal reporting, was the genre’s defining characteristic.
The New Testament’s engagement with 1 Enoch further illustrates this point: Jude draws from the pseudepigraphal book of 1 Enoch, with Jude 14-16 detailing a “prophecy” made by Enoch regarding judgment on sinners and the ungodly, drawing on 1 Enoch 9:1, Jude cites Enoch not as historical documentation but as authoritative theological witness to eschatological judgment. The pseudepigraphal genre was never intended as literal history; it was visionary theology dressed in ancient authority.
The question remains, if we take Enoch seriously as actual history then why not the myriads of other pieces of ancient Jewish a Pseudopigrapha, a vast literary catalogue: the Apocalypse of Abraham, Apocalypse of Adam, Apocalypse of Daniel, Apocalypse of Elijah, Apocalypse of Zephaniah, and multiple versions of Baruch (2, 3, and 4 Baruch) and Ezra texts (including the Greek Apocalypse of Ezra, Questions of Ezra, Revelation of Ezra, and Vision of Ezra)? The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs represent a major collection, along with individual testaments attributed to Moses, Job, Solomon, Adam, and the Three Patriarchs (Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob), why not toss them in as well? All the same genre and vein that Enoch finds itself in.
The collection extends to works attributed to David (More Psalms of David), Jeremiah, Isaiah (including the Vision of Isaiah), Habakkuk, Zephaniah, Zechariah, and multiple works attributed to Solomon, including the Psalms of Solomon and Testament of Solomon. The Sibylline Oracles, Eldad and Modad, and the Book of Jubilees also claim ancient authorship. Some of these documents in their earliest iterations are as early as the 3rd century BC (through others the 4th or 5th centuries AD).
Sure, read 1st Enoch. But don’t confuse it for something it isn’t.
rta_askjames retweeted
Here are 4 philosophically robust (and introductory) cases for Theism that are far better than Douthat's book. I do appreciate PhilRel going main stream, but we shouldn't sacrifice our standards and rigor for the sake of popularity.
A philosopher utterly wrecks Ross Douthat's terrible arguments for God in his book about why "everyone should be religious": currentaffairs.org/news/ross…
rta_askjames retweeted
A common response to the fine-tuning argument is to say that of course the universe is finely tuned, because if it wasn't we wouldn't be here to observe it.
That's a truism and a tautology, not an explanation.
Think of it this way. You're standing before a firing squad of dozens of skilled shooters, all with loaded weapons pointed straight at you, who all fire at you simultaneously. Yet you walk away unscathed. Your response? Well, if I hadn't survived, I wouldn't be here to observe it. Does that explain this extremely improbable outcome? No. It's a statement of the obvious, but you'd be searching for answers.
In the same way, the fine-tuning of the universe to allow conscious life cries out for an explanation. The possibilities are that this happened by
1. Chance
2. Necessity
3. Design
Option 1 is the firing squad problem. The odds are so overwhelmingly against this "just happening" that proponents have resorted to untestable and bizarre explanations like an infinite multiverse.
There is no evidence for Option 2. Nothing in the laws of nature requires the finely-tuned parameters of the universe to be the way they are.
Logically, this leaves Option 3 as the most probable explanation.
When I was a physics student coming out of my lifelong atheism, I was deeply moved by this argument. It didn't matter what my prejudices were, the logic was so sound that I couldn't see any way around it.
rta_askjames retweeted
A long wait isn't, by itself, evidence against divine action. Unless he shows that God couldn't have good reasons for a long preparatory history, the timeline alone does no argumentative work. Btw, his account of the Incarnation & atonement is a strawman.
vatican.va/content/catechism…
The idea that god would wait 13 billion years (universe start) or even 4.5 billion years (earth formation) or even 8 million years (human ancestor identified) or even 300,000 years (modern human identified) before he sent himself down in the guise of his son to be brutally murdered to forgive himself for misdemeanours against himself is too ridiculous to be believed in the 21st century.
Lovely
The Ethiopian Ge’ez Bible is an incredible contribution to the Bible’s translation history, but it is *not* considered the oldest and most complete Bible. The Garima Gospels (which only includes the 4 Gospels in Ge’ez) date no earlier than the 4th century and more likely come from the 6th century. We don’t have an extant complete Ethiopian Bible until the 14th century. P45 (sections housed at the Dublin, Chester Beatty Library and Vienna, Austrian National Library) is our earliest collection of the four Gospels and Acts all in one volume predates the Ethiopian collection by 200 years. We have entire Genesis to Revelation copies of the Bible in Greek centuries prior to any analogous Ethiopian version. The Bible in the picture of the OP is from the 16th century.
16
Love this
An ambitious high schooler asked me for advice about his chances in succeeding in a career in philosophy. "Is it worth trying?" Here was my answer for anyone else who might benefit or be interested:
<<
Thank you for your message.
To your questions, my *general* advice is to continue to follow your inspiration. It is hard to say what job opportunities will be available to you, or even whether you will create your own platform to hire others based on your natural interests and accumulation of knowledge over time. In my case, at age 15, I read philosophy, reflected on my own, and wrote down my ideas in various forms. These activities were fun, and they opened up more opportunities later. I pursued an undergrad degree in computer science, thinking that would be more lucrative and also personally aligned, but in the long term, it was my philosophy interests that won out (with computer work serving my idea work). As I think of it, I didn't even need to choose between computer programming and philosophy, but rather to orient which activity serves which.
I read somewhere that half the people who start a grad program in philosophy finish it, and then only half of those who finish it get a job as a professor. A good grad program is also very selective. I think Notre Dame accepted about 5% of applicants when I applied. So a particular track to a job as a philosophy professor tends to be rare and narrow.
But I did not calculate ahead if I would succeed, but instead I followed my inspiration. I think a person succeeds *100% of the time* at reaching the results of their inspiration. You might find that your inspiration leads you along a winding road that is unique to you, or you might find familiar, universal steps along the way. Either way, your inspiration is the your greatest power to both discover your path of success and to reach it.
Hope that helps,
Josh
9
Amazing
The story of the feeding of the 5k is a treasure mine for analysis. It is the only miracle besides the resurrection of Jesus that is found in all 4 Gospels. This story allows us to read it across each account and check for corroborative or contradictory details, that would allow us to validate it as a historical event or identify it as a fraud. What we find then in this particular story is very helpful
12
rta_askjames retweeted
I am thrilled at the atheist response to my post about new scientific developments in biology, since it shows the ignorance of atheist ideology. Many comments ask me to present references, which allows me to promote my book "Beyond Evolution" which is full of citations.
#NewProfilePic
It's a bit of rebranding and refocusing. Hope you still continue with me 😌
1
41






































