James Sinclair retweeted
Exactly.
How many missiles and drones were fired at warships in the Red Sea and how many hit...
Making generational affecting defence decisions on the basis of poorly understood events in a localised area, is a truly dangerous step to take.
The sinking of RFS Moskva has much in common with the loss of HMS Sheffield in 1982. Navies can expect to lose ships in a war, especially if badly-equipped or the crew is not operating at peak performance.
It would be a big mistake to think the lesson is that "expensive" warships should be abandoned in favour of "cheap" uncrewed systems.
James Sinclair retweeted
Odin's Eye Extra: What fate the once proud British frigate HMS Lancaster, marooned in a decommissioned state in Bahrain, where the US 5th Fleet HQ and nearby naval support facility (wherein the ship lies) are said to be under Iranian missile attack?
The plight of the Duke Class (Type 23) warship is emblematic of a current (and also previous) UK Govt having no serious interest in naval matters, or it would not also have discarded the LPDs (and the concept of having a littoral group in that part of the world ready to evacuate British citizens). Or allowed Britain's once world-leading mine warfare capabilities (useful in past war for keeping shipping lanes free of mines) to degrade further. The UK Govt, which has allowed frigate after frigate to pay off years before new ones are commissioned, was relaxed about seeing off another in Bahrain, without the expense or trouble of getting the vessel home.
It also seems unconcerned about not having replaced the RFA Argus as a Primary Casualty Reception Ship and not vexed either by no RFA Diligence-style forward battle damage repair vessel (in case shore bases become untenable - there again if you have no naval presence there's nothing to get damaged).
Not that the Royal Fleet Auxiliary as a whole is of much importance, or so it seems - a service the UK Govt is content to see degrade and become inactive due to strikes by its personnel over pay and conditions.
The message on the proper use and deployment of naval power even in a defensive respect is clear. No clue. No care. And the new war in the Middle East will once again expose that fact.
The UK knows how to send a few fighter jets to Cyprus and the Middle East, and that is about it. You are on your own UK citizens in the firing line - with the airports and bases under missile blitz, crack on with begging for a place on someone else's ship (or just hunker down)! Britain in 2006 still evacuated its citizens by sea from war zones - using some of the very vessels that have now been binned.
James Sinclair retweeted
Awwww did someone take your hard work and use it to train a model to mimic your expertise without compensation
James Sinclair retweeted
Dr Christine Goulter, in her work ‘A Forgotten Offensive’, stated that aerial minelaying sank one vessel for every 31 sorties, whereas the (more photogenic) ‘direct attack’ required 104 sorties per vessel sunk, with significantly higher loss rates in aircraft.
During WWII mines laid predominantly by British aircraft sank a total of 255 German military and 631 merchant ships worth 168,271 and 683,630 tons respectively in the waters off NW Europe. This cost the British 533 aircraft in return during minelaying sorties. #TheLongestCampaign
What an epic few days. Huge thanks to everyone who supported / donated, my van was full on arrival. Anyone wanting to do more - speak to the White Eagle Club! Thanks @MontyHalls for organising and letting me contribute.
Replying to @MontyHalls
@MontyHalls #MontysHaul #Van2 has arrived. Absolutely full, as is the white Eagle Club, a phenomenal central logistics hub.
1
1
James Sinclair retweeted
Van now three quarters full, and one last stop to do! Thanks a million one and all. Next stop Donnington - be there in 45 minutes or so. Folks are buying decent medical kit online, and giving it to us in the van - a brilliant effort by all. #Ukraine
Replying to @MontyHalls
@MontyHalls #MontysHaul day 2 schedule:
#Van1 LymmTruckstop 09-10
RivingtonSvcs 1035-1135
DonningtonSvcs 1515-1615
#Van2 LiecsterForestEastSvcs(N) 09-10
Newport Magnell Svcs 1050-1150
Cambridge Svcs 1310-1410
Replying to @MontyHalls
@MontyHalls #MontysHaul #Van1 schedule:
HiltonPark Services 2020-2120
Keele Services 2150-2250
#Van2 schedule
HopwoodPark Services 1945-2045
Corley Services 2125-2225
Liecester Forest East Services 2255-2355
Spread the word! Medical Kit, Torches, warm baselayers.
@MontyHalls #MontysHaul now @ Corley Services Southbound till 2225. Next stop Leicester forest East eta 2255.
1
2
Last stop for #Van2 of #MontysHaul tonight. Liecster forest East. Here for a while then again 0900-1000 tomorrow.
#MontysHaul @MontyHalls van repacked ready to go while @ Gloucester Services. Here till 1840. Next stop #Van1 Hilton Park Services 2020-2120 #Van2 Hopwood Park Services 1945-2045
James Sinclair retweeted
Absolutely - going well with folks offering all manner of great support and donations. Medical kit a priority. Next stop Gordano Services from 4pm to 5pm.
PLEASE RT SHARE @MontyHalls #MontysHaul is off! Vans 1 & 2 @ Exeter Services for the next 30 minutes. MedicalKit, batteries, Torches and baselayers desperately needed. Next stop Taunton Services 1420-1520.
Now at Taunton, next stop Gordano M5 Northbound! #MontysHaul
PLEASE RT SHARE @MontyHalls #MontysHaul is off! Vans 1 & 2 @ Exeter Services for the next 30 minutes. MedicalKit, batteries, Torches and baselayers desperately needed. Next stop Taunton Services 1420-1520.
1
PLEASE RT SHARE @MontyHalls #MontysHaul is off! Vans 1 & 2 @ Exeter Services for the next 30 minutes. MedicalKit, batteries, Torches and baselayers desperately needed. Next stop Taunton Services 1420-1520.
James Sinclair retweeted
A plan is emerging. Tuesday / Weds next week, we'll be at a Motorway Services near you. Got old medical kit, warm clothing, torches, batteries? Please take a moment, take a drive, and make a difference. Route and timings shortly. @BBCDevon





























