
Bookish Christian wife photographing vintage America & old cars. '40s-donning old movie fan. 100% old-fashioned & likes Detroit hockey. #BeautyMatters.
The scenic route.
Joined May 2009
- Tweets161K
- Following5K
- Followers3.4K
- Likes122K
Cute, yes, but he has also demolished three "tough chewer" toys in as many days, and only one is something I'm (probably) able to safely repair. ๐
5
145
My Grant post hit a chord with many. Some took exception to it thinking it denigrated Lee and other CSA commanders.
My whole point is the reputation of Grant as a first-rate military commander has undergone a considerable reassessment in recent decades. Once too often characterized as an unimaginative butcher who prevailed through sheer numerical superiority, Grant is now increasingly recognized as an exceptionally gifted tactician, operational commander, and grand strategist. In my judgment, the reassessment is entirely justified. Indeed, he deserves consideration as perhaps the greatest military commander in American history.
Perhaps his greatest achievement was recognizing that winning a war required something considerably more than winning battles. It required the coordination of armies, resources, transportation, logistics, and political purpose within a coherent strategy. He understood that the Union's advantages would mean little unless they were employed with determination and unity of command.
The old caricature of Grant as a plodding butcher has largely given way to a more informed appreciation of his generalship. It is about time. He was not merely a general who had more men. He was a general who knew what to do with them.
Lee was a great captain. Grant was a great captain who also understood how to conduct an entire war.
And when Grant crossed the Rapidan in May 1864, he established something that had been conspicuously absent from the Union war effort: a commander who would not turn back. That decision, and the strategic resolve behind it, may well have been among the most consequential acts of generalship in American history.
Upon assuming command of all Union armies in March 1864, he understood that the Confederacy had to be confronted as a unified military problem. Its armies could no longer be permitted to operate independently, reinforcing one another or exploiting opportunities created by the inactivity of Union forces elsewhere. Grant established a common strategic objective and coordinated operations across multiple theaters. Sherman, Sheridan, Thomas, Meade, and other commanders would operate within that larger design.
An interesting contemporary document illustrates the magnitude of his authority. A dispatch dated March 18, 1865, from his headquarters at City Point bears the letterhead, "Head Quarters Armies of the United States." Grant signs it simply, "U. S. Grant, Lt. Gen." His formal rank was lieutenant general, but his responsibility extended to the entire Union military establishment. The distinction is significant. He was not merely commanding an army in Virginia; he was directing the military effort of a nation.
His advantage over Lee, therefore, was not simply the number of soldiers available to him. It was that he commanded a unified military system operating toward a common strategic purpose. Lee, for all his brilliance, was operating within a Confederate command structure beset by competing authorities, geographical separation, diminishing resources, and political difficulties. Indeed, Lee himself was eventually appointed general-in-chief of Confederate armies in February 1865, but by then the opportunity for effective centralized direction had largely passed.
The contrast should not be interpreted as a disparagement of Lee. He was a magnificent battlefield commander, possessing extraordinary tactical instincts and an ability to inspire devotion among his soldiers. His victories in the Seven Days, Second Manassas, Fredericksburg, and Chancellorsville remain impressive military achievements. But there is a distinction between winning battles and conducting a war. Lee's invasions of Maryland and Pennsylvania, particularly the latter, involved strategic risks that a resource-poor Confederacy could ill afford. Grant, by contrast, increasingly demonstrated an understanding of the entire war rather than merely the immediate battlefield.
The Overland Campaign of 1864 is perhaps the clearest illustration. After the Wilderness, Spotsylvania, and North Anna, Grant did something that previous Union commanders had repeatedly failed to do: he continued south. Rather than retreating after suffering heavy casualties, he moved toward Richmond and Petersburg. His message was unmistakable. The Union would no longer abandon its strategic objective whenever Lee inflicted a costly tactical setback.
This is where the familiar description of Grant as a butcher becomes particularly misleading. Offensive warfare against a determined opponent, especially one occupying favorable defensive positions, inevitably produces substantial casualties. Lee himself suffered grievously at Malvern Hill, Antietam, and Gettysburg. Grant's losses were enormous, but so were the Confederate losses, and the Confederacy possessed neither the manpower nor the industrial capacity to replace them. Grant understood this asymmetry and was prepared to exploit it. He also understood that the destruction of Lee's army was more important than the capture of any particular piece of territory.
None of this means that Grant was infallible. Cold Harbor was a costly mistake, and his unsuccessful frontal assaults at Vicksburg deserve criticism. But great commanders are not measured by an absence of mistakes. They are measured by their ability to recognize the essential requirements of a campaign, adapt to circumstances, and achieve their objectives. Grant repeatedly demonstrated those qualities.
There is also something particularly admirable about his temperament. He was not given to theatrical displays, grandiose pronouncements, or the cultivation of a heroic public image. He was generally composed, practical, and remarkably persistent. He understood the relationship between military operations and political objectives. The purpose of the war was not simply to defeat Lee, but to preserve the United States. The two objectives were inseparable.
In comparing the great American commanders, Washington must always occupy a unique position as the indispensable military and political figure of the Revolution. Sherman was an extraordinary operational commander, and Lee was unquestionably one of the most gifted battlefield generals of the nineteenth century. But Grant's combination of tactical competence, operational imagination, strategic vision, logistical understanding, and ability to direct a vast military establishment places him in a category of his own.
This is such fun. The knots are terrific!
Welcome to Port Wenn! Who else watches Best Medicine on Fox? This pattern was inspired by the show. #BestMedicine
4
202
Against the dancing in Chick-fil-a ads. They're just...weird.
The country music one was particularly bad.
As someone who can't eat their food, I have no dog in the fight other than not wanting weirdness/cringe and the marvel of fried chicken being associated with one another.
2
2
147
Since my wonderful husband returned home from work several hours ago, I have mentioned the American Civil War three times, WWII three times, WWI once, but the Roman Empire ZERO.
Gotta fix this.
"But God, being rich in mercy, because of the great love with which he loved us, even when we were dead in our trespasses, made us alive together with Christโby grace you have been saved..."
Ephesians 2:4-5
10
152
Jen ๐บ๐ธ retweeted
The pastor ought to have two voices: one, for gathering the sheep; and another, for warding off and driving away wolves and thieves.
~John Calvin
Jen ๐บ๐ธ retweeted
There are different ways of approaching a piece of art, but if you can't talk about art without talking about ideology, politics, or social issues, you can't talk about art.
Jen ๐บ๐ธ retweeted
โCome to Jesus just as you are. Don't delay to cleanse yourself; come to him to do it all.โ
โ Charles Spurgeon
What a handsome place!
Brรธndums Hotel in Skagen, Denmark, was originally a merchant house, but in 1859, merchant Erik Brรธndums was granted the status of host and furnished a few rooms to welcome guests
The house has been expanded throughout the years and has become a desired destination for both artists and culinary enthusiasts. We were lucky enough to have stayed there for a night and drank in the atmosphere of a hotel largely unchanged by time
(In the main house, you don't have an en suite bathroom; you have to go down the hall for both the toilet and the shower and frankly, that inconvenience just adds to the authenticity)
5
82
"For though the Lord is high, he regards the lowly, but the haughty he knows from afar. Though I walk in the midst of trouble, you preserve my life; you stretch out your hand against the wrath of my enemies, and your right hand delivers me.
The Lord will fulfill his purpose..
1
4
63
Oh, like a jewel!
If you love cranberry as much as I do, you'll love this easy cranberry butter. I use the stove top method. Just look how pretty! theviewfromgreatisland.com/mโฆ
5
165































