Anthropology; social progress; happiness; open-mindedness, academic freedom; civilization is for everyone. Also photography.

Edinburgh, Scotland
Joined May 2011
Lots of good things could come from raising awareness of slavery, but only if we do this honestly.
Yes, the monarchy was deeply implicated in the slave trade. But not the British monarchy. The biggest African slavers were not pirates or bandits. They were kings. In the 1750s, King Tegbesu of Dahomey, in present-day Benin, was reported to be making £250,000 a year from selling slaves. That astronomical sum, equivalent to perhaps £45 million today, was vastly more than any British aristocrat While Tegbesu was trafficking human beings, the future George III, who had recently become Prince of Wales, was becoming a convinced abolitionist. He wrote a monograph arguing that “slavery is equaly [sic] repugnant to the Civil Law as to the Law of Nature”. He went on, as King, to sign the abolition of the slave trade into law in 1807. That act prompted incredulous rage among West African chiefs. In the 1840s, King Ghezo of Dahomey, played by John Boyega in the 2022 film, The Woman King, fiercely resisted such pressure. “The slave trade is the ruling principle of my people. It is the source and the glory of their wealth,” he complained. Contrast his attitude with that of his British fellow-monarchs. Although Victoria, as Queen, was expected to refrain from expressing political opinions, her husband was under less constraint. Albert made his very first speech as Prince Consort to the Society for the Extinction of the Slave Trade and for the Civilization of Africa. His words are a reminder of how determined Britain was to ensure that ending the Atlantic slave trade did not simply push the commerce eastwards. “I deeply regret that the benevolent and persevering exertions of England to abolish that atrocious traffic in human beings (at once the desolation of Africa and the blackest stain upon civilized Europe) have not as yet led to any satisfactory conclusion. But I sincerely trust that this great country will not relax in its efforts until it has finally, and for ever, put an end to a state of things so repugnant.” The difference between the British Crown and contemporary African monarchies can be glimpsed in the story of Aina, a young Yoruba girl owned by King Ghezo of Dahomey. In 1850, a naval captain called Frederick Forbes came to Dahomey to try to convince Ghezo to stop selling slaves. He was unsuccessful but, during his visit, he was offered Aina as a gift. Forbes knew that such slaves were generally destined for human sacrifice, so he accepted the child, naming her Sara Forbes Bonetta. When Sara arrived in Britain, Queen Victoria became her godmother, paid for her education and arranged for her to marry a wealthy Yoruba businessman. Are the British really the baddies here? Critics talk of telling our nation’s story “warts and all”; but they rarely get around to the “and all”. The “and all” surely includes the vast sums devoted to stamping out slavery, calculated by Chaim Kaufmann and Robert Pape as 1.8 per cent annually of GDP between 1808 and 1867, the most expensive moral foreign policy in human history. Even if there were a case for reparations in principle (which there is not) that sum alone – not counting the billions given in aid – would surely have covered any debt. What we are seeing is not a debate about history, but an argument about contemporary politics. Critics want to convince us that Britain became rich through exploitation rather than, as was actually the case, through private property, free contracts and independent courts. The easiest way to demonstrate the negative correlation between capitalism and slavery is to look at the places where human bondage is most prevalent today – in order, North Korea, Eritrea, Burundi, the Central African Republic and Mauritania. If William III owning shares in the Royal African Company bothers you more than the continuing abomination of slavery in those places, you need to ask yourself some hard questions about your motives.
1
1
5
236
If you commit to the resistance against genderist insanity, you'll be fighting for lots of values - justice, safety, conviviality, decency, freedom, etc. But most fundamentally, you'll be fighting in defence of truth. Without truth, none of these other values can prevail.
There is no price too high in the fight for truth.
1
4
198
Scotland the dreich. What's not to like?
26
325
Young gulls coping amazingly well with #StormBoelo
1
1
11
280
Full marks for her expressions of moral righteousness. And in the pecking order of morally compelling global issues, the question of which childrens fiction characters are acceptable as Christmas decorations is right up there.
Jolyon's Good Law Project now harassing the Mayor's office because the Oxford Street lights will be Harry Potter themed and therefore trans-exclusionary.
7
324
Those who speak out honestly know they will face hate mail and ostracism. But by trying to prevent unfairness from happening, they're not just protecting women from unfair competition, they're protecting "trans" males from being encouraged to cheat.
The world No. 1 in women's tennis, Aryna Sabalenka, unleashes a devastating and unfiltered statement: "It's vital to protect fairness. Biologically, men are much stronger than women. It's not fair. It's not equality. It's not women's sports if we let biological men compete against us." She sides with Sophie Cunningham and sends a clear message: women are not going to keep staying silent while they steal our titles, podiums, and opportunities from us.
1
21
513
Here you go, another #StormBoelo pic - Eriskay from South Uist this afternoon.
4
4
59
818
And here's the Eriskay causeway staying solid.
3
2
24
406
Weaver's Castle, Stack Island, from Eriskay just now.
1
26
419
Good morning.
3
5
50
546
Good morning.
7
3
62
585
Well, not the best picture but it does capture what it felt like to be on the beach in the teeth of today's #StormBoelo #ICMPhotography
2
2
46
2,270
…and the East-facing kitchen window #StormBoelo. Glad the tide is turning.
1
1
49
1,553
Kitchen window right now #StormBoelo #OuterHebrides
4
3
1
96
2,622
I agree with this except for the last word. Pride, shame, and apologies only make sense for stuff you were in some way responsible for. We shouldn't punish, blame, reward, or praise people for things people did several generations ago.
An excellent letter in The Telegraph today. Hope King Charles takes note !
3
18
560
Two of Glasgow's reputable museums have leapt on the "consentist" bandwagon as an excuse to hide their mummies. It's immature attention seeking. But why? And where might it lead? Must we now close Culloden and Bannockburn because the fallen didn't give consent to be visited?
2
4
45
1,655
So if a player celebrates a goal by taking his shirt off he gets a yellow card, but it's just fine to celebrate by doing a throat-slit gesture? #NotSoClassy @nicholasjackson @AstonVilla @PremierLeague
1
2
261
There's more than a hint of Kafka's Hunger Artist about this video. I'm picturing a huge circle of slack-jawed admirers who gradually, one by one, peel away muttering excuses like "sorry I've got three episodes of Antiques Roadshow to catch up on before Love Island".
This is painful to watch. You can almost see the cogs moving. An absolutist has realised her original position was built on toxic sand and tries to head for decent solid ground. And fails.
2
3
35
3,660
Why did so many posh Brits support communism? And then, why did so many posh Germans support Baader Meinhof? And in this era, now let's ask how so many people became so deeply ashamed of their comforts and privileges that they lurched towards defence of terrorism in desperation.
This has gone viral in France. The wonderful black woman is a credit to France. The smug, haute-bourgeois blonde an embarrassment.
4
2
24
864
Definitely no Storm Austen here in South Uist. Bracing for Boelo though.
3
12
144
2,208
…and looking the other way, a fine moon.
9
90