Replying to @dastarkhon
Who are modern Indian Muslim ? Urdu is isn’t language of all of India. Only one region.
Also setting, clothes & dresses are all urdu speakers.
Literally the grandmas speaks urdu bruh not punjabi or any other language.
7
Replying to @mali36396 @dastarkhon
Yea Persian is a foreign language.
Hindavi (proto Urdu) isn’t foreign and Mughals have nothing to do with it. Mughals nobility itself assimilated to Urdu.
35
Replying to @mali36396 @dastarkhon
It wasn’t language of entire subcontinent bruh
Muslim league imposed it on you. Only few elite in Lahore spoke it.
Iqbal isn’t known in Pakistan for his Persian poetry. He chose two foreign civilizational languages.
Persian & Urdu.
1
2
51
Replying to @mali36396 @dastarkhon
So ??
They wrote in it because Urdu was a civilization language of Delhi & Agra the capital of subcontinent.
Even Marathi Asha Bhosle & Tamil AR Rehman sang in it.
Ahmed Faraz & Iqbal would be nobody if they wrote in any other language.
1
1
54
Replying to @dastarkhon
Says who ?
This is not elite Pakistani culture. This is elite Muhajir/Hindustani Muslim culture. Urdu isnt even native to Pakistan & it’s not your culture
Even a lot of Indian Hindus speaks like this. Here is Gulzar Dehlvi who was invited in mushahira in Karachi.
2
7
186
-M. retweeted
My heart goes out to Mohamed Yusuf and his family following this horrific assault.
The Islamophobia and anti-Somali hate spreading online have real-world consequences.
We must confront this hatred, stand with our Somali community, and demand justice for Mohamed.
-M. retweeted
“Bond should be Black”
“Bond should be a woman”
No. James Bond should be a ginger Muslim revert from Birmingham. He should be Barry from Four Lions.
Replying to @subalterndesi
Tbf political families in India barely even hold land and influence.
Someone with 30 acres is literally a Chaudhary which is nothing. I think 50 acres is max you can own.
1
1
33
-M. retweeted
Wrong. Hindustani is just another word for Urdu.
Hindustani did not predate Urdu. It is the same as Urdu.
British colonial officials were in the habit of using the two terms interchangeably, but the name Urdu soon acquired greater popularity than Hindustani.
However, the two meant the same thing.
Replying to @RupakChatto @amitjulka
No.
Bhojpuri isn’t included in it. It’s just a recent phenomenon.
Closest to khadi boli is braj & haryanvi. Even Awadh was historically periphery of “Hindustan”
17
Replying to @RupakChatto @amitjulka
You are the one who added Bhojpuri & Punjabi in your initial tweet.
Read history of Sirhind and where the word comes from.
East of Sirhind is Punjab and west of Awadh is Bhojpuri.
Hindustani has shared & institionalized literary cannon.
Amir Khusrau wrote in all dialects
1
38
Replying to @RupakChatto @amitjulka
Every language is formed from several regional dialect.
Going by your logic no language exists. There is no Bengali. It is sylhet, rangpuri, rarhi, varendri
Punjabi itself has dialects like jhangochi, majhi, doabi, shahpuri
1
45
Replying to @RupakChatto @amitjulka
No. Urdu and Hindi are register of Hindustani and they are dialect of Hindi.
Even Punjabi can be considered dialect of Hindustani.
1
46












