Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1) profile picture

Catholic convert/revert. Former Nazarene, Presbyterian (PCA). Married 46 yrs. Father of two, one disabled w/CP. Grandpa. Vietnam Vet

Joined October 2021
Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)Photo by Rick Miller (@RickWMiller1)
Rick Miller retweeted
"When I was an evangelical," writes Catholic author Casey Chalk, "we were encouraged to memorize Bible verses that we believed to most succinctly capture the heart of the gospel." These included: “For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God” (2 Cor. 5:21). “He who did not spare his own Son but gave him up for us all, how will he not also with him graciously give us all things?” (Rom. 8:32). “But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed” (Isa. 53:5). Chalk explains that all of these verses were used to support an understanding of salvation known as penal substitutionary atonement. Such a concept effectively means that the guilt of mankind’s sin was transferred to Christ, so God treated Jesus as a sinner, or even the personification of sin, thus necessitating God’s wrath upon him. “Whatever sins I, you, all of us have committed or shall commit, they are Christ’s sins as if he had committed them Himself,” says Martin Luther in his Commentary on Galatians. “Christ is here exhibited in another view, as transferring to himself the punishment due to us, and wiping away our guilt in the sight of God,” writes Calvin in his Institutes of the Christian Religion. But is that the best reading of these verses? There are strong theological and exegetical reasons to say no. First, it is an odd sense of justice indeed that involves transferring punishment from the guilty to the innocent, which does not solve the problem of guilt for committed sins. Indeed, such a framework might actually imply that “one injustice (sin and incurred guilt) is followed by another one (guilt is transferred from the guilty to the innocent),” one that implicates God himself. Moreover, why can God not simply forgive the sins? “Is God the Father so ruthless that someone must necessarily suffer the punishment for sin, and if it is not the sinner himself, then it can (must?) be his beloved Son?” This is a cold, ruthless form of justice, in which God simultaneously loves and hates. What, then, are we to make of the verses above? And what DID Jesus' sacrifice on the cross mean? Read more here: bit.ly/4zRBgPl
10
7
68
9,859
Hadrian renamed Judea with the Roman colonial name "Syria Palaestina" in 135 CE. He changed it after the Bar Kokhba Revolt failed in order to erase the Jews. The Roman Empire is long gone. The Jews are still here.
13
116
5
377
5,014
"Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do; and greater works than these will he do, because I go to the Father.” John 14:12 Q&A 1. What did Jesus mean by "greater works than these" in John 14:12? 2. What are the "greater works" believers will do? 3. How can anyone do greater works than Jesus? 4. Why are the sacraments greater than Jesus' visible miracles? Where does "greater works than these" appear in the Bible? This looks like a good resource for studying Scripture in more depth. Has anyone here subscribed? What do you think of it, and has it been worth the cost? catholicproductions.com/blog…
2
2
57
International law is clear: using civilian hospitals for military purposes makes them legitimate military targets. And it’s a war crime.
International law is clear: hospitals must be protected. Period.
48
316
2
2,579
13,038
Why all schools of Protestantism are wrong. Scripture itself describes authoritative teaching and governance within the Church: Acts 15:6–29: The apostles and elders resolve a doctrinal controversy and communicate a binding decision. 2 Thessalonians 2:15: Christians must hold fast to apostolic traditions taught orally or by letter. 1 Timothy 3:15: The Church is the pillar and bulwark of truth. 2 Timothy 2:2: Paul commands Timothy to entrust his teaching to reliable men who will teach others. Matthew 18:17–18: Christ gives the Church authority to judge disputes and bind and loose.
2
1
4
164
Why Mormonism cannot be true. Matthew 16:18: Christ promises that the powers of death will not prevail against his Church. Matthew 28:20: Christ promises to remain with his disciples until the end of the age. John 14:16: Christ promises that the Holy Spirit will remain with his followers forever. 1 Timothy 3:15: Paul identifies the Church as the pillar and bulwark of the truth.
2
145
Why evoke the story of creation and Eden at the end of the Exodus? “The tabernacle is a portable garden of Eden where God dwells with his people.” Walking with God A JOURNEY THROUGH THE BIBLE, Tim Gray and Jeff Cavins
48
The year is 155. Justin Martyr is defending Christianity to Emperor Antoninus Pius in his First Apology, chapters 65-67. He is not writing theology. He is describing the liturgy to an outsider, matter-of-factly, the way you would describe anything routine. And the routine is the shocking part.
2
8
131
12,894
Most evangelicals can quote John 3:16 by heart. Almost none can quote the verse where Peter says, point blank, "baptism now saves you." It's 1 Peter 3:21. And it's worth reading slowly. The setup is Genesis. Peter points back to Noah: "eight persons were saved through water." Then he says baptism "corresponds to this" and "now saves you." Look at the typology carefully. The flood was not a picture of something that had already happened to Noah. The water itself was the instrument God used to lift the ark and carry those eight souls to safety. Peter deliberately chose a type where water does the saving. Then he clarifies what he does NOT mean: "not as a removal of dirt from the body." In other words, the water is not magic because it washes skin. It saves "as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ." That's an outright exclusion of the bare-symbol reading. If baptism were only an outward sign of a prior decision, Peter had every opportunity to say so. Instead he says the water, joined to Christ's resurrection, saves. Here's the uncomfortable comparison: the same interpreters who insist "this is my body" must be symbolic because a literal reading sounds "too Catholic" also insist "baptism now saves you" cannot mean what it plainly says. At what point does a hermeneutic of "the opposite of Rome" stop being exegesis?
9
21
90
2,489
Rick Miller retweeted
I am profoundly encouraged by Pope Leo XIV's words to the Peruvian bishops that they must combine “doctrinal fidelity with pastoral closeness”, while insisting that they must discern which paths genuinely lead to Christ and denounce those which do not. After years in which the ambiguity and mixed messages of the Francis pontificate too often left Catholics wondering whether pastoral accompaniment was being presented as an alternative to doctrinal fidelity, this clarity is enormously welcome. Of course the two approaches can never be in opposition, authentic pastoral charity demands fidelity to the truth, precisely because it is the truth that sets us free. However, there is an uncomfortable question here because some bishops & cardinals continue to employ a language of accompaniment, dialogue and discernment that seems markedly at odds with the clarity Pope Leo is now articulating. The difficulty is no longer simply what Rome is saying, but whether Rome is prepared to insist that its bishops actually teach accordingly & of course many of Pope Leo's episcopal appointments are men who are openly contradicting much of what he has been saying in South America! Can a change in papal rhetoric alone restore doctrinal coherence after years of confusion? Surely at some point Pope Leo will need to translate his words into episcopal appointments, governance and, where necessary, correction? A Pope teaches not only through his words, but through the shepherds he appoints and the conduct he is prepared to tolerate. The direction Pope Leo is articulating is deeply encouraging, the question now is whether that clarity will become the governing principle of his pontificate.
6
18
1
113
2,665
Jesus “Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven.”
39
What the Catholic Church Teaches About Humility and Becoming Humble The Catholic Church teaches that humility is a fundamental Christian virtue, essential to holiness, prayer, repentance, and our relationship with God and others. Humility is not thinking poorly of yourself. It is seeing yourself truthfully before God, recognizing both the dignity He has given you and your complete dependence upon His grace. The humble person recognizes that everything good ultimately comes from God, that he remains a sinner in need of mercy, and that whatever gifts he possesses are meant to be used in God’s service. But there is something especially important in Catholic teaching: Humility is not simply something we achieve through self-discipline. It is a virtue we cultivate by cooperating with God’s grace. 1. Jesus Christ is our perfect model of humility Jesus gives us a direct command: “Learn from me; for I am gentle and lowly in heart.“ Matthew 11:29 Christ’s humility is most clearly demonstrated in His Incarnation, His obedience to the Father, His washing of the disciples’ feet, and His sacrifice on the Cross. Philippians 2:5–8 tells us that Christ humbled Himself, taking the form of a servant and becoming obedient unto death. Notice that Jesus was humble without ever ceasing to know who He was. He did not deny His divine identity or pretend to be less than He was. Instead, He placed Himself entirely at the service of the Father’s will. This teaches us something essential: Humility is not denying our worth. It is abandoning pride and self-exaltation so that we can love and serve as Christ did. 2. Humility is the foundation of prayer The Catechism is particularly explicit on this subject. CCC 2559: “Humility is the foundation of prayer.” The Catechism explains that when we pray, we must recognize our position before God. We are not self-sufficient. We need His mercy, wisdom, forgiveness, and grace. A proud person approaches God as though God owes him something. A humble person approaches God knowing that everything is a gift. Consider Jesus’ parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector in Luke 18:9–14. The Pharisee boasts about his religious accomplishments. The tax collector acknowledges his sins and asks for God’s mercy. Jesus declares that the tax collector, rather than the Pharisee, went home justified. Religious observance without humility can become an occasion of pride. 3. Humility requires knowing the truth about ourselves St. Teresa of Ávila famously taught that humility is walking in truth. This understanding is deeply Catholic. Humility involves recognizing two truths simultaneously: Without God’s grace, we cannot attain supernatural holiness or salvation through our own efforts. With God’s grace, we are adopted children of God, called to holiness and capable of genuine virtue. Humility therefore avoids two opposite errors: pride, which exaggerates our independence or importance, and false humility, which denies the goodness God has placed within us. A humble man can acknowledge that he has knowledge, ability, or accomplishments without boasting about them. He recognizes those things as gifts and responsibilities. 4. Humility is the opposite of pride The Catechism identifies pride as one of the seven capital sins (CCC 1866). Pride places the self at the center. Humility places God at the center. Pride says, “I know better.” Humility says, “Lord, teach me.” Pride resents correction. Humility is willing to examine whether the correction is deserved. Pride wants recognition. Humility is content to do good without receiving credit. Pride enjoys winning arguments. Humility wants truth to prevail, even when that means admitting an error. Importantly, humility does not require remaining silent when the truth needs defending. Christ Himself corrected error, confronted hypocrisy, and spoke with authority. We can firmly defend the faith while remaining charitable, patient, and willing to learn.
63
Rick Miller retweeted
2
18
34
527
In his wide-ranging interview with President Donald Trump, 60 Minutes correspondent (and devout Catholic) Ross Douthat asked the President if he could forgive his political enemies if it was the only thing standing between him and eternal life. After some back and forth, Trump finally said, "The answer is no. I want to be honest, no...I do hate some of my enemies. I think they’ve been terrible. Look what they’ve put me through, the weaponization." Douthat pressed harder, saying, "Mr. President. You have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me that before the judgment throne of God you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that’s been given to you? Come on. Help me out here." Still unmoved, Trump said, "I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will." Instead of invoking the president’s “most charmed and remarkable life,” perhaps Douthat could’ve more effectively pivoted to scriptural common ground with his Protestant brother in Christ: namely, the Lord’s Prayer. Why? Read more here: bit.ly/4euMGzM
25
2
2
89
12,684
Rick Miller retweeted
PURGATORIAN MANUAL: DAY EIGHT PAIN OF HELPLESSNESS AND DESOLATION The souls in purgatory have entered into the realm of Divine Justice. The penance and satisfaction due for their faults must be made, either by the pain of Purgatory itself, or by the suffrages of the faithful, consisting in prayer, good works and the spiritual treasure of indulgences bestowed upon them; for the suffering souls can no longer merit and are entirely unable to assist themselves. A sick man and a beggar have a tongue to ask for help, and the very sight of their misery will move others to compassion. The suffering souls, however, have no resource but that of patience, resignation and hope. To all their moans there is but one answer, "the night hath come, in which no man can work." Hence in their extreme desolation and distress, they incessantly cry out to us for relief and assistance. But since they can not do this in a manner perceptible to us, holy Church does it for them by instituting many touching devotions in their behalf. Can we, then, be cold and heartless towards these souls? "A hard heart will fare evil at the last." Be not, then, indifferent to your own interests. Prayer: Have mercy, O Lord, upon the suffering souls in Purgatory, in their helplessness and desolation. Comfort them by the prayers and petitions of the just in Heaven and upon earth; shorten the time of their suffering, and reward them with joys eternal. Through Christ Our Lord. Amen. Special Intercession: Pray for the most forsaken and helpless souls. Lord grant them eternal rest, and let perpetual light shine upon them. May they rest in peace. Amen. (Three times) Practice: Deny yourself a little comfort, or some special consolation, and offer it for the most forsaken souls in Purgatory. Invocation: My Jesus, mercy !
8
75
3
274
6,315
Rick Miller retweeted
PURGATORIAN MANUAL: DAY NINE THE PAIN OF FIRE IN PURGATORY The Church has given no decision regarding the word "fire" in relation to Purgatory; but, according to Theologians and Doctors of the Church, we are to understand a material fire. Concerning this, Bishop Colmar of Mayence, a great friend of the holy souls, writes: "Besides being deprived of the vision of God, the souls in Purgatory must endure the torture of a fire, the effects of which are so much more painful because it is an instrument in the avenging hand of God "; a fire, as St. Augustine says, in comparison to which our material fire is as nothing ; a fire that entirely penetrates the soul, in whatever manner this may be accomplished. How, and to what extent this is done, we know not, but may draw our conclusion from similar instances. St. Gregory the Great says : "As the fallen angels, although pure spirits, are tormented by the material fire of Hell, so may a similar fire torture the souls of the departed in Purgatory." The justice of God can punish a spirit by means of a material substance as well as He can in His omnipotence give life to a body by the agency of a spirit. According to the holy Fathers, the fire of Purgatory does not differ from the fire of Hell, except in point of duration. "It is the same fire," says St. Thomas, "that torments the reprobates in Hell, and the just in Purgatory. The least pain in Purgatory," he adds, "surpasses the greatest sufferings of this life." Nothing but eternal duration makes the fire of Hell more forcible than that of Purgatory. Prayer: Refresh, O Lord, the suffering souls in Purgatory, with the dew of Thy grace, that their pains may be relieved, and, in Thy mercy, hasten the moment of their deliverance, that they may meet Thee in Heaven where no fire but that of Thy holy love shall consume them. Through Christ Our Lord. Amen. Special Intercession: Pray for all the souls in Purgatory, particularly for those who are forgotten by their relatives. Lord grant them eternal rest, and let perpetual light shine upon them. May they rest in peace. Amen. (Three times) Practice: Endeavor to spread the devotion for the holy souls in Purgatory as much as possible. Invocation: My Jesus, mercy!
5
42
160
3,509
Rick Miller retweeted
God bless Cardinal Zen.
JUST IN: Cardinal Zen calls for Pope Leo to remove Cardinal Grech, Cardinal Hollerich & Cardinal Fernández from their roles He also urges Pope Leo to put an end to the Synod in Synodality & its follow up stages “If we now seek to accommodate the world, we betray our own mission,” he says re the Synod
17
136
3
1,141
14,974