Pinned Tweet
Brethren of Purity:
We're a collective of followers of various schools of Islamic Philosophy and Mysticism. We've all joined together for one common purpose - to promote The Eternal Wisdom (Hikmah) and to counter a destructive force that is overtaking Islam - Wahabism/Salafism...
Cooked.
Replying to @HikmatiIslam @JohnCleese
We Hikmati Muslims, for example, seek to ground metaphysics in rational argument and investigate historical claims through the historical-critical method, rather than treating inherited religious narratives as automatically reliable.
Consider the accusation that appeared obsessively throughout your replies, and which has become the anthem of uncritical attacks on Islam: Muhammad’s supposed marriage to a nine-year-old ʿĀʾisha.
In 2022, Oxford researcher Joshua Little completed a doctoral study applying rigorous historical-critical analysis to the relevant hadith traditions.
His conclusion was that the famous marital-age report most likely an eighth-century Iraqi forgery, circulating through ʿĀʾisha’s great-nephew to elevate her standing amid early sectarian disputes.
The striking irony is that dogmatic Muslim traditionalists and many of your most aggressively anti-Muslim admirers reproduce precisely the same epistemological mistake.
Your British and American supporters who reacted and the Muslim fundamentalists are the same. One side unquestioningly defends the inherited narrative. The other unquestioningly weaponises it.
Neither has established its historical authenticity by the methods appropriate to historical investigation.
Some among your minority critics may encounter this research, revise their assessment and concentrate instead on better-substantiated objections.
Others will simply repeat the accusation, because their purpose is never historical understanding. Their motive is brute, racist, uneducated hostility - the type of people you targeted in Life of Brian.
That is the difference between criticism governed by evidence and prejudice that merely borrows the language of criticism.
Which brings me to the question of your legacy.
If your objective genuinely is to diminish dogmatism, superstition, injustice, cruelty and religious intolerance, then indiscriminate ridicule of Islam is an intellectually lazy and strategically inferior approach.
You need not become Muslim, accept Islamic Neoplatonism, agree with Hikmati Islam or abandon criticism or mockery of religion.
But you could learn to distinguish the intellectual traditions capable of challenging religious dogmatism from the doctrines and institutions perpetuating it.
You could introduce that distinction to the more thoughtful portion of your audience and support the intellectual legitimacy of movements seeking reform through reason, historical criticism and philosophical inquiry, even while disagreeing with their conclusions.
That would do considerably more to undermine destructive dogma than repeatedly entertaining an audience whose most enthusiastic contributions include unintelligent outbursts, racial abuse, historical misinformation and threats of violence.
Comedy can expose ignorance. It can also legitimise it, entertain it and give it an audience.
You’ve already established your comedic legacy, John.
If you want an intellectual or moral legacy to accompany it, the question is whether you’re willing to pursue the most effective path rather than merely the easiest one.
Brethren of Purity retweeted
Replying to @reasoned_islam @Leafywashere00
Justification is contingent on one’s epistemic horizon.
Muslims for the entirety of Islamic history did not enjoy the benefits of today’s access to accumulated knowledge or intellectual baseline and toplines.
Today, Muslims ought to do better if they want to avoid any materially relevant meaning of kufr: denialism.
Moreover, framing the institution as ‘western’ scholarship is understandable in certain political contexts but it’s better described as simply ‘modern academic’ scholarship.
Finally, naming him Uncle Josh is endearing. We prefer to call him Sheikh Yūsha’ Saghīr (ح).
Reaching haqq requires effort. Part of that effort will be to not merely believe as our forefathers believed.
Brethren of Purity retweeted
Replying to @Haqiqatjou
If Rasūlullāh (ص) were alive today, his primary objective would be to lead the Axis of Resistance.
In his place, Imām Khamenei is taking that responsibility.
We are blessed to be witnessing this. This is how Aqidah is actually forged. You either like a person or hate a person and based on that, develop a ruling on their beliefs.
Thank you Dr Maleek for bringing back the real Salafi method.
Another white supremacist Salafi usually casually racist remarks.
Bro thinks you need to know Arabic to know logic. 😂😂
Logic is language-neutral. Even an Italian-speaking Thomist would deep fry your incoherent theology without understanding even a lick of Arabic.
Both you and your operator are MIA. What happened? No guts to reply?
unavailable
1
21
1,241
Such differences in the Dawah scene will only help Muslims in the long run. Due to such acts, they will probably wake up and realize how shallow the whole enterprise was to begin with.
My intention has always been to invite people to Islam. I understand that certain moments can be taken out of context or come across differently than intended. I always strive to conduct myself with modesty, dignity, and Islamic etiquette.
Some of the comments I’ve seen from so-called Muslim men have been disgusting, vile, and completely unacceptable. It is perfectly fine to voice disagreement without resorting to disrespecting me or my loved ones. I sincerely hope this is not how you would choose to advise your Muslim sisters going forward.
In the context of the conversation, it was evident that I was referring to the topic of debating and did not intend anything other than such.
May Allah guide us all and keep our intentions sincere.
Here is the screenshot of the message sent to @Allahyari5's operator.
Standard debate rules. Neutral moderators. Openings, rebuttals, cross-exam, and closings. Nothing extraordinary.
Now let's see whether Mr. Allahyari runs or not. He knows he doesn't even know the basics.
This is to announce that Allahyari has been invited to schedule a formal debate on Bayat al-Ghadeer's platform, which is likely to be fair to both sides. His operator has also been messaged.
Now, if he runs away, we know exactly who is scared and avoiding the discussion.
unavailable
1. Have you observed the one who denies the ultimate consequences of his actions?
2. He is the one who drives away the orphan with contempt,
3. And does nothing to encourage the feeding of the poor.
4. So woe to those who pray,
5. Yet remain heedless of what their prayers demand
Wahhabism and Racism are inherently connected. It is very hard to find a Wahhabi who is also not racist.
Replying to @AmmarKazmi
You are a Pakistani Marxist sectarian rafidah shia who curses Muslim scholars, supports tyrants who massacre Muslims, and works in Iranian state-owned media studios.
Apart from being Pakistani because you do not represent our Muslim brothers:
pick a bloody struggle.
Just like you lecture people about the benefits and barakat of political quietism and Western Imperialism to the people who suffer because of it?
Checks out.
unavailable
God logic literally didn't deal with any question that cause the Bible (NT) Dilemma and people think he somehow won.
It's beyond ridiculous.
Replying to @DeadMemesSavior @brethrenfpurity
DL literally had no answer to the issues of circumcision, repentance, animal sacrifice, Sabbath observance, kosher diet, Jerusalem temple, oath taking, eye for an eye, and/or why Marcion rejected the Old Testament as canon.
Even Wahhabis are not as braindead as Allahyari followers. Even they realize debates usually happen on neutral platforms and moderated.
It is really Allahyari followers who think that it is absolutely okay for a debate to happen with one interlocutor calling in dhimmi style.
You can cry as much as you want about not being a Zio puppet. The truth is that you are one and that is not going to change.
unavailable












