I mean if you abolish the IRS, you still have to do your taxes. It's weird how you dodged the entire point with a meme.
You can go around “abolishing” those ulema but the question “What physically counts as 'intercourse' when it comes to breaking a fast or Hajj?” still remains.
What an odd comparison. We need the ulama about as much as we need the IRS.
I agree to your terms.
Abolish them both!
35
The IRS has guidelines for criminals to pay taxes on stolen stuff. Here's an absurd delivery:
"What would Americans do without the IRS to tell robbers how to file their taxes?! God forbid they realize that if they’re robbing banks, they have bigger problems than tax compliance!"
What would Muslims do without their millennium of scholarly tradition to tell them whether bestiality invalidates Hajj and fasting?
God forbid they have to use their brains and realize that if they're having sex with animals, they have bigger problems to worry about than whether their Hajj or fasting is invalidated. 🐐
And remember, Malik didn't deal in hypotheticals.
islamweb.net/amp/en/fatwa/32…
If I were the most followed Bible scholar on social media, you'd never hear the end of it.
Replying to @InspiringPhilos
Context for those who like reading things in context.
Idk, call me crazy, but when someone says you have no value because you only produce "unreadable and illiterate" academic work, it doesn't seem out of place to remind them of the well-read non-academic work you have.
6
486
Reasoned Islam retweeted
Life is long . You will change your mind on some of your strongest opinions.
Reposted by David Falk, lol.
Ripping my defenses of my professional integrity & contributions—in the face of attacks on my character because of Huff’s deceptions—entirely out of context to misrepresent them as isolated examples of narcissism is precisely the kind of bad-faith engagement that got IP blocked.
2
15
1,278
Reasoned Islam retweeted
Ripping my defenses of my professional integrity & contributions—in the face of attacks on my character because of Huff’s deceptions—entirely out of context to misrepresent them as isolated examples of narcissism is precisely the kind of bad-faith engagement that got IP blocked.
Actual scholarship (@maklelan) > fake ass apologetics (@InspiringPhilos)
“Whatever encompasses all of that (i.e, the heavens) is necessarily above it.”
[Ibn al-Qayyim in al-Ṣawāʿiq al-mursala 2/892]
3
227
I know this is not fruitful but I think alot of Muslims would invoke this “scholarly attention” as an “Even that guy... ” and not as a main arbiter for Quran’s reliability.
let's invoke "scholarly attestation" when the qur'an is preserved but not when there is near unanimous consensus on the mass unreliability of hadith, bringing back this gem from reinhart on the cognitive dissonance among muslim apologetics
1
25
921




























