It seems that, now that @Craig_Truglia and @RealDavidNak have both been obliterated in their debates with @ApostolicOrtho, their next recourse is to produce decontextualized slop to try to save face for their Chalcedonian narrative.
But notice how he titled his book “Let the heavens rejoice” - when Agen has already unquestionably demonstrated that the reunion (and its immediate aftermath contextualizing it) actually solidifies St Cyril’s Anti-Dyophysitism. This is why we say that they are just here to defend names, they’re not here to actually believe anything with conviction. That’s why they’re willing to say that they don’t really believe the Tome in Leo’s Nestorianizing corpus’ context, but in some anachronistic neochalcedonian context which is easily falsified by protochalcedonian history. That’s why they’re willing to say that they disagree with St Theodotus’ Conciliar Homilies in Ephesus 431, painting him as a former Nestorian (instead of the former friend who he and St Acacius explained themselves to be). They don’t actually believe in any of this stuff. They’re just here to defend names that they concoct into a self-contradictory narrative, that has at least 5 mutually exclusive dogmatic episodes of history.
David, you conceded the entire debate vis a vis the 433 reunion, when you admitted that St Cyril’s explanation of it excluded a duality of natures after the union while being able to affirm natural differences. Your attempt to save face doesn’t pivot from the obvious.
FORTHCOMING from Uncut Mountain Press
~ DECEMBER 1st release:
— The Mystery of Christ: An Orthodox Catechism from the Holy Mountain (Hardcover) (578 pages)
— The Holy Eldress Galactia of Crete: Her Legacy and Teachings (350 pages)
~ Limited Edition for Apologia Conference ONLY (with later general release, Jan-April 2027):
— Saints of the Prisons [20th Romanian Confessors] (Hardcover) (704 pages)
— The Debate: A Monk, A Prince and Three Muslim Scholars (112 pages)
— Let the Heavens Rejoice: An Orthodox Analysis of Anti-Chalcedonian Claims (540 pages)
— Criteria and Prerequisites for Orthodox Empirical Theology (252 pages)
The first thing to note, is that this very confused individual (who earlier had said Chalcedonians will fight tooth and nail to say Christ is “substantially one” - then made his point of disagreement with us a profession of “one substance”), is now even confused when it comes to the human constitution.
Notice that he takes the very immature, unlearned “argument” that contrary properties (examples given are fire and water, infinite and finite) coming from different natures cannot come to constitute an unconfused, singular, composite nature. But lo and behold, he doesn’t realize he’s already done this with the immaterial soul and the material body. The aphysicality of the soul and the physicality of the body. The rationality of the soul and the irrationality of the body.
Granted, this confused man is clearly not quite representative of his religion, so we can’t hold it against them collectively. I wonder, though, how many realize on their side that it is an Apollinarian argument that two perfect natures cannot constitute one perfect nature, to which the Theologian responded that this is possible precisely because of contrary realms of predicates (the noetic, carnal, and transcendent).
No, St Athanasius says that even the Meletians (who were recent schismatics) have no Eucharist, because they (no longer) lawfully preside after their full schism from the Church:
Contra Arianos, 1.11;
“But the cup which belongs to the mysteries, and which if it be broken intentionally, makes the perpetrator of the deed an impious person, is found only among those who lawfully preside. This is the only description that can be given of this kind of cup; there is none other; this you legally give to the people to drink; this you have received according to the canon of the Church ; this belongs only to those who preside over the Catholic Church, for to you only it appertains to administer the Blood of Christ, and to none besides…
… We say this, not as if a cup even of the schismatics was broken by Macarius, for there was no cup there at all; how should there be? Where there was neither Lord's house nor any the belonging to the Church, nay, it was not the time of the celebration of the mysteries.”
When this individual sees that a document clearly rejects his faith, I can admire his honesty in not contesting that. But instead, his response is to say “this is from the 3rd council… why are you presenting it as if it’s from the council?” It just goes to show the stages of denial that we can go through when our biases are challenged.
Replying to @dioscoros_ @sinan_thesecond
No, this is a homily from the 3rd council. The council did not affirm this teaching. They taught that the two natures are in union in one Jesus Christ but still two distinct natures. Why are you taking a homily from Theodotus and framing it as that being from the council?
1
11
502
Dioscoros retweeted
You know what I haven't done Erick?
I've never had to argue percentages. I argue the primary evidence 100% demonstrates my Church.
Meanwhile, the Great Schism's lead-up mutually falsifies RC and EO.
You give EO 300/500.
You give RC 470/500.
I give myself 500 and ya'll 0
Replying to @ApostolicOrtho
The proof that this is a self own is that you are spending a great deal of work trying to prove OO
Hill, you already conceded that EO theosis is wrong when you conceded that the saints do not become identical to the Lord. Yet it was shown to you that Maximus very explicitly says and then elaborates that they do become identical to the Lord, twice in the same passage. You then put your head into the sand and claimed “kai tauton auto” doesn’t mean that “and identical to him” even though that’s very obviously what it means.
You aren’t a serious interlocutor, you’re doing your own religion a disservice by continuing to speak after showing you don’t know the first thing about EO. Sit down and learn about your own religion first.
Dioscoros retweeted
Hmm, fair point. Maybe instead I should have shown your saint describing a male emperor lying in bed with another man, kissing him mouth to mouth, and pressing his face upon his “members”: as an analogy for God and repentant sinners.
You can blame all these low blows on C2A
Come on Hill, just because it’s June it doesn’t mean you have to go with the cultural tidal wave. Also, even those within EO who study this recognize that Symeon fantasized about the sin of that burned-down place. @EthanWayne2001 is honest about it, brought the receipts, and none of the Dyerite mobsters were able to refute the perspicuousness of Symeon’s blasphemous homoeroticism:
Double standards for the double-minded Christ-dividers. The fact that that “man” felt so free to publicly threat in a bragging way one of his own religious body’s seminarians just goes to show how unchecked the hierarchy of the Byzantines is. Time will tell if he’s disciplined.
DeYoung threatening to “go after 😂” an Orthodox Christian who “offended” his bf Sorin but his reaction to his Jewish friend mocking Saint Paul is…..
1
12
1,042
Notice that Hill, in the context of foolishly using a faulty, unverified translation, admits that it is heretical to believe we become identical to Christ. Yet, the very Greek of what he underlined says that very thing, he just didn’t know what he was underlining says in the Greek:
καὶ γενέσθαι ζώσας εἰκόνας Χριστοῦ, καὶ ταὐτὸν αὐτῷ μᾶλλον κατὰ τὴν χάριν
Now, here here a multi-choice question for those paying attention:
Does ταὐτὸν refer to:
a) oneness
b) bananas
c) identity
d) Temu Dyer
e) Hill
Choose carefully…
Yet again, Ted complains about St Basil the Great refuting his religion, since his canons recommend to reject certain decisions of Rome out of pastoral care. Also, he is ignorant of the fact that these Basilian canons are accepted by Trullo and thus 2 Nicaea, and as such are infallible.
St Basil the Great 3 - Ted 0. Not a close contest.
Uh oh, St Basil says that Rome not only isn’t infallible, but that if they forbid baptizing the schismatics/heretics, that he recommends ignoring them and baptizing them anyways. Also, he attests that Nicaea’s canon is about economy (meaning it’s consistent with the Cyprianic-Dionysian-Basilian-Severian doctrine), and that he himself has the freedom to baptize Novatians anyways. It looks like Ted’s incoherent rambling is yet again, well, incoherent. I recommend he sticks to what he’s good at; posting stuff about the Walmart-brand Eastern Catholics.
St Basil the Great 2 - Ted 0.
Replying to @dioscoros_
The Pope can't be infallible and override a council but Saint Basil is? Read the Council of Arles and Nicea over again. Sacraments performed by those in simple schism who retain the priesthood remain valid despite being illicit.
St Basil the Great vs Ted:
Replying to @10Kidus
That's not how it works. Holy Orders remain valid irregardless of changing bishops. This is a Sacrament
Dioscoros retweeted
By the grace of God and through prayers of my beloved fathers and brethren, I was ordained a full deacon by His Grace Bishop David of the Coptic Orthodox Diocese of New York and New England for service at our mission parish in Chicopee MA. Pray for our witness to Christ.
Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye compass sea and land to make one proselyte, and when he is made, ye make him twofold more the child of hell than yourselves.
Dioscoros retweeted
An EO apologist just admitted Ephesus was wrong 🤦♂️#orientalorthodox #syriacorthodox #copticorthodox #orthodoxchristian
@10Kidus @DETELZROY @SubDeaconDaniel @iamschuyler97 @orthoalexandria
Comments like this just go to show that the Nestorians best expose themselves. Notice how this guy is saying that his heterodox faith is being attacked based off of 2 statements in the picture:
1) That St Cyril/his council of Ephesus accepted Alexandrian Miaphysite Christology.
2) That there was varied acceptance of this Christology during and after 451.
None of those 2 statements are even objected to within a Chalcedonian framework. The heretics are always saying that they accept an “orthodox interpretation” of St Cyril’s Miaphysitism, and yet this poor fellow wants to reverse this? Also, the heretics’ own Three Chapters (of Chalcedon) controversy was a self-admission that a letter contained in Chalcedon’s minutes (letter to Mari) was an insufficient level of acceptance of St Cyril. The fact that you even had a controversy about the Three Chapters (of Chalcedon) proves that the second statement bears truth.
Once again, the best exposition of the heretics is their own insanity. But by all means, do not prevent yourself from reading the work on account of this.
Replying to @BrotherAugusti2
Really can’t help himself from attacking the Orthodox faith, over and over, in a book that has nothing to do with Monophysitism or the Nestorian controversy. Even if there’s stuff I like about this book I will be very hesitant to recommend it because of how obnoxious I find these passages and the spiritual danger they can present to those who are not well-grounded in the history of our faith. Second time he’s done this now in the Introduction alone.
You should know that St Jerome takes the position that St Dionysius’ policy is dogmatically in accordance with St Cyprian, and he notes that he defended St Cyprian’s dogma against Stephen of Rome. You evidently did not read St Jerome, for he nowhere says that Stephen was right, and testifies to the veracity of Sts Cyprian and Dionysius being against Stephen but with each other. But alas, you’re caught up in the lies of Rome, which doesn’t even know whether baptism in the name of the Trinity is required, or if the name of Christ only suffices.































