Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola) header
Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola) profile picture

Economist at @bancaditalia | Former @wto researcher | PhD at @IHEID. International trade enthusiast. Views are my own.

Bologna, Emilia Romagna
Joined February 2014
Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)Photo by Gianmarco Cariola (@gmcariola)
I defended my PhD in International Economics at the @GVAGrad on June 13! I am grateful to the many amazing people I met during my time in Geneva. Here a #ShamelessSelfie with my committee, @BaldwinRE, Julia Cajal-Grossi and Gianmarco Ottaviano. #EconTwitter #PhD
1
1
1
14
3,123
A guide for students of economics: Ten statements that demonstrate that someone does not understand modern economics or what an equilibrium is, and that you can safely ignore everything else they say. 1. “Equilibrium means the economy is stable or at rest.” Many assume that an equilibrium is a peaceful state with no forces at play. Instead, an equilibrium is just an arrangement of actions and expectations over time that are mutually consistent. It can be locally unstable, explosive, or fragile. Nothing in the definition of equilibrium implies stability. 2. “Equilibrium implies optimality or social efficiency.” Equilibrium is often conflated with efficiency, but equilibrium merely reflects decentralized consistency, not welfare maximization. Market power, externalities, incomplete markets, nominal rigidities, and frictions routinely produce inefficient equilibria. I often teach a first-year macro graduate course, and not a single one of the equilibria I define is efficient. 3. “Equilibrium is a unique outcome.” Many often expect models to have one equilibrium. In reality, multiple equilibria arise naturally in dynamic, strategic, and incomplete-market environments. Models of coordination failures, self-fulfilling expectations, bubbles, overlapping generations, and liquidity traps all hinge on the existence of equilibrium multiplicity. 4. “Equilibrium requires perfect foresight or perfect information.” Equilibrium does not assume agents know the future. In fact, equilibria are often stochastic. The definition of equilibrium only requires that beliefs are consistent with the (perceived) stochastic laws of motion implied by the model. Bayesian learning, noisy signals, ambiguity, and subjective uncertainty all fit well within an equilibrium framework, provided beliefs converge to an internally consistent (but possibly incorrect) distribution. Bonus point: equilibria are compatible with agents having diverging beliefs that never converge to a single Dirac distribution. 5. “Real economies are rarely in equilibrium, so the concept is unrealistic.” Equilibrium is not meant to describe the daily state of the world. It is a conceptual device used to understand the outcome of our models under the assumptions we make. Also, see point 1 above. 6. “Equilibrium requires agents to be fully rational in a psychological sense.” Equilibrium only assumes internal consistency: agents optimize given preferences and constraints. It does not assume realism about human cognition. We can and do define equilibria in models with behavioral biases, bounded rationality, inattention, or rule-of-thumb behavior. We only need to ensure that the resulting actions and beliefs are mutually compatible. 7. “Equilibrium eliminates dynamics or learning.” Equilibrium is sometimes misinterpreted as a static state in which nothing evolves. In fact, many equilibria are sequences of probability distributions over states driven by shocks, policy rules, and endogenous responses. Learning dynamics (Bayesian updating, adaptive rules, experience-based expectations) can occur within equilibrium if the evolution of beliefs is self-consistent. 8. “Equilibrium renders expectations unimportant.” A common misconception is that equilibrium mechanically determines outcomes. In reality, expectations are often central: they determine investment, consumption, asset prices, and policy responses. Many equilibria differ only in their expectations. This is why communication, credibility, and forward guidance matter even in fully rational models. 9. “Equilibrium excludes policy intervention.” Some interpret equilibrium as a laissez-faire concept. In fact, equilibrium analysis is the foundation of modern policy evaluation. Fiscal, monetary, and regulatory interventions work through equilibrium responses (prices, wages, interest rates, quantities) and must satisfy equilibrium conditions to be credible. Equilibrium is a tool for policy design, not a barrier to it. 10. “Equilibriums…” Aequilibrium is a Latin neuter noun of the second declension, which forms a nominative plural in “a”. It is composed of aequus (equal; the same root as equality or equity) and libra (balance or scales or the name of several currencies over history). A final thought: “equilibrium” is a term of art. Its meaning in economics differs from its use in the natural sciences or in everyday language. Terms of art are ubiquitous across academic disciplines, and the first act of intellectual diligence when one starts studying a discipline is to learn what they mean.
82
592
137
2,236
778,789
1/ Hi, my name is Isaac Martinez. I am a PhD student in Economics at the LSE, and I wanted to share something personal. On July 6, 2025, I suffered a stroke while I was finishing my PhD. It was completely unexpected and changed my life. #EconTwitter #EconJobMarket
26
349
28
1,057
252,212
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
The value of words: Evidence from non-financial disclosure regulation Antonio Accetturo, @Audingus1, @gmcariola, Annalisa Frigo, Marco Gallo @bancaditalia @UfficioStampaBI ow.ly/GlnY50Wt4Qk
1
3
4
1,353
Ten smart ways of using ChatGPT for academic purposes (that do not involve any plagiarism):
6
182
2
1,082
171,718
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
New CEPR Discussion Paper - DP20343 The Value of Words: Evidence from Non-Financial Disclosure Regulation Antonio Accetturo, @Audingus1, @gmcariola, Annalisa Frigo, Marco Gallo @bancaditalia ow.ly/k8zt50W7yy0 #CEPR_BCF #EconTwitter
1
1
3
1,374
🧵New Research Bulletin by D. Essers, L. Lebastard, M. Mancini, L. Panon and J. Timini: "Critical input disruptions – mapping out the road to EU resilience" ecb.europa.eu/press/research… 1/4
1
3
4
750
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
📢#Concorso #Bankitalia 61 assunzioni di laureate e laureati con orientamento economico 📌Vuoi lavorare in un’istituzione che protegge il valore della moneta e tutela la stabilità dei prezzi e del sistema finanziario? La Banca d’Italia offre opportunità per quattro diversi profili con competenze economiche Approfondisci qui 👉 bit.ly/3XeBAp1 e mettiti in gioco! ⏰ Puoi candidarti entro le 16.00 del 16 ottobre 2024
1
9
1,513
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
Our paper "Inputs in distress: Geoeconomic fragmentation and firms' sourcing" is now also available as a @NBB_BNB_NL Working Paper: nbb.be/en/articles/inputs-di… 👇A short thread and some cool graphs (courtesy of my excellent co-authors🙏) 1/8
🙏Very thankful to have been part of this 5-country exercise to chart impact of potential disruptions to critical inputs from high-risk countries👇 bancaditalia.it/pubblicazion… Co-led by @mikmanc, @LudovicPanon @bancaditalia and Laura Lebastard @ecb + joint w other ESCB colleagues
1
4
1
12
1,921
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
🙏Very thankful to have been part of this 5-country exercise to chart impact of potential disruptions to critical inputs from high-risk countries👇 bancaditalia.it/pubblicazion… Co-led by @mikmanc, @LudovicPanon @bancaditalia and Laura Lebastard @ecb + joint w other ESCB colleagues
4
1
19
2,155
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
A study on Italian firms reveals that disruptions in critical inputs from high-risk countries have substantial output losses in specific sectors & regions. @AleBarbaBorin, Cariola, Gentili, Linarello, @mikmanc, Padellini, @LudovicPanon, Sette @bancaditalia ow.ly/UE9R50Qvmhp
11
16
2,131
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
Quantifying geopolitical risk: new evidence @voxeu 🔗 cepr.org/voxeu/columns/input… @bancaditalia
1
21
2
57
14,636
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
Un grazie a Ignazio #Visco, con noi in Banca d’Italia da 51 anni e Governatore dal 2011. Esprimiamo sincera gratitudine al Governatore per aver guidato l'Istituto con integrità e passione al servizio del Paese. Auguriamo al Governatore il meglio per il futuro.
5
31
8
209
18,656
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
The four factors that explain how we got to such high inflation? • Charts in 🧵👇 • @R2Rsquared Ricardo Reis #inflation personal.lse.ac.uk/reisr/pap…
1
18
2
48
#Bankitalia #Economieregionali L’esposizione dell’economia dell’#EmiliaRomagna ai mercati russo e ucraino appare complessivamente contenuta. Nel 2021 le esportazioni regionali verso i 2 paesi rappresentavano rispettivamente il 2,1% e lo 0,6% del totale 👉 bancaditalia.it/media/notizi…
2
1
Our work on the determinants of preference utilization is finally out as a @wto working paper! More exciting stuff on trade and development will be released in the next few days 😎 wto.org/english/res_e/reser_…
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
When one big commodity exporter invades another, the whole world suffers • food & energy price hikes creating “human catastrophe” in poorer nations (Malpass)+debt distress (IMF) perfect storm of increasing inflation, lower growth & higher interest rates • #RussiaUkraineWar
2
8
2
19
Gianmarco Cariola retweeted
How many #Bucha before we move to a full oil and gas Russia embargo? Time is over.
3,024
3,612
552
19,938