Castamere (@insights198) profile picture
Joined January 2022
Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)Photo by Castamere (@insights198)
It's possible the steppe/Northern Euro part in Ashkenazis is tough to model exactly because it is partly Tajik-like from ancient times, and also a bit of Czech-Polish from the last 1000 years
1
27
I've seen Levantine results with 3% Turkic, and up to 10% Steppe. This is not that dissimilar to Ashkenazis, could be from the same Tajik-like classical times Iranic migration into the Middle East
29
no problem. No need to reply, would be good to read a blog post on your replies to some of my lines of argument. Hope you keep up the North Africa genetic-historical posts, you're the Razib of that area of the world!
1
946
traits like sickle cell or lactose tolerance vary depending on such ancestry categories, even stuff like prostate cancer. There is not a real debate as to their meaningfulness if PC concerns are not a thing
1
43
or take the EDAR mutation, which makes East Asians have distinct hair, earwax and other stuff. Guess which groups have very little of it
37
no, I do not believe that. I'm saying a random 100% White American and an random African-American are more closely related by autosomal DNA to Europeans and Africans respectively
2
1,026
no, my argument here is that natural selection or even just a bottleneck( which is documented by the way genetically) can increase intelligence in a short time span.
2
823
nah, anthro nerds still use Caucasian for West Eurasian, which seems vaguer to most readers on the face
1
936
never head this before, but makes a lot of sense
963
no offense, but those last ones are less than 2% of the global Jewish population, and less in the US. It's not surprising people don't immediately think of them when thinking of Jews
1,152
nahh, he was quite handsome. Lost his hair early though
2
1,333
nah, Jews often have narrow jaws despite good socio-economic status. More of a settled population thing vs more recently HG or herders
3
4
1,384
nah. Jews often have narrow jaws and they are quite well fed. Caucasian people with long history of settled living have it more often, while more recently HG groups have big jaws. East Asians are somewhat different though, despite long history of settled living
2
1,029
nah, North Euros are cool and have great accomplishments, but are not connected to the Israelites. Come on, we have DNA and even good anthropologists like Coon would laugh at this
2
1,033
nah, you won't find SS Africans with blonde hair, non-odd mutation blue eyes, or red type British skin color. Humans who left Africa have been subject to different selection pressures that Africans don't automatically share
1,055
I am aware that the West Af advantage seems to be present only in shorter lengths, for instance. But you're likely mistaken in saying that outliers have their own dynamics separate from average tendencies of their ethnic group
1
909
neutral theory is clearly mistaken in many aspects, but what about the molecular clock is wrong? why can't modern humans derive from an expansion out of Africa 70k or so years ago? the khoisan don't seem to have arrived from anywhere recently, while East Asians look more "recent"
807
nah, even being half-German, he is quite Eastern looking
1
733
no, the Founding Fathers invented it
2
961
it does in certain fields, like physics or complex math. Not in business and many professions that are less technical
975
interesting, that's one of the few old school-ish guitar solos I've heard on hit radio in a long time...
1
911
neoteny is increasing, agreed
833