Ale (@AleJohnson242) profile picture
Joined October 2023
Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)Photo by Ale (@AleJohnson242)
Yefet Cohen, Samaritan communal leader and the curator of the Samaritan museum speaking to Pavel Bernstein: "The Most High chose the name - Israel (Jacob). Israel doesn't [exclusively] belong to the Samaritans, nor to the Jews. There is no Samaritan religion, just as really, there is no Jewish religion. We are [both] the Nation of Israel."
To be clear, Jacob has absolutely no clue on what the consensus view of the Samaritan community is are on Ashkenazi Jewish indigeneity. He just posts a hearsay anecdote about what a Jewish person said 'all the Samaritans were saying' in 1967, and claims to speak for all of them. The NYT in 2021 reported on about the nuances of Samaritan identity; a Samaritan they interviewed said he identified as a Palestinian and an Arab growing up, but came to strongly support Israel because he believes Israel preserves the existence of the Samaritan community. The NYT mentioned both Samaritan Likud voters and Samaritan members of the PLO. nytimes.com/2021/08/22/world…. The general tenor of the article is that the Samaritans seem to have more cultural similarities with the Palestinians, but are treated well by Israel and many see support for the state as being in their interest. Regardless, it appears that the community straddles both sides of the Israel-Palestine conflict, and its views cannot be summed up in the reductive and frankly disrespectful manner Jacob attempts to. If one wanted to figure out what Samaritans think about these issues, one would have to carry out a detailed anthropological study, not just meme.
3
22
2
184
22,103
Teaching galitzianers how to auramaxx
This is how a 40 year old Litvak looked like in 1866. From here catalog.ethnomuseum.ru/entit…
1
19
Jewish branches of Israelite origin among Yemenite Jews: J-Y3088 E-BY8508 Branches very unlikely to be of Arab origin among Yemenite Jews: R-FT280556 Q-M323 Edge toward non-Arab origin in Yemenite Jews: G-FT354322 Line from other Jewish diasporas in Yemenite Jews: R-FTB6807 Never let them get away with this shit
🔷️ تُثبت الدراسات التاريخية والجينومية الحديثة أن اليهود اليمنيين هم جزء أصيل لا يتجزأ من النسيج العربي القحطاني الأصيل ، ولا صلة جينية تربطهم بالنسل الإبراهيمي العبراني ؛ حيث يمثلون مجتمعاً عربياً محلياً أعتنق الديانة اليهودية كـ «هوية دينية وثقافية » وليس كعرق أو نسب سلالي .
7
13
1
132
5,135
We’ll write abt this more, but briefly: 1) yes, the difference between toshavim (pre-Sephardic) & megorashim is worth noting 2) there is almost no evidence of Jewish continuity in Morocco from Roman times 3) Berber ancestry is very low 4) the two groups seem closely related
*Aktchually* he's probably not Sephardic (patrilineally speaking) but toshav As his amazigh surname (despite the "ashkenization" attempt) suggests his people never left Morocco since Roman times Azenkod : gazelle teapawt.org/BreizhLondon/status/21…
6
5
1
51
6,935
Remember kids: Jews aren't a race, but Jewish endogamy is racist
Replying to @PeterBeinart
Greenblatt is a racist who loves Nazis. I sure wouldn't want anyone I love to marry into that family.
1
4
149
Replying to @JoeRoganRecaps
Where to even begin. (Other than the fact that we’ve tested dozens and reviewed the test results of hundreds of Israelis of different backgrounds…)
1
1
20
741
I remember when Stewart used to talk about how Jewish he himself looks.
This quoted post is unavailable.
144
Replying to @sickofskis
Do I? I often get mistaken for Lebanese or Turkish. Which makes sense given that I'm from a Levantine/Eastern Mediterannean ethnic group.
1
2
279
Goyim discovering that Moroccan Jews don't look Moroccan
Replying to @AureleTobelem
Why you look Iranian?
3
172
"Every Jew who leaves the Ghetto is a prey for a schmalzownik. In schmalzownik terminology a Jew is a <cat> slinking through the city streets…The schmalzowniks walk around in the streets stopping anyone who looks Semitic in appearance…They are a real plague of locusts, descending in their hundreds and maybe even thousands on the Jews on the Aryan side and stripping them of their money and valuables and often clothing as well" - Władysława Zawistowska
Replying to @Y40IFRQTTING
The reason they could tell who was Jewish was bc Jews were wearing Jewish related clothing and hair styles. And back then Jews all lived in the same area around each other and went to temple all the time. They couldn’t tell off rip who’s Jewish.
1
2
362
“Marek Edelman had a ‘typical Jewish appearance,’ so his being sent to the Aryan side was out of the question.” — The Leadership of the Jewish Combat Organization during the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising: A Reassessment, p. 55, note 56
Replying to @notistotny
They were able to make ‘educated guesses’ primarily because of segregation and the actual physical identifier they used was checking for circumcision.
1
1
163
Yet again, reply instantly followed by a block. But remember kids, "the 9ohoyuni is the coward".
1
2
199
Replying to @LibyaLiberty
That's a quote from a letter he sent to someone in the USSR during the 1930s, after having been denied citizenship in France during the rise of the Nazis, who were already busy attacking his work. The USSR was known for checking foreign mail and Chagall was in a precarious position for where to seek help. Meanwhile, see the letter written to a friend in Haifa during the same period. Still think he thought of himself as a Russian?
1
2
1
7
258
Watermelons are pretending to be neutral, surprised observers that anyone would take issue with Chagall being called Eastern European, but at the same time will refuse to call Bibi Middle Eastern
1
96
I also don't think Mamdani arbitrarily chose Chagall. Chagall is very much more significant to Soviet Ashkenazim than to Ashkenazim from earlier waves. The reason(s) for this, I can go into later. Now, the former gets called "Russian" often enough by earlier Ashkenazim, that it does make Mamdani's job here a lot easier.
At most charitable, confusing Soviet Ashkenazim as "Eastern European" and the constant presence of Chagall copies in Soviet Ashkenazi households led to Chagall being implied as "Eastern European". Chagall is of course specifically known for depicting Jews and Jewish scenery in the Pale. Chagall's household in the Pale didn't eat syrniki with sour cream (this is a product of later Soviet assimilation). Chagall's family also didn't wear the clothing featured with such designs (similarly, I can't find old pictures of Samaritan women in tatreez). The surname Chagall is a Litvish variation of Segal (contraction of Segan Levia - wonder if watermelons will consider him "indigenous to Palestine" because his surname is a contraction of an Aramaic word and a Hebrew word. Can't pull the "but Mileikowsky" diversion here.). This is of course not alluding to the modern frumverse's use of "Litvish" to mean misnaged, as Chagall's family was almost surely/definitely Chassidic.
102
At most charitable, confusing Soviet Ashkenazim as "Eastern European" and the constant presence of Chagall copies in Soviet Ashkenazi households led to Chagall being implied as "Eastern European". Chagall is of course specifically known for depicting Jews and Jewish scenery in the Pale. Chagall's household in the Pale didn't eat syrniki with sour cream (this is a product of later Soviet assimilation). Chagall's family also didn't wear the clothing featured with such designs (similarly, I can't find old pictures of Samaritan women in tatreez). The surname Chagall is a Litvish variation of Segal (contraction of Segan Levia - wonder if watermelons will consider him "indigenous to Palestine" because his surname is a contraction of an Aramaic word and a Hebrew word. Can't pull the "but Mileikowsky" diversion here.). This is of course not alluding to the modern frumverse's use of "Litvish" to mean misnaged, as Chagall's family was almost surely/definitely Chassidic.
New Yorkers experience the abundant contributions of our Eastern European neighbors every day. As we pair syrniki with sour cream in Brighton Beach, look in wonder at a Chagall painting at MoMA and banter with babushkas in Rego Park. Last week, we celebrated Eastern European heritage at Gracie Mansion, because the story of New York City cannot be told without the story of our Eastern European neighbors. From new immigrants to those who've lived here for generations, Eastern Europeans have built New York City. We owe them a city they can afford to call home.
3
2
1
15
682