
Mostly a lurker around these parts Trying to make forecasting more impactful at @metaculus
Portland, OR
Joined April 2009
- Tweets1.5K
- Following1.5K
- Followers738
- Likes1.6K
There might be a simpler reason why no company is reporting that the layoffs are caused by automation... 🤔
📢 NEW essay: the narrative that AI is replacing software engineers seems to be based on AI-washing of layoffs. Among the many lines of evidence: New York State requires firms to disclose which layoffs were due to AI. When there are legal consequences to lying, almost no company blames AI.
The best data suggests that software engineer employment in the U.S. is still growing, though slightly more slowly compared to a no-AI counterfactual world. But even this doesn’t account for increased entry into entrepreneurship.
Why haven’t AI agents replaced software engineers? Many kinds of knowledge work, including software development, can be seen as a “decide-execute-deliver sandwich”. AI compresses the middle but the other two layers resist automation in a way that will not be overcome by capability improvements alone. In 2026, the middle has already been squeezed and there isn’t much room for further compression, so there isn’t a future capability leap that will cause discontinuous impacts, either.
The essay also has a detailed breakdown of the difference between vibe coding and agentic engineering. Conflating the two has unfortunately led to a lot of confusion.
We acknowledge that there’s a lot of uncertainty about the future. But we think the unknowns are more about how we will define and carve up roles and who can adapt to the changing needs, and less about whether software engineering skills and judgment will remain in demand (they will).
Given that the AI-capabilities-cause-mass-layoffs narrative seems to be false even in a sector with very few regulatory barriers, we think most other professions are likely to be even more cushioned. (The claim isn’t that automation never displaces jobs, but that there are many downstream links in the causal chain, and that we have collective agency to act on those downstream decision points to ensure better outcomes for workers.)
This essay by me and @sayashk is the first in a series. Feedback is welcome! We hope that our unique vantage point (leading an AI agent evals research group + fluency with the labor economics literature + the "normal technology" framework for understanding AI impacts + being coders ourselves and well connected to the software engineering community) gives us a way to bring complementary perspectives together for a deep dive into how AI is transforming the profession, in a way that hasn't been done before.
Read the essay here for lots of other details: normaltech.ai/p/why-ai-hasnt…
1
91
Leonard Barrett retweeted
Excited to be on Odd Lots to talk about the politics of AI.
AI today is less important than it will ever be.
Over the past year, AI rose in issue importance faster than any issue we track — it's now more important to voters than climate change, child care, and abortion.
Reminder. @tracyalloway and I are interviewing @davidshor and @ByrneHobart tomorrow about the politics of and prospects for a white collar wipeout. Should be a really fun, uplifting conversation. Come by and say hi
Partnering with OpenAI for national security ✨ For the first time ever, the latest reasoning models from OpenAI will be used for energy and national security applications on the Lab's Venado supercomputer. See more about this strategic partnership 👇 ow.ly/JuUc50UQJGr
4
208
Leonard Barrett retweeted
We think it's great that Future Perfect's @dylanmatt, @mbolotnikova, @dylanlscott, @OshanJarow, @bryanrwalsh & @IzzieRamirez will share their 2025 forecasts. (And check back on how they did.)
So we collaborated with FP so you can forecast along with them:
metaculus.com/c/future-perfe…
Leonard Barrett retweeted
Is it common in your circles for people to say “congratulations” when someone mentions they’ve left their job? || Where do you live?
36%Common || US
21%Uncommon || US
10%Common || non-US
33%Uncommon || non-US
1,359 votes • Final results Leonard Barrett retweeted
Like sports analysts or weather forecasters, GiveWell researchers often make predictions about our research and grants. We launched a page on @Metaculus to solicit external feedback on those forecasts.
📆 Deadline is Dec 1, 2024
🏆 Up to $2,250 in prizes
bit.ly/3O20RP4
My curiosity runs wild re: how rcv affected turnout, user error, etc. Not at all clear here, but directionally consistent with my hunch that increasing difficulty of filling out a ballot would significantly impact participation.
Very happy to be wrong but haven't yet seen anything pointing counter to this hunch.
I'm not absolutely certain I am reading this correctly, but this is how I am reading voter participation in Portland's mayoral and city council elections as of Nov 7.
1
129
Will the @nytimes needle go live tonight?
15%Yes
48%No
37%Results
27 votes • Final results Leonard Barrett retweeted
Stop thinking about who is going to win the U.S. election.
Predict the consequences. The consequences are what should inform political debates.
You'll learn a lot if you try, see @metaculus or @ManifoldMarkets
Leonard Barrett retweeted
As I understand it @metaculus has one of the best election forecasting track records:
metaculus.com/questions/1124…
Leonard Barrett retweeted
Trump and Harris in a dead heat over here, by the way. One forecaster, one vote. metaculus.com/questions/1124…
Does anyone know if this draft vacant property registration policy ever took effect in PDX? Trying to pull all the levers to get an absentee neighbor (perfectly good house vacant for >3 years) off the dime to rent or sell the house. @PNWelcome @andersem
portlandonline.com/shared/cf…
1
91
This just reminded me that I was in Spain recently and impressed to see that every surveillance camera is accompanied with a public notice of its existence, complete with an email address where you can request footage. I think it’s a GPDR thing. Pretty cool.






























