Noah Roth (@noahroth) header
Noah Roth (@noahroth) profile picture

Father of 5, Husband, Israeli Jew, US Expat. CEO/CBO, 1xfounder, 3xExit (@conduit, @hawkespeers, @getrevelator), 21xMarathon. #Yankees #Knicks #SingleMalt

Between the River and The Sea
Joined June 2007
Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)Photo by Noah Roth (@noahroth)
We've reached our cruising altitude of 30,000 tweets. Flight attendants will be through the cabin shortly w/ complimentary cocktail service.
17
6
2
54
International law is clear: hospitals lose their protected status when they are used for military purposes. Period.
International law is clear: hospitals must be protected. Period.
459
2,272
58
20,699
237,258
In the Oslo era, agreements would be painstakingly negotiated, but when it came to carry them out, Israel was expected to carry out commitments that were parallel to Palestinian commitments in the text even when those were manifestly unfulfilled. There was a kind of knowing...
The severe flooding and winter conditions that have struck Gaza are aggravating an already grave humanitarian situation. We urge Israel to allow immediate, unimpeded access and sustained distribution of humanitarian assistance and early recovery support at scale, and to reopen all Gaza border crossings. My statement on behalf of the EU ↓ consilium.europa.eu/en/press…
6
74
12
437
43,629
Noah Roth retweeted
Senator Fetterman just completely silenced far-left agitators in the Capitol Building. “Why do you people support Hamas so much?”
319
872
52
5,454
250,664
The biggest mistake observers make about October 7 is believing it to be an expression of Palestinian despair. It was an expression of Palestinian hope, the climax of three or four years of burgeoning optimism in local intellectual discourse with a massive global tailwind.
6
41
2
220
11,060
If you want an indicator of how much the world changed on October 7, 2023, just remember that before that day's events, whenever there was some rain and flooding in Gaza, activists and "humanitarians" would blame Israel for opening a non-existent dam.
5
59
1
373
8,847
שוב גאה שהצבעתי למפלגה הזאת.
אחד הדברים היפים שקרו בעקבות הבחירות הוא הודעות מבוחרים שלנו שהדגישו עד כמה הם שלמים עם הבחירה שעשו בהצבעתם למפלגה ששמה את ה״מה״ מעל ה״מי״. משתפת כאן פוסט יפיפה של מתנאל בוזגלו שרלבנטי במיוחד על רקע הדיווחים האחרונים: ״לאחר הבחירות שאלו אותי אם אני מאוכזב שנתתי את קולי למפלגה שלא עברה את אחוז החסימה. האמת היא שעוד לפני ההצבעה שלי הערכתי שרוב הסיכויים שהמפלגה לא תעבור. מדוע בכל זאת הצבעתי להם? יש לא מעט סיבות טובות. אירועי הימים האחרונים רק מחזקים זאת. רציתי קואליציה של מפלגות ציוניות. בשונה משאר המפלגות בגוש השינוי שדיברו ללא הרף על על גוש המשרתים הם היחידים שהבינו שהמשמעות היא שבירת הגושים. שוב ושוב שמעתי את אנשי גוש השינוי מבטיחים קואליציה ללא מפלגות חרדיות, ללא מפלגות ערביות וללא ביבי. זה היה מחזה משעשע. כולם מבינים שהמספרים לא מתכנסים ולמרות זאת אנשים מרשים לעצמם להבטיח הבטחות שיאלצו להפר. אז הנה, שבוע וחצי לאחר הבחירות וכבר מדברים על כך שצריך להתפשר. באופן לא מפתיע הפשרה היא על אותה הבטחה שעמדה בלב קמפיין הבחירות. ״בימים שלפני הבחירות ידידי יונתן ווינברג ערך ראיון עם עינת וילף. היא טענה שחלק ניכר ממי שמובילים את קמפיין המשתמטים יעדיפו ממשלה שלא תתקן את המצב (ואולי אף תעמיק אותו) אם המשמעות תהיה הזזת נתניהו. לא הייתי צריך את הראיון הזה כדי להצביע לאישה הכי רצינית ועניינית שיש כאן. מלכתחילה לא קניתי את הרוח הכאילו ערכית שעלתה מאותם אזורים. ועדיין, היא היחידה שדיברה על מה ולא על מי. היא היחידה שגם מבינה את גודל האתגרים שלנו וגם פועלת באופן ענייני כדי לטפל בהם. ״כבר קרה לי שהצבעתי למפלגות שלא עברו את אחוז החסימה. אני חושב שמעולם לא הייתי שלם כ"כ עם ההצבעה שלי.״ קישור לפוסט המקורי בפייסבוק: facebook.com/share/p/1F8WCW2…
69
"If you move the goalposts of the crime during the trial, you think the accused is innocent." Brilliant from @ha
Why they NEED it to be a genocide. From a live event at Valley Beth Shalom Synagogue, Encino, California. With Rabbi Nolan Lebovitz and Reverend Drew Sams, Senior Pastor of Bel Air Church.
2
2
19
934
This should have said "brilliant from @havivrettiggur ." Not really sure what happened there.
29
נצחוני @grok, נצחוני @grok.
היי @grok תנור של עכנאי מקבל טומאה? תענה בכן או לא
1
3
105
Inter Alia, Democrats who insisted they needed El-Sayed to win the Senate have been shown to be dishonest or bad at math tonight - because they didn't ever need El-Sayed to win the Senate. And now they've elected and empowered an antisemite.
86
112
6
869
17,392
A lot of people who praised Liz Cheney for putting "country over party" are upset today and I find deep irony in all of it.
61
209
14
1,780
30,888
כי אם החרש תחרישי בעת הזאת רווח והצלה יעמוד ליהודים ממקום אחר ואת ובית אביך תאבדו. ומי יודע אם לעת כזאת הגעת למלכות.
Haley Stevens isn't dumb. She knew before she backed Mike Rogers that she was abt to become the Democratic Party's greatest pariah this cycle. And that she'd never resurrect her political career if she did this. If AES loses, she gets blamed. If he wins, she looks weak. There is no political upside to what she did. And yet she chose to do it anyway. Bc clearly she felt it was the right thing to do -- despite all the voices in her ear telling her not to. Gutsy.
4
174
Noah Roth retweeted
I am endorsing Mike Rogers for the United States Senate today.
71,361
27,958
18,477
161,479
32,691,417
“The Whole Package Jabotinsky Government” (Or Why “The Iron Wall” Provides the Blueprint for Israel’s Next Government) Jabotinsky is enjoying a renewed popularity these days among parties of Israel’s “Change Bloc,” which are drawing on his far-reaching vision of joint Jewish-Arab government to justify a Jewish-Arab coalition and government. Yet in doing so, they conveniently skip over the Iron Wall required to make that vision of equality and partnership possible. After all, Jabotinsky made clear that such cooperation could not exist “as long as the Arabs have even a glimmer of hope of getting rid of us,” and that the only way to extinguish every last glimmer of such hope is through sustained strength, until “not a single crack is visible in the Iron Wall.” The purpose of the Iron Wall was to bring the enemies of Zionism to the point where they understand that there is no longer even the slightest chance of defeating it. It turns out, then, that every side of Israeli politics has the part of Ze’ev Jabotinsky’s “Iron Wall” that it likes, and the part it conveniently forgets. The right clearly loves the Iron Wall itself, the insight that the Arabs will not willingly reconcile themselves to Jewish sovereignty, and that as long as they retain the hope of defeating Zionism, they will continue trying. But there is also a tendency, at times, on the right to stop there and retreat into a kind of fatalistic helplessness that says, “That’s just how it is” and “That’s just how they are,” turning the Iron Wall from a means into an end. But the Iron Wall was indeed a means, not an end. On the other side of the Iron Wall, Jabotinsky envisioned a Jewish state in which every citizen enjoyed equal rights. On the left and in the Change Bloc, there is a tendency, rightly so, to celebrate the Jabotinsky who championed individual rights, civic equality, and human dignity, and who imagined a government in which the prime minister would alternately be Jewish with an Arab deputy, and vice versa. But wrongly, they tend to skip over the fundamental condition Jabotinsky placed on all of this: the Iron Wall that would extinguish every Arab hope of ending Jewish sovereignty. I am a great believer in Jewish-Arab cooperation, but like Jabotinsky, I believe that such cooperation can only be real after full and final recognition, without the slightest crack or glimmer of hope, that the Jewish state can ever be eliminated. In the book "Peace Not Now", I gave this the somewhat provocative name “Arab Zionism.” But it is simply another, and arguably more positive, way of saying that Arabs have finally come to terms with Zionism and no longer follow antizionism and its deceptive promises. Indeed, precisely those who advocate political cooperation and shared government between Jews and Arabs, whether Jews or Arab themselves, should be ardent Zionists, uncompromising in their support for Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people and for the fulfillment of the Zionist vision. This, for the simple reason that in every Arab country where Jews lived, once that country was no longer ruled by European powers and became sovereign, the prospect of Jewish citizens enjoying equal political standing was met with persecution, pogroms, confiscation of property, and ultimately the ethnic cleansing of Jews from those countries. Therefore, Israel’s next government should be a Full Jabotinsky Government, the whole package. It should bring together all parties that insist on an Iron Wall against antizionism, including within the State of Israel itself. The Arab parties should be required not merely to recognize Israel fully as the nation-state of the Jewish people, but to give that recognition concrete expression. When they present a vision of peace based on “two states,” they must make clear that one of those two states is the Jewish state, and that Arabs in Gaza, the Palestinian Authority, Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon have no “right of return” into Israel and are not “fifth-generation refugees.” This is the clearest indication that they have fully come to terms with Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people and are willing to give that acceptance its full expression. The Iron Wall, therefore, is not merely a security doctrine directed outward. It must also become the foundation of a renewed Zionist consensus within Israel itself: state-provided Zionist education in Hebrew for all Israeli citizens, including Arabic speakers and the ultra-Orthodox, and military service in support of national missions, equally required of everyone (without all the dishonest schemes of “community service” that would simply become another way of funneling billions into autonomous communities hostile to the state). These are not merely mechanisms for sharing the burden. They are the means by which a common civic ethos is built, one in which every citizen knows that they belong to the state, enjoy its rights, and bear responsibility for its defense and continued existence. Jabotinsky himself would have scorned the notion that, in the sovereign Jewish state in the Land of Israel, some would refuse to take part in the defense of the Jewish state in the name of preserving a diasporic way of life. Nor would he have excluded Arab citizens from this shared ethos. The idea is that one can be ultra-Orthodox and Zionist, and one can be Arab and Zionist. There is no need to give up one's religion, language, culture, or identity in order to be a partner in the Jewish state. But there is a need to accept the legitimacy of Jewish sovereignty and the shared responsibility to defend it. What Israel needs now is a government that stops picking only the half of Jabotinsky’s doctrine that suits it. A broad, mainstream Zionist government that places Jewish sovereignty, civic equality, shared education, and universal service at the foundation of the Israeli social contract. The time has come for Jabotinsky’s Iron Wall Government. The whole package.
34
88
22
390
18,710
Noah Roth retweeted
If Israel was “bombing Gaza indiscriminately”, why did those indiscriminate bombs kill under 2% of women, 6% of men, but “discriminate” against 100% of these generals? Could it be the IDF was, in fact, as discriminating as it’s possible to be in an urban warzone? Generalocide.
These are Sinwar’s generals—Mohammed Deif, Marwan Issa, Ahmed al-Ghandour, Ghazi Abu Tama’a, Mohammed Odeh, Izz al-Din al-Haddad, Ayman Nofal, Rafa Salama, Raed Saad, Mohammed Shabaneh, Hakem al-Issa, Bassem Issa, Raed Thabet and Mohammed Sinwar—laughing as they planned their war to destroy Israel. Israel killed them all, and all their allies, up to Nasrallah and Khamenei. They failed totally.
105
690
24
3,527
79,716
I'm one of the 63% of Jewish-Americans opposed to the current Israeli government. The ad is still antisemitic. Thank you for coming to my TED talk.
Replying to @jonlovett
63% of Jewish-Americans are opposed to the current Israeli government and 61% believe Israel has committed war crimes. So, saying an ad criticizing Israel’s war crimes is somehow against Jews sounds like a dual loyalty trope. It is empirically incorrect and helps spread antisemitism. Very disappointing.
348
160
24
2,568
132,284
This is called Tuesday.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
73
Replying to @JYuter
@JYuter In unrelated news, I have been learning R' Hai Gaon, הלכות ממרים, and יסוד המשנה ועריכתה with my Hesdernik son. He asked where I "came up with" this. I told him that none of it is new and I learned it from your father שליט"א.
1
97
tl;dr He may come over with questions the next time you are at דרכי נעם for davening. 🤣
1
30