poulsard retweeted
it’s a common complaint that contemporary male pop stars are boring and play it too safe … I think it’s because we clowned on the best male pop star to ever do it. like we were eating pretty good and didn’t appreciate it.
Don't agree with all of this (indie and indie rock are not the same) but very interesting thread overall and and a necessary callout of Pitchfork inventing a fake genre
Didn’t see too much praise for the recent Pitchfork list, although you get the impression they aren’t particularly bothered about that. Getting everyone riled up seems to be half the intent when it comes to these lists. Gets the clicks in. But I know one set of people who must have been impressed with it. The staff at Rolling Stone. And any other websites fond of this kind of thing. I’m sure they were doffing their caps and giving it a minute’s round of applause, in an outpouring of respect and adoration for what this list has achieved. Because it’s managed to go beyond the usual bickering over inclusions and omissions, selections and rankings. Instead, the outrage is about the actual genre itself. What exactly is it they are ranking here? What’s its origins, classifications and criteria?
And how Pitchfork has managed this is pretty fucking genius. What they’ve done is invent their own genre, a brand new one just for this list, but given it the title of an existing genre. One that’s used by music fans, but, let’s be clear here, not all of them. Then they’ve told us this isn’t just a list that ranks the genre’s best albums, but that they will also attempt to actually define it. They’ve given it an origin story that’s a work of fiction, established rules and parameters that are both far-reaching and ridiculously narrow, and then broken those rules as they see fit. All to accommodate whoever they want to include, while leaving themselves an out to exclude others.
Let me just explain what I mean when I say this title isn’t used by all. I live in the UK. More specifically, Scotland. Even more specifically, Glasgow, a city with a legitimate claim to being the home of indie. Of course, plenty of acts and labels point the way towards indie before the clock strikes year zero in a wee flat on West Princes Street. But were these artists making indie music as we know it? Nope. So, the labels weren’t home to indie artists then. Orange Juice, though, that’s as good a shout as any for the first indie band. Right from their first release in February, 1980, they walk, talk, act, look and sound just like one. And the music they make is indie music. The rest of the Postcard Young Team are the same. And Postcard Records is as indie as a label ever gets. It was ran out of Alan Horne’s cupboard, for fucks sake.
So, the sound of young Scotland was the first sound of indie, a genre that is part of the musical ecosystem in Glasgow. I’ve never heard anyone call it “indie rock.” Moving beyond Glasgow, I worked in Manchester for a good while, I’ve family down Liverpool, I spent years in London, all big music cities, I’ve never heard it called that. On the telly and in the papers, it’s not a phrase I’ve seen often, or, at least, till it later made its way in as an Americanism. We’ve always had indie-pop, for a more melodic, janglier take on indie. But in everyday conversation, it’s indie, and the assumption is that it will rock.
Of course, the name indie itself comes from the UK independent charts, even if it’s been a very long time since a record’s musical identity was in anyway defined by how it was released. So, if we go with my belief about Postcard and Orange Juice, then throw in the fact that the name of the genre comes from our charts, it’s pretty clear that indie as a recognisable sound has its roots in the UK. But that’s not what Pitchfork claims. In the introduction to their list, we’re told:
“Indie rock is primarily an American musical art form that began in earnest around 1980, started to really take shape in 1988, and has since splintered into many forms.”
🧵
2
561
poulsard retweeted
As someone who is friends with many of the type of women who sought out old ass men in their late teens/early twenties I can confirm you are not getting a demure virgin ready for children but an absolutely traumatized bpd art hoe ready to destroy your life from the inside out! And tbh she betta werk. Just date a woman ur age and have a happy child free life, be rich go to France a lot or something
poulsard retweeted
There is no free market, don’t be a child. There never was. Capitalism flourished because the government enforced some very crazy shit with extreme violence. Or did you think patents and joint stock companies and paper money existed in the state of nature?
poulsard retweeted
Robert Christgau's promo copy of the first Squirrel Bait record at Academy on 12th Street (spotted by Ken Wissoker).
poulsard retweeted
both an incredible archive of canonized indie rock at the time and a list of songs that whip absolute fuckin ass
poulsard retweeted
The correct version can be found in Wilbur Zelinsky (1973), Cultural Geography of the United States.
poulsard retweeted
I’ll say it. Cahokia should be as recognizable to Americans as the pyramids of Egypt.
A city of enormous earthen monuments, elaborate neighborhoods, and thousands of people, sitting right here in the Mississippi Valley.
How did we end up with so many Americans who’ve never even heard of it?



































































